fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006Interesting interview

  
 
JohnJ80
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Interesting interview
DaveMart wrote:
Either IS in lens will have to sell at effectively zero premium, or in body IS will be as common as AF is now - I seem to remember a lot were unenthusiastic about that when it came out, on the grounds that real men MF'd
Regards,
DaveMart


Big assumption here. First it must be proven that in body IS is as good as in lens IS before there is zero premium on in lens IS.

As well, the in body IS cameras need to get some semblance of market share - considerably more than single digit share - to the point where it is threatening to the market leaders. That is a long way from happening.

J.
Sep 22, 2006 at 09:02 PM
kdlanejr
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Interesting interview
There are other alternatives to in camera IS and in lens IS.

Here is one.

http://www.ken-lab.com/stabilizers.html
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:06 PM
Gochugogi
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Interesting interview
Especially since it does not really seem to cost very much for this technology...unlike the lens based IS which costs you a miniumu of $500 per lens.

Did you mean IS costs an extra $500 per lens or Or did you simply mean IS lenses start at $500? Hmm, the EF 28-135 IS USM sells for $425 new. So I guess that means you get the lens free and are only paying for the IS feature, albeit with discount? The EF 70-300 IS USM is $550, so $500 IS and $50 lens?

Whatever, I find it desirable to have IS for both my film and digital bodies.
Sep 23, 2006 at 12:28 AM
Drioannis
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Interesting interview
I had said it many times...Canon WILL make IS body and an affordable one.WHEN is the big question.I am not going to buy any IS lens mainly because the good ones costs,but also because Canon will be obligated by antagonism in the market and must not stay behind.I think that Nikon will make the first steps because she has not FF sensor to answer to Canon.The VR body will be a perfect way to equal things at list in the crop sensor category.
Sep 23, 2006 at 02:07 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Interesting interview
JohnJ80 wrote:
DaveMart wroteEither IS in lens will have to sell at effectively zero premium, or in body IS will be as common as AF is now - I seem to remember a lot were unenthusiastic about that when it came out, on the grounds that real men MF'd
Regards,
DaveMart
Big assumption here. First it must be proven that in body IS is as good as in lens IS before there is zero premium on in lens IS.

As well, the in body IS cameras need to get some semblance of market share - considerably more than single digit share - to the point where it is threatening to the market leaders. That is a long way from happening.

J.

I think at entry level cameras will be bought 'with stabilisation' rather than how good it is being critical, hence my comment about low or zero premium.
And of course, inroads won't be made instantly, so the whole process may take some time - that is one reason why it makes financial sense for Canon and Nikon to hang tough.
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 23, 2006 at 04:02 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Interesting interview
kdlanejr wrote:
There are other alternatives to in camera IS and in lens IS.

Here is one.

http://www.ken-lab.com/stabilizers.html

I can't see too many 400D buyers going for one of those!
Too bulky for most, and far too much hassle.
There is one technology which may come in though - comparing frames just like in a video camera.
Processing speeds would need to increase and there would have to be a move to EVF first though.
At the bottom level I see a merger between video cameras and still cameras in some way, although the cameras won't like it.
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 23, 2006 at 04:06 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Interesting interview
Let's just cut to the chase here.

I have a friend who's the proud owner of a Konica Minolta 5D with the in-body IS. I trust him when he says that it works wonders both in low light long shutter times and for the 200 to 300 mm tele range. I've seen some of his photos which underline that point very clearly.

It may not be as effective as in-lens IS, and it does not have the benefit of stabilising the viewfinder, but nonetheless it can help considerably. Would I like to have that on my camera? Well, yes, that would be nice. Would I like to have that at virtually no price premium? That would be nicer still. Will it make me switch camera system? On its own, that's not likely. But I can see that it will sway some newcomers who haven't got a lens set to speak of.
Sep 23, 2006 at 04:07 AM
Koivulehto
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Interesting interview
DaveMart wrote:
...
There is one technology which may come in though - comparing frames just like in a video camera.
Processing speeds would need to increase and there would have to be a move to EVF first though.
At the bottom level I see a merger between video cameras and still cameras in some way, although the cameras won't like it.
Regards, DaveMart


I am afraid we are drifting away from the original topic of Interesting interview. However, advanced merging of video and still cameras could turn out pretty interesting results. Nowadays you can have a vague idea of possibilities if you rotate your camera's jog wheel quickly when viewing burst shots of moving squirrels or other lively subjects.

Even more off the topic: Why do we shoot stills instead of video? I know I do it because of the relative ease of manuscripting, processing, showing and viewing of the still images, and because of the comparisons we see around: Unless you only subscribe to very high quality photo magazines, it is not so very difficult to produce something comparable or even better still images yourself than what you see around yourself daily. With video it is very different: from TV and DVD we see well manuscripted, directed, played, edited and productized films each evening, which make our own pathetic attempts look really miserable, no matter how much hard work we would put in them. Besides, showing them to others is much more difficult than showing still images.
Sep 23, 2006 at 04:23 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Interesting interview
EOS20 wrote:
Imagine if Nikon teamed up with Sony (Since Nikon is using Sony sensors) And Nikon used the same In body IS as Sony! Where would that leave Canon?


Not sure about Canon, but it would leave Nikon with an inferior IS system on their body. I've heard of one test report that puts the Sony IS system at about a 1-stop advantage over no IS at all. Not very effective if you ask me.

And, there's no way to move the sensor around enough to correct for one of Nikon's big lenses (which is arguably where IS is needed the most).
Sep 23, 2006 at 05:45 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Interesting interview
MikeZ wrote:
That's all great, the only "problem" is that based on the controlled tests and reviews the sensor based IS does work like a charm and gives you at least 2 extra stops if not more.
This simple fact leads me to believe that you are much more likely to be wrong than the laws of physics


The last test I saw gave Sony's system a 1 stop advantage over no IS at all. And that wasn't on a very long lens where IS is actually useful.

Do you have any idea how far the sensor would have to move to correct a simple 2-3 degree movement on a 24 mm lens? How about 300 mm? 500 mm? You might want to study the concept a bit before slinging out insults.
Sep 23, 2006 at 05:57 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Interesting interview
10DFT wrote:
[...]

The last test I saw gave Sony's system a 1 stop advantage over no IS at all. And that wasn't on a very long lens where IS is actually useful.

Do you have any idea how far the sensor would have to move to correct a simple 2-3 degree movement on a 24 mm lens? How about 300 mm? 500 mm? You might want to study the concept a bit before slinging out insults.


For what it's worth, DPReview found the Alpha 100 to bring 2 stops better performance, tested on 50 mm focal length, 75 mm effective.

As for degree of movement, I just tested myself: At about 25 meter distance my aim drifts about 20 cm from the mark I was aiming for, say 40 cm total. That puts my camera shake at, give or take some, just under one degree.

300 mm focal length has a FOV of little under 5 degrees horizontal, corrected for APS-C crop. If my aim is steady within a degree, it means the sensor has to be able to move 1/5th of it's width to be able to compensate. An APS-C sensor is under 24 mm wide, so this proverbial on-the-back-of-a-napkin calculation suggests a correction shift of 2.4 mm away from centre.

Having said this, I know I have a pretty decent steady hand myself, I usually beat the 1/(effective mm) rule by a stop. A movement of up to 4 mm from centre seems possible, looking at the diagrams of the in-lens IS mechanism, so there is room left for more compensation. Even so, it's pretty clear to me that around or above 300 mm you hit the limit with in-body IS.

Oh, one additional note: All this talk about angles only says something on the range of the IS, it has no say on the speed of the IS. It's all fine to have a shift of -x to + x mm available, but as long as there is no information about response time, acceleration and speed, you can not tell which angle speeds can be compensated.
Sep 23, 2006 at 07:17 AM
MikeZ
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Interesting interview
10DFT wrote:
MikeZ wroteThat's all great, the only "problem" is that based on the controlled tests and reviews the sensor based IS does work like a charm and gives you at least 2 extra stops if not more.
This simple fact leads me to believe that you are much more likely to be wrong than the laws of physics
The last test I saw gave Sony's system a 1 stop advantage over no IS at all. And that wasn't on a very long lens where IS is actually useful.

Do you have any idea how far the sensor would have to move to correct a simple 2-3 degree movement on a 24 mm lens? How about 300 mm? 500 mm? You might want to study the concept a bit before slinging out insults.


Just because somebody is telling you that you're wrong doesn't mean that you're being insulted.
As for studying the concept I did and the proof is in the pudding. Most reviewers including DPR give KM and Sony system a 2 stop advantage. Who should I believe? People who actually have the camera and are experienced testers or you who has a "theory" that it doesn't work?
Sep 23, 2006 at 07:49 AM
Gingerbaker
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Interesting interview
An interesting discussion here. Jam-packed with cynicism and hypotheses, which makes for the most enjoyable reading.

I would like to know what is the benefit of using BOTH in-camera and in-lens IS?

I think we can agree on the fact that both work, and that in-camera IS costs almost nothing to implement ( we find it on inexpensive P&S cams, and CD players).

If in-cam and in-lens used simultaneously can have at least an additive effect, then why are we arguing here?

3 or 4 or 5 stops of stabilization is an incredible advantage for a photographer, and is highly preferable to a large aperture lens boosting shutter speed a bit, because the utility of IS is seen at all apertures and shutter speeds.

So - can these technologies be used simultaneously, and what is the nature of the benefit?
Sep 23, 2006 at 07:51 AM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Interesting interview
Gingerbaker wrote:
[...]

So - can these technologies be used simultaneously, and what is the nature of the benefit?


With their current implementation? No, they can not work together. Lens-IS re-aims the light to compensate. Body-IS shifts the sensor to compensate. If both separate systems are active, then the actual shake is amplified. The sensor will move to the side to compensate, while the lens re-aims to keep it centered.

Hypothetically speaking, if both systems are tightly linked AND calibrated together, then they may complement each other. But that will only work once both systems are programmed to take the other into account. Even then, things remain extremely tricky. How are you going to measure the in-effectiveness of the lens-IS, the remainder of unsharpnes so to say? After all, you can't do that with gyro sensors.
Sep 23, 2006 at 07:59 AM
Remford
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Interesting interview
There are other issues which pertain as much to the homogeny of the EOS system as much as the stabilization system itself. At present, those who implement camera-based IS do so by either microactuation or floating the sensor in a magnetic field that receives compensation information from gryo motion sensors. While APS-C sensors have been successfully stabilized in this manner, the mass and size of the full-frame sensors are beyond the current practical technologies for successful, effective, and reliable in-camera stabilization.

This creates a challenge for Canon as the vast majority of their lens line is shared over the entire EOS line, and simply implementing IS in their 1.6x crop sensor bodies then off-sells customers from their IS lenses, not to mention the need to develop either compensatory or overriding mechanisms for an IS lens to peacefully coexist with an IS body. Because they also sell such a large volume of full-frame bodies, (and 1.3x crop as well), the need to keep their stabilization based in the lenses is a fact of life for now, and in practical terms of the marketplace, for as long as the EOS mount exists as we know it.

However, over time, given that Canon offers the EF-S mount as a specialized subset, they DO have the option of offering non-IS lenses geared specifically for the 1.6x crop sensor should they choose to migrate to sensor-based IS on those models. However, this would be on a relatively limited scale, with a limited number of lenses as defined by the eventual size and scope of the EF-S product line-up, and limited to those who do not seek any economies of scale or commonality benefit while also shooting full-frame.

Given that lens-based IS also provides for better overall stabilization potential as it can be tuned for each individual lens, and they also allow me the flexibility of adding IS to a body that doesn't otherwise have it, I'm perfectly comfortable with the cost delta per lens. It's part of shooting with the best in class (which doesn't always happen to be the cheapest).
Sep 23, 2006 at 08:11 AM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Interesting interview
Remford wrote:
Given that lens-based IS also provides for better overall stabilization potential as it can be tuned for each individual lens, and they also allow me the flexibility of adding IS to a body that doesn't otherwise have it, I'm perfectly comfortable with the cost delta per lens. It's part of shooting with the best in class (which doesn't always happen to be the cheapest).


You might be comfortable with the extra cost, but at entry level I doubt that Canon can get away with any cost delta at all, and if that is so they will loose entry level business, which is where the big volume is, which they certainly won't be comfortable with.
You make a very cogent case for the difficulties Canon has in doing in-body IS, so I really think that Canon have a problem, unless they can greatly reduce the premium of entry level IS lenses.
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 23, 2006 at 08:37 AM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Interesting interview
MikeZ wrote:
Just because somebody is telling you that you're wrong doesn't mean that you're being insulted.


I'm not insulted that you are claiming I'm wrong, even though I am not wrong. You just don't want to discuss the physics of the situation.

I've seen Phil's test. The graphic results are not in perfect alignment with his quote of "about 2 stops", but I'd give it more than 1 stop, maybe a stop and a half. With a 50 mm lens. Try the same test with a big long telephoto and the system will be woefully ineffective. There's no way to move the sensor far enough with enough speed to account for the magnified shake motions that occur with long lenses.

Photography Monthly just tested the Sony Alpha anti-shake system with a 70-300 mm lens. At 300 mm, they got less than 1 stop of improvement. That's nearly useless.

As for studying the concept I did and the proof is in the pudding. Most reviewers including DPR give KM and Sony system a 2 stop advantage. Who should I believe? People who actually have the camera and are experienced testers or you who has a "theory" that it doesn't work?

In other words, you don't understand how it works, but you'll take someone else's word that it is effective (BTW, where's these other reviewers?). That's fine - it's your money. But when you really need IS, the camera-bases system will be very ineffective compared to the lens-based systems that are out there now. What's marginally effective at 50 mm will not be effective with a long, heavy lens. And a long and heavy lens presents the type of situation where IS is the most needed.
Sep 23, 2006 at 10:41 AM
Joe Tidwell
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Interesting interview
Am i simplifying this too much or is the answer for canon pretty simple. All they have to do is lower the prices on IS based lenses to something more reasonable to compete with entry level dslr's that have in body IS.

I was happy when the announced the 70-200 f4 IS cause i though it would be more affordable over the 2.8 version. After i found out the price i lost half my interest in it. If canon would just lower the prices on entry level IS lenses they could compete.

I guess corporate greed and profit margins play a big part in canon cutting prices though.
Sep 23, 2006 at 11:49 AM
jwcn
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Interesting interview
While it is generally believed that Canon is a commercially savvy company which knows how to squeeze the last penny out of a hapless comsumer, the commercial interests do not always conflict with technical good sense. In this case, I tend to give them the benefit of doubt and believe until proven wrong that IS built into lenses is better than that in the camera body. Think of where the bulk of the weight lies when you hold a 70-200mm F2.8 and you may see my point. The current controversy reminds one of the switch from FD to EF lens mount nearly two decades ago. A lot of people, including me, cried foul at the time and some perhaps even cursed the company. But in the event, we all know what EF has brought to the Canon users. Without this painful and necessary move, Canon would still be living in the shadow of Nikon. So, let's hold our breath and see how the body-based IS evolves before passing our judgement.
Sep 23, 2006 at 12:30 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Interesting interview
I tend to give them the benefit of doubt and believe until proven wrong that IS built into lenses is better than that in the camera body.

I don't think anyone is disputing that lens based IS will provide better results than camera based IS...but for zero cost to you, you have the option of camera based IS when using a Sony or a Pentax. The camera based IS might not provide much for telephoto users...but think of what an extra 2 stops of hand holdability does with the 85 1.2 or the 35 1.4

Yeh, really I don't see a use for the in camera IS.
Sep 23, 2006 at 01:27 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister