I’m not sure why any midzone dip in the 50/1.4GM or 50/1.2GM matters in the least. Both lenses are so sharp that the sharpness in their “midzone dips” is as sharp or sharper than almost any other lens at its sharpest aperture.
No one would ever be able to see the midzone dip in a final print from either of these lenses.
Jonas B wrote: Jonas B wrote: Earlier quotef/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?freaklikeme wrote: Earlier quoteNo, no, no. Not mine. Not even a rental. My boss gave me the go ahead to request evaluation copies because our video team wanted to compare it to the Nano 50, so I did all my standard testing on it as well. I only had it out of my test environment briefly yesterday afternoon, but the FC didn't impact my real world shots. Just don't try to do two-dimensional reproduction work (or shoot test charts) at wide apertures and you'll probably never see it (just like most people wouldn't see the mid-zone dip on the GM). I'll have it out more this afternoon and let you know if I find a situation where it's impactful.Ah, I see. Not your then. Fun to try out anyway I guess!
Some people even don't notice the midzone dip on some of the Leica m-lenses... To me it sounds as "sharp enough" (which I btw not find the Summilux-M 35/1.4 to be talking about midzone dips).
Earlier quoteThere haven't been a lot of surprises. I know the CA is disappointing. I find it a little disappointing on my beloved APO-Sonnar 135/2, but I forgive it because it doesn't let me down in any other way. I'm sure the Otus 50 will be that kind of lens for some manual 50 lovers.But the APO-Sonnar is better, no?! That's at least my guess judging from influencer material.
Earlier quoteThe only things I can objectively say favor the Otus over the APO-Lanthar are transmission, because the Otus is between a half and third stop ahead of the Lanthar at like apertures down to f/4, the distance scale is easier to read, so it's faster to prefocus before bringing the camera to your eye, vignetting is lower, distortion's lower and simple, and the Lanthar shows more degradation in resolution the closer you focus. There may be enough there to change some Lanthar lovers' minds about taking on a relative giant instead, but the Lanthar packs so much power in so little space, my guess is the Otus will be an additional 50 for some; not a replacement. Subjectively, I prefer the Otus in use. I like packing and carrying little lenses, but, once I'm shooting with them, I'd rather have more weight and grip. If I were going to pick a slower, less expensive alternative to the Otus, I'd gravitate to the APO-Lanthar 65/2 for several reasons, but a lot of it would be for that size and weight.Hmm. Nothing of that make me think about getting an Otus.
The distance scale I'm not sure what you mean. The color? I'm a metric guy so the white numbers are easy to see.
The distortion? Frankly I have neveer thought about the Lanthar distortion. FM says negligible, Lenstip says 0.38% and I don't care.
Degradation in resolution the closer you focus? I have to get close enough start worrying. That of course depends on what the lens is used for...
Your observation on the light transmission is interesting. It's not a deciding factor for me but can probably be for some users. When i need more photons I get by using slower shutter speed. At least for the most of the time.
As I suspected the Otus is not for me. I'm happy to read about your findings though. It sounds as some will be happy with the lens!
Thank you for getting back with your report, it's appreciated!...Show more →
It's a living and, in this case, it saved me the cost of a rental. I think mid-zone dips go unnoticed until they've reached the levels of the Zony 50/1.4. It's hard to ignore on that lens. People who notice them most are the people who shoot (certain subjects) with an APS-C camera or crop mode on their FF. They're far more likely to notice the minor loss of fidelity.
No, the APO-Sonnar is not better when it comes to spherochromatism at like apertures. It scatters it better because it takes on some under-corrected SA close focused. The APO-Sonnar's closer to an overgrown APO-Summicron 90 than it is any of the Otus lenses. And I wouldn't have it any other way. There are plenty of stronger performing faster 135s available now, but none of them draw like that lens.
It's the size and placement of the distance scale that makes it easier to read. With the Lanthar, I have to tilt the camera up to see over the EFV hump. With the Otus, it's further out with bigger print, so it's visible without tilt practically until you have the camera to your eye.
Yeah, I didn't think I was going to change your mind. The truth is no one makes a crap fast fifty these days. They're all separated by a matter of degrees with different sets of compromises. But the question was what performance metrics I thought were positives for the lens, and that's my answer.
You're welcome. I'm happy to contribute what I can.
Maximilian wrote: freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wroteSo a couple days in and I'm impressed.[...]Congratulations to your new Otus!
To sum it up the lens seem to behave as expected then? The to me new observation on the FC - it's mild but do you think it will have impact on real life images?
----
f/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?No, no, no. Not mine. Not even a rental. My boss gave me the go ahead to request evaluation copies because our video team wanted to compare it to the Nano 50, so I did all my standard testing on it as well. I only had it out of my test environment briefly yesterday afternoon, but the FC didn't impact my real world shots. Just don't try to do two-dimensional reproduction work (or shoot test charts) at wide apertures and you'll probably never see it (just like most people wouldn't see the mid-zone dip on the GM). I'll have it out more this afternoon and let you know if I find a situation where it's impactful.
There haven't been a lot of surprises. I know the CA is disappointing. I find it a little disappointing on my beloved APO-Sonnar 135/2, but I forgive it because it doesn't let me down in any other way. I'm sure the Otus 50 will be that kind of lens for some manual 50 lovers.
The only things I can objectively say favor the Otus over the APO-Lanthar are transmission, because the Otus is between a half and third stop ahead of the Lanthar at like apertures down to f/4, the distance scale is easier to read, so it's faster to prefocus before bringing the camera to your eye, vignetting is lower, distortion's lower and simple, and the Lanthar shows more degradation in resolution the closer you focus. There may be enough there to change some Lanthar lovers' minds about taking on a relative giant instead, but the Lanthar packs so much power in so little space, my guess is the Otus will be an additional 50 for some; not a replacement. Subjectively, I prefer the Otus in use. I like packing and carrying little lenses, but, once I'm shooting with them, I'd rather have more weight and grip. If I were going to pick a slower, less expensive alternative to the Otus, I'd gravitate to the APO-Lanthar 65/2 for several reasons, but a lot of it would be for that size and weight.Thank you for your interesting information.
Since I understand that you tested lots of lenses, I'd like to ask you two questions.
1. Talking about midzone dip, have you seen it in the Sony GM 1,2/50mm as well?
2. How does the LoCA of the Otus ML 50mm compare to that of the original Otus 55mm?
You're welcome.
1. Nope. You wouldn't even see it in the 1.4GM in real world shooting, but the 1.2GM is (again, by a matter of degrees) the most problem-free fast fifty I've ever tested (ten times, since I did the eval copies and then the eight copies we ordered).
2. It's worse, but the 1.2GM is almost exactly the same at like apertures as the 55.
mudlake wrote:
I’m not sure why any midzone dip in the 50/1.4GM or 50/1.2GM matters in the least. Both lenses are so sharp that the sharpness in their “midzone dips” is as sharp or sharper than almost any other lens at its sharpest aperture.
No one would ever be able to see the midzone dip in a final print from either of these lenses.
We are in a gear forum, man. Hairs will be split here. Some multiple times.
freaklikeme wrote:
Yeah, I didn't think I was going to change your mind. The truth is no one makes a crap fast fifty these days. They're all separated by a matter of degrees with different sets of compromises. But the question was what performance metrics I thought were positives for the lens, and that's my answer.
You're welcome. I'm happy to contribute what I can.
Of all parameters size and weight are high on my list. The Otus would have to be super special to get a place in my bag. I was interested but then the (from what I have seen in dubious material) CA came as a surprise.
I was still slightly interested as Zeiss has a spot in my hart since the film days. The C/Y 35/1.4 will be remembered. Of course, that was long ago and film is film and I was younger and for the most of the time I went out with one lens only.
I got what I asked for and I appreciate your comments as I trust you more than the babbling ambassadors. Thanks again!
Today Cosina announced that for Japan market Otus ML 50/1.4 E-mount and RF-mount versions will be released on 5/30, but Z-mount version release is postponed to July.
Ta. Five APD and two aspherical elements, in a count of 15 in total. The asph are #5 and #8, which breaks from their Otus v1 practice of just one asph as the end element. Still a hefty fellow at 1030 grams, less focus throw at 244 degrees, down from 260 degrees (Otus v1 85mm) and 351 degrees (Otus 100mm) for those with rubber wrists and tendrils for fingers.
BTW, taking a look at the Loxia 85mm, it's much the same MTF at f2.4 as this one is at f1.4, and Loxia is (clearly) better at best aperture (f5.6 vs f4). I mention it because they compete on the same (E) mount. Loxia has 220 degrees throw, around half the weight, tiny filters/hood. But f1.4, important and a different class entirely.
Maximilian wrote: Knut. wrote… I would really like an 18mm from Zeiss. Is it only me?a (truly) apochromatic 1,4/18mm from Zeiss would be gorgeous.
Would also be quite impractical I believe. The original Zeiss Otus 28 f/1.4 is the widest f/1.4 APO lens that I know of and it was very large. A lens that wide with that sort of performance would be unprecedented. I think we are a lot more likely to get an 18 f/2.8 if Zeiss develops a non-Otus, non-APO line of manual focus mirrorless lenses. I would be very happy if they develop such a line of lenses, but until then I will be happy with my Batis 18 f/2.8, which is really a very nice lens.
