fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

  
 
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.9 #1So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Wickedfn4u wrote:
So posting on to a thread about problems with a body stating that yours is fine and all others should be too is very useful insight. I bought mine from a local vendor and Dell they have been to canon 3 times now the 4th time have been asked to send my lenses in too. They will not replace they keep telling me they can fix it. You know what you cannot know the level of frustration people with the problem have faced. Simple, yes you are for missing the point not all bodies perform to a level not only
...Show more →

Now that's more like it. Sharing your experience on the issue is much more productive than posting "joke" references and insult replies to those whose experience has differed from yours.

And I didn't say all of my misses were because of the "spray excuse". I did however correctly point out that my camera would sometimes focus on the dirt or sand after impact of a golf shot. And there were others I admitted to missing focus. The old "human excuse", my most commonly used...

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 12:48 PM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.9 #2So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
72chevelle454 wrote:
Is this "Spray Focus" too..

I know exactly what your talking about Chris.



Surely a Mk3 can't focus so quickly and accurately, you pre-focused on this plane right?

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 12:50 PM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.9 #3So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
"a filed report" as in filed where?
Mar 07, 2008 at 01:11 PM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.9 #4So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ChrisDM wrote:
And I didn't say all of my misses were because of the "spray excuse". I did however correctly point out that my camera would sometimes focus on the dirt or sand after impact of a golf shot. And there were others I admitted to missing focus. The old "human excuse", my most commonly used...


Just out of curiosity, have you seen the 'ghosting' that was apparent in the closeup of the swing by the guy in the dark blue shirt? It would be interesting to see that logo on his sleeve at 100%...
Mar 07, 2008 at 01:21 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.9 #5So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
drisley wrote:
AJ Nadershahi wrote
hhski wroteicandyimages wrote:
here's a link I came across someone posting samples of their 1D Mark III and Nikon D3
http://www.pbase.com/hildrup/07q4

As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.

I went to the said link. I was looking at the thumbs and wondered where the nikon images started. I knew immediately from the over saturated blue and red that was one reason I switched to canon
You've fallen into the same trap of basing your assumption by viewing low res jpeg images on a web site without knowing the camera settings that were used with each body.
I've seen many raw images from both, and have have heard similar complaints about the "plasticky" look of the D3 images from magazine editors. I'm just not a fan of the over saturated, plastic look coming out of the D3, either. Personal taste I guess.
AJ Nadershahi wrote
gbee wroteI held off going to Nikon after a filed report showed several failed in the snow ...
You made up your mind based on one report from a photographer that kept taking camera bodies from a warm humid area to a cold outdoor environment without regard to condensation. And when the first one failed, he repeated this antic on consecutive bodies. Yet oddly enough there haven't been any other such reports before or since.
Unfortunately, that last sentence is incorrect.. I've seen many similar reports of the D3 failing in cold temperatures. In fact, a friend of mine went shooting with his Canon gear with a bunch of nonik's here in Canada, and while his 40D performed admirably,the noniks had nothing but problems (including D3's). So while not all
...Show more →

Drisley, you sound like a stuck record. I've read this same post from you at least 25 different times on a couple of forums. I guess it is safe to say you don't like the D3.
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:05 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.9 #6So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
chez wrote:
drisley wrote
AJ Nadershahi wrote
hhski wroteicandyimages wrote:
here's a link I came across someone posting samples of their 1D Mark III and Nikon D3
http://www.pbase.com/hildrup/07q4

As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.

I went to the said link. I was looking at the thumbs and wondered where the nikon images started. I knew immediately from the over saturated blue and red that was one reason I switched to canon
You've fallen into the same trap of basing your assumption by viewing low res jpeg images on a web site without knowing the camera settings that were used with each body.
I've seen many raw images from both, and have have heard similar complaints about the "plasticky" look of the D3 images from magazine editors. I'm just not a fan of the over saturated, plastic look coming out of the D3, either. Personal taste I guess.
AJ Nadershahi wrote
gbee wroteI held off going to Nikon after a filed report showed several failed in the snow ...
You made up your mind based on one report from a photographer that kept taking camera bodies from a warm humid area to a cold outdoor environment without regard to condensation. And when the first one failed, he repeated this antic on consecutive bodies. Yet oddly enough there haven't been any other such reports before or since.
Unfortunately, that last sentence is incorrect.. I've seen many similar reports of the D3 failing in cold temperatures. In fact, a friend of mine went shooting with his Canon gear with a bunch of nonik's here in Canada, and while his 40D performed admirably,the noniks had nothing but problems (including D3's). So while not all D3's have the problem, the same can be said for the MK3 (in regard to AF issues). I know of way, way more people with MK3's that work better than any camera they've ever owned (me included), than I do people with problematic ones. So I do agree with the statement about these forums creating a reality of their own.
Drisley, you sound like a stuck record. I've read this same post from you at least 25 different times on a couple of forums. I guess it is safe to say you don't like the D3.





Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 02:23 PM
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:21 PM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.9 #7So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
drisley wrote:
[
I've seen many raw images from both, and have have heard similar complaints about the "plasticky" look of the D3 images from magazine editors. I'm just not a fan of the over saturated, plastic look coming out of the D3, either. Personal taste I guess.

I've seen many similar reports of the D3 failing in cold temperatures. In fact, a friend of mine went shooting with his Canon gear with a bunch of nonik's here in Canada, and while his 40D performed admirably,the noniks had nothing but problems (including D3's). So while not all D3's have the problem, the same can
...Show more →

Drisley,

No offense intended, but you've built-up a reputation in these forums for making quite a few unjustified claims. Please provide some links to backup your comments.

P.S. what raw processor was used to view these raw files? Need I point you again to the sorry sap in the Lexus forum that made grandiose claims of bad D3 focus and noisy raw files, which were eventually debunked due to his raw work flow?

Otherwise yes, these forums do make their own reality. Hence it's always a good idea to backup ones claims with valid reports and analysis.




Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 02:28 PM
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:26 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.9 #8So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
AJ Nadershahi wrote:
drisley wrote[
I've seen many raw images from both, and have have heard similar complaints about the "plasticky" look of the D3 images from magazine editors. I'm just not a fan of the over saturated, plastic look coming out of the D3, either. Personal taste I guess.

I've seen many similar reports of the D3 failing in cold temperatures. In fact, a friend of mine went shooting with his Canon gear with a bunch of nonik's here in Canada, and while his 40D performed admirably,the noniks had nothing but problems (including D3's). So while not all D3's have the problem, the same can be said for the MK3 (in regard to AF issues). I know of way, way more people with MK3's that work better than any camera they've ever owned (me included), than I do people with problematic ones. So I do agree with the statement about these forums creating a reality of their own.
Drisley,

No offense intended, but you've built-up a reputation in these forums for making quite a few unjustified claims. Please provide some links to backup your comments.

P.S. what raw processor was used to view these raw files? Need I point you again to the sorry sap in the Lexus forum that made grandiose claims of bad D3 focus and noisy raw files, which were eventually debunked due to his raw work flow?

Otherwise yes, these forums do make their own reality. Hence it's always a good idea to backup ones claims with valid reports and analysis.




agreed. also, using lines like "i have a friend who..." or "my friend said.." in every single post is really not very convincing. i would like to see proof of all the claims that are being made.
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:30 PM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.9 #9So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
chez wrote:
Drisley, you sound like a stuck record. I've read this same post from you at least 25 different times on a couple of forums. I guess it is safe to say you don't like the D3.


Actually Drisley was all set to switch to Nikon D3 and had one on reserve, but he didn't like waiting for his turn when they were first released.

Hmmmm. Kind of like the boy asking the pretty girl to a dance and getting dumped, so now he hates her and trys to point out her flaws.

Sorry Drisley, just poking some innocent fun at your expense. I can only get away with doing this because I used to be the boy that would get dumped all the time.


Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 02:56 PM
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:53 PM
David Israel
Offline
Details
p.9 #10So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
The original question is..."Would you buy one now?"

My $4,000.00 answer is..."yes." I have had mine for only a week, but it has been a week of sheer bliss. Mind you, it is winter time and I haven't shot in AI mode, in hot weather, yet. But I don't feel that I took a huge gamble making this purchase.

Dave I.
Mar 07, 2008 at 03:02 PM
Gene_C
Offline
Details
p.9 #11So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v315/Geniousc/5U5Y1612.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v315/Geniousc/feet-at-100.jpg

Mar 07, 2008 at 03:25 PM
Mike1
Offline
Details
p.9 #12So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
geniousc wrote:
I am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens
...Show more →

Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309


Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 03:35 PM
Mar 07, 2008 at 03:34 PM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.9 #13So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Mike1 wrote:
I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.


Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?
Mar 07, 2008 at 03:51 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.9 #14So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Mike1 wrote:
geniousc wroteI am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.
Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309


ok, i have not used micro af adjustment at all. with that said, i do have a question for you: do you think that it is normal that we should recalibrate all our lenses in order to get good results with the mkIII even though we got great results from the exact same lenses with all of our previous bodies? for example, if i used my 500 F4 on 2 1DmkII, 3 1DmkIIn, 5D, 40D, 20D and got fantastic results with all of them, why should i send my lens or calibrate it just to get it to work with the mkIII? and what should i do if i shoot with both a mkIII and a mkIIn? and what are you going to do if you get a new lens, should you send your body and new lens to Canon every single time you get a new lens? what about all the people that rent long expensive lenses for events instead of buying, should they send those too or just calibrate them every single time they rent one?
Mar 07, 2008 at 03:51 PM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.9 #15So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Mike1 wrote:
geniousc wroteI am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.
Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309


Your tone is insulting. Glad you have a camera that works, want to trade your 1DMkIII for my 1DMkIII?
Mar 07, 2008 at 03:51 PM
Mike1
Offline
Details
p.9 #16So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
AJ Nadershahi wrote:
Mike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.
Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?


Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.


Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMT

Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 04:35 PM
Mar 07, 2008 at 04:16 PM
blonde
Offline
Details
p.9 #17So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Mike1 wrote:
AJ Nadershahi wrote
Mike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.
Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?
Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrate ed every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight
...Show more →

and you don't see anything wrong with that!??!?!?!?
Mar 07, 2008 at 04:19 PM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.9 #18So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
And this is acceptable?
Mar 07, 2008 at 04:26 PM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.9 #19So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I'm just trying to get my mind around this.

Seems odd that a manufacturer that designs and builds high tolerance gear used in chip manufacturing would produce (and find acceptable) such sloppy measurements.

I suppose they don't consider their consumer clients to be as critical as their business clients.

Mar 07, 2008 at 04:27 PM
Hatteras photo
Offline
Details
p.9 #20So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

Mike1 wrote

Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrate ed every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.



Why then was this a rarity before the 1D MIII and now is so comon
Mar 07, 2008 at 04:27 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister