redman wrote:
I have 2 MKIII's. One is a 522XXX serial # bought in June of 2007. The other is a Blue Dot that I purchased in November, 2007.
Up until recently I had been preaching that this was the BEST camera that I had ever used. Saturday, I shot a baseball game where I was forced to shoot extreme side lighting at 4:00pm in bright sunshine. The MKIII's performed horribly. Less than 50% keepers. on most of the misses, the MKIII threw the focus about a foot in front of the focus plane making all the images so soft they were unusable. I was shooting with a 400 f2.8 so the DOF was already pretty shallow.
When I was able to get the sun to my back and the players were lit fully frontal, the MKIII performed brilliantly. But side lighting or back lighting, it was a nightmare. My MKIIN would rarely miss in any of these circumstances.
Now, if you take the MKIII's indoors for basketball, gymnastics or shoot nighttime sports (i.e. football. baseball) the MKIII is the BEST body that I ever used, hands down. I just don't think that I should be forced to change bodies to get the shots I need depending on the amount of daylight or dark that I must deal with.
Sorry to hear that.....I shot the WCHS Brandon game with a 300F2.8 at about the same time with much better luck. I have some pitch sequences that were heavy side lighting and they are fine. I'm still holding on to the MKIIN until the fat lady sings on the III. I believe the IIN will out perform the III in bright light (nuclear sun). My main worry now is the upcoming hot weather.
I did have one shot of the left fielder where the AF went to the fence on shot 1....ten yards in front of the guy for shot 2.....and dead on for shot 3. At ten frames a second, the AF moved the point of focus almost 90 feet between two frames. That puppy is fast. The AF going to the fence was my fault of course.
Most of my problems seemed to arise from shots of batters where I prefocus and then use the shutter to trigger the shot. Since I use back button focus. The focus plane shouldn't move from that spot. But when I fire the shutter the focus point jumps out in front of the batter a little. Some of my side lit pitching sequences are just as bad. Keep in mind, this is manually focused. The mirror HAS to still be messed up for that to happen.
It was especially visible on "Road Neutral Gray Uniforms" against a black background. Don't know what the coincidence is for that to happen.
mill4570 wrote: redman wroteI have 2 MKIII's. One is a 522XXX serial # bought in June of 2007. The other is a Blue Dot that I purchased in November, 2007.
Up until recently I had been preaching that this was the BEST camera that I had ever used. Saturday, I shot a baseball game where I was forced to shoot extreme side lighting at 4:00pm in bright sunshine. The MKIII's performed horribly. Less than 50% keepers. on most of the misses, the MKIII threw the focus about a foot in front of the focus plane making all the images so soft they were unusable. I was shooting with a 400 f2.8 so the DOF was already pretty shallow.
When I was able to get the sun to my back and the players were lit fully frontal, the MKIII performed brilliantly. But side lighting or back lighting, it was a nightmare. My MKIIN would rarely miss in any of these circumstances.
Now, if you take the MKIII's indoors for basketball, gymnastics or shoot nighttime sports (i.e. football. baseball) the MKIII is the BEST body that I ever used, hands down. I just don't think that I should be forced to change bodies to get the shots I need depending on the amount of daylight or dark that I must deal with.
BOBBob,
Sorry to hear that.....I shot the WCHS Brandon game with a 300F2.8 at about the same time with much better luck. I have some pitch sequences that were heavy side lighting and they are fine. I'm still holding on to the MKIIN until the fat lady sings on the III. I believe the IIN will out perform the III in bright light (nuclear sun). My main worry now is the upcoming hot weather.
I did have one shot of the left fielder where the AF went to the fence on shot 1....ten yards in front of the guy for shot 2.....and dead on for shot 3. At ten frames a second, the AF moved the point of focus almost 90 feet between two frames. That puppy is fast. The AF going to the fence was my fault of course.
Jeff wrote: redman wroteI have 2 MKIII's. One is a 522XXX serial # bought in June of 2007. The other is a Blue Dot that I purchased in November, 2007.
Up until recently I had been preaching that this was the BEST camera that I had ever used. Saturday, I shot a baseball game where I was forced to shoot extreme side lighting at 4:00pm in bright sunshine. The MKIII's performed horribly. Less than 50% keepers. on most of the misses, the MKIII threw the focus about a foot in front of the focus plane making all the images so soft they were unusable. I was shooting with a 400 f2.8 so the DOF was already pretty shallow.
When I was able to get the sun to my back and the players were lit fully frontal, the MKIII performed brilliantly. But side lighting or back lighting, it was a nightmare. My MKIIN would rarely miss in any of these circumstances.
Now, if you take the MKIII's indoors for basketball, gymnastics or shoot nighttime sports (i.e. football. baseball) the MKIII is the BEST body that I ever used, hands down. I just don't think that I should be forced to change bodies to get the shots I need depending on the amount of daylight or dark that I must deal with.
BOBNow that sounds familiar, and exactly illustrates why I think that every last MkIII out there (BD included) is essentially the same: i.e., not quite as good as the MkII/n.
Understood...getting another MKIIN lined up as we speak....
I do the same thing, but with the buttons on the lens. I have those set to switch between One Shot and Servo. On a batter, I hit the lens button and the AF which means I have prefocussed in One Shot. I get much better results this way. Same on a pitcher from the side. I also have the L-R expansion turned on.
Can you get an "N" for what you sold yours for? Man that's got to hurt.
I had the same issue.. For that matter...I "could" still have that issue. One shot or Servo, or Servo lock and release... Terrible front focusing. Trip to Irvine (after trip to VA) seems to have helped. Of course, I do have to dial in +10 of micro adjustment or it's a foot or 2 front focused on the ground with my 300 F2.8.
EDIT: What I still don't understand is why the image looks focused in the viewfinder prior to shutter release. It's not like we're "continuing to AF" throughout the shot. It is locked supposedly.
For the most part, I don't know if it works or not anymore as I am tired of dealing with it and worrying about every frame. I have shot a bunch since the latest service center visit, but mostly in low light. Those results are great.
Tried both latest BD Mark III and earlier Mark III with SM fix.
And i only do oneshot, no AI SERVO. As you know i have tried 7-8 Mark IIIs so far, no AI SERVO, ONESHOT mode only.
So my answer to the OP's question is:
YES and NO
YES---both latest BD and SM fixed Mark IIIs are performing much much better than those Mark IIIs i had tried before the SM fix came out.
NO---Still not up to the standard as 1D series bodies i have used, mainly for it's inconsistency on AF, even at ONESHOT mode, same condition shooting same subject, say 10 shots, you may get 2 very soft images, but no explainations for why the images are soft or OOF...blurred image...in this case you can see the image was perfectly focussed through the viewfinder...but the image recorded on the sensor was OOF or very soft...
So the fix is working, but still have room to improve.
You know, one of the things that strikes me as odd is that there are some very serious shooters having very serious problems and they are being largely discounted by Canon and some of the folks here. If you look at Andrew and Peter's
web sites you'll have to come away with the idea that these guys and many others like them know what they are doing and probably have some idea when their cameras aren't working properly. Does Canon really think that they can just send cameras back and say they "meet factory standards" and nobody is going to notice that they don't focus? The more I think about this the more at a loss I am to explain Canon's reaction.
Under the current situation with the MkIII having known AF issues Canon should never have returned a camera to anyone without absolute testing of the AF to be sure that it was working as advertised. The comment "met factory standards" evidently does not include accurate AF. I'm sure Canon has the ability to use focus charts with a variety of lens to determine when or if a camera body will focus on the chart. In both Jeff and Henry's case and the street sign shots, these had to have been like this when they left Canon. To return them to the owner like this certainly doesn't help the reputation of the MkIII. As of right now I have a Blue Dot version that seems to work well but I have yet to shoot at f2.8 in hot weather so I'm still on edge and keeping my fingers crossed.
Hrow wrote:
Does Canon really think that they can just send cameras back and say they "meet factory standards" and nobody is going to notice that they don't focus? The more I think about this the more at a loss I am to explain Canon's reaction.
Edited by Hrow on Mar 11, 2008 at 12:27 AM GMT
Perhaps Canon decided to adopt the late Sen. George Aiken's famous advice to Presidents Johnson and Nixon: "The way to get out of Vietnam is to declare victory and leave."
Henry is right. Canon just doesn't seem to know what they are doing on
this camera. It must be frustrating for people like Chuck Westfall to have to
deal with irate camera owners and not get the support he needs from the factory.
About ten months now and still all of this? This is ridiculous.
It seems my 1DMkIII is fixed now. Last Thursday I had all my gear calibrated.
This weekend I was out with my 400DO and 500L, shooting birds, etc.
In the past my keeper rate was about 25% and now its above 90%. Almost everything is sharp. I tried to track birds against a "busy" background and no problems.
Yesterday I did a couple of (unscientific) tests in one-shot with my shorter lenses and the were all sharp as well.
So finally, after about 9 monts, I have a proper functioning 1DMkIII
Ben D. Mor wrote: Hrow wroteDoes Canon really think that they can just send cameras back and say they "meet factory standards" and nobody is going to notice that they don't focus? The more I think about this the more at a loss I am to explain Canon's reaction.
Edited by Hrow on Mar 11, 2008 at 12:27 AM GMTPerhaps Canon decided to adopt the late Sen. George Aiken's famous advice to Presidents Johnson and Nixon: "The way to get out of Vietnam is to declare victory and leave."
Mine just came back, it was the 3rd time its been back for the focusing issue. It started out in VA. then it went to NJ....and then finally it was sent to the NY office. The stated that the AF Sensor needed calibration, all seems fine so far......I have shot one time and it performed magically. No OOF shots all were in Focus.
jbfaulconer wrote:
Mine just came back, it was the 3rd time its been back for the focusing issue. It started out in VA. then it went to NJ....and then finally it was sent to the NY office. The stated that the AF Sensor needed calibration, all seems fine so far......I have shot one time and it performed magically. No OOF shots all were in Focus. Sweet!!!
Yes indeed. It is nice to learn that Canon takes care of the issue so that the users can finally have the eminently capable tool they expected.
When was your 1D III manufactured, was it an early non-blue dot version?
Chris Dees wrote:
It seems my 1DMkIII is fixed now. Last Thursday I had all my gear calibrated.
This weekend I was out with my 400DO and 500L, shooting birds, etc.
In the past my keeper rate was about 25% and now its above 90%. Almost everything is sharp. I tried to track birds against a "busy" background and no problems.
Yesterday I did a couple of (unscientific) tests in one-shot with my shorter lenses and the were all sharp as well.
So finally, after about 9 monts, I have a proper functioning 1DMkIII
Glad to hear it Chris, my only thought or concern is what happens if you buy a new lens? Do you have to send it in each time for calibration?