fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2007 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

When will Mark III focusing issues be resolved?

What issues, my Mark III works perfectly16% · 52
Firmware 1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.314 will be released today and resolve all issues2% · 8
More firmware will be released in the near future that fixes the problems16% · 51
Canon will have a mechanical fix in the next few months26% · 83
When the Mark III N is released40% · 131
Total Votes325

Archive 2007Canon's Mark III fix time frame

  
 
nathanray
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Canon's Mark III fix time frame
sorry i havent read the whole thread but,,, how many other canon bodies have had problems after being released?
Oct 04, 2007 at 10:56 PM
nathanray
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Canon's Mark III fix time frame
ive had 3 1d's, 2 mark II's and a Mark IIn and the only one that has been to CPS for a serious repair other then cleaning and calibration has been the mark IIn. maybe im just lucky
Oct 04, 2007 at 11:01 PM
MindGame
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Canon's Mark III fix time frame
pixelman wrote:
Other than banding on original 1d can anyone recall anything else being fixed? Didn't think so There's a good chance it's a six month thing or more. A 'n' version would getto-ize the resale value of the body. They likely will do a hardware fix and for the next fix years at resale time people will be looking for a pdf's print out of repair work or some such thing.


The flare issue on the 24-105 IS and the vertical orientation issue with the 70-300 IS were fixed by Canon, I think?
Oct 04, 2007 at 11:55 PM
UA935
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Canon's Mark III fix time frame
jomor wrote:
So I guess every one is giving up on this thread? Is the Mk3 a dead topic now? Everyone just to dammed frustrated to talk about it any more?


It would seem that way.

I am utterly p***** off with mine and Canon.

4 E-mails to my CPS rep on the issue in two weeks, number of replies from CPS a big fat zero, that is how much Canon thinks of its customers.

Oct 05, 2007 at 01:05 AM
Geoff Costello
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Canon's Mark III fix time frame
Paul B wrote:
beewee wroteFrom what I've been told by a Canon product specialist, it seams that a physical design fix is required. The guy I spoke to at a CPS expo mentioned that the 40D's AF was designed specifically to withstand large temperature fluctuations (unlike the 1D3) and even the 1Ds3 has a slightly modified AF module that is a somewhat improved version of the 1D3's AF system.

There are basically two options, Canon does a mass recall to swap out AF modules for 1D3 owners or Canon slaps all the early adopters of the 1D3 in the face and quickly releases a 1D3n.
It's strange that the 1D3 wouldn't be designed for large temperature fluctuations (and the 40D would) given that it's presumably used under more taxing outside conditions than a "consumer" body. Did he say why this was the case?


This is consistent with what I have been told as well. Net:

  1. Canon realises there is a issue with temperature sensitivity in the AF sensors used in the 1D III where the sensitivity changes with increased temperature insight the camera
  2. This issue is variable between sensors and some running changes have been made to address it in newer 1D III - which are much less prone to the problem.
  3. The 40D AF is simpler and uses a different chip design to be much less temperature sensitive and does not encounter the problem.
  4. The 1Ds III also has changed sensor chip designs to reduce temperature sensitivity.
  5. Canon are still hopeful of a firmware fix to the temperature sensitivity issue by making the firmware more tolerant to changes in AF sensitivity but it is proving harder to completely fix than anticipated.
  6. Canon have released several versions of firmware for the 1D III to address a number of AF related faults and enhancements and believe that for the majority of users the 1D III with current firmware has better performing AF than the 1D IIn.
  7. Canon only have a relatively small proportion of 1D III cameras returned / reported for AF faults (less than 5% and in most outlets less than 1% or 2%)
  8. There has been a degree of confusion with the 1D III AF anyway due to the complexity of the CF settings it is easy to make changes that cause issues and Canon have found that the majority of calls / service enquiries relate to that.
  9. New ID III returned for Canon Service with AF issues sensors have their AF sensors checked and replaced if faulty (only a very small proportion are actually ‘faulty’ by Canon’s standard)
  10. Many 1D III customers simply do not encounter the AF issues due to some combination of their shooting style, AF CF settings or temperature and lighting conditions or particular AF sensor temperature tolerance.
  11. Canon is very embarrassed by the issue and has a internal product team trying to fix it. Free replacement using next generation AF units (as per the 1Ds III) for affected customers remain a fall back should the firmware fix not found soon. However Canon does not want to unnecessarily create “panic’ with a recall program when it perceived by them that the vast majority of 1D III customers to be unaffected.


Hope this helps
Oct 05, 2007 at 03:14 AM
deadeyedick
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Canon's Mark III fix time frame
My take on the whole issue as well.
Oct 05, 2007 at 07:02 AM
aeubank
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Canon's Mark III fix time frame

Count me in as one of the unaffected ones.
Sure, there are SOME people with issues in their cameras, but MOST people that actually OWN the samera are not having these problems. Most of the complainers I see here (and some with the loudest opinions) do not appear to even OWN the camera.

For the small numbers that actually have problems, Canon seems to be owning up to fixing their cameras (or working on a solution). For the other 90% of owners, get out there and shoot!! For the 90% of respondents that do not own the camera, you wouldn't know how awesome this camera is. STOP letting someone think for you. PURCHASE the camera and form your OWN opinions..



Oct 05, 2007 at 07:06 AM
redman
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Canon's Mark III fix time frame
I am one who plunked down my cash, rolled the dice and got a body that works. At least it works to what I believe is within specs. I have shot in all conditions including the RG extremes and the MKIII has performed well. Flawlessly...No. Within specs....I THINK so. I believe that it focuses as well as my MKIIN.

Having said that, I'm the kind of guy that will get up from the blackjack table while I am ahead. So, I am waiting to see how Canon responds to all this. I will not be ordering anymore stuff from Canon until I can tell that my investment in the Canon branding will be solid. If they just sit on this and do nothing, I will evaluate my position and act accordingly. Until then, I will be studying and watching the Nikon camp to see how the users of the D3 respond to it's release.
Oct 05, 2007 at 07:34 AM
Flying Dog
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Canon's Mark III fix time frame
beewee wrote:
From what I've been told by a Canon product specialist, it seams that a physical design fix is required. The guy I spoke to at a CPS expo mentioned that the 40D's AF was designed specifically to withstand large temperature fluctuations (unlike the 1D3) and even the 1Ds3 has a slightly modified AF module that is a somewhat improved version of the 1D3's AF system.


I call bu||crap on that one. Nothing more than internet rhetoric, of which there is much too much of in regard to the MkIII. There is no hard evidence that the problem is even temperature related, only anecdotal hypotheses.

Also, no one around here knows about the AF assembly in the 1Ds MkIII, beyond rightly assuming that it's exactly the same (as that in the 1D MkIII) since it is so close to release. If they have 'fixed' the 1Ds MkIII's AF, one could easily assume that they'd also have a hardware fix for the 1D MkIII by now.

Paul B wrote:
It's strange that the 1D3 wouldn't be designed for large temperature fluctuations (and the 40D would) given that it's presumably used under more taxing outside conditions than a "consumer" body.


Which illustrates exactly why the 'information' is bunk. Of course, it's all conjecture until Canon steps up to the plate and releases the pursed lips.
Oct 05, 2007 at 11:01 AM
deadeyedick
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Canon's Mark III fix time frame
redman
Online
Image Upload: On
Registered: Jan 31, 2004
Total Posts: 2390
Country: United States

Re: Canon's Mark III fix time frame
I am one who plunked down my cash, rolled the dice and got a body that works. At least it works to what I believe is within specs. I have shot in all conditions including the RG extremes and the MKIII has performed well. Flawlessly...No. Within specs....I THINK so. I believe that it focuses as well as my MKIIN.

Having said that, I'm the kind of guy that will get up from the blackjack table while I am ahead. So, I am waiting to see how Canon responds to all this. I will not be ordering anymore stuff from Canon until I can tell that my investment in the Canon branding will be solid. If they just sit on this and do nothing, I will evaluate my position and act accordingly. Until then, I will be studying and watching the Nikon camp to see how the users of the D3 respond to it's release.



