douglasf13 wrote:
Lotusm50, are you saying that the C/Y 21mm on Sony is not a suitable alternative to the ZE 21mm? Besides, more Zeiss is not a reason to switch to Sony. Stabilization on all lenses, a better VF, robust build, AF Zeiss, and a red channel is for some.
For the great majority of users -- not necessarily you or I -- adapted lens that have to be used totally manually are not an acceptable option. So no, being able to use a c/y 21mm is not a suitable option for the majority of users.
More Zeiss, and good Zeiss coverage of prime focal lengths that you use is indeed a reason to switch to Sony. It is the prime reason for many. Quite frankly, merely having a competitive camera isn't going to get all those Canon and Nikon users to switch -- the time and financial costs of switching are large, and slight differences in IQ (whether subjectively better or not) out of the body isn't going to do it. There is a small survey (of mainly pros) on Rangefinder magazine's website -- if you are going to buy a camera in the next 6 months what brand would it be? 46% say Canon, 43% say Nikon, 8% say Pentax, almost 3% say Olympus. 0% say Sony. I don't expect it to stay at 0% as the pool grows. But it is clear that Sony does need something to get more pro's to switch.
Sony's ace in the whole, is the quality and brand recognition they get from Zeiss. It gives them desirability, but right now Sony is doing little to exploit that desirability, the relationship seems half-hearted. There are just 4 full frame Zeiss lenses for Sony. We need more of a reason to switch. Personally, I want to switch but there is not enough reason yet to make me want to go through the hassle and cost of switching. We are waiting for this to be complete Sony/Zeiss system and unfortunately there is no substantive indication at all that it is coming.