fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!

  
 
DavidP
Offline
Details
p.13 #1So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
drobertfranz wrote:
II also had an unrelated problem so the camera needed to go back to Canon again. I sent a detailed letter and some examples of the AF issues and this time when I go the camera back it really seemed to work as I expected.


Thanks. Do you know what they did on that last trip?
Mar 09, 2008 at 09:50 AM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.13 #2So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
DavidP wrote:
drobertfranz wroteII also had an unrelated problem so the camera needed to go back to Canon again. I sent a detailed letter and some examples of the AF issues and this time when I go the camera back it really seemed to work as I expected.
Thanks. Do you know what they did on that last trip?


It was quite vague on what exactly they did. AF ajustments was the jist of it....
Mar 09, 2008 at 10:37 AM
drobertfranz
Offline
Details
p.13 #3So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Chris Dees wrote:
drobertfranz wrote
DavidP wrote
drobertfranz wroteAfter 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera.
Can you please give a quick summary of the history of these three trips?

Also, was this a pre-blue-dot body, or post-blue-dot body?

Thanks!
Body was pre blue dot...

I received the camera in late June of 07.. Focus on static subjects was inconsistant as was AI Servo. Target aquisition was my biggest issue. The camera just could not aquire subects nearly as well and my MK2's. I sent it to Canon before any fixes were announced. Came back a little better but not much. The firmware upgrades seem to help the one shot AF quite a bit.
I then sent the camera in for the mirror fix and that helped quite a bit but I felt that it still wasn't up to Canons claims about AF performance and I still was having OOF images pop up for no apparent reason. I also had an unrelated problem so the camera needed to go back to Canon again. I sent a detailed letter and some examples of the AF issues and this time when I go the camera back it really seemed to work as I expected.
And again this is exactly how it was with my copy (July).


This is very interesting.. I had a long discussion with a Canon USA big wig last week. I'm photographing in the Pro Tour of Nature Photography Contest (kinda like the PGA Tour of Photography) in April and I was discussing with him some other issues concerning the contest and he asked me if I had a mk3 and my experiences with it. So I gave him the full story.. It sounds to me as if Canon USA is frustrated with Japan's handling of the entire debacle. I tried to get some info on future moves by Canon but got nowhere...

Mar 09, 2008 at 10:49 AM
Chris Dees
Offline
Details
p.13 #4So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
All my lenses (11) were calibrated together with the 1D3.
It took them all day, so I guess it's quite a lot of work.
They didn't want to tell me anything. It's just calibrated (but this was not the first time ).
I guess there's something else going on.
Mar 09, 2008 at 11:06 AM
AJ Nadershahi
Offline
Details
p.13 #5So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Chris Dees wrote:
All my lenses (11) were calibrated together with the 1D3.
It took them all day, so I guess it's quite a lot of work.
They didn't want to tell me anything. It's just calibrated (but this was not the first time ).
I guess there's something else going on.


Can you imagine if you took your car in the shop for service and they refuse to tell you what they did? (Hint: It used to be that way due unscrupulous shops, which forced the enactment of laws that force full disclosure.)

Maybe this is what the camera industry needs.

Mar 09, 2008 at 12:39 PM
apdieb
Offline
Details
p.13 #6So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I now know why they put a "300k" shutter in the Mk3. The 1st 150k are for testing and calibrating.

Forward thinking.

Mar 09, 2008 at 09:00 PM
simonella_viru
Offline
Details
p.13 #7So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
well, i've had my fixed 1d3 for two days now. first day, i shot some ai-servo static subjects with great success. second day: i shot in ultra-bright, sunny winter conditions with my 70-200 f/2.8 IS and 85L lenses (wide open or close to it to get <= 1/8000 shutter). both lenses performed very well, without micro adjustment. i took pics of my sis's kids and we all know that kids are fast. my keeper rate was around 90%+. though i did get some inexplicably grossly mis-focused shots. but hey, 90%+ is really good for me...

the other thing i've noticed, which is really strange to me, is that the pics look fuzzy on my camera lcd. when i look at these same pics on my computer screen, they're sharp. i have firmware 1.1.3 and that's the same firmware i had way before the fix i just had. before i sent my camera out for the fix, i swear it wasn't this bad.

