blonde wrote: Mike1 wrotegeniousc wroteI am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309ok, i have not used micro af adjustment at all. with that said, i do have a question for you: do you think that it is normal that we should recalibrate all our lenses in order to get good results with the mkIII even though we got great results from the exact same lenses with all of our previous bodies? for example, if i used my 500 F4 on 2 1DmkII, 3 1DmkIIn, 5D, 40D, 20D and got fantastic results with all of them, why should i send my lens or calibrate it just to get it to work with the mkIII? and what should i do if i shoot with both a mkIII and a mkIIn? and what are you going to do if you get a new lens, should you send your body and new lens to Canon every single time you get a new lens? what about all the people that rent long expensive lenses for events instead of buying, should they send those too or just calibrate them every single time they rent one? ...Show more →
Adding to my quote above. A camera is like a car, each and every one of them has its own characteristics, they will behave in a similar way, but no two will be exactly alike. Before I moved to Argentina, I made sure that CPS made sure that my lens are calibrated to the 40D 1st and the 1D3 2nd, with the 40D being the primary camera for the adjustments, then the Mark III. Any fine AF tuning can be done via the Mark III, you can't do it to the 40D, therefore the 40D is the primary camera used for calibration and 1D3 as secondary.
IMO Renting is scary, you don't know where it has been, what it has been used for, and what's wrong with it. It could be dropped a few times as far as I know. Owning your own lens is the best way because you know EXACTLY who, what, when and where it came from. Not only that, people have a tendency to be careless when the equipment is not theirs, plus their equipment insurance will cover what they use. I've seen the cameras & lens that have been coming in & out of the news room. At best, they become donations by the time they are retired. What I'm saying is that you know the lens that you owned inside & out. Renting or "checking out" the lens from work is a hit & miss for me, I would have to reserve it in advance and have it tested before I'm out on an assignment. If I just grab a lens from the rental place or work without checking it out 1st, I'm pretty much gambling with my job, and I don't think I'm crazy enough to risk that.
Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrate ed every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Why then was this a rarity before the 1D MIII and now is so comon ...Show more →
I guess quality is decreased as demands have increased. Look at how many DSLR owners have popped up since the 1st Digital Rebel. You, as a customer, have to be on the lookout for things like that. I've always had all of my lens in for calibration to the all of the new bodies I bought since the film days. Back then, there weren't as many "pro" cameras as there are now so they "had" more time to pay closer attention to quality. The Mark III was supposed to be a low production camera and the demand had exceeded the supply. Noticed the LONG waiting list for it after it came out, and the "fixed" ones just started to pop up now? Just ask ANY Leica (minus the M8 digital) or Lamborghini or Ferrari owners about quality and customer service. Now it's just crunching the numbers to meet the demands, not every lens or camera will get tested, but rather, random and like i said, it's just like rolling the dice and hope that your number comes up. Canon rushed the Mark III out of the factory to meet the demands. Think about Microsoft when Vista came out and the same with their XP operating system, which was not "fixed" until Sp1 a year later, then followed by a disasterous initial release of SP2.
Mike1 wrote: blonde wroteMike1 wrotegeniousc wroteI am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309ok, i have not used micro af adjustment at all. with that said, i do have a question for you: do you think that it is normal that we should recalibrate all our lenses in order to get good results with the mkIII even though we got great results from the exact same lenses with all of our previous bodies? for example, if i used my 500 F4 on 2 1DmkII, 3 1DmkIIn, 5D, 40D, 20D and got fantastic results with all of them, why should i send my lens or calibrate it just to get it to work with the mkIII? and what should i do if i shoot with both a mkIII and a mkIIn? and what are you going to do if you get a new lens, should you send your body and new lens to Canon every single time you get a new lens? what about all the people that rent long expensive lenses for events instead of buying, should they send those too or just calibrate them every single time they rent one?Adding to my quote above. A camera is like a car, each and every one of them has its own characteristics, they will behave in a similar way, but no two will be exactly alike. Before I moved to Argentina, I made sure that CPS made sure that my lens are calibrated to the 40D 1st and the 1D3 2nd, with the 40D being the primary camera for the adjustments, then the Mark III. Any fine AF tuning can be done via the Mark III, you can't do it to the 40D, therefore the 40D is the primary camera used for calibration and 1D3 as secondary.
IMO Renting is scary, you don't know where it has been, what it has been used for, and what's wrong with it. It could be dropped a few times as far as I know. Owning your own lens is the best way because you know EXACTLY who, what, when and where it came from. Not only that, people have a tendency to be careless when the equipment is not theirs, plus their equipment insurance will cover what they use. I've seen the cameras & lens that have been coming in & out of the news room. At best, they become donations by the time they are retired. What I'm saying is that you know the lens that you owned inside & out. Renting or "checking out" the lens from work is a hit & miss for me, I would have to reserve it in advance and have it tested before I'm out on an assignment. If I just grab a lens from the rental place or work without checking it out 1st, I'm pretty much gambling with my job, and I don't think I'm crazy enough to risk that. ...Show more →
ok, so you would be fine if your car only got 10mpg instead of the advertised 25mpg because "it has it's own character"?
blonde wrote: Mike1 wroteblonde wroteMike1 wrotegeniousc wroteI am on my second 1D3. The first one was returned because the camera was giving poor focus with a 300L that I have. The horror stories around here had me all revved up . The second one did the same thing with the same lens, long story short the lens needed calibration. There was nothing wrong with either camera. As a former owner of both a 1D2n and 1D2, I would put my current blue dot up against either one. It's the finest camera I have ever owned. This is a typical shot with the sun setting, lens most likely wide open, i'd have to look at the shot data to confirm, single point focusiing, no expansion.Thank you. I've had similar results with my Mark III as well. My lens are always sent in whenever I get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies. I just had this posted up to see what the other current 1D3 owners are REALLY doing before they started to cry "wolf" again. https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/623309ok, i have not used micro af adjustment at all. with that said, i do have a question for you: do you think that it is normal that we should recalibrate all our lenses in order to get good results with the mkIII even though we got great results from the exact same lenses with all of our previous bodies? for example, if i used my 500 F4 on 2 1DmkII, 3 1DmkIIn, 5D, 40D, 20D and got fantastic results with all of them, why should i send my lens or calibrate it just to get it to work with the mkIII? and what should i do if i shoot with both a mkIII and a mkIIn? and what are you going to do if you get a new lens, should you send your body and new lens to Canon every single time you get a new lens? what about all the people that rent long expensive lenses for events instead of buying, should they send those too or just calibrate them every single time they rent one?Adding to my quote above. A camera is like a car, each and every one of them has its own characteristics, they will behave in a similar way, but no two will be exactly alike. Before I moved to Argentina, I made sure that CPS made sure that my lens are calibrated to the 40D 1st and the 1D3 2nd, with the 40D being the primary camera for the adjustments, then the Mark III. Any fine AF tuning can be done via the Mark III, you can't do it to the 40D, therefore the 40D is the primary camera used for calibration and 1D3 as secondary.
IMO Renting is scary, you don't know where it has been, what it has been used for, and what's wrong with it. It could be dropped a few times as far as I know. Owning your own lens is the best way because you know EXACTLY who, what, when and where it came from. Not only that, people have a tendency to be careless when the equipment is not theirs, plus their equipment insurance will cover what they use. I've seen the cameras & lens that have been coming in & out of the news room. At best, they become donations by the time they are retired. What I'm saying is that you know the lens that you owned inside & out. Renting or "checking out" the lens from work is a hit & miss for me, I would have to reserve it in advance and have it tested before I'm out on an assignment. If I just grab a lens from the rental place or work without checking it out 1st, I'm pretty much gambling with my job, and I don't think I'm crazy enough to risk that.ok, so you would be fine if your car only got 10mpg instead of the advertised 25mpg because "it has it's own character"?
With the way I drive, yes, I would get 10 MPG on an advertised 25 MPG on the car...
Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrate ed every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Why then was this a rarity before the 1D MIII and now is so comon I guess quality is decreased as demands have increased. Look at how many DSLR owners have popped up since the 1st Digital Rebel. You, as a customer, have to be on the lookout for things like that. I've always had all of my lens in for calibration to the all of the new bodies I bought since the film days. Back then, there weren't as many "pro" cameras as there are now so they "had" time to pay closer attention to quality. The Mark III was supposed to be a low production camera and the demand has exceeded the supply. Noticed the LONG waiting list for it after it came out and the "fixed" ones just started to pop up now? Just ask ANY Leica (minus the M8 digital) or Lamborghini or Ferrari owners about quality and customer service. Now it's just crunching the numbers to meet the demands, not every lens will get tested, but rather, random and like i said, it's just like rolling the dice and hope that your number comes up. ...Show more →
and again, does this seem right or normal to you? do you think that it is ok that we should "roll the dice and hope that our numbers come up" when i pay $4500 for something?
btw, i shipped a lens today that i sold to somebody and it cost me $40 to ship it UPS ground. do you honestly think that i can afford to ship $15k worth of gear to Canon every single time i buy a new lens or body?
quite frankly, all you are doing right now is reinforcing what some of us have been saying all along: canon not only screwed up the mkIII but they also showed just how much they suck as a company.
Have you heard about photographers who used to get a blue dot version of the 1D Mark3, meaning a replacement instead of repair?
We all know now that the 1D Mrk3 have serious and bad AF issues.
Why some cameras have been repaired and some others( few I guess) replaced?
Few people on another US forum had the chance to get a new one!
Why not all of us?
IMO opinion, Canon should replace all the "disfonctionnl" bodies for new blue dot ones.
Here in Montreal I paid 5500$CAN. And if I add the taxes, it went up to 6200$.
I'm probably one of those who pays the most for it.
Mike1 wrote: AJ Nadershahi wroteMike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMT...Show more →
Mike1, I must say that I am flabbergasted that anyone would think having to go through 5 or 6 lenses AND THEN send that lens into Canon for calibration was acceptable so I'll assume you are just playing around. If you aren't and think this is normal, then the folks where you buy your stuff must have some really nasty names that they call you behind your back.
Hrow wrote: Mike1 wroteAJ Nadershahi wroteMike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMTMike1, I must say that I am flabbergasted that anyone would think having to go through 5 or 6 lenses AND THEN send that lens into Canon for calibration was acceptable so I'll assume you are just playing around. If you aren't and think this is normal, then the folks where you buy your stuff must have some really nasty names that they call you behind your back.
I always do that, this has been a common practice for me, choosing the least of the evils, and no, the store that I buy my equipment from is fine with that. In fact, I know ALL of the guys in the camera dept, including the general manager. They know that I will be back if the equipment that I bought does not work. Doing it on the spot saves me & them a lot of headaches of doing the returns &exchanges. I'm not the only one that goes to that store & do that, there are others. This is why i would rather pay more from a local store over the internet; A++ customer service.
Mike1 wrote: Hrow wroteMike1 wroteAJ Nadershahi wroteMike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMTMike1, I must say that I am flabbergasted that anyone would think having to go through 5 or 6 lenses AND THEN send that lens into Canon for calibration was acceptable so I'll assume you are just playing around. If you aren't and think this is normal, then the folks where you buy your stuff must have some really nasty names that they call you behind your back.I always do that, this has been a common practice for me, choosing the least of the evils, and no, the store that I buy my equipment from is fine with that. In fact, I know ALL of the guys in the camera dept, including the general manager. They know that I will be back if the equipment that I bought does not work. Doing it on the spot saves me & them a lot of headaches of doing the returns &exchanges. I'm not the only one that goes to that store & do that, there are others. This is why i would rather pay more from a local store over the internet; A++ customer service....Show more →
"choosing the least of the evils", i can't believe that you are willing to accept having to choose the least of the evils when buying such expensive items. i guess we all have different standards and expectations but at least it explains how you are ok with this whole mkIII thing...
Hrow wrote: Mike1 wroteAJ Nadershahi wroteMike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMTMike1, I must say that I am flabbergasted that anyone would think having to go through 5 or 6 lenses AND THEN send that lens into Canon for calibration was acceptable so I'll assume you are just playing around. If you aren't and think this is normal, then the folks where you buy your stuff must have some really nasty names that they call you behind your back.
I think what Mike1 is trying to tell you is that everything has tolerances and in fact it does. The camera is made in one factory, the lens in another, they meet up in USA. So you are expecting everything to be right on to the millimeter and you don't want to pay very much for it yet your looking for world class precision. And you want availability all over the world?Think about it, no way is this going to happen because there are tolerances. Not with Canon, not with Nikon, not with anybody. JMO Why do think all the new Nikons have microfocus adjustments? Because all of their lenses are right on? No way!
JeanYves Ahern wrote:
Have you heard about photographers who used to get a blue dot version of the 1D Mark3, meaning a replacement instead of repair?
We all know now that the 1D Mrk3 have serious and bad AF issues.
Why some cameras have been repaired and some others( few I guess) replaced?
Few people on another US forum had the chance to get a new one!
Why not all of us?
IMO opinion, Canon should replace all the "disfonctionnl" bodies for new blue dot ones.
Here in Montreal I paid 5500$CAN. And if I add the taxes, it went up to 6200$.
I'm probably one of those who pays the most for it.
Canon may have to do just that as many pros are starting to get restless. Here is a post from Sportsshooter.com on Canon's recent PR release about the 1D3. Robert Hanishiro seems to be making the switch to the D3. He is a long time Canon shooter who founded Sportsshooter.com.
geniousc wrote: Hrow wroteMike1 wroteAJ Nadershahi wroteMike1 wroteI get a new body for a calibration to the new bodies.Are you suggesting it is normal (and expected) to have to send your gear in for calibration due to sloppy tolerances during manufacturing and assembly?Yes, because of Canon's QC's definition of "acceptable" focus. I've spoken to Canon's technicians, not customer reps and was told that it's around +/-8. If your camera was a +3 and the lens is -2, it's fine, but if your camera is a +3 and the lens is +8, you're pretty much in need of a calibration. I had to go through about 5-6 different 24-105 at the local store before I choose the best one. So yes, it is normal to have it calibrated every time you get a new body unless you can live with the slight differences.
Edited by Mike1 on Mar 07, 2008 at 07:35 PM GMTMike1, I must say that I am flabbergasted that anyone would think having to go through 5 or 6 lenses AND THEN send that lens into Canon for calibration was acceptable so I'll assume you are just playing around. If you aren't and think this is normal, then the folks where you buy your stuff must have some really nasty names that they call you behind your back.I think what Mike1 is trying to tell you is that everything has tolerances and in fact it does. The camera is made in one factory, the lens in another, they meet up in USA. So you are expecting everything to be right on to the millimeter and you don't want to pay very much for it yet your looking for world class precision. And you want availability all over the world?Think about it, no way is this going to happen because there are tolerances. Not with Canon, not with Nikon, not with anybody. JMO Why do think all the new Nikons have microfocus adjustments? Because all of their lenses are right on? No way! ...Show more →
so again let me ask you: is this the first camera that canon has ever designed and built? because i for one, don't remember having to send all my lenses when i bought my 15 previous cameras...
geniousc wrote:
I think what Mike1 is trying to tell you is that everything has tolerances and in fact it does. The camera is made in one factory, the lens in another, they meet up in USA. So you are expecting everything to be right on to the millimeter and you don't want to pay very much for it yet your looking for world class precision. And you want availability all over the world?Think about it, no way is this going to happen because there are tolerances. Not with Canon, not with Nikon, not with anybody. JMO Why do think all the new Nikons have microfocus adjustments? Because all of their lenses are right on? No way! ...Show more →
Biggest bunch of crock I've recently had the pleasure to read in these forums.
Yes, I am expecting tolerances to be within reasonable limits so that you don't have to receive your new camera and lens, then promptly ship them to a service center to have them brought up to usable levels. (I feel silly just typing this scenario!)
Isn't that what production technology and computer controlled production is supposed to allow? Are we making progess or taking steps backwards?
Isn't that what production technology and computer controlled production is supposed to allow? Are we making progess or taking steps backwards?
Well if I do as everyone suggest and go back to my M2, I think that would be doing the moon walk a few steps.
Edited by Wickedfn4u on Mar 07, 2008 at 10:23 PM GMT
Hrow wrote:
Me thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters.
I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.
Tom_W wrote: Hrow wroteMe thinks we have some folks from Canon's PR department trolling around these waters. I'm pretty certain that they're around, but probably not the ones that we think are them. I suspect more reading and less posting. If they want to get a feel for this part of the market.
If their PR dept was here, they'd be squashing the vocal opponents by FIXING their problems. I doubt they are here.. And I think the arrogance is over the top with their latest statement.
ChrisDM wrote:
Here's the bottom line on this camera, plain and simple (perhaps too simple for some of the dramatic doomsdayers to accept): Does the 1DMk3 have features you must have? Well then, you're in luck because there are obviously great working bodies out there. Take advantage of either Canon's warranty or a reputable dealer's exchange policy until you get a good one... Or, you can live without the features of the new 1DMk3? Even better still. Go shoot with your old Mk2 or buy a Nikon. End of discussion, problem solved.
Personally, the high ISO performance was too good for me to pass up. I bought an early model, and in fact it had jittery AF. I sent it to Canon, they fixed it, now it's awesome. No problem. Obviously this isn't an ideal scenario, but for me the trouble I went through was easily worth it. This camera rocks... But for people to bring up words such as "hate" when referring to a company or tool have obviously got bigger problems than choosing which camera to buy.
So see my post above about Canon breaking a working M3. What are your thoughts on that?
Also, what are your thoughts on those that have sent theirs in SEVERAL TIMES to be fixed only to get them back worse than before?
You speak as if your experience is how it is for everyone. It most obviously is not the case. If things were so cut and dry as you put it, there would be no reason for anyone to discuss this. Very easy to throw suggestions when you're not the one experiencing the issue.
Also, I am not quite certain where you get off judging people and making statements about their "bigger problems". Why not keep your opinions to yourself if you have nothing constructive to add or do you just get off on gloating about your camera? If the latter is the case, I'd take your last statement and apply it to yourself.
There is a difference having a working camera and having an intelligent discussion with those that are experiencing problems. You can be constructive and try and help. Just throwing out random stats about things being overblown, etc..dismissing ones frustrations and so forth is a waste of your time and we'd all be better off without it. IMHO.