fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

  
 
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.8 #1So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
My own experience based on several different bodies and lenses.

Few years ago using N80, (consumer grade film camera), I got caught in sudden storm during a long hike. By the time I make it to shelter the camera is dripping wet as I coudn't even attempt to protect it from the drenching downpour. Thought it was a done deal, but the darn thing still works last I used it a few weeks ago for nostalgia sake. (My F2AS has been going strong for well over 25 years.)

Several years later using a D70 (non sealed body) near a waterfall and loose my footing. Camera gets dunked in a pool of churning water as I try to grab anything nearby to keep from falling into the pile of stones 30 feet below. Camera still worked.

Another incident this time with D200 (semi-sealed) where an unexpected ocean surge drenched the gear in sea water, all of which continue to work to this day.

Luckily my newest assortment of gear hasn't yet encountered these types of scenarios, but based on my own experience I'm not worried about their reliability.

Seems there are positive and negative stories all around us.


Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 02:41 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 02:38 AM
xrayvision
Offline
Details
p.8 #2So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
WOW these canon executives are the most ingenious idiots I know.
They'll buy time and make people think their defective autofocus is OK by telling us they tested it and its the best ever.

More than ever now I will not put down my 8000 on the 1dsIII until it has been in wide circulation for at least 6 months with no autofocus problems. I really think it will be the mk IV release before these fools have an autofocus that works as it should.

I eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.

Guess you fixed me eh Canon??
Mar 07, 2008 at 06:53 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.8 #3So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
AJ Nadershahi wrote:
My own experience based on several different bodies and lenses.

Few years ago using N80, (consumer grade film camera), I got caught in sudden storm during a long hike. By the time I make it to shelter the camera is dripping wet as I coudn't even attempt to protect it from the drenching downpour. Thought it was a done deal, but the darn thing still works last I used it a few weeks ago for nostalgia sake. (My F2AS has been going strong for well over 25 years.)

Several years later using a D70 (non sealed body) near a
...Show more →

Note to self... remember to avoid buying a camera from AJ.


Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:03 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 07:03 AM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.8 #4So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Here's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to pass up. I bought an early model, and in fact it had jittery AF. I sent it to Canon, they fixed it, now it's awesome. No problem. Obviously this isn't an ideal scenario, but for me the trouble I went through was easily worth it. This camera rocks... But for people to bring up words such as "hate" when referring to a company or tool have obviously got bigger problems than choosing which camera to buy.

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 07:16 AM
CMOS
Offline
Details
p.8 #5So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
xrayvision wrote:
I eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.


1. Sony might have a body that can focus, but it sure doesn't have an 85 1.2L or an 35 1.4L.

2. You should sell on the Buy and Sell here, not fleabay.
Mar 07, 2008 at 08:25 AM
simonella_viru
Offline
Details
p.8 #6So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ChrisDM wrote:
Here's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to
...Show more →

Chris, with all due respect, i think you over-simplify. for instance, my vendor (B&H) will not take the 1d3 back. canon seems to drag their feet when it comes to repairing the 1d3. some users have reportedly sent their camera (and even lenses) back 2 or 3 times to get it fixed and they still have problems. selling, is not an option if your 1d3 sucks (if you're ethical) for self-explanatory reasons. so you're kinda stuck. and when you've been going through this dance for 6 months+, you really start to get peeved...

just thought i'd throw that out there.
Mar 07, 2008 at 08:32 AM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.8 #7So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
simonella_viru wrote:
ChrisDM wroteHere's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to pass up. I bought an early model, and in fact it had jittery AF. I sent it to Canon, they fixed it, now it's awesome. No problem. Obviously this isn't an ideal scenario, but for me the trouble I went through was easily worth it. This camera rocks... But for people to bring up words such as "hate" when referring to a company or tool have obviously got bigger problems than choosing which camera to buy.

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Chris, with all due respect, i think you over-simplify. for instance, my vendor (B&H) will not take the 1d3 back. canon seems to drag their feet when it comes to repairing the 1d3. some users have reportedly sent their camera (and even lenses) back 2 or 3 times to get it fixed and they still have problems. selling, is not an option if your 1d3 sucks (if you're ethical) for self-explanatory reasons. so you're kinda stuck. and when you've been going through this dance for 6 months+, you really start to get peeved...

just thought i'd throw that out there.


Well, I couldn't imagine a reputable dealer not accepting a return/exchange on a brand new camera, that sucks... But at least Canon is willing to fix it. They certainly nailed mine. And I know I'm not some mythical lucky minority. I shot a PGA tour event a few weeks ago where most pros were shooting snappy new Mk3s... But there were also a surprising number of D3's there, and even a Sony A700... I'm glad Canon is getting some competition now though, we will all benefit.

Tournament photos, some 1DMk3 some 1DsMk3:

http://www.pbase.com/chris_miller/buick_08


Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 08:48 AM
Wickedfn4u
Offline
Details
p.8 #8So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ChrisDM wrote:
Here's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to
...Show more →


That is not even worthy of a response, ok one what a joke!

Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 09:08 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:08 AM
xrayvision
Offline
Details
p.8 #9So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
CMOS wrote:
xrayvision wroteI eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.
1. Sony might have a body that can focus, but it sure doesn't have an 85 1.2L or an 35 1.4L.

2. You should sell on the Buy and Sell here, not fleabay.


The only thing that will guidemy decsion is the quality and performance of the Sony body. I doubt it will beat Canon. I hope it does though.
Ebay lets me get top dollar for my used equipment. The safeguards there have worked well for me so far.
Sony has an expanding selection of Zeiss glass which often trumps Canons offerings. Canon makes great glass no doubt. I love my 85 1.2. I just had to exchange the 35 1.4 (quickly) because it had an optical defect on arrival from the dealer. The 24-105 I have was quite noticably sharper at 35mm and 4.5! This quality control issue with Canon glass has hit me three times with $1000+ lenses
Zeiss has a solid decades long tradition of not shipping lens assembies with optical defects. Glass will be no problem for sony. Zeiss will assure that.
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:28 AM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.8 #10So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hrow wrote:
AJ Nadershahi wroteLuckily my newest assortment of gear hasn't yet encountered these types of scenarios, but based on my own experience I'm not worried about their reliability.

Seems there are positive and negative stories all around us.
Note to self... remember to avoid buying a camera from AJ.


No worries. I wouldn't sell gear without full disclosure.

Usually though I end up wearing out gear to the point it's better to donate than to try and sell it.
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:32 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #11So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
xrayvision wrote:
CMOS wrote
xrayvision wroteI eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.
1. Sony might have a body that can focus, but it sure doesn't have an 85 1.2L or an 35 1.4L.

2. You should sell on the Buy and Sell here, not fleabay.
The only thing that will guidemy decsion is the quality and performance of the Sony body. I doubt it will beat Canon. I hope it does though.
Ebay lets me get top dollar for my used equipment. The safeguards there have worked well for me so far.
Sony has an expanding selection of Zeiss glass which often trumps Canons offerings. Canon makes great glass no doubt. I love my 85 1.2. I just had to exchange the 35 1.4 (quickly) because it had an optical defect on arrival from the dealer. The 24-105 I have was quite noticably sharper at 35mm
...Show more →

i'll try to get this through to you the easy way. just because it says zeiss on it from sony doesn't make it a real zeiss. it is a zeiss design manufactured in japan. and so far the lenses they have been putting out have been less then stellar performers overall.
example: http://www.slrgear.com/reviews/showproduct.php/product/973/cat/83

on sonys video cameras today the top end no longer sports the zeiss logo. they now have it monikered fujinon one of the most used lenses in the video world. MARKETING!


Edited by sjms on Mar 07, 2008 at 10:49 AM GMT

Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 09:49 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:46 AM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.8 #12So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Wickedfn4u wrote:
ChrisDM wroteHere's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to pass up. I bought an early model, and in fact it had jittery AF. I sent it to Canon, they fixed it, now it's awesome. No problem. Obviously this isn't an ideal scenario, but for me the trouble I went through was easily worth it. This camera rocks... But for people to bring up words such as "hate" when referring to a company or tool have obviously got bigger problems than choosing which camera to buy.

Chris M

www.imagineimagery.com
That is not even worthy of a response, ok one what a joke!


This isn't dpreview, so please post useful insights or experience or move on. Thank you.
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:47 AM
James R
Offline
Details
p.8 #13So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
xrayvision wrote:
CMOS wrote
xrayvision wroteI eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.
1. Sony might have a body that can focus, but it sure doesn't have an 85 1.2L or an 35 1.4L.

2. You should sell on the Buy and Sell here, not fleabay.
The only thing that will guidemy decsion is the quality and performance of the Sony body. I doubt it will beat Canon. I hope it does though.
Ebay lets me get top dollar for my used equipment. The safeguards there have worked well for me so far.
Sony has an expanding selection of Zeiss glass which often trumps Canons offerings. Canon makes great glass no doubt. I love my 85 1.2. I just had to exchange the 35 1.4 (quickly) because it had an optical defect on arrival from the dealer. The 24-105 I have was quite noticably sharper at 35mm
...Show more →

It was explained to me that the lenses are Zeiss in name only and not actually manufactured by Zeiss under its high standards. Does anybody know if that is true?
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:47 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #14So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
James R wrote:
xrayvision wrote
CMOS wrote
xrayvision wroteI eagerly await reviews of the Sony cameras performance tests. Ebay is on standby for my Canon equipment.
1. Sony might have a body that can focus, but it sure doesn't have an 85 1.2L or an 35 1.4L.

2. You should sell on the Buy and Sell here, not fleabay.
The only thing that will guidemy decsion is the quality and performance of the Sony body. I doubt it will beat Canon. I hope it does though.
Ebay lets me get top dollar for my used equipment. The safeguards there have worked well for me so far.
Sony has an expanding selection of Zeiss glass which often trumps Canons offerings. Canon makes great glass no doubt. I love my 85 1.2. I just had to exchange the 35 1.4 (quickly) because it had an optical defect on arrival from the dealer. The 24-105 I have was quite noticably sharper at 35mm and 4.5! This quality control issue with Canon glass has hit me three times with $1000+ lenses
Zeiss has a solid decades long tradition of not shipping lens assembies with optical defects. Glass will be no problem for sony. Zeiss will assure that.
It was explained to me that the lenses are Zeiss in name only and not actually manufactured by Zeiss under its high standards. Does anybody know if that is true?


they are of a zeiss design within the parameters of sony. they are all manufactured in japan. its marketing my boy
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:51 AM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.8 #15So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
xrayvision wrote:
Sony has an expanding selection of Zeiss glass which often trumps Canons offerings. Canon makes great glass no doubt. I love my 85 1.2. I just had to exchange the 35 1.4 (quickly) because it had an optical defect on arrival from the dealer. The 24-105 I have was quite noticably sharper at 35mm and 4.5! This quality control issue with Canon glass has hit me three times with $1000+ lenses
Zeiss has a solid decades long tradition of not shipping lens assembies with optical defects. Glass will be no problem for sony. Zeiss will assure that.


I wouldn't count on that "Zeiss" logo on the Sony glass. And I certainly wouldn't mistake Sony "Zeiss" glass for the legendary true Zeiss distagons etc... And fortunately for us Canon shooters the old school, optically stunning true Zeiss glass is easily adaptable to our bodies...

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:52 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #16So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
fortunately for those of us that have nikon in addition to canon need not adaptorize. it just goes on as it should
Mar 07, 2008 at 09:59 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.8 #17So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ChrisDM wrote:
They certainly nailed mine. And I know I'm not some mythical lucky minority. I shot a PGA tour event a few weeks ago where most pros were shooting snappy new Mk3s... But there were also a surprising number of D3's there, and even a Sony A700... I'm glad Canon is getting some competition now though, we will all benefit.

Tournament photos, some 1DMk3 some 1DsMk3:

http://www.pbase.com/chris_miller/buick_08


Well Chris, you certainly don't appear to be in the 'mythical lucky minority'...

Buick08-Small-0028.jpg
Buick08-Small-0036.jpg
Buick08-Small-0049.jpg
Buick08-Small-0051.jpg

No, admittedly I don't have the luxury of full-res images to assess your editing and/or post-processing, but as I go through some of these images, I'd guess that either they were slight 'misses' that accidentally got left in, or your camera is indeed just like everyone else's: Not quite as good as the MkIIn's that preceded it.

-Jeff

PS: Just how 'new' were those "snappy new MkIII's" that all those pros were shooting with? Something tells me 'all those pros' get some benefits that we mere mortals aren't lucky enough to get...

Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 10:16 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 10:16 AM
ChrisDM
Offline
Details
p.8 #18So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Jeff wrote:
Well Chris, you certainly don't appear to be in the 'mythical lucky minority'...

Buick08-Small-0028.jpg
Buick08-Small-0036.jpg
Buick08-Small-0049.jpg
Buick08-Small-0051.jpg

No, admittedly I don't have the luxury of full-res images to assess your editing and/or post-processing, but as I go through some of these images, I'd guess that either they were slight 'misses' that accidentally got left in, or your camera is indeed just like everyone else's: Not quite as good as the MkIIn's that preceded it.

-Jeff

PS: Just how 'new' were those "snappy new MkIII's" that all those pros were shooting with? Something tells me 'all those pros' get some benefits that we mere mortals aren't lucky
...Show more →

Some were misses, and others were what I will call "spray focus", which my partner also experienced shooting his Mk3 at motocross events. The AF system picks up sand coming off the face of the club, or dirt off the wheel, etc, leaving the subject... I have since learned to compensate for this incredible sensitivity by shooting AI Focus mode or manual focus in these situations where possible.

And yes, most of us are CPS members, and I think we get a little priority. But of course you don't have to be a CPS member to get "the fix".

Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Mar 07, 2008 at 10:51 AM
72chevelle454
Offline
Details
p.8 #19So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Is this "Spray Focus" too..

I know exactly what your talking about Chris.

http://i.pbase.com/o6/35/679535/1/80633233.yCfzEjEU.NewFolder2RCC_0388.jpg
http://k43.pbase.com/o6/35/679535/1/80633235.5DrFrJdf.NewFolder2RCC_0396.jpg

Edited on Mar 07, 2008 at 10:57 AM
Mar 07, 2008 at 10:56 AM
Wickedfn4u
Offline
Details
p.8 #20So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ChrisDM wrote:
Wickedfn4u wrote
ChrisDM wroteHere's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.

Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to pass up. I bought an early model, and in fact it had jittery AF. I sent it to Canon, they fixed it, now it's awesome. No problem. Obviously this isn't an ideal scenario, but for me the trouble I went through was easily worth it. This camera rocks... But for people to bring up words such as "hate" when referring to a company or tool have obviously got bigger problems than choosing which camera to buy.

Chris M

www.imagineimagery.com
That is not even worthy of a response, ok one what a joke!
This isn't dpreview, so please post useful insights or experience or move on. Thank you.

So posting on to a thread about problems with a body stating that yours is fine and all others should be too is very useful insight. I bought mine from a local vendor and Dell they have been to canon 3 times now the 4th time have been asked to send my lenses in too. They will not replace they keep telling me they can fix it. You know what you cannot know the level of frustration people with the problem have faced. Simple, yes you are for missing the point not all bodies perform to a level not only expected but stated. So if your body works great move on but for ours that do not we do need support from each other to figure out what canon cannot. The last thing I need is someone who has not experienced the issues telling me what I should do.

And looking at those pictures say #28 that is very common with my results but a soccer or football player running at me with no "spray" excuse, target right on their chest. That type of picture cannot be turned in or sold and I have files full I have sent canon trying to resolve this.
Mar 07, 2008 at 11:46 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister