The thread you reference has been in place for over a year with only 18 posts, with about half explaining how to test for focus accuracy. Are you attempting to compare that to this fiasco?
I'm not referencing any thread? where did I do that?
What were the results of the tests before the harware and firmware fix?
* If the Mark III was already the best performer of the EOS Series, then the tests are not complete and their point is moot.
* If the Mark III wasn't already the best performer of the EOS Series, then why did it hit the street as is? Wasn't its AF supposed to be a big selling point and the camera marketed as the best in its class?
* If they didn't test it, the least we can say is that it was a pretty big mistake...
Jeff wrote:
Just out of curiosity, have you seen the 'ghosting' that was apparent in the closeup of the swing by the guy in the dark blue shirt? It would be interesting to see that logo on his sleeve at 100%...
I did notice that, and looking at it at 100% is even more obvious. But I just went back and looked at the subsequent frames and it is not there on others... Most likely this was a result of me handholding at 520mm equivalent at 1/320 second. Its all I can think of given this isn't a regular trait of this lens or camera.
Mike1 wrote:
Wow, a few days of being sick & with a lot of time on the net got me this...
Mike1, I sincerely hope you are feeling better soon, because your continuing condescension due in part to generalizations that are based solely upon your opinions and your own personal experience is getting tiresome. Henry has been through it all (even more than I have, knock on wood), and to suggest that he has somehow brought it upon himself or approached Canon in an ineffective manner is simply nonsensical.
ChrisDM wrote:
I did notice that, and looking at it at 100% is even more obvious. But I just went back and looked at the subsequent frames and it is not there on others... Most likely this was a result of me handholding at 520mm equivalent at 1/320 second. Its all I can think of given this isn't a regular trait of this lens or camera.
Chris M
www.imagineimagery.com
Hmm. You are lucky it is an isolated occurrence, because it was characteristic of both my malfunctioning early-production MkIII (502xxx), and Rob's most recent test camera(s).
That may be the last straw for me then. I was planning on buying a 300/3.8L IS, but it ain't gonna happen if this is the end of the story. If 'not quite as good as the MkIIn' is as good as it gets, that's not good enough for me, given how the camera was marketed.
-Jeff
After 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera. My focus aquistion is extemenly fast and I'm now holding my focus great in AI Servo. In AFPS (all 45 activated) I was able to quickly aquire and hold fast flyng small in the frame ducks in flight against a very busy BG. I've never been able to do that before. Tried a car coming at me at 40mph and did a 25 shot burst and all were extemely sharp to sharp. All would have been publishable. Didn't test a person running towards me but should be no problem at all. My serial was 522xxx...
Shame on Canon for putting us through this but if my camera is any indication then their press release seems reasonable to me...
Jeff wrote: Earlier quote"After the AF mirror Adjustment, including the updated firmware version 1.1.3, the EOS-1D Mark III AF function performed better in our tests than all previous EOS camera models."Considering their testing methods allowed the MkIII to be designed, built, and hit the streets in the condition it was in, this statement has no meaning for me. It's their testing methods that allowed the camera to become the debacle that it has.
That may be the last straw for me then. I was planning on buying a 300/3.8L IS, but it ain't gonna happen if this is the end of the story. If 'not quite as good as the MkIIn' is as good as it gets, that's not good enough for me, given how the camera was marketed.
-Jeff
After 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera. My focus aquistion is extemenly fast and I'm now holding my focus great in AI Servo. In AFPS (all 45 activated) I was able to quickly aquire and hold fast flyng small in the frame ducks in flight against a very busy BG. I've never been able to do that before. Tried a car coming at me at 40mph and did a 25 shot burst and all were extemely sharp to sharp. All would have been publishable. Didn't test a person running towards me but should be no problem at all. My serial was 522xxx...
Shame on Canon for putting us through this but if my camera is any indication then their press release seems reasonable to me...
drobertfranz wrote:
After 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera. My focus aquistion is extemenly fast and I'm now holding my focus great in AI Servo. In AFPS (all 45 activated) I was able to quickly aquire and hold fast flyng small in the frame ducks in flight against a very busy BG. I've never been able to do that before. Tried a car coming at me at 40mph and did a 25 shot burst and all were extemely sharp to sharp. All would have been publishable. Didn't test a person running towards me but should be no problem at all. My serial was 522xxx...