Another vote for common sense.
Oct 05, 2007 at 04:16 PM
deadeyedick
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Canon's Mark III fix time frame
aeubank
Offline
Buy and Sell: On
Registered: Feb 21, 2006
Total Posts: 473
Country: United States

Re: Canon's Mark III fix time frame

Count me in as one of the unaffected ones.
Sure, there are SOME people with issues in their cameras, but MOST people that actually OWN the samera are not having these problems. Most of the complainers I see here (and some with the loudest opinions) do not appear to even OWN the camera.


Try as you may, you just cant shut these people up. In most cases they have NO personal hands on experience, but have made it their business to stick their heads in and prove just how really stupid they . There is one member who bought a 1ds2 instead of a 1d3. His 1ds2 AF didn't work, and the camera had to go back to Canon service. For all I know, it may still be there. You may well believe that this person would put all of his spare time into researching AF problems with this model of camera, and what the fix may be, and when, etc etc...........but no, has endlessly been theorising the problems of the 1d3, and how smart it was not to have bought one....Hello ! [ maybe this is to feel better about the fact it is he who has the BUM camera ] I have read all the talk, back and forth about the AI servo problems some owners are having since the beginning, and In my opinion, all that non owners are achieving is to muddy the waters regarding Canons perception of the magnitude of the problem, and reduce the joy of ownership and possible marketplace value of those who have one that works to their expectations. My advice to these people is to GET A LIFE
Oct 05, 2007 at 04:40 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Canon's Mark III fix time frame
Flying Dog wrote:
Also, no one around here knows about the AF assembly in the 1Ds MkIII, beyond rightly assuming that it's exactly the same (as that in the 1D MkIII) since it is so close to release.


At least with the 1Ds and 1Ds2, Canon have officially stated that the AF was *different* compared to the 1D and 1D2, respectively, even if only in minor details. Who knows how much different, but in both cases the official literature mentioned "adjustments" between the different bodies. And they didn't mean bug fixes back then
Oct 05, 2007 at 05:32 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Canon's Mark III fix time frame
Probably about three days after my D300s arrive.

EB
Oct 05, 2007 at 06:53 PM
aeubank
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Canon's Mark III fix time frame
deadeyedick wrote:
aeubank
Offline
Buy and Sell: On
Registered: Feb 21, 2006
Total Posts: 473
Country: United States

Re: Canon's Mark III fix time frame

Count me in as one of the unaffected ones.
Sure, there are SOME people with issues in their cameras, but MOST people that actually OWN the samera are not having these problems. Most of the complainers I see here (and some with the loudest opinions) do not appear to even OWN the camera.


Try as you may, you just cant shut these people up. In most cases they have NO personal hands on experience, but have made it their business to stick their
...Show more →


I'm not attempting to shut anyone up here. I'm stating that the Mark III that I own does not have the AF issues identified by others. This is an awesome camera. Everyone has their own opinion.

This issue has gotten way out of control. Mostly fueled by people that have no firsthand knowledge of the issue. I would say that Canon's reaction to this issue is about right. This assumes that more than 90% of the cameras are actually functioning to spec, and the rest is a bunch of Internet hot air from people that do not own the camera to begin with.

I'd like to hear from some of the guys here what kind of response should Canon provide to this issue? Assuming they've only seen a handful of cameras that were actually defective, what should be said to appease all of the haters?

Oct 06, 2007 at 05:14 AM
UA935
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Canon's Mark III fix time frame
I think Canon have only seen as you put it "a handfull of cameras" becuase what is the point in sending your body in if they don't have a fix?

And yes I do own a MK III and yes it does have AI servo issues in bright sunlight.

I have now sent 4 e-mails to my CPS rep over a two week period and as yet they have not had the courtesy to provide any form of response.
Oct 06, 2007 at 05:55 AM
deadeyedick
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Canon's Mark III fix time frame
I'm not attempting to shut anyone up here. I'm stating that the Mark III that I own does not have the AF issues identified by others. This is an awesome camera. Everyone has their own opinion.

This issue has gotten way out of control. Mostly fueled by people that have no firsthand knowledge of the issue. I would say that Canon's reaction to this issue is about right. This assumes that more than 90% of the cameras are actually functioning to spec, and the rest is a bunch of Internet hot air from people that do not own the camera to begin with.

I'd like to hear from some of the guys here what kind of response should Canon provide to this issue? Assuming they've only seen a handful of cameras that were actually defective, what should be said to appease all of the haters?


I hear you aeubank, and for what it is worth, my 1d3 seems to function as yours does.
Oct 06, 2007 at 06:07 AM
Garylv
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Canon's Mark III fix time frame
You know, it'd be nice to think only a very small percentage of the cameras have a problem as some people claim. But it just doesn't add up.

Do you honestly think Canon would arrange to have professional photographers from around the world beta testing the new firmware at the IAAF World Championships in Osaka if they felt the trouble was "only a very small percentage of the cameras"?

Do you guys really think that? Seriously?

During the different times RG tested cameras from varying production times, six out of six showed the exact same defect.

Only a small percentage?

I think most people know with this particular issue, the number of returned cameras is not an indication of how many cameras have been affected. Why? Because those of us who have been following this from the beginning remember when the Canon service centers were telling customers to NOT send their cameras in. The service centers were waiting for clarification from Canon Japan and they did not have a fix. Still don't.

Some of the people who did send their cameras in said it came back performing exactly the same.

It's obvious many people went into a waiting mode at that point, assuming Canon would have a fix relatively soon. Some returned the camera for a refund.

So now we're well into October and most people are still waiting. Even though RG warned the fix would be slow to come, I think most people were expecting Canon to have some kind of answer before this.

The very nature of this issue makes it difficult for everyone to notice. It's not like the compact flash door is breaking off all the cameras and everyone can see it clearly.

In fact, for the people who do a wide variety of photography in varied lighting using a number of lenses, I can easily see how those people might not notice the problem at all. Some of them do, obviously, but many don't. And it's very easy to see why.

Those of you who do not see any trouble when shooting in bright mid-day type lighting, consider yourselves lucky. At least so far. A number of people said they finally saw the trouble later after owning the camera for an extended time. The AF issue may rear it's ugly head on your cameras yet; in the right conditions.

It's unfortunate for all of us Canon has been so quiet on the issue. Especially if they continue to be silent. Imagine trying to sell your MarkIII later when that time comes, and you try to convince the buyer you had one of the cameras that did not have the dreaded focus issue. Good luck.

I think if Canon DID reveal all the facts right now, they would tell you all cameras are exactly the same at this point in time. When they prove they have corrected the issue, we will ALL benefit from that news.




Edited by Garylv on Oct 06, 2007 at 01:11 PM GMT
Oct 06, 2007 at 07:06 AM
Lasse Eriksson
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Canon's Mark III fix time frame
aeubank wrote:
Count me in as one of the unaffected ones.
Sure, there are SOME people with issues in their cameras, but MOST people that actually OWN the samera are not having these problems. Most of the complainers I see here (and some with the loudest opinions) do not appear to even OWN the camera.

For the small numbers that actually have problems, Canon seems to be owning up to fixing their cameras (or working on a solution). For the other 90% of owners, get out there and shoot!! For the 90% of respondents that do not own the camera, you wouldn't know how
...Show more →

Agree, it's an awesome camera. I haven't noticed any "AF issue" and neither has anybody that I know. When reading here it's like all cameras are bad and not working !!
I'm sure there a re some "bad copies" out there. But I'm also sure that most are good



Edited by Lasse Eriksson on Oct 06, 2007 at 02:13 PM GMT
Oct 06, 2007 at 07:12 AM
Mariner
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #19Canon's Mark III fix time frame
Garylv wrote:
You know, it'd be nice to think only a very small percentage of the cameras have a problem as some people claim. But it just doesn't add up.

Do you honestly think Canon would arrange to have professional photographers from around the world beta testing the new firmware at the IAAF World Championships in Osaka if they felt the trouble was "only a very small percentage of the cameras"?

Do you guys really think that? Seriously?

During the different times RG tested cameras from varying production times, six out of six showed the exact same defect.

Only a small percentage?

I think most people
...Show more →

Nicely said and should be read by all.
Regards-John
Oct 06, 2007 at 07:14 AM
Nick G Walker
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Canon's Mark III fix time frame
As a follow up reply I have posted some of my findings with the MKIII and 100% crops https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/577668
Oct 06, 2007 at 07:16 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister