fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006Interesting interview

  
 
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Interesting interview
Semi off-topic: I've had an electoral course on patents (which does not make me an expert, but I may know a tiny bit more than average) so I'm betting that the idea of a floating lens element to counteract camera/lens shake is expired.

Or, less likely, the invention was found to be too obvious, from a technical point of view, and therfore it was not granted a patent in the first place. But I'm betting expiration.
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:12 AM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Interesting interview
Beni wrote:
I had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.



...and what about the image circles of EF-S lenses (and the like).
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:15 AM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
bouch wrote[...]

The lens you mention, the Tamron 12-24, is still basically a 35mm lens on an APS camera. Only the EF-S lens with their shorter back focus distance are really APS lenses. People complain all the time that their lenses aren't good enough in the corners on FF. Imagine how bad it would be if the sensor was moving around.

[...]
I have to correct two things: The TOKINA (sorry, not Tamron) lens is optimised for an APS-C sized sensor. The fact that EF-S allows for deeper intrusion of the rear element into the camera has little to do with optimisation for projection circle.

Most EF-S lenses can be hacked to work on the 10D, while some will wreck its mirror. Which means not all EF-S lenses fully utilise the possibility that the specifications allow.

Sigma optimises for the smaller projection circle and puts a DC tag in the lens designation. Tamron puts the Di II tag in there. Tokina has
...Show more →

Exactly. One *can* mount a Tokina 12-24 on a 1D or 5D, but the image circle will not cover the sensor at all focal lengths. So, no, it is not basically a 35mm lens (which is why it is not marketed as such).
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:20 AM
pookipichu
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Interesting interview
bouch wrote:
pookipichu wroteThe United States is a country formed and built by complainers. If people didn't complain or were supressed from complaining by wiretaps, secret prisons, threat of professional destruction by outing undercover operatives working for national security, hegemonistic cabal, we'd be living in a fascistic society.

Edited by pookipichu on Sep 22, 2006 at 03:41 PM GMT
Wow, you got me pookipichu! Unfortunately for you I work for the govenrment, and now I'm going to authorize wiretapping for all the 'Jade Youngs' in NYC. This is becuase I'm a fascist and I don't want any 'leftists' like you forcing Canon to implement in camera IS. If you don't shut up then you're going to Gitmo!

Oh, by the way, Sony, Mintolta, Pentax, etc. all use APS sized sensors and 35mm lenses... meaning the image circle is much bigger than the sensors.


Interesting you thought I was talking about the US... in any event I have no political affiliation so I'm no more a "leftist" than anyone else who cares about human rights. As you seem so tender on the subject, I assume you are a republican and I will refrain from discussing what human rights and dignity are.

PS- Tamron, Tokina and Sigma make reduced image circle sensors for Sony, Minolta and Pentax...

PPS- Furthermore, funny you don't see the irony in complaining about complainers.

Edited by pookipichu on Sep 22, 2006 at 05:29 PM GMT
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:23 AM
EOS20
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Interesting interview
Pentax and Minolta also have there own lineup of "Digital" lenses designed for APS-C sized sensors.
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:25 AM
mh2000
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Interesting interview
yeah, yeah, that's what I'd be worrying about if I was comparing an $800 XTi to an $800 A100. Gee, I can get an A100 with some top Zeiss primes using in body IS or an XTi with some top L primes and no IS. Man, Zeiss + IS would be nothing but a total waste! ? (Ok, as a system, Canon still leads... but come on... if Sony can do it, so can Canon... but maybe Nikon has to blink first?)

Me_XMan wrote:
I will never buy in-body IS. It's wasted money since depreciation is way faster with body than lens.
...

Sep 22, 2006 at 11:34 AM
EOS20
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Interesting interview
Imagine if Nikon teamed up with Sony (Since Nikon is using Sony sensors) And Nikon used the same In body IS as Sony! Where would that leave Canon?
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:37 AM
lexvo
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Interesting interview
Maybe there is some parallel here with the old discussion of AF-motor in the body vs. AF-motor in the lens?
Sep 22, 2006 at 11:39 AM
mh2000
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Interesting interview
No, because EF lenses with in body motors were still cheaper than Nikon lenses.

lexvo wrote:
Maybe there is some parallel here with the old discussion of AF-motor in the body vs. AF-motor in the lens?

Sep 22, 2006 at 11:46 AM
mh2000
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Interesting interview
no, because EF lenses were still cheaper than Nikon lenses.

lexvo wrote:
Maybe there is some parallel here with the old discussion of AF-motor in the body vs. AF-motor in the lens?

Sep 22, 2006 at 11:47 AM
JohnJ80
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
Good point on reliability JohnJ80, allthough I think that if the sensor can no longer move, you're not out of luck in the "Taking pictures" market. In most cases you'll just loose the IS functionality. But you're off on your assumption that IF in-body IS is superior, it would have been done first.

Canon and Nikon both have developed in-lens IS because you can not stabilise film!



I'm more worried about the reliability of the electrical connection to the sensor than I am about the IS functionality. This connector will be suspect and a point of failure. If it fails, the sensor would either be (a) degraded performance or (b) non functional. If the IS fails, it is most likely as you say.

on the point of whether is in body or in lens is better. I'm speaking in a digital context. If it is significantly better and lower cost giving market advantages then i'm sure the other two would meet that need. If it is more difficult to produce, then I'd think Canon and Nikon would have an advantage there with deeper pockets to aid in figuring it out.

I'll bet if Konica/Sony starts getting real market share, you will see the price on IS drop. However, I don't think that will happen - there are other huge barriers to Sony rather than the type of IS. Everyone keeps talking about the demise of Canon and/or Nikon and it never happens. Canon just keeps moving out and increasing market share (dunno about Nikon, don't follow them enough to know).

J.
Sep 22, 2006 at 12:57 PM
mh2000
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Interesting interview
Back when I bought my EOS 650 Canon was only the number 3 Japanese camera maker... thanks to their technological inovation they climbed to number 1 relatively quickly. I wouldn't write Sony off and assume that Canon will stay number one. I'm sure Nikon didn't see Canon ever taking them on... and "winning."
Sep 22, 2006 at 01:07 PM
nobody235
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Interesting interview
Me_XMan wrote:
I will never buy in-body IS. It's wasted money since depreciation is way faster with body than lens. :(

so, will you never buy a $8k camera? cause depreciation is way faster with those.
i think you should just stick to the $500 cameras. their depreciation is slower
Sep 22, 2006 at 01:28 PM
nobody235
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Interesting interview
Tentacle wrote:
bouch wrote[...]

The lens you mention, the Tamron 12-24, is still basically a 35mm lens on an APS camera. Only the EF-S lens with their shorter back focus distance are really APS lenses. People complain all the time that their lenses aren't good enough in the corners on FF. Imagine how bad it would be if the sensor was moving around.

[...]
I have to correct two things: The TOKINA (sorry, not Tamron) lens is optimised for an APS-C sized sensor. The fact that EF-S allows for deeper intrusion of the rear element into the camera has little to do with optimisation for projection circle.

Most EF-S lenses can be hacked to work on the 10D, while some will wreck its mirror. Which means not all EF-S lenses fully utilise the possibility that the specifications allow.

Sigma optimises for the smaller projection circle and puts a DC tag in the lens designation. Tamron puts the Di II tag in there. Tokina has
...Show more →


i don't follow the argument. so are you saying that the pentax won't work with DC lenses? cause the image circle is too small, and so the in-body stabilization won't work?
i haven't seem a disclaimer of that sort, and i don't think that is true. thus, it works.
Sep 22, 2006 at 01:34 PM
Tentacle
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Interesting interview
nobody235 wrote:
[...]

i don't follow the argument. so are you saying that the pentax won't work with DC lenses? cause the image circle is too small, and so the in-body stabilization won't work?
i haven't seem a disclaimer of that sort, and i don't think that is true. thus, it works.


No, you seem to reverse what I say

My point is: All lenses that are "APS-C optimised" (So, DC, Di II, DX and EF-S) project their focus on an area AT LEAST the size of APS-C. People tend to expect a sharp dark-light transition, but that is not the case: How this works is that the intended projection area is slightly bigger than APS-C to begin with and the design team does not devote time and effort to check quality far outside the APS-C area.

But... they do leave a margin. A margin in which the in-body IS will work.

Sigma DC lenses, which are of the APS-C optimised flavor, work with the Konica Minolta 5D and 7D. (Yes, they have in-body IS too) So, APS-C optimised projection means enough margin to have in-body IS work. The same applies to the rest of the clan.
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:24 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Interesting interview
I will never buy in-body IS. It's wasted money since depreciation is way faster with body than lens.

With the digital age, we've entered the era of disposable cameras...we all sell our old cameras when the new better version comes out. With in-camera IS, with each upgrade of camera, we have the possibility of upgrading the IS capabilities, while keeping our most precious and expensive investments in lenses alone. This to me is a huge benefit of camera IS.
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:49 PM
JohnJ80
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Interesting interview
mh2000 wrote:
Back when I bought my EOS 650 Canon was only the number 3 Japanese camera maker... thanks to their technological inovation they climbed to number 1 relatively quickly. I wouldn't write Sony off and assume that Canon will stay number one. I'm sure Nikon didn't see Canon ever taking them on... and "winning."


For major market share changes, it usually takes a major technology transition - like film to digital. There is nothing like that, i.e. that major, on the horizon in this industry as they consolidate the end of this one. Sony has not done anything even close to being earthshaking, they are a company in turmoil and financial distress, and they are taking on market leaders that have gargantuan market share compared to theirs. Any one of those characteristics has a greater chance of being fatal rather than successful. Recall that in the film days, Canon, Nikon and Minolta where much more tightly grouped in terms of market share.

J
Sep 22, 2006 at 02:57 PM
nathanlake
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Interesting interview
EOS20 wrote:
Intresting artical.

I think the main reason why Canon won't add in body IS is not just becuse they belive that lens IS is better, But becuse they know that they can charge us more to buy IS lenses! Not really much point in adding more IS lenses to the lineup if they are going to charge us a huge markup prices over the non-IS equivalent. What Canon needs to do is make IS lenses more affordable!

I would like in body IS as a option, As Lasse mentioned, You could always turn it off when using IS lenses, and you can
...Show more →

I agree I would like to see in body IS, but I disagree with your guess at Canon's motivation. I would guess it is more a matter of cost for them. They have done the R&D for lens based IS. They have a system that works and is well respected. If they now develop an in-body IS, there is a huge up front cost that they might be unwilling to incur.

I would rather see them incorporate IS in a larger number of lenses and since the R&D costs have already been recovered (and competition is growing) drop the cost to the consumer.


Sep 22, 2006 at 03:04 PM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Interesting interview
chez wrote:
Earlier quoteI will never buy in-body IS. It's wasted money since depreciation is way faster with body than lens.
With the digital age, we've entered the era of disposable cameras...we all sell our old cameras when the new better version comes out. With in-camera IS, with each upgrade of camera, we have the possibility of upgrading the IS capabilities, while keeping our most precious and expensive investments in lenses alone. This to me is a huge benefit of camera IS.


With the Contax AX, rather than compromise the quality of the Zeiss lens lineup by adding AF motors, they implemented in-camera AF by moving the film plane closer or further away from the rear element. They effectively added AF to every Contax-Zeiss lens without touching the lenses. It worked remarkably well and had the added feature of making every lens capable of macro.

I welcome the idea of in-camera IS because, if I did choose to use IS, it would work with any lens (Canon or not) that is mountable on the EOS mount. Also, the next body and next body after that would simply improve the whole system. It is a moot point, though, because I still have no need for IS. Maybe on a 400mm if I ever need one.

It'll never happen, but I'd like to see Kyocera bring out a Contax AX-D. FF, 16MP, C/Y mount, no AA filter, built-in IS (not a must), and sensor-plane focusing. I'd pay $5000 (and my left nut) for that.
Sep 22, 2006 at 03:23 PM
Adrian Warren
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Interesting interview
Interesting discussion so far!

Does anyone know of a third party IS lens can be used on a camera with inbody IS? There are third party IS type lenses out there afterall, like the Sigma 80-400 OS.

Personally I suspect that the correction applied by in lens IS would conflict with in body IS unless you use some sort of linked IS system...

Personally I'd love to see both in one setup - ideally with a fast lens and clean high ISO. Just imagine being able to handhold 100% sharp in any light :)
Sep 22, 2006 at 03:48 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister