Tariq Gibran wrote:
I guess I interpreted your remark as referring to marketing and sales since you were writing about markets when you stated that. The fact that Sony recently moved into the number three DSLR slot behind Canon and Nikon is telling. I'm sure Sony view the A900 as much as an "Image" product as anything else. By that standard, it will probably serve them well. The reviews thus far have also been very positive overall. When it comes to the specs relating to actually using the camera to take still photographs (and there is always more to it then specs we all know), the A900 kills the 5DII in areas such as the 100% huge prism, 5FPS, in body Image stabilization and so forth. Both Canon and Sony may be surprised at just how many advanced amateurs and of course pros actually value some of these specs which are missing from the 5DII. Then, of course, when you add in those AF Zeiss lenses, the A900 becomes a compelling choice for those pros who do not need the best high ISO capability. Beyond that main advantage, and the gimmicky movie mode, the Sony looks pretty good. Well, I guess the other advantage the 5DII has is its ability to use a larger variety of Alt lenses. That's the one I'm weighing right now.
While I always expected Sony to move to number two, and I'm not sure if some of the others will even survive, they did so more at the expense of the smaller companies than they did of Canon and Nikon.
Also understand that Sony is doing this at great cost. They are losing money here, where both Canon and Nikon are profitable. How long can they keep that up?
I totally agree that Sony sees this as an image builder. The question is whether it will work out that way.
I don't see the 100% prism as having much value at all, esp. when compared to 98%. 5FPS is nice, but it's not that much more than 3.9. If it were 6, or 7, it would be different. In body image stabilization is also nice, but it hasn't helped anyone gain marketshare. With both Canon and Nikon having inexpensive lenses with it built-in now, it means even less. I don't know what your "and so on" consists of.
It surely seems to me that you are stretching here in the last half of your post.
High ISO quality has been the holy grail of D-SLR users, and it seems that both Canon and Nikon are addressing it well. If you ask most photographers which is more important to them, I would bet it's that, rather than the minor goodies the A900 has that you mentioned. Most of the comparisons being thrown around have been of ISO quality comparisons. Wonder why?
The few Zeiss lenses are very good. But most amateurs won't be able to afford more than one, if that. They are very expensive. The rest of Sony's lenses are meh, and are not designed for digital at all, and don't preform wonderfully. Most of their lenses are very old, and were good, but not great, even when they were introduced. Both Canon and Nikon, again, have been addressing that over the past few years, while Sony has been criticized for not doing more about it.
You may think the movie mode is gimmicky, but it's interesting that many writers in the business have been saying that in a few years, every D-SLR will have it. And so far, the quality of the Canon's video has been praised as being very good, and usable, indeed.
Also, the Sony is priced at $3,000, I believe, correct me if I'm wrong. The 5D mkII is priced at $2,700. The D700 is $3,000, but it being said that Nikon must lower its price to compete with the 5D mkII. If so, then the A900's price must also come down. With Sony already losing money from its digital camera lines, that will just plunge them further into the red. Can, and will they do it?