stuuke wrote:
Just for fun but when do you think Canon will have the Mark III issues resolved?
I personaly think is a hardware design issue, which is a pretty serious flaw since generally those things arent resolved easily. The fact that the problems are somewhat random are even more troublesome since its unerving not knowing if and when it will happen. With a 1 series camera you expect and require a certain dependability. $^%# does happen but when there is a widespread problem it makes you wonder...
The folks over on DPreview are now talking about a class action law suit against Canon. Once I would have laughed at that suggestion and considered it a very unlikely to bear fruit. However, it now seems like a reasonable way to get them to address the issue and state a time frame for the fix. If they can't come up with a solution then they will need to reaquire the faulty cameras and either issue credits or cash refunds based upon sales receipts and even including taxes. Such an admission also will make them liable for any damages, real or imagined, suffered by the original purchaser. Frankly, I'm rather amazed they have gotten away without dealing with this problem before now. There are law firms that specialize in these types of issues and I'm certain would love to get their hands on a Class Suit.
Hang in there-John
Don't make the mistake of ascribing the FF D3's noise performance to the D300. The approximate pixel size is (approx) 8.4 and 4.6-respectively. And since that describes area the difference is squared. So if the D3 is good to ISO 6400 then the D300 should have equivalent noise performance at ISO 1600 (approx-all other things being equal which they seldom are).
Another way to consider this" in making the D300 pixel smaller (same sensor size more Mega pixels) noise is increased and can only be decreased by better software algorithms. As they say "The Devil is in the Details" so I know we all are anxious to have real world feedback from the new Nikons-and the 1Ds III too.
SoundHound wrote:
Don't make the mistake of ascribing the FF D3's noise performance to the D300. The approximate pixel size is (approx) 8.4 and 4.6-respectively. And since that describes area the difference is squared. So if the D3 is good to ISO 6400 then the D300 should have equivalent noise performance at ISO 1600 (approx-all other things being equal which they seldom are).
Another way to consider this" in making the D300 pixel smaller (same sensor size more Mega pixels) noise is increased and can only be decreased by better software algorithms. As they say "The Devil is in the Details" so I know we all are anxious to have real world feedback from the new Nikons-and the 1Ds III too....Show more →
I'll bear that in mind next time I'm over in the D3/D300 thread...
nathanlake wrote:
At this point, more important than the camera problem is the public relations problem they have created. They should either admit there is a problem and state their commitment to fixing it or explain what needs to be done to operate the camera to give good results. There is really no other choice.
Unfortunately, I think we're going to get the "other choice." I don't see any indication that Canon is going to do anything other than clam up until they figure out how to fix the problem and then just issue the fix. Unless this next firmware fix actually solves the problem, I'd bet that we're in for some significant redesigning and time delays. I'm sure they're working hard on it and will come up with the "best solution." But it might take some time (I guess the fact that Canon says the 1DsMkIII will start shipping in November means Canon thinks they can solve the 1DMkIII problem within two months? But that assumes Canon actually knows what the issue is, and how to fix it, and that the November ship date is not just something they're hoping for....)
As outsiders we don't really have much in the way of data points about what's going on inside Canon. The next really interesting data point for us all will be what happens with the 40D. If there are AF problems with that, we'll know there's something seriously wrong with Canon's internal processes. Actually, we already know there are process issues--the design/engineering shortcomings and then what I'd call the testing problem (i.e they apparently made some change in the way they tested and were unable to detect the MkIII's problems.) We just don't know at this point whether the process issues affect more than one model. Not that I'm trying to be overly critical of Canon. I think every large organization commits bloopers periodically; the question is how fast they can recover.
I was with a guy today that said the problem with the AF is something that is changeable. Unless it is something a lot more major. he said he was pissed off and it was acting like a piece of crap. so he gave canon a call and then told him exactly what to do. Some technical stuff but basically there is something turned on say if you had a certain focus point on that you see....there is really little points all around it but you cant see them and there is a way to deactivate those or something and that solves the problem? or solved his problem? he said it performs amazingly now. he said he did the same adjustments to his 1dmkIIn and he has noticed a increase in AF performance.
SoundHound wrote:
Don't make the mistake of ascribing the FF D3's noise performance to the D300. The approximate pixel size is (approx) 8.4 and 4.6-respectively. And since that describes area the difference is squared. So if the D3 is good to ISO 6400 then the D300 should have equivalent noise performance at ISO 1600 (approx-all other things being equal which they seldom are).
Another way to consider this" in making the D300 pixel smaller (same sensor size more Mega pixels) noise is increased and can only be decreased by better software algorithms. As they say "The Devil is in the Details" so I know we all are anxious to have real world feedback from the new Nikons-and the 1Ds III too....Show more →
If the D3 has 8.4um pixels then the D300 must have ~ 8.4/1.5 = 5.6um. They aren't much smaller than the 40D pixels. The D300 pixels only have 44.5% the area of the D3 pixels though. I'm not sure where you got the 4.6um from for the D300?
Mariner wrote:
The folks over on DPreview are now talking about a class action law suit against Canon. Once I would have laughed at that suggestion and considered it a very unlikely to bear fruit. However, it now seems like a reasonable way to get them to address the issue and state a time frame for the fix. If they can't come up with a solution then they will need to reaquire the faulty cameras and either issue credits or cash refunds based upon sales receipts and even including taxes. Such an admission also will make them liable for any damages, real or imagined, suffered by the original purchaser. Frankly, I'm rather amazed they have gotten away without dealing with this problem before now. There are law firms that specialize in these types of issues and I'm certain would love to get their hands on a Class Suit.
Hang in there-John...Show more →
I was the one that suggested that tongue in cheek. I know Americans love a class action for anything. The best one was the fatso's suing McDonalds for making them eat sh!t.
Pixel Perfect wrote: I was the one that suggested that tongue in cheek. I know Americans love a class action for anything. The best one was the fatso's suing McDonalds for making them eat sh!t.
I own a MKIII, 504XX, early model ordered the day of announcement and received in first batch. It focuses more consistently accurate than any of my previous Canon DSLRs (D30, 10D, 1D, 20D, 1DMKII, 30D, 5D, 1DMKIIn). I feel there is a problem with a large number of MKIIIs. Maybe I got lucky ... my longest lens is a 300 F4 and my longest F 2.8 lens is a 70-200.
Canon will never admit to a problem with this camera but will try to tweak it into acceptance with firmware updates. RG will never admit to it being fixed well enough to focus as well as / better than his MKIIns.
After much thought, I think it could be a design issue related to the layout of the high precision cross sensors. In previous 1 series, the cross sensors are clustered side-by-side around the center, in the MKIII there are 19 cross sensors spread throughout the 45 points. Have not seen this idea mentioned before but when using the center point only with expansion on, using the previous layout of cross sensors you would get a cluster of high precision cross sensors working together, but with the MKIII you only get one cross sensor working with lower precision sensors next to it. In a demanding situation like using a 300 @ F 2.8 with a narrow DOF, could the lack of more side-by-side cross sensors be the culprit
I am very aware of all the Af issues facing the 1d3 and if it was just firmware the amount of canon 1d3 bodies out there would be alot more since Canon could release at will new firmware..The fact that there is a shortage and no one has the 1ds in stock means, at least to me, that Canon jp has decided that there is a serious defect that probably will require new hardware to completely resolve the AF problems that really exist!
Edited by ALFRED VITANZA on Sep 07, 2007 at 09:43 AM GMT (Reason: spelling)
Pixel Perfect wrote: Mariner wroteThe folks over on DPreview are now talking about a class action law suit against Canon. Once I would have laughed at that suggestion and considered it a very unlikely to bear fruit. However, it now seems like a reasonable way to get them to address the issue and state a time frame for the fix. If they can't come up with a solution then they will need to reaquire the faulty cameras and either issue credits or cash refunds based upon sales receipts and even including taxes. Such an admission also will make them liable for any damages, real or imagined, suffered by the original purchaser. Frankly, I'm rather amazed they have gotten away without dealing with this problem before now. There are law firms that specialize in these types of issues and I'm certain would love to get their hands on a Class Suit.
Hang in there-John I was the one that suggested that tongue in cheek. I know Americans love a class action for anything. The best one was the fatso's suing McDonalds for making them eat sh!t.
We love our class actions. It's part of being a service-driven economy which, as any economist will tell you, is the goal to which all countries should aspire. Everyone should be so lucky . And don't get me started on the topic of fatties doling out advice on health issues (see advertisements for Michael Moore film.)
stuuke wrote:
I'm really surprised that we haven't heard anything about the firmware tests that took place last week.
The silence is deafening.
Canon now has a full blown marketing nightmare. Whatever the real situation is with the 1D III, they have had more bad press in the last 3 months than in the last 10 years and it's been all self inflicted. Even for them to come out with an official statement saying they take this issue seriously and will do all they can to get to the bottom of the problems many unfortunate people are experiencing they would have garnered a lot more respect.
I'll guarantee that Canon's corporate scum bag lawyers have placed a gag on any body saying anything. The engineers probably know what's going on, but can't say squat.
Pixel Perfect wrote: I was the one that suggested that tongue in cheek. I know Americans love a class action for anything. The best one was the fatso's suing McDonalds for making them eat sh!t.
Is this true? Has this actually happened? If so, what were the results? I mean, no one forced them to go inside and buy it, right?
Yes I mentioned class action as a joke. I don't think the legal wheels turn that fast even if there were a serious attempt to do so. I doubt it would happen, but you never know in America.
From what I've been told by a Canon product specialist, it seams that a physical design fix is required. The guy I spoke to at a CPS expo mentioned that the 40D's AF was designed specifically to withstand large temperature fluctuations (unlike the 1D3) and even the 1Ds3 has a slightly modified AF module that is a somewhat improved version of the 1D3's AF system.
There are basically two options, Canon does a mass recall to swap out AF modules for 1D3 owners or Canon slaps all the early adopters of the 1D3 in the face and quickly releases a 1D3n.