MedHead wrote:
The "jump ship" folks just seem more focused on buying gear than taking photographs, and that attitude seemed prevalent to me with this thread. It was like they were looking for an excuse to proclaim their departure from the brand.
That is an extremely derisive generalization that is in no way borne out by the data, at least here at FM.com. Many of us who contemplate dumping Canon gear do so for very real reasons, yet don't take the decision lightly. Loss of money in the exchange, loss of productivity getting up to speed with a new system, loss of time making the transition.
Having been one of the ones to get a 'bad' MkIII which was recently replaced by Canon with a 'good' MkIII (which still has its share of issues, and I'm confident is representative of the current cameras coming off the line), if given the opportunity for a full refund, I'd take it in a second. I'd love to be afforded the luxury of sitting back and watching what happens over the next few months, and having my $4500 investment back, which is only worth $3500 now. Our 'choice is only clear' if we get a full refund.
As for backing up to a 30D (or whatever), there are reasons that I upgraded my 1Ds to the 1D MkIII, and there are reasons that I upgraded my 30D to a 40D. Just because those cameras 'still took pictures' doesn't mean that they suited my needs. Suggesting that MkIII users downgrade to 2+ year old technology is not a reasonable solution for those relying on the equipment for a business.
mill4570 wrote:
The camera is tax deductible, and I have found areas where I can use it without worry. Canon has paid for all shipping and repairs to the camera so far, and although I don't believe it is completely fixed, it is not hurting my reputation as a photographer. If it did, that would be my fault not Canon's. Canon is responsible for providing me the camera described in their Whitepaper / Press Release.....the one I paid for.
And paid a $500 'upgrade' in price, to boot! Now that I have a recent iteration of the MkIII, I agree with the above. It is usable for 90%+ of what I shoot, the problem is I cannot predict when the AF is likely to take a siesta.
From my new BD MkIII, two pictures that I believe any 'working' 1D MkIII could have produced, under an as-yet-undetermined set of circumstances:
R Longenbach wrote:
Jeff, those pics are from your BD? wow. Very similar to my current results.
Yes Roger, but they are very infrequent compared to 'the lemon', and I currently suspect (nothing more) that it has something to do with the angle and/or quality of the light. The altitudes at which I use my equipment is from 5000-14000' MSL, and atmospheric conditions can be very different up here (especially in regard to IR light).
LIke I said, this only happens very infrequently now, but I cannot predict when it is likely to occur, which is a potential problem for non-personal shooting. These are gross focusing errors to which user error cannot be assigned; there is still something wrong with the way the system functions, and now having a camera that 'works' most of the time, I can fully understand why many people think their camera works for the types of shooting that they do, only to find out later that there is indeed a problem (reflected by the anecdotal evidence of many posted here and on other forums). I fully believe that my camera is representative of all 'working' MkIIIs out there, as well as RG's recent test cameras. 90%+ of the time the results are stellar, but when it misses, it misses big, with no apparent reason. FWIW, that first shot of the skier was representative of a sequence of 20+ shots where the camera was simply incapable of attaining proper focus, despite repeated attempts to re-focus.
As I've said before, and despite Canon's recent protestations to the contrary while fully admitting that they "continue to investigate", this isn't over yet...
In my opinion, Canon has not yet provided the "press release" camera I paid for. I believe Canon Engineers also believe the camera has not lived up to their expectations. Corporate "talking heads" aside, I believe Canon's Engineering Group is still looking at the MKIII. I believe it was developed to out perform the IIN in "every" test of AF and IQ, not just some.
My previous post was not aimed at giving Canon a pass on the MKIII. By any standard, Canon has fumbled the ball with this one. I am saying that images sent to a client are my responsibility, not Canon's.
As for the rush to Australia.....don't think for one minute those guys only brought MKIII bodies with them to that event. They had a backup plan and bodies.
In my opinion, Canon has not yet provided the "press release" camera I paid for. I believe Canon Engineers also believe the camera has not lived up to their expectations. Corporate "talking heads" aside, I believe Canon's Engineering Group is still looking at the MKIII. I believe it was developed to out perform the IIN in "every" test of AF and IQ, not just some.
My previous post was not aimed at giving Canon a pass on the MKIII. By any standard, Canon has fumbled the ball with this one. I am saying that images sent to a client are my responsibility, not Canon's.
As for the rush to Australia.....don't think for one minute those guys only brought MKIII bodies with them to that event. They had a backup plan and bodies.
There is always a work-around. Some use the Mk IIn. I bought a D3 for its higher ISO performance and use my MK III as a second body. Note that, for low light, RG says that the Mk III is the king. My, un-repaired, early Sn# Mk III has always AFed well in dim light.
I caution anyone from making a decision to buy a $4/5K body by viewing, "someone's," JPEGs. Rent a camera and shoot RAW under your own conditions. My experience is that, with ACR and ISO 1600 or less, that D3 and Mk III landscapes look much the same when processed identically in ACR.
But my D3 NEFs look better at 6400 than my MkIII's CR2s at 3200 while shooting my dancers-with the IQ edge to the D3. But I can get most any look from ACR with either camera. So I am keeping my many Canon lenses while waiting for Canon's next shoe to drop.
SoundHound wrote:
There is always a work-around. Some use the Mk IIn. I bought a D3 for its higher ISO performance and use my MK III as a second body. Note that, for low light, RG says that the Mk III is the king. My, un-repaired, early Sn# Mk III has always AFed well in dim light.
I caution anyone from making a decision to buy a $4/5K body by viewing, "someone's," JPEGs. Rent a camera and shoot RAW under your own conditions.
I completely agree. I usually go through about 3-4 lens with the same body at the store after paying for my camera. Bringing a laptop & a card reader at the store helps a lot. If it does not live up to my expectations, I would just simply ask for an exchange on the spot.
Hrow, I understand what you're saying, but it still doesn't fully compute with me. It would appear you saw a reason to begin purchasing Canon products. You saw value in the body you own(ed). Why then, when a newer model comes out, do so many people suddenly *seem* to consider their current camera a worthless piece of technology, when it has been providing great pictures?
Jeff, regardless of how it's taken, that's how I often perceive the comments on this forum when someone decides to switch. It's coming from my admittedly short experience with photography, but my long experience with forum users. People like to be dramatic online, and this forum is at times, no exception. The "taking my toys and going home" approach rarely seems to me to be from someone of a level head, but rather from someone with the flair for the dramatic. Again, that's my perception, and I apologize if you were offended from my opinion. I just can't find the decision to switch because of one camera body to be a sensible move.
MedHead, If I could take the financial hit and make the switch I probably would look at/ test the D3. I love and have loved my canon gear up to now, but I get no support from them. When I bought my bodies upgrading from M2's and came to them and said something is wrong I was told it was me and how I was using them. All along I am sure they knew there was a problem as they admitted it to RG when he got his first test of the pre production M3. I would have much more respect and confidence in the company if they had said we know and will find the fix, I would and did end up waiting for that to happen. My newer BD bodies do function way better than the non-BD but still only if at best equal to my M2's. Going back wards does not make any sense at all. If I bought a bum Chev PU and they could not make it better why would I go buy an older one when Ford has a new model that does everything I need it to do for work and far better than a 2004? Canon does not own me I own Canon and if they cannot live up to their commitments it is my business to do the best for me. Jumping for one model may not make sense but if they see my value as customer in this light (sending out an it's all OK cuz we say so even though it is not) then I need someone that will be backing me up or looking out for my best interest when I buy or use their products.
Wickedfn4u wrote:
MedHead, If I could take the financial hit and make the switch I probably would look at/ test the D3. I love and have loved my canon gear up to now, but I get no support from them. When I bought my bodies upgrading from M2's and came to them and said something is wrong I was told it was me and how I was using them. All along I am sure they knew there was a problem as they admitted it to RG when he got his first test of the pre production M3. I would have much more respect and confidence in the company if they had said we know and will find the fix, I would and did end up waiting for that to happen. My newer BD bodies do function way better than the non-BD but still only if at best equal to my M2's. Going back wards does not make any sense at all. If I bought a bum Chev PU and they could not make it better why would I go buy an older one when Ford has a new model that does everything I need it to do for work and far better than a 2004? Canon does not own me I own Canon and if they cannot live up to their commitments it is my business to do the best for me. Jumping for one model may not make sense but if they see my value as customer in this light (sending out an it's all OK cuz we say so even though it is not) then I need someone that will be backing me up or looking out for my best interest when I buy or use their products....Show more →
i know you can't see it but i can promise you that i am clapping right now you said exactly what i wanted to say and summed up my feelings perfectly.
Wicked, I'd rather not voyage into analogies. My point is simple, and you're free to disagree with it: if I were to be able to own an MKII, and decided to purchase an MKIII, only to find out it was defective, I would not move to Nikon. Instead, I would just go back to my MKII, because it performed admirably, and fulfilled my needs up until I suddenly "realized" they didn't because Canon told me the MKIII was what I should buy. I wouldn't be pleased with Canon, but I certainly wouldn't believe that a bad attitude from Canon would make my MKII explode or suddenly take bad pictures.
I marvel at the attitude amongst people who have been long-time users of their current camera, who, upon the release of a new product, suddenly believe their current camera is anathema. That's what I've been seeing with the MKIII: long-time Canon fans, including those who seemed happy with their MKII Ns, suddenly leaving to Nikon because the latest-and-greatest from Canon didn't please them. If someone doesn't have a bunch of lens purchase, I can understand the fickle attitude: but when someone has invested so much money into the company, I would think a little clearer head would be expected.
I get what you're saying, and I am in no way trying to claim Canon is in the right. I merely don't understand what appears to me to be a knee-jerk reaction.
You really are missing the point. I did not say that my M2 stopped taking pictures. I am looking to take better, faster, lower light or whatever pictures I can and this camera was suppose to help in that. Technology advances it is not suppose to go back wards. I do not want to go back to, I want to improve on and a M2 does not do that. What then are my options stick with the M3 or look at something else. Again I own canon they don't own me.
It is not really a knee jerk reaction, I have been batteling this for almost a year now. I get asked a lot why I went with Canon, and my answer is that is where my glass is invested. If I were to start again to day, I would look at both Nikon and Canon and see who had the best bang for the buck. Now maybe that start is here.
MedHead, either you're avoiding the main point being made, or simply not paying attention to it.
These people are stating they have lost faith in Canon due to failure with their service center and the way the corporation as a whole has been handling this issue by blaming the photographer or repeatedly claiming they have found a fix, when this hasn't been the case.
To some people these issues are as much, if not more, important than the quality/quantity of equipment the company has to offer.
Wickedfn4u has nailed it. You are missing the point. You are assuming that people ran out and bought a 1DMkIII because it was the latest and greatest. What you are failing to recognize is that many people bought it for specific reasons and purposes.
For my purposes I need a camera that is weather sealed, has pro level AF, has great ISO performance, is no more than a 1.3x crop, does 5+ FPS, has a VF that I can manually focus easily and that doesn't cost $8,000. Until the 1DMkIII came along the only camera that met those requirement was the MkII - which as I said earlier, I really didn't care for.
The only cameras that currently met those requirements are the 1DMkIII and the D3.
The 20D had not been meeting my needs for some time and I played the waiting game for some time. To go back to playing that waiting game in the hopes that the next camera they release is better means going back to a camera that wasn't meeting my needs. That doesn't make much sense as was proven to me this week when I shot the Philadelphia Flower Show using my 20D. One day with the camera reminded me why I upgraded. It is not that it is a bad camera, it just isn't designed to do what I want it to do.
BTW... if you are wondering why haven't I switched yet it is because Nikon doesn't have a good option for a lightweight, affordable pro-quality 300mm with VR. I rely on my 300mm F4 IS so losing that lens in particular is a big deal to me which makes the decision process tough.
You will not have to go back in history very far to find some very disgruntled people in the Nikon camp because of their service and atttitude towards their customers. Most of this is the Japanese culture I believe. I don't excuse Canon's behavior but it will not get better at Nikon.
As far as fixing the problem....I believe Canon has fixed one issue with the camera, although I believe there are still some unresolved problems. If you go back through this thread, the number of people who actually own the MKIII and are dissatisfied with it can be counted on one hand. (After repair or BD)
Henry's camera is broken, plain and simple.....it will be replaced but unfortunately not as quickly as he would like. Henry also shot a working MKIII as a loaner....if that camera did not work to his satisfaction, then no MkIII is going to. His choices are switch to Nikon or play the waiting game. Some MkIII cameras are just plain bad actors. The service center can not fix them, but they have guidelines to follow, a pain in the ass for sure. I feel bad for anyone who owns a $4500 camera that can't take a picture of a street sign in broad daylight. But sometimes bad things happen to good people.
As far as Medhead missing the point, I can't say but he has an opinion that is shared by many here.
You will not have to go back in history very far to find some very disgruntled people in the Nikon camp because of their service and atttitude towards their customers. Most of this is the Japanese culture I believe. I don't excuse Canon's behavior but it will not get better at Nikon.
Hmm, I was one of those that switched from Nikon to Canon due to extremely poor customer service and poor quality control. I had serious problems and lip service with both their film scanners and SLRs and swore I'd never buy another Nikon product. I know nobody is perfect but Canon has been good to me and I have no major complaints. The few minor issues I had I was able to clear up quickly and was treated extremely well at Canon Hawaii.