fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008Some better A900 samples

  
 
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #1Some better A900 samples
Yes, I mentioned the M series in my post and there were additional optical benefits to going with a retrofocus design beyond just the M5 as stated by Erwin Puts in the Leica Lens Compendium:

"The gradual change from symmetrical to retro-focus
types for the M-body, was necessary since the introduction of the M5. The
second, more disguised argument for the change to this newer type of designs is
the optical potential of these designs. As soon as the designer has familiarized
himself with the inherent characteristics of retro-focus designs, (s)he has more
opportunities for correction."

The only pure wide angle lens design I am aware of which does not suffer from terrible vignetting and other optical issues are the Zeiss Biogons. The large Rodenstock Grandagons and Schneider Super Angulons both suffer from pretty severe vignetting and require a center filter for critical evenness.

But I'm glad you have seemingly retracted your stance that a pure wide angle lens design is actually not in use by Leica these days when you were in fact originally claiming the superiority and use(by Leica!) of such a design only a few posts back.

Mel Gross wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
Mel Gross wroteBut, it was always considered to be a negative to have retrofocus lenses. That was one reason given for Leica's high quality wides. It's easier to design a lens that's not retrofocus.
There are many optical issues with a non retrofocus design for wide angle lenses. Severe vignetting is one of the biggest which is why center filters are required for non retrofocus, large format lenses. Leica noticed the optical benefits of using retrofocus designs quite a while back which is why their modern wide angle lenses even for the M series are actually of a slight retrofocus design.
Yes, for SLR's with a long backfocus.

But I meant the "M" series, which I though you understood me to mean. With those, it's different. Superior quality is easier with a pure wideangle design. Vignetting is mostly due to designing a compact lens. The new Zeiss 18/3/5 is a good example of this. It vignettes by 3 stops wide open, and even at 8, it's a good one stop plus off. Only at 11 does it look good, though, even there, vignetting is present.

The reason why Leica went to a slightly retrofocus design for some of their wider lenses for
...Show more →
Oct 07, 2008 at 04:26 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #2Some better A900 samples
Il Medico wrote:
Wow! Canon fanboy got up on the wrong side of the crib today!

Mel Gross wroteAll this talk about how much better the IQ of the 5DII is. How can you tell? There are little to no credible samples.

Absolutely ZERO comparisons in the same conditions with the same processing.

It's a know fact the Sony has a relatively poor jpeg engine and these jpegs are what are showing up.
Earlier quoteSony's RAW images have problems. Who cares about their JPEGs?
Says who? Take a look around for samples. There are many ways to process RAW files, not all of them good.

Earlier quoteI currently shoot with a 40D, 24-105 and 70-200/2.8. I'm seriously thinking of moving to a FF for a variety of reasons.

Unfortunately the 5DII does little to make me want one. The build/feel is not there. It's kind of slow feeling- the responsiveness apparently hasn't changed from the original.
Earlier quoteYou're moving from a 40D, and you're concerned about build/feel? If you owned a 5D, you wouldn't be talking about that, or responsiveness.
I've used a 5D. Build is the same or less than the 40D. It's also very slow in comparison- overall responsiveness.

Earlier quote5fps is 25% faster than 3.9%. 25% is kind of a lot- no?
Earlier quoteNo! It's not a lot. If you can't get a shot with 4 fps, then it's not likely you will get it with 5.
Then 5 to 6, 6 to 7, 7 to 8, 8 to 9, 9-10 matter not either. So I guess Canon is milking all the sports photogs by having them pay extra for 10fps.

You're a real piece of work.

Earlier quoteThe AF module on the A900 most likely will be much better than the 5D/5DII. The A700 focus tests are pretty good- equal to or better than the 30/40D in most reviews.
Earlier quoteNow who's making assumptions?
It's far less of an assumption than what
...Show more →
Earlier quoteIf you were here for a good deal of this thread, you would know that those of us who actually have this camera are almost all satisfied with the autofocus. The one on the mkII is slightly improved over that.
Earlier quoteThe 30/40D autofocus is not as good as the one from the 5D, esp. for tracking in servo.
Earlier quoteInbody IS is much more important to me at this point than a so-so movie mode.

