Alan Parker wrote: KarmaKramer wroteFor incremental advantages, if any, over current excellent 50s. Manual focus. Oh and 4 large probably. That’s either a tough sale or a buyers remorse commercial.It just strikes me as a bit unusual. People love their CV50/1 or CV50/2 APO. Will these people really swap to a new Zeiss?
How important is APO to people at f/1.4? There's just a lot questions like that I think. So unless the rendering is out of this world it's an uphill battle for Zeiss for their 50mm.
Oh, and on price from the rumors I have seen it does not look like they will be $4,000 US like the original Otus lenses (the $4,000 number came from the guy who runs SAR and he is notoriously bad at guessing prices), but more in the low to mid $2,000 US price range. That price estimate, however, is extrapolating from European prices and how they typically translate into US prices (and there is the added uncertainty of whether the European prices include VAT). So as always we won't know the exact price until they are announced, which is only days away at this point, but I don't think it will be anywhere near $4,000. If it is, then I think these lenses face a much steeper uphill barrier.
Weight is relative with such lenses.
The niche that is served by these lenses usually attaches great importance to all-metal construction with the highest craftsmanship, which is exactly what you will find here and that is what drives the weight.
More important for me personally are the dimensions and here the new Otus 50/1.4 is absolutely comparable with a Sony 50/1.4 GM, a little less bulbous, but 4mm longer.
Zeiss Otus 50/1.4: 77 x 100mm, 677g
Sony GM 50/1.4: 81 x 96mm, 516g
The extra weight is also limited when you consider that you are probably getting a lens that is built like a tank for decades of use.
A good example of this would be my old Canon FD 85mm F/1.2 L, which also weighs just under 700g, but is very compact and fits snugly in the hand like a little hand grenade (egg).
As long as the weight is well balanced and not top-heavy, I think this is overrated if the dimensions fit.
Excessive dimensions are problematic, but 200g more or less is less so.
Weight, on the other hand, when properly balanced, can sometimes even be beneficial in terms of overall feel. https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52402904673_03f03b441e_b.jpg
The 85/1.2 feels much better in the hand than the lighter Z 50/1.8 S, or even the 35/2 AL-Z.
The compact dimensions, measured against the key data, on the other hand, are much more important and advantageous than the naked weight.
Steve Spencer wrote:
Oh, and on price from the rumors I have seen it does not look like they will be $4,000 US like the original Otus lenses (the $4,000 number came from the guy who runs SAR and he is notoriously bad at guessing prices), but more in the low to mid $2,000 US price range. That price estimate, however, is extrapolating from European prices and how they typically translate into US prices (and there is the added uncertainty of whether the European prices include VAT). So as always we won't know the exact price until they are announced, which is only days away at this point, but I don't think it will be anywhere near $4,000. If it is, then I think these lenses face a much steeper uphill barrier....Show more →
The estimated prices come from a reseller who advertised the lenses prematurely. If the seller played us all or not we don't know but it seems unlikely.
Check the other thread, page 9 post 3 and 4. The UK VAT is included and calculated for, The price difference between the EU and the USA is unknown.
The lenses will be hard to sell with these prices so I don't think they can go higher.
Vento wrote:
[...]The 85/1.2 feels much better in the hand than the lighter Z 50/1.8 S, or even the 35/2 AL-Z.
I have to envy anyone feeling that 670 grams in the bag feels better than 290 grams in the bag.
Perhaps you are saying the 670 grams balances better on your camera? having owned a couple very front heavy lenses I understand that detail but In any case you carry around close to 400 grams more and it feels better. OK.
Jonas B wrote: Steve Spencer wroteOh, and on price from the rumors I have seen it does not look like they will be $4,000 US like the original Otus lenses (the $4,000 number came from the guy who runs SAR and he is notoriously bad at guessing prices), but more in the low to mid $2,000 US price range. That price estimate, however, is extrapolating from European prices and how they typically translate into US prices (and there is the added uncertainty of whether the European prices include VAT). So as always we won't know the exact price until they are announced, which is only days away at this point, but I don't think it will be anywhere near $4,000. If it is, then I think these lenses face a much steeper uphill barrier.The estimated prices come from a reseller who advertised the lenses prematurely. If the seller played us all or not we don't know but it seems unlikely.
Check the other thread, page 9 post 3 and 4. The UK VAT is included and calculated for, The price difference between the EU and the USA is unknown.
The lenses will be hard to sell with these prices so I don't think they can go higher.
Yeah, if those prices in British pounds are real and include VAT, then I think we will see a price something like $2,000 US for the 50mm and $2,400 for the 85mm if we do a straight conversion of the currency. Who knows if they will do that, however, as you point out. Here are Sony, Nikon and Canon retail prices from B & H:
To me the converted prices from the British prices if they include VAT look like they will be pretty competitive with the Sony, Nikon, and Canon premium lenses, but of course this is all guess work at this point. We will know in a couple of days.
Steve Spencer wrote:
To me the converted prices from the British prices if they include VAT look like they will be pretty competitive with the Sony, Nikon, and Canon premium lenses, but of course this is all guess work at this point. We will know in a couple of days.
Maybe you should use the prices of the 1.4 lenses rather than the 1.2 lenses for price comparison, don't you think?
I have a 50gm 1.2 and love it. No interest in the 50 new Otus, but I have a feeling Zeiss is gonna put out a real impressive product, if they are putting Otus on it in 2025. Micro contrast beasts of sorts and lots of pop. I hope they do, and I am happy seeing the old guard of photography in the mix. My guess is that I will find one that I like and get it eventually. I really like my Batis and Loxia that I have, and adding an Otus sounds like a plan in my book. .
old-gregg wrote:
My speculation is that these lenses have nothing to do with Zeiss. They are designed and manufactured by Cosina, who probably made an agreement with Zeiss to slap their logo on top to increase margins and share some % with them.
Why do I think so?
- Because the Zeiss AG is simply too huge (~€10B revenue) to be bothered by a minuscule markets such as manual-focus photo lenses.
- Because Zeiss does have a long-standing tradition to license their brand
- Because Cosina have been making Zeiss photo lenses for ages
I find this kind of conspiratorial thinking to be downright silly.
1. I bet you they sell a lot more M mount or Otus lenses than Master Primes for cine. Both segments are likely not a big part of the overall business of being Zeiss.
2. Licensing out their brand is something everyone does to some extent, but these are flagship products for Zeiss...not Chinese phones.
3. Cosina is the reason why we can afford Zeiss.
Honestly we should all be praising Cosina constantly. They are the biggest reason a lot of people can afford to shoot Leica. They consistently lower the cost of world class optics by many factors, while consistently raising the bar for quality. I mean look at this recent release of the 35/3.5. Who else would release something this cool? Or the APO line. Leica releases an APO Summicron, VM releases a lens 98% as good for a fraction of the cost. Cosina is a manufacturing powerhouse. It means Zeiss can design optics and have them built affordably. Win win.
I think the 'problem' for Zeiss is that lenses from all makes are so good now, what distinguishes them? I have an F2 and an M4-P. If I wanted a premium normal, I probably would not bother with the Otus because the APO VM is just as good and super small. Mirrorless users can buy Nikon/Sigma/Sony and get spectacular quality and AF.
For me personally I think Zeiss should update their M lineup and allow Cosina to adapt the designs for mirrorless. Focus on smallish, boutique type optics. The Otus line up is cool but so impractical. If they're making lenses that big they should just be for the GFX or X2D.
I have no interest in the 50 or 85, but an Otus wide angle or macro lens would certainly be interesting. I hope that they will also make clear what lenses will follow.
speedgraphic wrote:
I think the 'problem' for Zeiss is that lenses from all makes are so good now, what distinguishes them? I have an F2 and an M4-P. If I wanted a premium normal, I probably would not bother with the Otus because the APO VM is just as good and super small. Mirrorless users can buy Nikon/Sigma/Sony and get spectacular quality and AF.
This. For me at least. I just can't manually focus an f/1.4 lens quickly and accurately...I couldn't when I was in my 20s and shot Contax either. I love the idea of it, I'm just no good at the execution. For anything under f/2 I think I'm AF only, and therefor I don't think I have a need for a fast MF lens. I covet CV's 50 APO for its size and performance, but I would pair it with my Loxia 25/85 and use it quite differently than I would a 1.4.
For fast lenses, the AF offerings from Sony and Sigma are pretty incredible - unimaginable maybe even a decade ago.
For MF, Cosina is doing really fun and unexpected things with Voigtlander, like the 50/2.2 and 35/3.5. Those designs interest me more in the MF context.
Dave Sanders wrote: speedgraphic wroteI think the 'problem' for Zeiss is that lenses from all makes are so good now, what distinguishes them? I have an F2 and an M4-P. If I wanted a premium normal, I probably would not bother with the Otus because the APO VM is just as good and super small. Mirrorless users can buy Nikon/Sigma/Sony and get spectacular quality and AF.This. For me at least. I just can't manually focus an f/1.4 lens quickly and accurately...I couldn't when I was in my 20s and shot Contax either. I love the idea of it, I'm just no good at the execution. For anything under f/2 I think I'm AF only, and therefor I don't think I have a need for a fast MF lens. I covet CV's 50 APO for its size and performance, but I would pair it with my Loxia 25/85 and use it quite differently than I would a 1.4.
For fast lenses, the AF offerings from Sony and Sigma are pretty incredible - unimaginable maybe even a decade ago.
For MF, Cosina is doing really fun and unexpected things with Voigtlander, like the 50/2.2 and 35/3.5. Those designs interest me more in the MF context. ...Show more →
I'm way off topic...but lately I've been putting the Loxia 25/85 in my bag with the Sigma 28-45 and 14-24 (and 70-200 GM II if I think I need it). It's a great mix of landscape prime and impeccable zoom. Having f/1.8 in the 28-45 range is sort of the sweet spot of where I might want speed. I don't do portraits, etc.
Anyway...just me...I'm weird. But your comments hit home.
Jonas B wrote: Vento wrote[...]The 85/1.2 feels much better in the hand than the lighter Z 50/1.8 S, or even the 35/2 AL-Z.I have to envy anyone feeling that 670 grams in the bag feels better than 290 grams in the bag.
Perhaps you are saying the 670 grams balances better on your camera? having owned a couple very front heavy lenses I understand that detail but In any case you carry around close to 400 grams more and it feels better. OK.
If you do, then you should take the weight of comparable lenses and the Zeiss Otus 50/1.4 is just 160g heavier than a Sony GM II 50/1.4.
Otherwise, we can go straight back to pancake format and deny everything else its justification.
Because then even with a 50/2 Apo Lanthar you're carrying around 200g more weight than with one of Nikon's plastic-mount pancakes.
We are talking about a 50mm f/1.4 here, which apparently also fulfills the requirements of an apochromat, so weight and size comparisons only make sense with comparable optics.
And logically, I was referring to the weight of a lens and its weight distribution in practice, where a lens that sits comfortably in the hand can be advantageous compared to a compact flyweight without sufficient grip surface; weight and mass as such in the camera bag is certainly not an advantage.
Apart from that, I don't buy lenses like an Otus or Plena to go trekking in the Himalayas with, but they are used where weight is not a permanent obstacle.
I also don't walk around with all my equipment all the time, but often only with one or two prime lenses for the whole day or session.
The situation is somewhat different in the Z-mount, where there is a corresponding gap between the Z 50/1.8 S, which is outstanding for the price, and the Z 50/1.2 S, which is gigantic in size and weighs close to 1.1 kg.
The Z 50/1.4 is not really a high-quality alternative.
For fans of manual focusing, the Otus 50/1.4 Z is a very high-quality alternative that is almost identical in size to the Sony 50/1.4 GM and does not weigh significantly more.
old-gregg wrote:
My speculation is that these lenses have nothing to do with Zeiss. They are designed and manufactured by Cosina, who probably made an agreement with Zeiss to slap their logo on top to increase margins and share some % with them.
Why do I think so?
- Because the Zeiss AG is simply too huge (~€10B revenue) to be bothered by a minuscule markets such as manual-focus photo lenses.
- Because Zeiss does have a long-standing tradition to license their brand
- Because Cosina have been making Zeiss photo lenses for ages
I think you're going a bit too far in stating that Zeiss has 'nothing to do' with these lenses. I'm pretty sure that even if Cosina makes them, that Zeiss is on top of the process in order to protect its brand. After all, this is not the Contax brand that Zeiss also owns but doesn't use for anything, but the actual brand all their operations use.
Nifty Fifty wrote: Steve Spencer wroteTo me the converted prices from the British prices if they include VAT look like they will be pretty competitive with the Sony, Nikon, and Canon premium lenses, but of course this is all guess work at this point. We will know in a couple of days.Maybe you should use the prices of the 1.4 lenses rather than the 1.2 lenses for price comparison, don't you think?
Nope, Zeiss isn't aiming these at the price point of the 50 f/1.4 lens. Nikon offers a 50 f/1.4, but it isn't their professional S lenses, and at 50mm Sony and Canon do offer professional f/1.4 lenses, but their premium lenses are the f/1.2 lenses. Zeiss is clearly aiming these at the top of the line. And at 85mm Canon and Nikon don't even offer f/1.4 lenses. If you want these lenses and you are willing to pay the price for them, then you will be comparing them to the faster lenses from Sony, Canon, and Nikon at 50mm and Canon and Nikon at 85mm and you will have to sacrifice the half to a third of stop wider aperture for the characteristics of these lenses.
tsdevine wrote: Dave Sanders wrotespeedgraphic wroteI think the 'problem' for Zeiss is that lenses from all makes are so good now, what distinguishes them? I have an F2 and an M4-P. If I wanted a premium normal, I probably would not bother with the Otus because the APO VM is just as good and super small. Mirrorless users can buy Nikon/Sigma/Sony and get spectacular quality and AF.This. For me at least. I just can't manually focus an f/1.4 lens quickly and accurately...I couldn't when I was in my 20s and shot Contax either. I love the idea of it, I'm just no good at the execution. For anything under f/2 I think I'm AF only, and therefor I don't think I have a need for a fast MF lens. I covet CV's 50 APO for its size and performance, but I would pair it with my Loxia 25/85 and use it quite differently than I would a 1.4.
For fast lenses, the AF offerings from Sony and Sigma are pretty incredible - unimaginable maybe even a decade ago.
For MF, Cosina is doing really fun and unexpected things with Voigtlander, like the 50/2.2 and 35/3.5. Those designs interest me more in the MF context.I'm way off topic...but lately I've been putting the Loxia 25/85 in my bag with the Sigma 28-45 and 14-24 (and 70-200 GM II if I think I need it). It's a great mix of landscape prime and impeccable zoom. Having f/1.8 in the 28-45 range is sort of the sweet spot of where I might want speed. I don't do portraits, etc.
Anyway...just me...I'm weird. But your comments hit home.
Ha, well perhaps we're both weird then
My current landscape kit is the Loxia 24/85 and my newly acquired Sigma 70-200/2.8. I love the manual focus on my Loxias, but I'm rarely using them at f/2.4, let alone f/1.4.
When out and about, I often thrown in my Sigma 65/2 or 85/1.4 for more general purpose type stuff and portraits. However, partly due to your thread/photos from the 28-45, I've seriously been considering picking that one up.
It looks like a fantastic lens and I think it would cover most of my fast lens needs in that range too. I'm just struggling a bit with the size and the fact that I really do shoot a LOT of telephoto. For AF I have the Sigma 65 & 85 and the Sony 100, so I need to think about how much I'd miss that range in more of a 'one lens' zoom solution.
Vento wrote: Jonas B wroteVento wrote[...]The 85/1.2 feels much better in the hand than the lighter Z 50/1.8 S, or even the 35/2 AL-Z.I have to envy anyone feeling that 670 grams in the bag feels better than 290 grams in the bag.
Perhaps you are saying the 670 grams balances better on your camera? having owned a couple very front heavy lenses I understand that detail but In any case you carry around close to 400 grams more and it feels better. OK.If you do, then you should take the weight of comparable lenses and the Zeiss Otus 50/1.4 is just 160g heavier than a Sony GM II 50/1.4.
Otherwise, we can go straight back to pancake format and deny everything else its justification.
Because then even with a 50/2 Apo Lanthar you're carrying around 200g more weight than with one of Nikon's plastic-mount pancakes.
We are talking about a 50mm f/1.4 here, which apparently also fulfills the requirements of an apochromat, so weight and size comparisons only make sense with comparable optics.
And logically, I was referring to the weight of a lens and its weight distribution in practice, where a lens that sits comfortably in the hand can be advantageous compared to a compact flyweight without sufficient grip surface; weight and mass as such in the camera bag is certainly not an advantage.
Apart from that, I don't buy lenses like an Otus or Plena to go trekking in the Himalayas with, but they are used where weight is not a permanent obstacle.
I also don't walk around with all my equipment all the time, but often only with one or two prime lenses for the whole day or session.
The situation is somewhat different in the Z-mount, where there is a corresponding gap between the Z 50/1.8 S, which is outstanding for the price, and the Z 50/1.2 S, which is gigantic in size and weighs close to 1.1 kg.
The Z 50/1.4 is not really a high-quality alternative.
For fans of manual focusing, the Otus 50/1.4 Z is a very high-quality alternative that is almost identical in size to the Sony 50/1.4 GM and does not weigh significantly more.
Hey Vento, take it easy. There is no need to flip and start talking about pancake lenses. It was you comparing the feel in hand of the more heavy lens to a CV APO lens.
When shooting film during my first 30 years behind the camera a 50/1.4 always was my most used lens. Now the world is digital and I have found that at 50mm I don't need faster than f2.
Good for me. I usually walk around with the CV 50/2 APO and then a slow WA zoom like the Sony FE PZ 16-35/4. All day, or several days when traveling. Keep it good and very good but also keep it light.
When not out for taking images I usually have the A1 with the Sony 40/2.5 mounted in a satchel bag. The total weight is 910 grams. That's nice, the lens is not bad but really only for non-critical stuff.
It's still very cool if you are happy with a contraption around 1.5 kg.
If I were doing more portrait type shooting, I'd throw in the Sigma 65 as well. For macro I toss in the Sigma 105 macro, which also works great for landscape if the focal length works for a shot. It's one of the sharpest lenses I own.
I understand about the size and weight of the 28-45, but for me, it's a range that I shoot a lot. If you do more telephoto, then it probably becomes less attractive.
Dave Sanders wrote: tsdevine wroteDave Sanders wrotespeedgraphic wroteI think the 'problem' for Zeiss is that lenses from all makes are so good now, what distinguishes them? I have an F2 and an M4-P. If I wanted a premium normal, I probably would not bother with the Otus because the APO VM is just as good and super small. Mirrorless users can buy Nikon/Sigma/Sony and get spectacular quality and AF.This. For me at least. I just can't manually focus an f/1.4 lens quickly and accurately...I couldn't when I was in my 20s and shot Contax either. I love the idea of it, I'm just no good at the execution. For anything under f/2 I think I'm AF only, and therefor I don't think I have a need for a fast MF lens. I covet CV's 50 APO for its size and performance, but I would pair it with my Loxia 25/85 and use it quite differently than I would a 1.4.
For fast lenses, the AF offerings from Sony and Sigma are pretty incredible - unimaginable maybe even a decade ago.
For MF, Cosina is doing really fun and unexpected things with Voigtlander, like the 50/2.2 and 35/3.5. Those designs interest me more in the MF context.I'm way off topic...but lately I've been putting the Loxia 25/85 in my bag with the Sigma 28-45 and 14-24 (and 70-200 GM II if I think I need it). It's a great mix of landscape prime and impeccable zoom. Having f/1.8 in the 28-45 range is sort of the sweet spot of where I might want speed. I don't do portraits, etc.
Anyway...just me...I'm weird. But your comments hit home.Ha, well perhaps we're both weird then
My current landscape kit is the Loxia 24/85 and my newly acquired Sigma 70-200/2.8. I love the manual focus on my Loxias, but I'm rarely using them at f/2.4, let alone f/1.4.
When out and about, I often thrown in my Sigma 65/2 or 85/1.4 for more general purpose type stuff and portraits. However, partly due to your thread/photos from the 28-45, I've seriously been considering picking that one up.
It looks like a fantastic lens and I think it would cover most of my fast lens needs in that range too. I'm just struggling a bit with the size and the fact that I really do shoot a LOT of telephoto. For AF I have the Sigma 65 & 85 and the Sony 100, so I need to think about how much I'd miss that range in more of a 'one lens' zoom solution.
Alan Parker wrote: KarmaKramer wroteFor incremental advantages, if any, over current excellent 50s. Manual focus. Oh and 4 large probably. That’s either a tough sale or a buyers remorse commercial.It just strikes me as a bit unusual. People love their CV50/1 or CV50/2 APO. Will these people really swap to a new Zeiss?
How important is APO to people at f/1.4? There's just a lot questions like that I think. So unless the rendering is out of this world it's an uphill battle for Zeiss for their 50mm.
I agree with you.
I have the Voigtlander 50/1 and 50/1.2 Noktons which are so good in so many ways. Then the 50/1.2 GM is my favorite people lens since it makes it so easy to nail focus instantly and the output of that lens is the best I've seen. So I agree, for people like me, these Zeiss lenses have zero appeal. Even if they are APO, it is hard for me to understand how they could be noticeably better (emphasis on noticeably) than the 50/1.2GM.
I can’t find who said it since there are multiple threads discussing the return of the Otii, but I also think the lenses will need to deliver in multiple ways. At once a pleasing portrait lens with beautiful background separation, perhaps under corrected for SA and of course APO. And perfect for landscape compositions with corner to corner sharpness stopped down a bit (say to f2).
I mentioned more of my thoughts in the other Otus thread. But as a quick summary:
I do think Zeiss is entering a much more competitive market than when the original Otus came out. A sign of this could very well be the rumored lowered prices compared to the original Otus line. I am excited to see what Zeiss brings to the table tough. I agree that for most photographers a MF 50mm will not be able to replace the Sony 50mm f1.2, but I don't think Zeiss is trying to make a lens for most photographers or they would have gone with AF. I think the new Zeiss Otus will have a few unique features that Zeiss is hoping will appeal to a niche of photographers. Kind of like back in the DSLR days, the Sigma 50mm f1.4 Art appealed to more photographers than the Zeiss 55mm Otus, but for those photographers that were willing to deal with the size, weight, cost, and MF of the 55mm Otus it offered something uniquely different.