Shame on Canon for putting us through this but if my camera is any indication then their press release seems reasonable to me... ...Show more →
Same for me. I collected my gear on Thursday and today I was all day out birding.
I'm very satisfied with the results. AI-servo and one-shot seems to work perfect. Almost all bursts (up to 25 pictures) were 100% in focus.
There still place for user error.
Tomorrow I'll do some tests with the short lenses.
After reading countless number of pages from so many online forums, I have a strong feeling that canon has done some silent fixing in the newly manufactured units/copies (I am not sure since when). Question is: what we do with the old 1D3s?
I think you're right. In particular, there's a poll over on POTN that shows a drastic change in user satisfaction with the newer "blue dot" bodies. Perhaps there've been a few silent fixes along the way.
drobertfranz wrote:
After 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera.
Can you please give a quick summary of the history of these three trips?
Also, was this a pre-blue-dot body, or post-blue-dot body?
don't be silly, they gave you a solution in the form of keep sending all your lenses and bodies to us time and time again or in simple Hebrew words "Leh hapes"
ruhikant wrote:
After reading countless number of pages from so many online forums, I have a strong feeling that canon has done some silent fixing in the newly manufactured units/copies (I am not sure since when). Question is: what we do with the old 1D3s?
Tom_W wrote:
I think you're right. In particular, there's a poll over on POTN that shows a drastic change in user satisfaction with the newer "blue dot" bodies. Perhaps there've been a few silent fixes along the way.
It would be nice to know from which serialnumber things are better (if this really is the case of course).
Canon has struggled nearly one year with this AF problem ( since ref: RG website).
And there are still coming firmwares and callbacks for new fixations.
I hope it will end soon until the body looks like this: http://aycu03.webshots.com/image/47882/2003655498209946233_fs.jpg
DavidP wrote: drobertfranz wroteAfter 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera.Can you please give a quick summary of the history of these three trips?
Also, was this a pre-blue-dot body, or post-blue-dot body?
Thanks!
Body was pre blue dot...
I received the camera in late June of 07.. Focus on static subjects was inconsistant as was AI Servo. Target aquisition was my biggest issue. The camera just could not aquire subects nearly as well and my MK2's. I sent it to Canon before any fixes were announced. Came back a little better but not much. The firmware upgrades seem to help the one shot AF quite a bit.
I then sent the camera in for the mirror fix and that helped quite a bit but I felt that it still wasn't up to Canons claims about AF performance and I still was having OOF images pop up for no apparent reason. I also had an unrelated problem so the camera needed to go back to Canon again. I sent a detailed letter and some examples of the AF issues and this time when I go the camera back it really seemed to work as I expected.
Tom_W wrote:
I think you're right. In particular, there's a poll over on POTN that shows a drastic change in user satisfaction with the newer "blue dot" bodies. Perhaps there've been a few silent fixes along the way.
I think that any new body now is going to be fine. Seems like people I know that have recieved new MK3s recently are thrilled with the performance...
I've also heard that the 1ds3's AF is excellent...
drobertfranz wrote: DavidP wrotedrobertfranz wroteAfter 3 trips to Canon and lots of anquish I can now say that my mk3 performs better than any Canon body I've used and I've had nearly all of them since the Eos 1 film camera.Can you please give a quick summary of the history of these three trips?
Also, was this a pre-blue-dot body, or post-blue-dot body?
Thanks!Body was pre blue dot...
I received the camera in late June of 07.. Focus on static subjects was inconsistant as was AI Servo. Target aquisition was my biggest issue. The camera just could not aquire subects nearly as well and my MK2's. I sent it to Canon before any fixes were announced. Came back a little better but not much. The firmware upgrades seem to help the one shot AF quite a bit.
I then sent the camera in for the mirror fix and that helped quite a bit but I felt that it still wasn't up to Canons claims about AF performance and I still was having OOF images pop up for no apparent reason. I also had an unrelated problem so the camera needed to go back to Canon again. I sent a detailed letter and some examples of the AF issues and this time when I go the camera back it really seemed to work as I expected. ...Show more →
And again this is exactly how it was with my copy (July).