Wow! Canon fanboy got up on the wrong side of the crib today!
Mel Gross wrote:
All this talk about how much better the IQ of the 5DII is. How can you tell? There are little to no credible samples.
Absolutely ZERO comparisons in the same conditions with the same processing.
It's a know fact the Sony has a relatively poor jpeg engine and these jpegs are what are showing up.
Sony's RAW images have problems. Who cares about their JPEGs?
Says who? Take a look around for samples. There are many ways to process RAW files, not all of them good.
I currently shoot with a 40D, 24-105 and 70-200/2.8. I'm seriously thinking of moving to a FF for a variety of reasons.
Unfortunately the 5DII does little to make me want one. The build/feel is not there. It's kind of slow feeling- the responsiveness apparently hasn't changed from the original.
You're moving from a 40D, and you're concerned about build/feel? If you owned a 5D, you wouldn't be talking about that, or responsiveness.
I've used a 5D. Build is the same or less than the 40D. It's also very slow in comparison- overall responsiveness.
5fps is 25% faster than 3.9%. 25% is kind of a lot- no?
No! It's not a lot. If you can't get a shot with 4 fps, then it's not likely you will get it with 5.
Then 5 to 6, 6 to 7, 7 to 8, 8 to 9, 9-10 matter not either. So I guess Canon is milking all the sports photogs by having them pay extra for 10fps.
You're a real piece of work.
The AF module on the A900 most likely will be much better than the 5D/5DII. The A700 focus tests are pretty good- equal to or better than the 30/40D in most reviews.
Now who's making assumptions?
It's far less of an assumption than what the IQ of the 5DII will be.
If you were here for a good deal of this thread, you would know that those of us who actually have this camera are almost all satisfied with the autofocus. The one on the mkII is slightly improved over that.
No it's not (improved) It's identical.
The 30/40D autofocus is not as good as the one from the 5D, esp. for tracking in servo.
And you know this how? The 40D/50D have markedly better of center AF with the cross type sensors. AF tracking is faster in the 40/50D as well.
Inbody IS is much more important to me at this point than a so-so movie mode.
100% VF is important to me. Not having one is one of the more annoying aspects of the 30/40/50D.
That's the first thing you've said that makes sense. If YOU aren't happy without in camera IS, then buy a camera with it.
Didn't say I wasn't happy without it. You can read can't you? I said that inbody IS is more important to ME than a so-so video mode.
Again, the jury is still out on the absolute IQ characteristics of the A900 and the 5DII.
No doubt we need to see some technical tests in addition to the field tests. But there is little question that the 5D mkII will have better IQ.
Making assumptions are we? And by better you mean at high ISO, at low ISO what assumptions are you making?
As is stands I'd give up a stop or stop and a half for the better AF, better VF (not only 100% but bigger and brighter), better build and inbody IS.
Nice to see someone be willing to give up image quality. We don't see too many people like you .
Maybe this is news to you, but there is more to IQ than high ISO noise performance.
You don't have to worry, you will be giving up astop to a stop and a half noise and dynamic range. You aren't getting much in exchange, since the AF isn't much better, if at all, the build quality is likely lower, other than a bit more sealing, and the dubious gain of in body IS.
Go check out DPR's review of the D700. The A900 in JPPEG mode is over 1 stop BETTER than the old 5D. The 5DII may or may not be any better. So no loss in DR for the A900.
I can't see it being worthwhile when people comment on how noisy your pictures are, or how smeared the details are. I guess you'll just have to grit your teeth, and explain that the viewfinder is 100%, and there are a couple more gaskets in the body. That should do it.
Well I guess they'd be noisy if I made it a habit to shoot at ISO 3200 or more with no PP and printed them at 20x30.
Did I mention that you're a real piece of work?
A900 85/1.4 at ISO 1600 and 1/15 will beat the 5DMkII at 85/1.2 ISO 6400 at 1/80 (give or take).
That's a joke, right? The mkII will easily beat the A900 at 1600 with the 85 1.2. Or at any other ISO speed or aperture. If you can't handhold it then, you should stop shooting.
Again, I'm going to jump out on a limb here and assume you CAN read. I said that at ISO 1600 the A900 will be better than the 5DII at 6400.
It's not MY problem YOU can't handhold your non stabelized $1800 lens steady at 1/15 while someone with an A900 with the equally as good CZ 85/1.4 can.
The only thing giving me pause is all the Canon gear being sold, driving prices down.
I guess that's funny. Ha ha.
[\quote]
Check out the buy/sell forum- 5Ds and 40Ds going for peanuts. Lots of L lenses going for cheap as well.
Gene
Oh, and Canon has yet to seem to be able to make a properly designed VG. They all suck for fit and function. I shoot a lot of vertical shots but shooting with the grip is worse than not having one- so I don't have or use one. Annoying aspect #2 of the 30/40/50D and since it's the same basic design for the 5D/DII the same holds true for that VG as well.
That's a joke!
I'm not so sure you even own Canon equipment.
Not so sure you do either. Got any proof you're not just some Canon wannabe fanboy talking out your @ss?
If you "did" actually own any Canon gear AND actually used any one of Canon's abysmal VGs you'd know that what I said is true.
Of course you could just be justifying the your spending of $200 on a $75 VG with limited functionality.
Gene