Sorry,
think of is this way, the people that will buy a body with IS probably were never going to buy lenses of canon's top league L series anyway. In body IS gives those who dont know any better the opportunity to have 2 stops of stabilisation.
Are you telling me that you would buy a Sony SLR with in body IS instead of a 400D? I know I wouldnt.
All I am saying is that Canon wont release in-body IS because of the engineering problems that it causes "in camera" to do it properly. Without the mirror being stabilised you are working with a sort of false hope that the stabiliser will work once you take the shot.
I am not saying that in-body IS doesnt have its place, what I am saying is that everybody on this board has a canon, and has so for a reason. And even if canon release a in-body IS system you all would take the piss out of it for not being as good as the in-lens version anyway.
In-lens IS is simply a superior system hands down, and we should be praising canon for its creation, not covering them in criticism for their commitment to it.
Yes a spade is indeed a spade, and yes it will shake up the market. But you are forgetting that we are experienced photogs that can tell the difference, and we represent such a small proportion of the international market. Canon will sell 400D's like there is no tomorrow. Sony will sell Alpha's simply because the market will buy them cause it has a sony logo on it and they dont know any better.
anyway, what does it matter if Canon makes money from selling us IS lenses, at least they will be here in 50 years times still producing fantastic ground breaking stuff. I want them to make money because I keep having my hobby fuelled by great product. If canon make screw ups, anybody for that matter, they go out of business, like that other brand......what was their name again...Konica. Hang on, didnt they have in-body IS..........
I am not brand loyal to canon, but I see a company that "does it right", and I appreciate it.
cheers, Scott