100% VF is important to me. Not having one is one of the more annoying aspects of the 30/40/50D.
Earlier quoteThat's the first thing you've said that makes sense. If YOU aren't happy without in camera IS, then buy a camera with it.
Earlier quoteAgain, the jury is still out on the absolute IQ characteristics of the A900 and the 5DII.
Earlier quoteNo doubt we need to see some technical tests in addition to the field tests. But there is little question that the 5D mkII will have better IQ.
Earlier quoteAs is stands I'd give up a stop or stop and a half for the better AF, better VF (not only 100% but bigger and brighter), better build and inbody IS.
Earlier quoteNice to see someone be willing to give up image quality. We don't see too many people like you .
Earlier quoteYou don't have to worry, you will be giving up astop to a stop and a half noise and dynamic range. You aren't getting much in exchange, since the AF isn't much better, if at all, the build quality is likely lower, other than a bit more sealing, and the dubious gain of in body IS.
Earlier quoteI can't see it being worthwhile when people comment on how noisy your pictures are, or how smeared the details are. I guess you'll just have to grit your teeth, and explain that the viewfinder is 100%, and there are a couple more gaskets in the body. That should do it.
Earlier quoteA900 85/1.4 at ISO 1600 and 1/15 will beat the 5DMkII at 85/1.2 ISO 6400 at 1/80 (give or take).
Earlier quoteThat's a joke, right? The mkII will easily beat the A900 at 1600 with the 85 1.2. Or at any other ISO speed or aperture. If you can't handhold it then, you should stop shooting.
Earlier quoteThe only thing giving me pause is all the Canon gear being sold, driving prices down.
Earlier quoteI guess that's funny. Ha ha.
[\quote]

Check out the buy/sell forum- 5Ds and 40Ds going for peanuts. Lots of L lenses going for cheap as well.

Gene

Oh, and Canon has yet to seem to be able to make a properly designed VG. They all suck for fit and function. I shoot a lot of vertical shots but shooting with the grip is worse than not having one- so I don't have or use one. Annoying aspect #2 of the 30/40/50D and since it's the same basic design for the 5D/DII the same holds true for that VG as well.
Earlier quoteThat's a joke!
Earlier quoteI'm not so sure you even own Canon equipment.


If someone disagrees, they're a fanboy/ Perhaps you are the fanboy.

You make statements that are just plain silly.

As for the a900 RAW images. no doubt there will be a small improvement with a better RAW engine. But it won't make a huge difference. These things never do. The differences are subtle.

Your statements regarding the 5D build quality vs the 40D are a joke. Don't bother!

Speed, well, if you think moving up one fps makes a big difference, good for you. As far as being a piece of work goes, when you know something, and aren't just venting, you might make more sense.

As for my assumptions, I'm not making any. There have been two field reviews. They both said the same thing. Noise from the a900 is about the same as the 1Ds mkIII, but a bit worse at higher ISO's. Most people understand this already. It seems as though the 1Ds mkIII was Sony's target to match.

IQ is made up of numerous things. Several are sharpness, noise, and dynamic range. Those are the biggies.

I doubt anyone here that cares about ultimate image quality uses JPEGS for anything critical. It's the RAW quality that matters most.

As far as the a900 focus goes, we know what Sony has done there. No assumptions required.

I can read very well, you want to set up a situation that doesn't exist, and you want me to agree with it. I don't have to. I can easily handhold a camera with an 85/1/2 shooting at 1600 at what will turn out to be, 99% of the time a 90th to a 125th of a sec. Sorry, I don't shoot in total darkness. Maybe you do.

About those Zeiss lenses. We'll have to see how they preform on a FF sensor. So far, all the real tests have been done on an APS-C body.

Maybe you don't look at discontinued models much, but that's pretty normal, even for Sony.

How about your proof? You're the one making absurd statements.




Oct 07, 2008 at 05:30 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #3Some better A900 samples

I never meant to have you think that Leica never had retrofocus lenses for the "M" series all the way through the more recent history. If it sounded that way at first, it was my error. As you saw, though, the reason for going retrofocus was, as I said, the new M5, with its swing out meter. A mild retrofocus lens, rather than the extreme ones used for SLR's, particularly Nikon's, which had a lot of problems, and required bigger, and more expensive designs to get around the fact, could benefit from the newer technology.

Retrofocus lenses are more complex by nature, so more opportunities do present themselves. It's still easier to design a good lens that isn't retrofocus, because it's simpler.

As far as vignetting and design go, it's a matter of desire, more than anything else. I don't remember much about the Biogon, as I never used them, but the others did have vignetting. Otherwise the already very expensive, and heavy lenses would have been even heavier and more expensive. But, the Super Angulons had much better vignetting performance. Were they retrofocus? I don't remember. But they were much bigger and more expensive.

Tariq Gibran wrote:
Yes, I mentioned the M series in my post and there were additional optical benefits to going with a retrofocus design beyond just the M5 as stated by Erwin Puts in the Leica Lens Compendium:

"The gradual change from symmetrical to retro-focus
types for the M-body, was necessary since the introduction of the M5. The
second, more disguised argument for the change to this newer type of designs is
the optical potential of these designs. As soon as the designer has familiarized
himself with the inherent characteristics of retro-focus designs, (s)he has more
opportunities for correction."

The only pure wide angle
...Show more →
Mel Gross wrote
Tariq Gibran wrote
Mel Gross wroteBut, it was always considered to be a negative to have retrofocus lenses. That was one reason given for Leica's high quality wides. It's easier to design a lens that's not retrofocus.
There are many optical issues with a non retrofocus design for wide angle lenses. Severe vignetting is one of the biggest which is why center filters are required for non retrofocus, large format lenses. Leica noticed the optical benefits of using retrofocus designs quite a while back which is why their modern wide angle lenses even for the M series are actually of a slight retrofocus design.
Yes, for SLR's with a long backfocus.

But I meant the "M" series, which I though you understood me to mean. With those, it's different. Superior quality is easier with a pure wideangle design. Vignetting is mostly due to designing a compact lens. The new Zeiss 18/3/5 is a good example of this. It vignettes by 3 stops wide open, and even at 8, it's a good one stop plus off. Only at 11 does it look good, though, even there, vignetting is present.

The reason why Leica went to a slightly retrofocus design for some of their wider lenses for the "M" series had nothing to do with the quality issue.

It had to do with the swing down metering the cameras began to use. I had that M5 camera. The older wideangle lenses just barely made it.. Leica redesigned some of those lenses in their normal upgrade programs shortly after, to make newer cameras have better metering systems. More modern designs, such as the computer designs Canon first used with the new F1 series in 1969, aided new lens development. Older more manual methods could take several years to calculate new high grade lenses, and some areas of design couldn't be calculated at all in any reasonable time. Leica, as other top manufacturers, began to go to computer aided design as well. Better lenses resulted. Slightly retrofocus designs could easily be made that were better than the older designs, which also didn't take advantage of newer glasses and such.

Nowadays, with the amazingly high precision manufacturing techniques everyone can use, almost any design is possible. Internal element groups, moving in different directions at once are becoming common. Several groups can be moving at the same time by different amounts. This technique can actually change the type of lens design as focus progresses. A wide can become more retrofocus as it focusses out to infinity, and, of course, less so as focus moves closer—the best of both worlds.

In reality, today, a designer has so many tools at her disposal that almost any problem can be minimized. It just depends on what the price of the lens can be, and the size and weight it's thought people will accept.

Oct 07, 2008 at 05:41 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #4Some better A900 samples
Mel Gross wrote:
As far as vignetting and design go, it's a matter of desire, more than anything else. I don't remember much about the Biogon, as I never used them, but the others did have vignetting. Otherwise the already very expensive, and heavy lenses would have been even heavier and more expensive. But, the Super Angulons had much better vignetting performance. Were they retrofocus? I don't remember. But they were much bigger and more expensive.



Even the Super Angulons suffer from pretty bad vignetting which is why Schneider offer a center filter for them. I have used a number of them over the years. They are not perfect symmetrical designs, though close, and use the the famed tilting pupil trick to help with more even edge illumination.
Oct 07, 2008 at 06:36 PM
moire
Offline
Details
p.10 #5Some better A900 samples
dpr has some figures up from A900 in the D700 review:


Camera
Shadow range

Highlight range

Usable range
Nikon D700 (ISO 200) -4.4 EV 3.4 EV 7.8 EV
Sony DSLR-A900 (ISO 200) -5.1 EV 4.2 EV 9.4 EV
Canon EOS 5D (ISO 100) -4.7 EV 3.5 EV 8.2 EV
Nikon D300 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 4.1 EV 8.8 EV
Nikon D3 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 3.9 EV 8.6 EV


more in this thread http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1037&thread=29614228

the d700 review:
http://www.dpreview.com/news/0810/08100701nikond700review.asp
Oct 07, 2008 at 07:10 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #6Some better A900 samples
moire wrote:
dpr has some figures up from A900 in the D700 review:

Camera
Shadow range

Highlight range

Usable range
Nikon D700 (ISO 200) -4.4 EV 3.4 EV 7.8 EV
Sony DSLR-A900 (ISO 200) -5.1 EV 4.2 EV 9.4 EV
Canon EOS 5D (ISO 100) -4.7 EV 3.5 EV 8.2 EV
Nikon D300 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 4.1 EV 8.8 EV
Nikon D3 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 3.9 EV 8.6 EV

more in this thread http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1037&thread=29614228

the d700 review:
http://www.dpreview.com/news/0810/08100701nikond700review.asp


Yes, the usable DR of the A900 is looking very impressive. That was one area I was concerned about. Great news.
Oct 07, 2008 at 09:28 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #7Some better A900 samples
Tariq Gibran wrote:
Mel Gross wroteAs far as vignetting and design go, it's a matter of desire, more than anything else. I don't remember much about the Biogon, as I never used them, but the others did have vignetting. Otherwise the already very expensive, and heavy lenses would have been even heavier and more expensive. But, the Super Angulons had much better vignetting performance. Were they retrofocus? I don't remember. But they were much bigger and more expensive.
Even the Super Angulons suffer from pretty bad vignetting which is why Schneider offer a center filter for them. I have used a number of them over the years. They are not perfect symmetrical designs, though close, and use the the famed tilting pupil trick to help with more even edge illumination.


Yes, I agree. My 90 does vignette. but it's much better than the older one which I also had.

They aren't perfect, because those front elements must be larger, as they are in almost all "symmetrical designs, esp. the ones from the '60's on forward, to cut down on that vignetting.

If they made the front elements larger, to cut the vignetting down further, you could use it as an umbrella.
Oct 07, 2008 at 10:59 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #8Some better A900 samples
Tariq Gibran wrote:
moire wrotedpr has some figures up from A900 in the D700 review:

Camera
Shadow range

Highlight range

Usable range
Nikon D700 (ISO 200) -4.4 EV 3.4 EV 7.8 EV
Sony DSLR-A900 (ISO 200) -5.1 EV 4.2 EV 9.4 EV
Canon EOS 5D (ISO 100) -4.7 EV 3.5 EV 8.2 EV
Nikon D300 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 4.1 EV 8.8 EV
Nikon D3 (ISO 200) -4.7 EV 3.9 EV 8.6 EV

more in this thread http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1037&thread=29614228

the d700 review:
http://www.dpreview.com/news/0810/08100701nikond700review.asp
Yes, the usable DR of the A900 is looking very impressive. That was one area I was concerned about. Great news.


Don't forget that those are JPEG's at default settings. not too meaningful. Look at the Nikon's actual range in the review.
Oct 07, 2008 at 11:48 PM
moire
Offline
Details
p.10 #9Some better A900 samples
Yes, but it gives a little indication what we can expect from raw

comparing jpeg's at all arent a good idea from the start ...
Oct 08, 2008 at 03:24 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #10Some better A900 samples
The RAW DR should be even better! I think that is the encouraging aspect.
Oct 08, 2008 at 07:13 AM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #11Some better A900 samples
Tariq Gibran wrote:
The RAW DR should be even better! I think that is the encouraging aspect.


Despite what people may be thinking about my feelings here, I hope it will be as well. But from the looks at the RAW image comparisons put up in the review already, it's obvious they HAVE gotten the a900's RAW files. It doesn't look good. It's much noisier than the other three cameras tested. It's too bad.

I would have liked to see the results from the 1Ds mkIII side by side as well, since this is the camera that the a900 has been compared to in their own field report, as well as the one fron the Luminous Landscape. As they seem to have changed their testing procedures somewhat, older results may not validly compare to the new ones.

It should be an interesting next few months, with Canon, and likely Nikon, adding new top end cameras to the mix.
Oct 08, 2008 at 12:12 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.10 #12Some better A900 samples
Chasseur d'Images tested the A900, and they said noise is on par with 1dsiii, and detail is as good or better in some situtations.
Oct 08, 2008 at 01:24 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #13Some better A900 samples
douglasf13 wrote:
Chasseur d'Images tested the A900, and they said noise is on par with 1dsiii, and detail is as good or better in some situtations.


From what we know, so far, the IQ seems to be on about a par with the 1Ds mkIII.
Oct 08, 2008 at 01:33 PM
moire
Offline
Details
p.10 #14Some better A900 samples
Hopefully we will se some raw tests soon enough.
Oct 08, 2008 at 03:15 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.10 #15Some better A900 samples
douglasf13 wrote:
Chasseur d'Images tested the A900, and they said noise is on par with 1dsiii, and detail is as good or better in some situtations.


and

Mel Gross wrote:
From what we know, so far, the IQ seems to be on about a par with the 1Ds mkIII.



If these statement prove to be correct then I will be buying and a900. However, I have yet to read the Chasseur d'Images article, and don't know how they came to that conclusions or how comprehensive or rigorous their comparison was. If anyone has a copy, I would love to see it. So far, everything else I have seen, including RAW files suggest that it comes up short in terms of noise, and other comparisons indicate that fine detail is better with the 1DsMKIII (and by extension, therefore, the 5D MkII as well). I guess I am still waiting for a comprehensive and conclusive comparison test, hopefully with the 5D MkII.

Oct 08, 2008 at 03:42 PM
Andi Dietrich
Offline
[X]
Details
p.10 #16Some better A900 samples
Oct 08, 2008 at 03:56 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #17Some better A900 samples
It should not be long before we start seeing a lot of A900 images since it just started shipping from Sonystyle.com here in the U.S.
Oct 08, 2008 at 06:42 PM
Mel Gross
Offline
Details
p.10 #18Some better A900 samples
Lotusm50 wrote:
douglasf13 wroteChasseur d'Images tested the A900, and they said noise is on par with 1dsiii, and detail is as good or better in some situtations.
and

Mel Gross wroteFrom what we know, so far, the IQ seems to be on about a par with the 1Ds mkIII.
If these statement prove to be correct then I will be buying and a900. However, I have yet to read the Chasseur d'Images article, and don't know how they came to that conclusions or how comprehensive or rigorous their comparison was. If anyone has a copy, I would love to see it. So far, everything else I have seen, including RAW files suggest that it comes up short in terms of noise, and other comparisons indicate that fine detail is better with the 1DsMKIII (and by extension, therefore, the 5D MkII as well). I guess I am still waiting for
...Show more →

Remember that the 5D mkII will have better IQ than the 1Ds mkIII. Exactly how much better is yet to be determined. But the 5D had somewhat better noise characteristics than the 1Ds mkII, and the 5D mkII is supposed, according to Canon, to be 1 to 1.5 stops better in noise. If so, that could also mean that resolution at higher ISO's could be better, as less noise reduction would be needed.
Oct 08, 2008 at 06:57 PM
Lotusm50
Offline
Details
p.10 #19Some better A900 samples
Mel Gross wrote:
Remember that the 5D mkII will have better IQ than the 1Ds mkIII. Exactly how much better is yet to be determined. But the 5D had somewhat better noise characteristics than the 1Ds mkII, and the 5D mkII is supposed, according to Canon, to be 1 to 1.5 stops better in noise. If so, that could also mean that resolution at higher ISO's could be better, as less noise reduction would be needed.



Yes, I am aware of this (and stated as much in an earlier post somewhere). The real question is how much better. I suspect it is modest and incremental rather than earth-shattering. I guess we have to wait a couple weeks before we get better information. The 5D MkII is apparently due Oct. 18th

Oct 08, 2008 at 07:08 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.10 #20Some better A900 samples
One thing Sony really should have corrected on the A900 is the Minolta proprietary hot shoe. For anyone(like commercial and studio photographers) who use wireless slave triggers, this means we will have to buy(and keep track of!) a silly adapter.
Oct 08, 2008 at 07:16 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister