p.5 #1What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Reading this enlightening thread, I was wondering if we would see such a comment as this below, with not much hope I admit:
'It is very sharp, maybe a bit too sharp for my personal liking. I often reduce sharpness..'
Sharpness has been sanctified. Like money, you can never have too much of it! Just don't ask your women folk what they like in your photos of them. In brief - in film days the optical designers strove for maximum sharpness because film is a soft and forgiving medium. Enter the harsh mistress of digital and these same designers kept on going that way, and on and on, as technology improved and profits rose.
It was sold to you as perfection. But digital needs very careful calibration of lens aberrations, careful balancing of resolution and lens micro-contrast, and especially astute handling of high spatial frequencies ('sharpness') so as not to be very unpleasant to many subjects - like...human skin!
p.5 #2What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Out of everything I’ve used I’d have to give it to either my old Sigma 35mm 1.4 Art (The DSLR mount version) or my lowly Nikon Z50mm 1.8s. My 600 PF is super sharp too, but not quite at the level of the 50 stopped down to f2.
p.5 #3What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Sharpest lens I've ever owned was my Nikon 180mm f2.8 AF-ED. I still have it despite no longer owning any Nikon full frame dslr's or Nikon mirrorless bodies. I'll probably use it on my Nikon F100 and F5 film cameras some day.
p.5 #4What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
philip_pj wrote:
Reading this enlightening thread, I was wondering if we would see such a comment as this below, with not much hope I admit:
'It is very sharp, maybe a bit too sharp for my personal liking. I often reduce sharpness..'
While I understand your perspective, it is much harder to hide, or work around, the flaws of a poor optic, versus softening/smoothing/compressing the effects of 'too much' resolution or dynamic range. It may be my engineering perspective, but I can't wrap my head around the concept of too much resolution/detail/dynamic range/whatever.
Tossing data makes more sense than trying to fill in the gaps. I don't obsess over optical perfection, but my favorite lenses have a certain perceptual snap that sets them a level above. Sharpness, micro contrast, smoothness of Bokeh, or whatever criterian one may pick, they are perceivably different. I measure, test, and beat on mechanical things for a living, but try not to take that obsession into my photography.
p.5 #6What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Michel85 wrote:
My tripod is my sharpest lens. It makes each lens shine just a bit more in terms of when I value critical sharpness edge to edge.
Other than that I think most modern lenses have good sharpness, one just more than the other, especially in far corners.
I receintly purchased the Voigtlander 28mm APO. It is very sharp, maybe a bit too sharp for my personal liking.
I often reduce sharpness a bit by adding a bit of softness / grain. I seem to prefer that.
The tripod statement is very true! Now aIl I need is just an automagic, small, light, stable, quick setup and teardown tripod.
p.5 #8What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
A very sharp lens is all very good, but it is not the be-all-and-end-all as far as lens desirability is concerned, IMO. There are many other attributes that make up a great lens, sharpness only being one of them and even then it may not be a priority for some uses. Right tool for the right job. Many of my favourite images are from lenses going back many years that wouldn't be considered sharp compared to the modern day lenses and I dare say that having a sharper lens wouldn't have made them any more desirable.
p.5 #9What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
My now obsoleted Nikon AF 180mm 2.8D IF-ED. It's way sharper at 2.8 than any Nikon telephoto zoom i've ever used. A special mention goes to the Sigma 35mm 1.4 art and my Nikon D4S combo.
p.5 #12What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
For my somewhat modest collection it's the Nikon 50 1.8S. That lens isn't just crispy sharpness but also so much detail. Shortly after getting my Z8 and that lens I took a quick snap of my mother in law outside. The lighting happened to be just right and that image blew me away. It was not like looking at a picture, it was like looking at a real miniature person and the screen just disappeared.
p.5 #13What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
1. Leica SL APO Summicron 21mm (and most of the other APO SUmmicrons)
2. Hasselblad XCD 120mm macro
3. Sony 300mm 2.8 GM
4. Sharpest zoom: Sigma 300-600 f4
5. Olympus 75mm 1.8.
p.5 #15What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Probably the CV 50mm f/2 Apo-Lanthar, but I sold it because I found myself using a manual focus lens so rarely. I've become spoiled by the impressive autofocus performance of essentially all my excellent Sony OEM lenses.
I use the 24-70 f/2.8 GMII and the 50mm f/1.2 GM for that focal length.
Unless you're obsessed with pixel-peeping or print billboard size, it's amazing how well most lenses do these days. I share prints, yes, prints, with a small group monthly. We NEVER discuss technique, just whether the image is artistically successful. It's liberating not to worry about bokeh, center vs corner sharpness, and other concerns of the technically obsessed.
p.5 #16What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
I guess for today and claiming sharpest, the sensor pixel pitch viewed on matters.
In my case, I don’t recall being blown away by any lenses that resolved perfectly on my Fuji GFX100 or XH2, but the GF 55 and Nikkor 105/1.4 both were very close if not there, at least centrally and stopped down a few. The Fuji 8-16/2.8 APSC lens may have made it on the XH2.
The 135 Plena was superb on the Z9 45mp sensor, but so were many of my other Z lenses; as was the adapted 105/1.4 G lens.
Today, and somewhat surprisingly, most of my zooms can resolve to the sensor of my Sony A7R6, at least centrally. This includes the 24-70/2.8 GMII, 70-200/4 G oss ii, Tamron 12-20/2.8(!) and Tamron 35-150/2-2.8…
p.5 #18What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Superscroll wrote:
For my somewhat modest collection it's the Nikon 50 1.8S. That lens isn't just crispy sharpness but also so much detail. Shortly after getting my Z8 and that lens I took a quick snap of my mother in law outside. The lighting happened to be just right and that image blew me away. It was not like looking at a picture, it was like looking at a real miniature person and the screen just disappeared.
The 50 1.8S is just stupid sharp , unbelievably so considering it's price point!
p.5 #19What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Lance B wrote:
A very sharp lens is all very good, but it is not the be-all-and-end-all as far as lens desirability is concerned, IMO. There are many other attributes that make up a great lens, sharpness only being one of them and even then it may not be a priority for some uses. Right tool for the right job. Many of my favourite images are from lenses going back many years that wouldn't be considered sharp compared to the modern day lenses and I dare say that having a sharper lens wouldn't have made them any more desirable.
Lance, I couldn't agree more. Sharpness is only one piece of the puzzle when it comes to what makes a great lens. Things like microcontrast, color rendition, and background rendering can have just as much, if not more, impact on the final image.
A lens with beautiful microcontrast, for example, can produce a sense of depth and tonal separation that some clinically sharp lenses simply lack. The same goes for color and the way a lens renders out-of-focus backgrounds. These characteristics all contribute to the overall look and feel of an image in ways that sharpness alone can't.
As you said, there's so much more to a lens than its ability to resolve fine detail. I think it takes years of experience, along with actually shooting and comparing different lenses, to fully appreciate what makes one lens more desirable than another. My own experience has certainly taught me that.
p.5 #20What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Lance B wrote:
A very sharp lens is all very good, but it is not the be-all-and-end-all as far as lens desirability is concerned, IMO. There are many other attributes that make up a great lens, sharpness only being one of them and even then it may not be a priority for some uses. Right tool for the right job. Many of my favourite images are from lenses going back many years that wouldn't be considered sharp compared to the modern day lenses and I dare say that having a sharper lens wouldn't have made them any more desirable.
This thread is presumably about the MTF, since sharpness really isn't defined well here.
I'd list AF, IS, weather sealing and durability as way up there in importance. If the lens does not hold up in the field and get the shot in challenging conditions year after year then you miss the devisive moments and the opportunity.