Steve Spencer wrote: Maximilian wroteKnut. wrote… I would really like an 18mm from Zeiss. Is it only me?a (truly) apochromatic 1,4/18mm from Zeiss would be gorgeous.Would also be quite impractical I believe. The original Zeiss Otus 28 f/1.4 is the widest f/1.4 APO lens that I know of and it was very large. A lens that wide with that sort of performance would be unprecedented. I think we are a lot more likely to get an 18 f/2.8 if Zeiss develops a non-Otus, non-APO line of manual focus mirrorless lenses. I would be very happy if they develop such a line of lenses, but until then I will be happy with my Batis 18 f/2.8, which is really a very nice lens.
Aw, it only weighs five pounds and it's spectacular...
You're just a mount change away from being native and you can swap out the scales for metric or imperial. Filters are going to be a problem. That's why I stick with an adapted F-mount Milvus 18. For the reasonable filter size. It has nothing to do with being 1/3 the weight or that my used copy was 1/35 the price.
Steve Spencer wrote: Maximilian wroteKnut. wrote… I would really like an 18mm from Zeiss. Is it only me?a (truly) apochromatic 1,4/18mm from Zeiss would be gorgeous.Would also be quite impractical I believe. The original Zeiss Otus 28 f/1.4 is the widest f/1.4 APO lens that I know of and it was very large. A lens that wide with that sort of performance would be unprecedented. I think we are a lot more likely to get an 18 f/2.8 if Zeiss develops a non-Otus, non-APO line of manual focus mirrorless lenses. I would be very happy if they develop such a line of lenses, but until then I will be happy with my Batis 18 f/2.8, which is really a very nice lens.
If they went for f4 (or f3.5), Apo correction and 600g - I would be a very happy camper with such a lens! I agree the Batis is nice, but I would prefer linear manual focus. This is holding me off.
18mm/f3.5 - this would be my dream.
I got a call from Map Camera announcing that my Otus 50/1.4 ML (E-mount) has arrived Tomorrow is the official release date in Japan and I'll go and pick it up tomorrow on my lunch break.
Looking forward to shooting with it, but weather report looks quite bad for the weekend and beyond since rainy season is basically starting.
Today I noticed that the street price of CV 50/1.0 E-mount version went up from 188K to 214K in all the best Tokyo stores that sell CV lenses (Map, Fujiya, Ogisaku). There was an announcement about the price change from Map Camera too. It was around 214K at launch but has been selling with a bit lower prices for a long while now. I wonder if it's a tactic to reduce price gap to Otus to make Otus more appealing. However, the Canon RF version of 50/1.0 continues to sell for 178K in the same stores whle RF Otus is coming out tomorrow as well.
Juha Kannisto wrote:
I got a call from Map Camera announcing that my Otus 50/1.4 ML (E-mount) has arrived Tomorrow is the official release date in Japan and I'll go and pick it up tomorrow on my lunch break.
I'm very curious about your thoughts! Marc from https://sonyalpha.blog/2025/05/27/zeiss-otus-ml-50mm-f1-4/ said it was rather lackluster, but he can be over critical sometimes.
Regardless it might just be a hard sale as 'we' have been discussing on here for months. Maybe the lens will just be an acquired taste?
The preview copies sent out to influencers can miss some problematic issues in new lenses, but it can cut the other way as well. The innate character of lenses can't be discovered in a few days, which is all the early recipients get before doing their time-pressured videos or articles.
It's only gotten worse with ever higher resolution cameras and ever better software used for inspection of aberrations.
Each new lens is essentially a journey of discovery, therefore. We need the early info, we need the reviews but we really need plenty of images taken by a range of users. Images are where the rubber meets the road.
People will mark Zeiss harder than other lenses and earlier Otuses, because (i) the maker trumpeted the APO label and (ii) due to the cost of these lenses. If people see *any* CA in a so-called APO lens, they will not hold back on their commentary. See the comments at Chris Frost's YT:
But the main reason is the appearance of some truly fabulous lenses operating in Zeiss's focal length sphere for the new Otuses. Zeiss's best hope is that the lenses have endearing character built into them. This is something (forgive me for saying so) we have not seen in the preview stage. Guys have just basically wandered around and processed their rather plain composition work for commentary. Few portraits..
ALL f1.4 lenses really need to be used with their intended use cases. It's mostly people. No one wants to read any more, but CZ tells you in their 50mm f1.4 ML blurb at their website:
'..capturing portraits, street scenes, or cinematic moments..'
And the video they offer has a guy with a tripod, setting up on a beach. We can add to this by looking at the focus throw - long throws (this Zeiss is 260 degrees) are for slow and painstakingly accurate work, short throws (Voigtlander, Leica, etc.) are for fast action and zone focusing.
I'd say the MLss are connoisseur lenses, made for tripod use and handheld general purpose nature and more considered (and leisurely) street shooting. The weight is another indication this is so (esp. the 85mm). Zeiss did win with the MFD (0.5m) and 67mm filters is not too bad in a large lens.