fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2006 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2006Interesting interview

  
 
mh2000
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Interesting interview
I don't remember the EOS cameras being that earth shatteringly different from the Nikons of the time... but I do remember trying them and the Minoltas and thinking the Canon was a little better and a lot cheaper... I had walked in to buy a Nikon and walked out with a Canon... that's what it takes, thousands of people feeling just a minor tug... it all adds up. All my Nikon snob friends thought I was crazy.

I'm not looking to change systems at this point, but if I was a new buyer I would look at both the Sony and Pentax offerings... and maybe go with one of them instead. 10 years ago with film cameras I never would have said that (rebel, elan, 3 and 1-series ruled!). I think Canon is going to have a hard time keeping the lead in all DSLR slots like it had managed to do in film bodies for quite a few years.

The little Pentax's are quite nice cameras and Pentax is putting out some very good lenses to go with them... Canon has nothing at the lowend to compete well IMO... maybe they'll settle for mid-high range cameras.

JohnJ80 wrote:
mh2000 wroteBack when I bought my EOS 650 Canon was only the number 3 Japanese camera maker... thanks to their technological inovation they climbed to number 1 relatively quickly. I wouldn't write Sony off and assume that Canon will stay number one. I'm sure Nikon didn't see Canon ever taking them on... and "winning."
For major market share changes, it usually takes a major technology transition - like film to digital. There is nothing like that, i.e. that major, on the horizon in this industry as they consolidate the end of this one. Sony has not done anything even close to being earthshaking, they are a company in turmoil and financial distress, and they are taking on market leaders that have gargantuan market share compared to theirs. Any one of those characteristics has a greater chance of being fatal rather than successful. Recall that in the film days, Canon, Nikon and Minolta where much
...Show more →
Sep 22, 2006 at 04:07 PM
Flappie
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Interesting interview
Well, I would be surprised to see Canon say that in camera IS would be better than what they are delivering.
As soon as they market a camera with AS integrated, they'll just swap opinion

In body AS has many advantages ...

Flappie
Sep 22, 2006 at 04:16 PM
hartgebm
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Interesting interview
I think Canon is doing the right thing here with keeping in-lens IS and not using in-body IS.

I think that one MAJOR factor that we are all forgetting here is this........fine, go change to sony or konica or whoever is offering in-body IS but remember one thing, and thats that Canon makes the best interchangable Autofocus lenses for any mainstream film or digital slr hands down, in the world.

Yes leica and zeiss make great stuff, but within the reach or the ordinary Mr Smith, no. Canon still offers that option with superb optics and the world best autofocus, no question.

I cannot beleive that anybody would want in -body IS. The mirror does not move so you dont see it through the viewfinder. Half the point of IS int he lens is to make composition easier for long lenses, not just when you press the shutter.

My 2c, I hope it makes sense.
Sep 22, 2006 at 04:56 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Interesting interview
cannot beleive that anybody would want in -body IS.

Give me a break Scott. You are telling me that you don't see the value of having IS on all the lenses you own? If Canon came out with IS, everyone here who is saying they don't need it would be praising Canon. Brand loyalty is great, but let's call a spade a spade. In body IS ( for under $1000 ) is a great feature that will shake things up.
Sep 22, 2006 at 05:25 PM
hartgebm
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Interesting interview
Sorry,

think of is this way, the people that will buy a body with IS probably were never going to buy lenses of canon's top league L series anyway. In body IS gives those who dont know any better the opportunity to have 2 stops of stabilisation.

Are you telling me that you would buy a Sony SLR with in body IS instead of a 400D? I know I wouldnt.

All I am saying is that Canon wont release in-body IS because of the engineering problems that it causes "in camera" to do it properly. Without the mirror being stabilised you are working with a sort of false hope that the stabiliser will work once you take the shot.

I am not saying that in-body IS doesnt have its place, what I am saying is that everybody on this board has a canon, and has so for a reason. And even if canon release a in-body IS system you all would take the piss out of it for not being as good as the in-lens version anyway.

In-lens IS is simply a superior system hands down, and we should be praising canon for its creation, not covering them in criticism for their commitment to it.

Yes a spade is indeed a spade, and yes it will shake up the market. But you are forgetting that we are experienced photogs that can tell the difference, and we represent such a small proportion of the international market. Canon will sell 400D's like there is no tomorrow. Sony will sell Alpha's simply because the market will buy them cause it has a sony logo on it and they dont know any better.

anyway, what does it matter if Canon makes money from selling us IS lenses, at least they will be here in 50 years times still producing fantastic ground breaking stuff. I want them to make money because I keep having my hobby fuelled by great product. If canon make screw ups, anybody for that matter, they go out of business, like that other brand......what was their name again...Konica. Hang on, didnt they have in-body IS..........

I am not brand loyal to canon, but I see a company that "does it right", and I appreciate it.

cheers, Scott
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:10 PM
Pixel Perfect
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Interesting interview
Beni wrote:
I had understood that you could not shift a FF sensor with an internal IS system simply because you don't have enough lens circle spare to do so as opposed to an APC system where you have plenty room to shift to given that it is a substantial crop of the lens imaging circle.

That makes the dilemma even worse for canon.


That doesn't quite make sense. We now have in camera IS that works fine with digital only lenses, ie lenses that have had there imaging circle diameter reduced by 1.5x. So they are now in the same situation as FF with FF lenses.
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:20 PM
MikeZ
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Interesting interview
hartgebm wrote:
I cannot beleive that anybody would want in -body IS. The mirror does not move so you dont see it through the viewfinder. Half the point of IS int he lens is to make composition easier for long lenses, not just when you press the shutter.

My 2c, I hope it makes sense.


No, it doesn't make sense since the other half the point of IS is to minimize the blurred pictures due to the camera shake when using ANY lens. Not just for a long lenses.
I can compose with my primes without the IS just fine and I can not believe that anybody would question the value of the sensor based IS because they can not see it in the viewfinder.

My 2c
Sep 22, 2006 at 06:31 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Interesting interview
All I am saying is that Canon wont release in-body IS because of the engineering problems that it causes "in camera" to do it properly. Without the mirror being stabilised you are working with a sort of false hope that the stabiliser will work once you take the shot.

No. Canon will not release ( until market pressure forces them ) in-body IS because they make too much money off the IS lenses. It has nothing to do with "engineering problems", but everything to do with profits.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:20 PM
rceres
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Interesting interview
""No, it doesn't make sense since the other half the point of IS is to minimize the blurred pictures due to the camera shake when using ANY lens. Not just for a long lenses.
I can compose with my primes without the IS just fine and I can not believe that anybody would question the value of the sensor based IS because they can not see it in the viewfinder.""

Camera shake does not really effect all lenses, or at least not equally. Why would anyone want IS on the 85 1.2L or 50 1.2L for example, never mind the 35 or 24 1.4 L's? IS is of little or no benefit there. Now for 200mm and up, IS is probably a miracle, but IS on a 300mm F2.8 lens is hardly a significant portion of the price. And, if you are spending that much on the lens, wouldn't you want the best possible (ie. in the lens) vibration mitigation? I sure would.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:27 PM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Interesting interview
I think a quick study of the physics of image stabilization will shed light on why putting the moving stabilization mechanism as close to the nodal point on the lens is the most efficient and effective way to achieve the stabilizing effect. The closer to the nodal point, the less corrective movement is necessary to stabilize an image. A sensor-based IS system will have to move a great deal longer than a lens-based stabilizing system to counter the shake that one might see in a handheld 300 mm shot.

It's the job of marketing to make us all forget the science behind photography, which is why they can sell Olympus "digital" lenses and sensor-based image stabilization. Unfortunately, and based on many responses on this thread, the marketers have more influence than the scientists, engineers, and physicists.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:46 PM
hartgebm
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Interesting interview
I must be missing the whole point here.......
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:50 PM
MikeZ
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Interesting interview
rceres wrote:
Camera shake does not really effect all lenses, or at least not equally. Why would anyone want IS on the 85 1.2L or 50 1.2L for example, never mind the 35 or 24 1.4 L's? IS is of little or no benefit there.


I hope you're kidding.
I can (unfortunately) show you plenty of slightly blurred shots from my 85L wide open at 1/80-1/100 where I couldn't handhold steady in low light.
There is a reason why a lot of people grab the 35L and marvel at the fact that they can shoot hand held at lower speeds in low light.
If I could get a blur-free images from 85L at 1/30 I would be in heaven.
You seem to have some nice primes in your arsenal, Let's see some of your shots from your EF100 f2 below 1/100 hand held, let's see how you can use this lens indoors without the flash hand held at low speeds.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:53 PM
hartgebm
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Interesting interview
10DFT, couldnt agree more.
Sep 22, 2006 at 07:56 PM
Tom_W
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Interesting interview
nathanlake wrote:
I agree I would like to see in body IS, but I disagree with your guess at Canon's motivation. I would guess it is more a matter of cost for them. They have done the R&D for lens based IS. They have a system that works and is well respected. If they now develop an in-body IS, there is a huge up front cost that they might be unwilling to incur.

I would rather see them incorporate IS in a larger number of lenses and since the R&D costs have already been recovered (and competition is growing) drop the cost to
...Show more →

The are putting IS in a larger number of lenses (note the 24-105, 17-55, and 17-85). I suspect that there will be the opportunity to buy an IS version of the entire midrange of Canon zooms in the next year or two.

The competition's in-body IS will likely put pricing pressure on the lens-based system of Canon and Nikon, but not at the high end. It's not likely that an effective sensor-based IS system will emerge that can be as effective as that of the bigger lenses that both Canon and Nikon produce.

If the competitive market dictates it, Canon will put IS in the body on the consumer DSLR bodies. I don't believe that it will be a favorable move in terms of absolute image quality, but it will certainly be a favorable move in terms of sales and marketing.

Kind-of a shame when the best image stabilizers available are already manufactured by the likes of Manfrotto, Gitzo, and Slik. It's pretty hard to beat the ultimate shake-cancelling effect of a good tripod.
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:00 PM
MikeZ
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Interesting interview
10DFT wrote:
I think a quick study of the physics of image stabilization will shed light on why putting the moving stabilization mechanism as close to the nodal point on the lens is the most efficient and effective way to achieve the stabilizing effect. The closer to the nodal point, the less corrective movement is necessary to stabilize an image. A sensor-based IS system will have to move a great deal longer than a lens-based stabilizing system to counter the shake that one might see in a handheld 300 mm shot.

It's the job of marketing to make us all forget the
...Show more →

That's all great, the only "problem" is that based on the controlled tests and reviews the sensor based IS does work like a charm and gives you at least 2 extra stops if not more.
This simple fact leads me to believe that you are much more likely to be wrong than the laws of physics
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:08 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Interesting interview
Alright, all you people bashing the in-body IS...would you be singing a different tune if the 400D had it. I'm sure you would. Who would not want in-body IS. You can turn it off if you don't want it. I just don't understand why anyone would defend Canon for not putting it into their bodies. Especially since it does not really seem to cost very much for this technology...unlike the lens based IS which costs you a miniumu of $500 per lens.
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:16 PM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Interesting interview
10DFT wrote:
Kind-of a shame when the best image stabilizers available are already manufactured by the likes of Manfrotto, Gitzo, and Slik. It's pretty hard to beat the ultimate shake-cancelling effect of a good tripod.


Not really a shame at all for those who have the sense to realize it and not get caught up in the bloody IS hype. On top of that, the lighting options and techniques available pretty easily cover the rest of the equation.

So, go ahead and stick IS in a body. Even if it is less effective than the lens-based IS. The pros won't care one way or the other.




Sep 22, 2006 at 08:19 PM
cogitech
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Interesting interview
chez wrote:
Alright, all you people bashing the in-body IS...would you be singing a different tune if the 400D had it. I'm sure you would. Who would not want in-body IS. You can turn it off if you don't want it. I just don't understand why anyone would defend Canon for not putting it into their bodies. Especially since it does not really seem to cost very much for this technology...unlike the lens based IS which costs you a miniumu of $500 per lens.


Fanboy doctrine dictates:

"If Canon doesn't do it, it is a bad idea, it sucks beyond belief"
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:21 PM
DaveMart
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Interesting interview
cogitech wrote:
10DFT wroteKind-of a shame when the best image stabilizers available are already manufactured by the likes of Manfrotto, Gitzo, and Slik. It's pretty hard to beat the ultimate shake-cancelling effect of a good tripod.
Not really a shame at all for those who have the sense to realize it and not get caught up in the bloody IS hype. On top of that, the lighting options and techniques available pretty easily cover the rest of the equation.

So, go ahead and stick IS in a body. Even if it is less effective than the lens-based IS. The pros won't care one way or the other.


The needs of non-pros are just as valid, and not everyone wants to lug a ton of gear, tripods and so on.
Different folk have different cost/performance/convenience trade offs - for instance some are happy to go along with 35mm, for others only MF will do.
In body IS will help most photographers, and most photographers are the ones who pay for the camera industry.
Either IS in lens will have to sell at effectively zero premium, or in body IS will be as common as AF is now - I seem to remember a lot were unenthusiastic about that when it came out, on the grounds that real men MF'd
Regards,
DaveMart
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:53 PM
JohnJ80
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Interesting interview
chez wrote:
Alright, all you people bashing the in-body IS...would you be singing a different tune if the 400D had it. I'm sure you would. Who would not want in-body IS. You can turn it off if you don't want it. I just don't understand why anyone would defend Canon for not putting it into their bodies. Especially since it does not really seem to cost very much for this technology...unlike the lens based IS which costs you a miniumu of $500 per lens.


You are making a mistake in your logic here. Namely, there is a big difference between 'cost' and 'price' and you are confusing the two. The $500 you are referring to is 'price.' If this becomes a competitive technology (it is not now, since it is on ho hum bodies) then look for this 'price' to decline as well as Nikon's VR technology. When the price is less than the cost, then a decision gets made on whether to withdraw the product from the market or not. I think it fair to say that Canon's Price reflects what the market will bear and is much in excess compared to their cost.

Either way, IS is secondary to me. Its nice, but by no means mandatory or even primary when I select lenses. I have a good tripod, and I use it, and that is much better than any IS anyhow.

J.
Sep 22, 2006 at 08:57 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister