mill4570 wrote:
You will not have to go back in history very far to find some very disgruntled people in the Nikon camp because of their service and atttitude towards their customers. Most of this is the Japanese culture I believe. I don't excuse Canon's behavior but it will not get better at Nikon.
Now, after you mentioned it, I remembered that, too. I was not a Nikon shooter back then and so, I didn't experience it first hand but I read about the complaints quite a bit....
I switched from Zorki RF to Canon many moons ago.
Don't know about Zorki's lens quality and copy variation...the only Zorki lens I had was inextricably seized on the camera.
What is sad is that corporate culture is so bad that really going Nikon or Canon doesn't make enough of a difference to either company. They are concerned with you up until the point of profitability. Canon has released a defective product, but instead of offering any unsatisfied user a refund they ignore the issue. Better to save money and pretend it never happend because they know that even if they lose a 1000 users it won't make a big enough difference.
Someone actuary or accountant has determined the risk and obviously the customer lost. Hard to say if profits and thus the continuation of a company is good or bad. I would like to think great service is more important but I am clearly wrong. Too many very large companies with very poor service prove that to me.
Iberian wrote:
Canon has released a defective product, but instead of offering any unsatisfied user a refund they ignore the issue.
No offense but I sure don't agree with that statement. There is a "recall", as you know. They may have not responded as fast as we would like them to respond but they did not ignore the issue. Where did you get that information?
You will not have to go back in history very far to find some very disgruntled people in the Nikon camp because of their service and atttitude towards their customers. Most of this is the Japanese culture I believe. I don't excuse Canon's behavior but it will not get better at Nikon.
No doubt that Canon is not the only company to have stumbled - The key is how they handle things moving forward. So far one year since the start of this MKIII issue and users are still complaining.
Nikon seems to have learned valuable lessons from prior mistakes as evidenced with how they have handled their most recent matters such as; D2h metering issue, D70 focus issues and circuit board failures (BGLOD), as well as D200 cameras that exhibited problems with banding. In each instance Nikon acknowledged and found a solid fix within a short time, and communicated their actions in a clear and concise manner. To this day they continue to honor repair requests even if the camera is out of warranty.
The way I see it Canon still has some issues they need to resolve to prevent further erosion of their reputation.
Edited by AJ Nadershahi on Mar 06, 2008 at 08:10 PM GMT
mill4570 wrote:
Henry's camera is broken, plain and simple.....it will be replaced but unfortunately not as quickly as he would like. Henry also shot a working MKIII as a loaner....if that camera did not work to his satisfaction, then no MkIII is going to.
Richard K.
Richard K.
Respectfully, I disagree. The loaner was marginal and clearly outclassed by my old 20D when using zooms. It too had a problem unless I am being unreasonable in my expectation that the 1DMkIII should perform at least at a 20D level. At this point I would be OK with an Mk3 that focused as well as my 20D and that doesn't strike me as a very high standard.
Hrow wrote:
Respectfully, I disagree. The loaner was marginal and clearly outclassed by my old 20D when using zooms. It too had a problem unless I am being unreasonable in my expectation that the 1DMkIII should perform at least at a 20D level. At this point I would be OK with an Mk3 that focused as well as my 20D and that doesn't strike me as a very high standard.
Henry, I don't think you're being unreasonable at all.
Having moved from a 20D to MkIII myself just two weeks ago I can say there is a distinct difference. Settling for a MkIII that is on par with a 20D would be wrong, and utterly unacceptable.
icandyimages wrote:
here's a link I came across someone posting samples of their 1D Mark III and Nikon D3 http://www.pbase.com/hildrup/07q4
As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.
I went to the said link. I was looking at the thumbs and wondered where the nikon images started. I knew immediately from the over saturated blue and red that was one reason I switched to canon
MedHead wrote:
Wicked, I'd rather not voyage into analogies. My point is simple, and you're free to disagree with it: if I were to be able to own an MKII, and decided to purchase an MKIII, only to find out it was defective, I would not move to Nikon. Instead, I would just go back to my MKII, because it performed admirably, and fulfilled my needs up until I suddenly "realized" they didn't because Canon told me the MKIII was what I should buy. I wouldn't be pleased with Canon, but I certainly wouldn't believe that a bad attitude from Canon would make my MKII explode or suddenly take bad pictures.
I marvel at the attitude amongst people who have been long-time users of their current camera, who, upon the release of a new product, suddenly believe their current camera is anathema. That's what I've been seeing with the MKIII: long-time Canon fans, including those who seemed happy with their MKII Ns, suddenly leaving to Nikon because the latest-and-greatest from Canon didn't please them. If someone doesn't have a bunch of lens purchase, I can understand the fickle attitude: but when someone has invested so much money into the company, I would think a little clearer head would be expected.
I get what you're saying, and I am in no way trying to claim Canon is in the right. I merely don't understand what appears to me to be a knee-jerk reaction....Show more →
So tell me... What do you say to those of us that HAD a great working Mark III for 6months... Sold their Mark IIN due to this... Then had Canon service the body only to royally mess up the AF with their "submirror FIX"... A second return to Irvine, CA has rendered better results, but not without a lot of user calibration and it certainly doesn't outperform my Mark IIN with AF consistency.
So again, what do you say to those that HAD a good one, sold the old one due to that, then had CANON BREAK the new one? I am NOT alone in this as I have had NUMEROUS inquiries about the EXACT same problem from other shooters. Basically, VA messing their cameras up via the submirror recall. It is not an isolated incident regardless of what some may think.
I understand that you are trying to make a point in general. But until you have sat in the shoes of those that actually own this expensive piece of gear and expect the company to take care of it's working pros, discounting another's feelings on the subject is somewhat shallow and without much substance as far as I am concerned.
BTW: Yes, I have backup bodies, but not another backup 1 series..
Think I am going to stop reading this thread now. This kind of stuff drives me crazy. Those that don't have problems preaching to those that do... I was on the "no problem" side for quite awhile, and after being a victim of Canon Service, I have an appreciation of those on the "problem" side. There is a real and valid reason for frustration and anger about this situation.
Apdieb, you know it is funny, I use to hate when you commented in the thread how yours was fine and though you never poo poo'd the ones with problems I never understood how or why you would comment in these threads. After the "fix" you now had a seat in our stadium and understood our pain. Trying to convey this to the company that it is not right and it is not just a few. Even if it was canon should make them work as promised. I am so glad yours is better but you should never have to do what we have done or tried to get them to just perform.
Thanks for your statement and none have been so true. to you!
hhski wrote: icandyimages wrote:
here's a link I came across someone posting samples of their 1D Mark III and Nikon D3 http://www.pbase.com/hildrup/07q4
As I was looking through those, I immediately thought the top half of pictures looked better, more colour and contrast, with a nicer, smoother tone. Then I realized they were the 1D MK3 pictures! The quality is close, but the D3 images do look a little "plasticky" a term I hear a lot about the D3 output. The reds look especially bad to me.
I went to the said link. I was looking at the thumbs and wondered where the nikon images started. I knew immediately from the over saturated blue and red that was one reason I switched to canon...Show more →
You've fallen into the same trap of basing your assumption by viewing low res jpeg images on a web site without knowing the camera settings that were used with each body.
I held off going to Nikon after a filed report showed several failed in the snow ~~~ Canon were always more rugged ... but I want a better MKIII ~~ as least as good as my MKIIn.
My fixed MKIII is overall better than my MKIIn ~ except in sport, The irony is I am actually getting more hits with the three but losing the peak of action and missing solo charges.
Seems like Canon are doing a Pontius Pilate with this statement .......
Wickedfn4u wrote:
Apdieb, you know it is funny, I use to hate when you commented in the thread how yours was fine and though you never poo poo'd the ones with problems I never understood how or why you would comment in these threads. After the "fix" you now had a seat in our stadium and understood our pain. Trying to convey this to the company that it is not right and it is not just a few. Even if it was canon should make them work as promised. I am so glad yours is better but you should never have to do what we have done or tried to get them to just perform.
Thanks for your statement and none have been so true. to you!...Show more →
Thank you...I appreciate that a lot.
Originally, I just wanted to show that there were some working bodies out there...As I think, in general, those that do not have problems rarely talk about it... I had absolutely no doubt some had issues and I felt it worthy of discussion from a differing point of view. Having now endured the "pure joy" of the problem...It is certainly enlightening and a reality check on how others have felt. I feel it incumbent upon myself to comment seeing that I have been on both sides...
Passing judgment on someone via a forum is not something that amounts to much in my opinion. Thick skin and understanding that forums are pretty much forms of anonymous communication are what keeps me coming back.
The fact that the Internet allows some people to play the superior knowledge card behind the keyboard and/or by signing up under handles or even multiple aliases will probably never keep me away, but will also never cease to annoy me either.
Here's to hoping everyone will get to a happy place with their Mark III's...Not likely, but worth a little semi-positive attitude at this late hour.
Succinctly put ... when Nikon did that to me ... I joined Canon ~ about 5 years ago now. Something has changed in Canon, I posted before that Nikon sacked their boss and Canon hired him ... only explanation IMPOV.
AJ Nadershahi wrote:
MedHead, either you're avoiding the main point being made, or simply not paying attention to it.
These people are stating they have lost faith in Canon due to failure with their service center and the way the corporation as a whole has been handling this issue by blaming the photographer or repeatedly claiming they have found a fix, when this hasn't been the case.
To some people these issues are as much, if not more, important than the quality/quantity of equipment the company has to offer.
gbee wrote:
I held off going to Nikon after a filed report showed several failed in the snow ...
You made up your mind based on one report from a photographer that kept taking camera bodies from a warm humid area to a cold outdoor environment without regard to condensation. And when the first one failed, he repeated this antic on consecutive bodies. Yet oddly enough there haven't been any other such reports before or since.
apdieb wrote:
The fact that the Internet allows some people to play the superior knowledge card behind the keyboard and/or by signing up under handles or even multiple aliases will probably never keep me away, but will also never cease to annoy me either.
It's always good to see some humor in ones own comments apdieb, eh?
January: Assignment to shoot the special needs children in their therapy pool to launch their annual fund-raiser. D1x - dies. D100 actually gets the shots but is badly fogged.
Next morning D1x is alive again but my lens in dead. Water damaged and is dumped.
For all my swimming pool assignments I have to have the people ready and waiting, I run in and get a quick snap and out. I kid you not.
Next January: same assignment with a 1D and 70~200 IS L ~ no fogging even after loitering in the pool area. Next swimming pool, 1D, 16~35mm lens and EX550 actually goes under the surface, was trying to get a very low angle of kids playing when some idiot says splash the photographer. I actually fire underwater and come up firing, five years on and I still have all this gear and it still works.
It was sadly the last time my D100 saw action, it was over my shoulder and was just splashed over ~~~ fzz.
That's my own personal experience. I'd have expected Nikon to have implemented their weather sealing to at least the same extent. My Nikon colleagues using the D3 do not consider it a weather sealed camera and always use a hood.
AJ Nadershahi wrote: gbee wroteI held off going to Nikon after a filed report showed several failed in the snow ...You made up your mind based on one report from a photographer that kept taking camera bodies from a warm humid area to a cold outdoor environment without regard to condensation. And when the first one failed, he repeated this antic on consecutive bodies. Yet oddly enough there haven't been any other such reports before or since.
Seems it would do everyone some good to step back and take a broader view of things. These forums can certainly create their own version of reality. ...Show more →