Edited on Mar 09, 2008 at 09:30 PM
Mar 09, 2008 at 09:28 PM
mbellot
Offline
Details
p.13 #8So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
ArtRider wrote:
Canon has struggled nearly one year with this AF problem ( since ref: RG website).
And there are still coming firmwares and callbacks for new fixations.
I hope it will end soon until the body looks like this:
http://aycu03.webshots.com/image/47882/2003655498209946233_fs.jpg



Well there's your problem...

No blue dot.
Mar 09, 2008 at 09:44 PM
ArtRider
Offline
Details
p.13 #9So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
mbellot wrote:
Well there's your problem...

No blue dot.


Hidden inside the battery compartment
Mar 10, 2008 at 02:01 AM
Oliver Francke
Offline
Details
p.13 #10So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Hi,

Tom_W wrote:
I think you're right. In particular, there's a poll over on POTN that shows a drastic change in user satisfaction with the newer "blue dot" bodies. Perhaps there've been a few silent fixes along the way.


definitely sign this statement with own experience ( my last MK III: UW0208)

Oliver.
Mar 10, 2008 at 04:06 AM
Mike1
Offline
Details
p.13 #11So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Chris Dees wrote:
Can you imagine if you took your car in the shop for service and they refuse to tell you what they did? (Hint: It used to be that way due unscrupulous shops, which forced the enactment of laws that force full disclosure.)

Maybe this is what the camera industry needs.



Check with your state's anti-lemon laws. Maybe this could apply to the defective Mark III that you got. Here's an "old" Times article talking about it.

Edited on Mar 10, 2008 at 06:26 AM
Mar 10, 2008 at 06:25 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.13 #12So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
simonella_viru wrote:
"...90%+ is really good for me.

the other thing i've noticed, which is really strange to me, is that the pics look fuzzy on my camera lcd. when i look at these same pics on my computer screen, they're sharp. i have firmware 1.1.3 and that's the same firmware i had way before the fix i just had. before i sent my camera out for the fix, i swear it wasn't this bad."


Glad to hear the repair went well Simon.

I don't know how many of you have tried this, but as far as the LCD goes, if you shoot RAW only you can safely set all the Piucture Styles you use to maximum sharpness (i.e. "7"), and that setting will be applied to the RAW file's embedded JPEG. The LCD preview at 10x is then much closer to representative of the actual file's sharpness, but it doesn't affect the RAW file. It's still not perfect, but much better IMO.

For those of you who shoot RAW+JPEG or JPEG only, I don't know what to say.

Jeff
Mar 10, 2008 at 06:57 AM
72chevelle454
Offline
Details
p.13 #13So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Jeff wrote:
simonella_viru wrote"...90%+ is really good for me.

the other thing i've noticed, which is really strange to me, is that the pics look fuzzy on my camera lcd. when i look at these same pics on my computer screen, they're sharp. i have firmware 1.1.3 and that's the same firmware i had way before the fix i just had. before i sent my camera out for the fix, i swear it wasn't this bad."
Glad to hear the repair went well Simon.

I don't know how many of you have tried this, but as far as the LCD goes, if you shoot RAW only you can safely set all the Piucture Styles you use to maximum sharpness (i.e. "7"), and that setting will be applied to the RAW file's embedded JPEG. The LCD preview at 10x is then much closer to representative of the actual file's sharpness, but it doesn't affect the RAW file. It's still not perfect, but much better IMO.

For those of you who shoot RAW+JPEG or JPEG only, I don't know
...Show more →

Jeff, we use our M3 this way, and you are right it helps with the preview attatched to the Raw file. I only set the one style to max sharpness. have you found that you need to set them all to max sharpness ?

Chad
Mar 10, 2008 at 07:03 AM
simonella_viru
Offline
Details
p.13 #14So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Jeff wrote:
Glad to hear the repair went well Simon.

I don't know how many of you have tried this, but as far as the LCD goes, if you shoot RAW only you can safely set all the Piucture Styles you use to maximum sharpness (i.e. "7"), and that setting will be applied to the RAW file's embedded JPEG. The LCD preview at 10x is then much closer to representative of the actual file's sharpness, but it doesn't affect the RAW file. It's still not perfect, but much better IMO.

For those of you who shoot RAW+JPEG or JPEG only, I don't know
...Show more →

thanks, Jeff. i am still not 100% convinced that everything is fine. even before the fix, my mk III had its good days. a broken clock is still right two times a day

thanks for the sharpness tip- i do shoot RAW. what you say explains why i had better sharpness before i sent it in for the fix. when canon took possession of my camera, they re-flashed it to 1.1.3 and blew away my settings...
Mar 10, 2008 at 08:15 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.13 #15So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I wish you the best of luck and hope things continue to go well for you, Simon.

Henry
Mar 10, 2008 at 08:35 AM
simonella_viru
Offline
Details
p.13 #16So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
hey, thanks Henry. i really wish i could tell you _exactly_ what they did- assuming that they fixed everything for good. though i still don't have a guarantee that, when it gets warmer here, focus won't act up again. nonetheless, the results are very promising thusfar.

i'll continue to exclusively use ai-servo, even for static subjects with wide-aperture lenses (85L, 35L, 70-200 f/2.8 IS). i will look out for the ghosting and inexplicably grossly misfocused shots. and we'll see what happens...

Simon
Mar 10, 2008 at 08:52 AM
redman
Offline
Details
p.13 #17So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
I have 2 MKIII's. One is a 522XXX serial # bought in June of 2007. The other is a Blue Dot that I purchased in November, 2007.

Up until recently I had been preaching that this was the BEST camera that I had ever used. Saturday, I shot a baseball game where I was forced to shoot extreme side lighting at 4:00pm in bright sunshine. The MKIII's performed horribly. Less than 50% keepers. on most of the misses, the MKIII threw the focus about a foot in front of the focus plane making all the images so soft they were unusable. I was shooting with a 400 f2.8 so the DOF was already pretty shallow.

When I was able to get the sun to my back and the players were lit fully frontal, the MKIII performed brilliantly. But side lighting or back lighting, it was a nightmare. My MKIIN would rarely miss in any of these circumstances.

Now, if you take the MKIII's indoors for basketball, gymnastics or shoot nighttime sports (i.e. football. baseball) the MKIII is the BEST body that I ever used, hands down. I just don't think that I should be forced to change bodies to get the shots I need depending on the amount of daylight or dark that I must deal with.

BOB
Mar 10, 2008 at 12:48 PM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.13 #18So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
72chevelle454 wrote:
Jeff, we use our M3 this way, and you are right it helps with the preview attatched to the Raw file. I only set the one style to max sharpness. have you found that you need to set them all to max sharpness ?


That setting applies only to the Picture Style in use, so if you change Picture Style, the sharpening will be set according to the sharpness setting in the Picture Style chosen. If you never change, it isn't such a big deal.

simonella_viru wrote:
hey, thanks Henry. i really wish i could tell you _exactly_ what they did- assuming that they fixed everything for good. though i still don't have a guarantee that, when it gets warmer here, focus won't act up again.


I still don't believe that temperature has much to do with it, as I've seen the AF errors while shooting in very cold environments. I think it has to do with the brightness/quality of the light.

Edited on Mar 10, 2008 at 12:55 PM
Mar 10, 2008 at 12:53 PM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.13 #19So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
redman wrote:
I have 2 MKIII's. One is a 522XXX serial # bought in June of 2007. The other is a Blue Dot that I purchased in November, 2007.

Up until recently I had been preaching that this was the BEST camera that I had ever used. Saturday, I shot a baseball game where I was forced to shoot extreme side lighting at 4:00pm in bright sunshine. The MKIII's performed horribly. Less than 50% keepers. on most of the misses, the MKIII threw the focus about a foot in front of the focus plane making all the images so soft they were unusable.
...Show more →

Now that sounds familiar, and exactly illustrates why I think that every last MkIII out there (BD included) is essentially the same: i.e., not quite as good as the MkII/n.
Mar 10, 2008 at 12:59 PM
simonella_viru
Offline
Details
p.13 #20So, Canon says the 1D3 is fixed!
Jeff wrote:
I still don't believe that temperature has much to do with it, as I've seen the AF errors while shooting in very cold environments. I think it has to do with the brightness/quality of the light.


Jeff, you're probably right. though, i did shoot on the weekend in INSANELY bright sunlit conditions. it was so bring that i could barely shoot at f/2.0 ISO100 (i.e. shutter speed was maxing out at 1/8000).

the conditions i shot in were: bright overhead sunlight with snow everywhere. i had really good results (90%+ keepers). THOUGH, i still have to ai-servo a moving car at 10fps. instead, i was shooting kids at 5fps (manual focus on eye, ai-servo)...

EDIT: lenses used: 85L II mostly (slow AF at that!), some 70-200 f/2.8 IS

Edited on Mar 10, 2008 at 01:21 PM
Mar 10, 2008 at 01:16 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister