philip_pj wrote:
Ta. Five APD and two aspherical elements, in a count of 15 in total. The asph are #5 and #8, which breaks from their Otus v1 practice of just one asph as the end element. Still a hefty fellow at 1030 grams, less focus throw at 244 degrees, down from 260 degrees (Otus v1 85mm) and 351 degrees (Otus 100mm) for those with rubber wrists and tendrils for fingers.
BTW, taking a look at the Loxia 85mm, it's much the same MTF at f2.4 as this one is at f1.4, and Loxia is (clearly) better at best aperture (f5.6 vs f4). I mention it because they compete on the same (E) mount. Loxia has 220 degrees throw, around half the weight, tiny filters/hood. But f1.4, important and a different class entirely....Show more →
My Loxia's not going anywhere, regardless of how things go with the new Otus 85. The Loxia is my landscape and pano ace (neither of which require a fast lens) and, despite its density, there's little chance of it getting replaced because it plays acceptably across my stock a1, UT a7rII, and bare sensor mono rII. What I expect out of the Otus is a better all-arounder; a manual lens that I can pack in with a fast 35 and a wide or tele, depending on where I'm going, and feel confident I'm going to be prepared for the opportunities presented.
They did wonders within the spec of the L85, I was surprised at this when I was getting a reference for the new Otus. It's always good to see the more established makers back in the business of new lenses, and going in at the top level - well, that's Zeiss. Their PR could do with a brush up, but that's nothing new either. I'd love to see them remake some older lenses, showing some respect for their older lenses.
Both are in Japanese but there are some auto-translation options available.
I also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.
I can't look at it without missing the silky smooth handling. I wonder how much Cosina would charge to take a Canon EF 35L II and remount it in a like body. The AF motor on mine is dead anyway, so there's no reason it shouldn't be a better MF lens. You know, aside from the thousands of dollars I'm sure such a customization would demand.
I know how you feel. I've had the 7artisans 35/1.4III glued to my mono rII since I received it last Saturday and, between work and the weather, I've only been able to test it for centering (perfect on the first copy!) and shoot a couple hundred shots of my dog and coworkers, all of whom are officially over it.
freaklikeme wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.I can't look at it without missing the silky smooth handling. I wonder how much Cosina would charge to take a Canon EF 35L II and remount it in a like body. The AF motor on mine is dead anyway, so there's no reason it shouldn't be a better MF lens. You know, aside from the thousands of dollars I'm sure such a customization would demand.
I know how you feel. I've had the 7artisans 35/1.4III glued to my mono rII since I received it last Saturday and, between work and the weather, I've only been able to test it for centering (perfect on the first copy!) and shoot a couple hundred shots of my dog and coworkers, all of whom are officially over it....Show more →
That would be a wonderful lens. I had the Canon 35 L II and it was a really nice lens. That said Zeiss has quite the heritage of really nice 35mm lenses, themselves. I always liked the rendering of the C/Y 35 f/1.4, and I have owned the ZE 35 f/1.4, the Milvus 35 f/1.4 and the ZM 35 f/1.4 and they were all interesting lenses and both the ZM and the Milvus were fantastic. A 35 Otus ML halfway between the Milvus and ZM (which would make it about the size of this 50 Otus ML) would be a lens I would be very much interested in getting. I hope Zeiss makes such a lens.
I probably won't get the 85 Otus ML, but I would be interested in a 28 or 35. It will be interesting to see how (or maybe if) Zeiss develops more Otus lenses.
Steve Spencer wrote: freaklikeme wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.I can't look at it without missing the silky smooth handling. I wonder how much Cosina would charge to take a Canon EF 35L II and remount it in a like body. The AF motor on mine is dead anyway, so there's no reason it shouldn't be a better MF lens. You know, aside from the thousands of dollars I'm sure such a customization would demand.
I know how you feel. I've had the 7artisans 35/1.4III glued to my mono rII since I received it last Saturday and, between work and the weather, I've only been able to test it for centering (perfect on the first copy!) and shoot a couple hundred shots of my dog and coworkers, all of whom are officially over it.That would be a wonderful lens. I had the Canon 35 L II and it was a really nice lens. That said Zeiss has quite the heritage of really nice 35mm lenses, themselves. I always liked the rendering of the C/Y 35 f/1.4, and I have owned the ZE 35 f/1.4, the Milvus 35 f/1.4 and the ZM 35 f/1.4 and they were all interesting lenses and both the ZM and the Milvus were fantastic. A 35 Otus ML halfway between the Milvus and ZM (which would make it about the size of this 50 Otus ML) would be a lens I would be very much interested in getting. I hope Zeiss makes such a lens.
I probably won't get the 85 Otus ML, but I would be interested in a 28 or 35. It will be interesting to see how (or maybe if) Zeiss develops more Otus lenses....Show more →
I love the Canon. Virtually flat fielded with no distortion and beautifully color corrected with nicely even resolution across the frame for structure (the higher frequency details do take a dive toward the corners). I wish the bokeh were a little more lively like it is with the Distagons, but it doesn't really bother me. It's one of the few lenses I don't have to run through a checklist of situational conditions before using it wide open. So long as I've got the depth right, it doesn't disappoint. And it compromises very little with the difference in sensor toppings. It's going to be tough to beat, but I'm hoping Zeiss gives it some competition with an ML Otus. We'll see how far they expand the line.
Aw, I thought you'd be down for the 85 as much as you loved the Milvus. It's almost 200g lighter!
Zeiss has been asleep for 10 years straight while Sony outpaced them, and now they want to regain market share real quick without proper innovation. I see them dropping out of the lens segment within 2 years.
While I still like my old ZEISS Distagon 35mm 1.4 lens, and its charming "3D" pop and colors, but I don't see Zeiss coming up with something truly better these days.
freaklikeme wrote: Steve Spencer wrotefreaklikeme wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.I can't look at it without missing the silky smooth handling. I wonder how much Cosina would charge to take a Canon EF 35L II and remount it in a like body. The AF motor on mine is dead anyway, so there's no reason it shouldn't be a better MF lens. You know, aside from the thousands of dollars I'm sure such a customization would demand.
I know how you feel. I've had the 7artisans 35/1.4III glued to my mono rII since I received it last Saturday and, between work and the weather, I've only been able to test it for centering (perfect on the first copy!) and shoot a couple hundred shots of my dog and coworkers, all of whom are officially over it.That would be a wonderful lens. I had the Canon 35 L II and it was a really nice lens. That said Zeiss has quite the heritage of really nice 35mm lenses, themselves. I always liked the rendering of the C/Y 35 f/1.4, and I have owned the ZE 35 f/1.4, the Milvus 35 f/1.4 and the ZM 35 f/1.4 and they were all interesting lenses and both the ZM and the Milvus were fantastic. A 35 Otus ML halfway between the Milvus and ZM (which would make it about the size of this 50 Otus ML) would be a lens I would be very much interested in getting. I hope Zeiss makes such a lens.
I probably won't get the 85 Otus ML, but I would be interested in a 28 or 35. It will be interesting to see how (or maybe if) Zeiss develops more Otus lenses.I love the Canon. Virtually flat fielded with no distortion and beautifully color corrected with nicely even resolution across the frame for structure (the higher frequency details do take a dive toward the corners). I wish the bokeh were a little more lively like it is with the Distagons, but it doesn't really bother me. It's one of the few lenses I don't have to run through a checklist of situational conditions before using it wide open. So long as I've got the depth right, it doesn't disappoint. And it compromises very little with the difference in sensor toppings. It's going to be tough to beat, but I'm hoping Zeiss gives it some competition with an ML Otus. We'll see how far they expand the line.
Aw, I thought you'd be down for the 85 as much as you loved the Milvus. It's almost 200g lighter! ...Show more →
I did really liked the Milvus 85 f/1.4, but I got the Milvus 85 instead of the original Otus 85 because I preferred the rendering of the Milvus. Now I have the Sony GM 85 f/1.4 first version and I very much like the rendering of that lens as well and I expect that I will prefer it over the new Otus 85 ML. It may make no sense to some but I actually like that the Milvus 50 ML isn't as sharp as the 50 f/1.4 GM and in the same way I think I will prefer that the original 85 f/1.4 GM likely won't be as sharp as the new Otus 85 ML. For portraits with Zeiss' MTF's I usually like the contrast percent to be 90, 80, and 60 at 10, 20, and 40 lp/mm respectively. If it gets sharper than that I generally don't like the look. The 50 Otus ML comes in really close to that. The 85 Otus ML has MTF that are higher and I expect I won't like that. Interestingly Milvus 85 f/1.4 and the original Sony 85 f/1.4 GM both come in close to 90, 80, & 60 percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm as measured by the folks at lens rentals blog.
Steve Spencer wrote: freaklikeme wroteSteve Spencer wrotefreaklikeme wroteJuha Kannisto wroteI also picked up my lens today and it seems to be a well centered copy and optimal infinity is right at the midpoint of infinity symbol. I had no chance to use it properly yet as it's been raining today and I had to work all day too. I hope to be able to shoot some during the weekend although weather will not be good.I can't look at it without missing the silky smooth handling. I wonder how much Cosina would charge to take a Canon EF 35L II and remount it in a like body. The AF motor on mine is dead anyway, so there's no reason it shouldn't be a better MF lens. You know, aside from the thousands of dollars I'm sure such a customization would demand.
I know how you feel. I've had the 7artisans 35/1.4III glued to my mono rII since I received it last Saturday and, between work and the weather, I've only been able to test it for centering (perfect on the first copy!) and shoot a couple hundred shots of my dog and coworkers, all of whom are officially over it.That would be a wonderful lens. I had the Canon 35 L II and it was a really nice lens. That said Zeiss has quite the heritage of really nice 35mm lenses, themselves. I always liked the rendering of the C/Y 35 f/1.4, and I have owned the ZE 35 f/1.4, the Milvus 35 f/1.4 and the ZM 35 f/1.4 and they were all interesting lenses and both the ZM and the Milvus were fantastic. A 35 Otus ML halfway between the Milvus and ZM (which would make it about the size of this 50 Otus ML) would be a lens I would be very much interested in getting. I hope Zeiss makes such a lens.
I probably won't get the 85 Otus ML, but I would be interested in a 28 or 35. It will be interesting to see how (or maybe if) Zeiss develops more Otus lenses.I love the Canon. Virtually flat fielded with no distortion and beautifully color corrected with nicely even resolution across the frame for structure (the higher frequency details do take a dive toward the corners). I wish the bokeh were a little more lively like it is with the Distagons, but it doesn't really bother me. It's one of the few lenses I don't have to run through a checklist of situational conditions before using it wide open. So long as I've got the depth right, it doesn't disappoint. And it compromises very little with the difference in sensor toppings. It's going to be tough to beat, but I'm hoping Zeiss gives it some competition with an ML Otus. We'll see how far they expand the line.
Aw, I thought you'd be down for the 85 as much as you loved the Milvus. It's almost 200g lighter! I did really liked the Milvus 85 f/1.4, but I got the Milvus 85 instead of the original Otus 85 because I preferred the rendering of the Milvus. Now I have the Sony GM 85 f/1.4 first version and I very much like the rendering of that lens as well and I expect that I will prefer it over the new Otus 85 ML. It may make no sense to some but I actually like that the Milvus 50 ML isn't as sharp as the 50 f/1.4 GM and in the same way I think I will prefer that the original 85 f/1.4 GM likely won't be as sharp as the new Otus 85 ML. For portraits with Zeiss' MTF's I usually like the contrast percent to be 90, 80, and 60 at 10, 20, and 40 lp/mm respectively. If it gets sharper than that I generally don't like the look. The 50 Otus ML comes in really close to that. The 85 Otus ML has MTF that are higher and I expect I won't like that. Interestingly Milvus 85 f/1.4 and the original Sony 85 f/1.4 GM both come in close to 90, 80, & 60 percent contrast at 10, 20, & 40 lp/mm as measured by the folks at lens rentals blog....Show more →
I get it. I think the original GM is gorgeous. A great lens ruined by FBW, in my estimation, because it plays well with my varied sensor toppings. Instead, I went with the Nikon 85/1.4G, which is a four camera lens because I also use it on the F100 (so beautiful with Portra). It's a bit lower in resolution centrally compared to the Milvus and GM, but more even across the frame. By f/2.8, I can't tell the difference between it and the GM unless the distortion's left uncorrected, and then it's only because the GM slightly pins and G slightly barrels. So that's what the Otus is up against for me. I'm interested because I've never had an 85 promising that level of performance wide open. Even the original Otus couldn't touch those MTFs. I've got to find out what that's like.
I managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. Saturday's weather was mostly rainy but the rain stopped at times and I did some walking around Shiibuya's Dogenzaka area with my A7CII & Otus. Today's weather was much better than forecasted, it was sunny from the morning until afternoon, but it got progressively cloudier later in the afternoon. I did a long walk around Nippori area, checked some shrines and Yanaka Ginza shopping street.
Most of the shots were at f1.4 or at f4, with a small number in-between. I exported them from Raw through C1 Pro and applied some of my usual presets and tweaked exposure a bit, nothing major.
I'm really liking the output from the lens. I find it to very sharp from wide open at focused point, at any distance. Depth of field at close distances seems very narrow (even more than expected for an f1.4). I also like the bokeh and overall rendering quite a bit. Focus ring is very smooth and has perfect feel, enjoyable to use. The very long focus throw is sometimes useful and sometimes a bit annoying when moving between infinity and very close distances.
I'm using the Sony grip extension on my A7CII with this lens to help with the balance as I shoot in vertical orientation a lot and without the grip extension it will be harder with lenses over 500g. I've been using very light lenses on my A7CII most of the time recently, so I need to get used to shooting with a somewhat heavier lens again.
Looking forward to shooting more with this lens, but I've got another new lens arriving already next Friday and 2 other new ones later in June so I'll have to keep rotating all the new ones
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. Saturday's weather was mostly rainy but the rain stopped at times and I did some walking around Shiibuya's Dogenzaka area with my A7CII & Otus.
Wow! Love the 3D pop on that!
Maybe it is a lens that does better in the real world than on the charts.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. Saturday's weather was mostly rainy but the rain stopped at times and I did some walking around Shiibuya's Dogenzaka area with my A7CII & Otus. Today's weather was much better than forecasted, it was sunny from the morning until afternoon, but it got progressively cloudier later in the afternoon. I did a long walk around Nippori area, checked some shrines and Yanaka Ginza shopping street.
Most of the shots were at f1.4 or at f4, with a small number in-between. I exported them from Raw through C1 Pro and applied some of my usual presets and tweaked exposure a bit, nothing major.
I'm really liking the output from the lens. I find it to very sharp from wide open at focused point, at any distance. Depth of field at close distances seems very narrow (even more than expected for an f1.4). I also like the bokeh and overall rendering quite a bit. Focus ring is very smooth and has perfect feel, enjoyable to use. The very long focus throw is sometimes useful and sometimes a bit annoying when moving between infinity and very close distances.
I'm using the Sony grip extension on my A7CII with this lens to help with the balance as I shoot in vertical orientation a lot and without the grip extension it will be harder with lenses over 500g. I've been using very light lenses on my A7CII most of the time recently, so I need to get used to shooting with a somewhat heavier lens again.
Looking forward to shooting more with this lens, but I've got another new lens arriving already next Friday and 2 other new ones later in June so I'll have to keep rotating all the new ones ...Show more →
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Zeiss glass, despite how modern it is, has such gorgeous tonal rendition and depth. And some character in the bokeh.
in a couple years when this comes down to price pretty significantly, I might pick one up. Great shots as always Juha 👍🏻
Curious to see their 28/35 wide Otus
Thanks very much! I traded away 4 of my other lenses (that hadn't been seeing so active use) to make budget for the Otus and luckily it was priced better in Japan to begin with I'm very happy with the purchase so far.
I'm also most interested in 28mm if they make one in ML line. 35mm could also be interesting to some extent but not quite as high as 28mm in my wanted list. If they make a 24mm or 25mm instead I would find it much less appealing.
I sure hope any wider option would be significantly smaller and lighter than the original Otus 28/1.4 (1.3kg+). Original 55/1.4 seems to have been just around 1kg. The weight of this ML 50/1.4 (around 700g) is quite close to my acceptable upper limit for any MF lens on my A7CII.
Alan Parker wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. Saturday's weather was mostly rainy but the rain stopped at times and I did some walking around Shiibuya's Dogenzaka area with my A7CII & Otus.Wow! Love the 3D pop on that!
Maybe it is a lens that does better in the real world than on the charts.
Thanks! I was also quite impressed with 3D pop that this lens can produce in many shots. Some early reviews indicated that it's not as sharp wide open as Zeiss glass is known for, but in my experience so far it's very sharp, not lacking anything in that regard.
I did notice on some of my disqualified shots that it was fairly easy to miss critical focus just a little bit when shooting wide open up close and relying only on focus peaking though. Also, since the lens is a bit on the heavy side, I think it's easier to end up having some slight camera+lens movement between focusing and taking a shot at least with my small & light camera. Need to use a different technique than with my tiny MF lenses.
Anyway, I think this lens adds something unique to my kit and I'm happy to have it
tsdevine wrote: Juha Kannisto wroteI managed to do some shooting with my new Otus ML 50/1.4 (Sony E version) on both days this weekend. Saturday's weather was mostly rainy but the rain stopped at times and I did some walking around Shiibuya's Dogenzaka area with my A7CII & Otus. Today's weather was much better than forecasted, it was sunny from the morning until afternoon, but it got progressively cloudier later in the afternoon. I did a long walk around Nippori area, checked some shrines and Yanaka Ginza shopping street.
Most of the shots were at f1.4 or at f4, with a small number in-between. I exported them from Raw through C1 Pro and applied some of my usual presets and tweaked exposure a bit, nothing major.
I'm really liking the output from the lens. I find it to very sharp from wide open at focused point, at any distance. Depth of field at close distances seems very narrow (even more than expected for an f1.4). I also like the bokeh and overall rendering quite a bit. Focus ring is very smooth and has perfect feel, enjoyable to use. The very long focus throw is sometimes useful and sometimes a bit annoying when moving between infinity and very close distances.
I'm using the Sony grip extension on my A7CII with this lens to help with the balance as I shoot in vertical orientation a lot and without the grip extension it will be harder with lenses over 500g. I've been using very light lenses on my A7CII most of the time recently, so I need to get used to shooting with a somewhat heavier lens again.
Looking forward to shooting more with this lens, but I've got another new lens arriving already next Friday and 2 other new ones later in June so I'll have to keep rotating all the new ones Beautiful shots Juha!
Thanks very much Tim! Fingers crossed that they would release a 28mm next
Juha Kannisto wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteZeiss glass, despite how modern it is, has such gorgeous tonal rendition and depth. And some character in the bokeh.
in a couple years when this comes down to price pretty significantly, I might pick one up. Great shots as always Juha 👍🏻
Curious to see their 28/35 wide OtusThanks very much! I traded away 4 of my other lenses (that hadn't been seeing so active use) to make budget for the Otus and luckily it was priced better in Japan to begin with I'm very happy with the purchase so far.
I'm also most interested in 28mm if they make one in ML line. 35mm could also be interesting to some extent but not quite as high as 28mm in my wanted list. If they make a 24mm or 25mm instead I would find it much less appealing.
I sure hope any wider option would be significantly smaller and lighter than the original Otus 28/1.4 (1.3kg+). Original 55/1.4 seems to have been just around 1kg. The weight of this ML 50/1.4 (around 700g) is quite close to my acceptable upper limit for any MF lens on my A7CII....Show more →
I think there are basically 3 ways that Zeiss may go with future lenses.
1) I think they will make at least one wide angle Otus ML, and if they make just one I think it will be a 28mm. I think 28, 50, & 85 makes a lot more sense that 35, 50, & 85.
2) They might make two wide angle Otus ML lenses, however, and in that case I think they would make a 35mm and a 25mm. I think 25, 35, 50, & 85 also makes sense.
3) They might make an Otus wide angle, but bring out a new line of lenses along side the Otus ML lenses. I don't think this is likely because they have Loxia lenses, but if they did build a (insert your favorite bird name here) line of lenses that was mostly f/2 or faster I think they might make an Otus ML 28 (which would be f/1.4) then a line of (new bird name) ML lenses with something like 18 f/2.8, 25 f/2, 35 f/1.4, 50 f/1.4, and 85 f/2. The 18 isn't represented by the Loxia lenses so wouldn't have to compete with that line, and the others could be consciously more street/portrait oriented and as I specified they are all half a stop to a stop faster than the Loxia lenses and in that way differentiated. Compared to the new Otus lenses, the 50 and 85 could be consciously smaller and less well corrected and cheaper. The 35 would need to have a similar performance too. The ZM 35 f/1.4 could be a model for it only adjusted for mirrorless. If they shoot for a $1,500 US price they might be able to make that work. The overlap with Loxia lenses is a fairly big potential problem, however, so I doubt this will happen even though I would like to see it happen.
Honestly these samples look fantastic. Much better that what I've seen when using the 50mm GM f1.2.
The lens reminds me the Lumix 50mm f1.4, I see the same 3D effect and sense of volume.
But this effect on the Zeiss is even more impressive, maybe because the lens looks insanely sharp, have you added some extra sharpening on C1 ?