Bokehddicted wrote:
Interesting. Is there precedence in the photo or cine business for such a limited range (28,50,85) from Zeiss or similar vendor?
I personally wouldnt complain. I would keep my loved Lox85 and combine it with the ML50 and ML28.
If the ML28mm 1.4 would have as much depth (3D pop) as the incredibly tempting Thypoch 28mm, i would be in heaven. Likely my dream manual kit!
freaklikeme wroteBokehddicted wroteIt WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.Would not, but I'm no oracle and not in on their go-forward strategy. It may well be a set like that.
Well, the original Otus line only went to four, and there's a strong argument that the 100 only saw the light of day because they were already using the design in the Supreme and they wanted to test the appetite for expansion. Had DSLRs not been dying quickly, or mirrorless shooters less picky about size and weight and adaption of lenses, they might've continued the line, I guess.
I know I'd like to see a 35. If this had been a 35, I'd buy instead of rent, because I know I'd want to spend more time with it. I use 50, but mostly for close-focus, where I don't need anything faster than f/2.8, or landscapes, where I don't need anything faster than f/5.6. I've tried out a lot of high performing fast normals, including two rounds with the Otus 55, but the lens that's stuck with me is the Rokkor 58/1.2, and that's only because it's such a beautiful mess wide open.
Jonas B wrote: freaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.
Personally, I would never make an axial CA evaluation solely from reviews and videos. I have never seen an f/1.4 lens that doesn't show axial CA at f/1.4 in at least some situations. What I really care about is not whether it occurs but how often it occurs and how easy it is to avoid it, and of course I care about that in my typical shooting scenarios.
I feel much the same way about axial CA as I do about flare. The fact that it can happen isn't what is important. What is important is whether or more accurately how often it happens in my shooting, and reviews just do a bad job of sorting that out. They tend to emphasize the existence of axial CA (and especially so with lenses labelled APO because some people have the wrong idea that APO means no axial CA) rather than how much of a problem the axial CA is.
So, for me I see enough positives about the lens including an f/1.4 aperture, a long focus throw, good but not too extreme sharpness, what looks like nice bokeh, and what looks like not perfect but pretty good CA correction, that I am likely to try out the lens at some point and see if I like it enough to buy it. YMMV, but I am more intrigued by the reviews and not turned off, but as always my experience with the lens will matter most.
Bokehddicted wrote:
It WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.
I know you asked Brad (freaklikeme) this question, and he provided a very reasonable answer, but I thought I would add my two cents. Zeiss has consistently brought out sets of lenses for mirrorless up to this point. First, it was the Batis series and that has 18, 25, 40, 85, and 135 mm lenses, and at about the same time they brought out the Loxia lenses. Those were of course 21, 25, 35, 50, and 85 mm lenses. So, I think it is reasonable to expect 5 or 6 Otus lenses.
That said, I think Zeiss is trying to find its place in the market. I don't think they want to compete with Voigtlander lenses especially as the Voigtlander lenses are made by the same company (Cosina) as they are using for these Otus lenses. It looks to me like they are trying to find a niche in mirrorless between their Milvus and Otus lines for DSLRs. I had and liked the Otus 28 and 55, and the Milvus 18 f/2.8, 21 f/2.8, 25 f/1.4, 35 f/1.4, 85 f/1.4, and 135 f/2 APO, and I currently have the Zeiss ZE 25 f/2. 50 f/2 Makro, and the 100 f/2 Makro and like those lenses a lot too. It is my positive experience with all of those lenses that to a large extent makes me interested in the new Otus lenses for mirrorless.
I think Zeiss is trying out these lenses and how many they make will likely be determined by how well this 50 and the 85 Otus do. If they sell well, then I think we will see at least a 5 lens set of Otuses. Probably something like 21, 25, 35, 50, & 85 (like the Loxia line) but maybe 25, 35, 50, 85, and 135 (which may be more fitting for these faster lenses especially if they let the 135 be f/1.8 or f/2). If they aren't a success and sell pretty poorly, then I think we might get just a 28 beyond the 50 and 85 and maybe not even that. If they sell moderately well, something like a 21, 28, 50, 85 set or a 28, 50, 85, 135 set also seems possible.
I think Zeiss probably has some ideas about what they would like to do, but I suspect before they will put any plan into production, they want to see how these lenses sell. I don't think they need huge volumes, but they need to sell enough to make decent profits and I think it is hard to know what sell enough will mean.
I just got a mail that the Otus 50/1.4 for E-mount is available for a retail price of 1899 euro’s. That is lower than the 2500 which was first mentioned.
Steve Spencer wrote:
Personally, I would never make an axial CA evaluation solely from reviews and videos. [...] YMMV, but I am more intrigued by the reviews and not turned off, but as always my experience with the lens will matter most.
I never make a, for me, complete evaluation from reviews. In this case however I have seen a level of CA which considering the price, size, weight and APO designation turns me off.
A lens this size and so on has to be freak'n close to perfect or it can't defend its place in my bag. Pretty good CA, good but not extreme sharpness, nice bokeh is not enough.
I read your next post and noted the Zeiss 50/2 makro and 100/2 makro are parts of your lens collection. Those lenses are also examples of too high axial CA for my taste. I think we simply judge this problem differently (what is acceptable and what is too much). (And yes, I am aware of the definition of an "APO lens" and know it is about amplifying red green and blue the same at the focal plane (IIRC), which has nothing to do with axial CA as we then per definition is in out of focus realm.)
It will of course be interesting to see how people here judge the 50ML once it is available and tried in real life by experienced people. I write "of course" as I would like to see Zeiss succeed in the current still photography world - but, as mentioned earlier, I don't think that will happen.
ustjwenew wrote:
I just got a mail that the Otus 50/1.4 for E-mount is available for a retail price of 1899 euro’s. That is lower than the 2500 which was first mentioned.
Much lower. Was that a retail price including local tax?
I got the mail from Zeiss as well. It mentioned the price as "1899 EUR (excl. German VAT; Prices may vary depending on the country or region)". Perhaps that will be the price at least in Germany before tax.
In Japan the lenses are not available, Cosina hasn't announced official release date here yet but it's still expected to be sometime in May (probably somewhere in the 2nd half). Japanese price is a bit better still with official price at 280000 JPY before tax, but actual price including tax in best shops at around 261K.
I'm planning to get the 50/1.4, not that I need it (I have the 3 native CV E-mount 50mm lenses as well as 50/1.4 GM, Sony Zeiss 50/1.4 Planar + others) but it would be very interesting to have one of these to play with and the 85mm is going to be too big and heavy for my purposes. Later I could also be interested in a 28mm if they release one.
It was 2.499€ incl vat in Germany at the time of announcement. It is listed now, and is shipping at some places, for 2.259€
Jonas B wrote: ustjwenew wroteI just got a mail that the Otus 50/1.4 for E-mount is available for a retail price of 1899 euro’s. That is lower than the 2500 which was first mentioned.Much lower. Was that a retail price including local tax?
I had a handful of ZE and Milvus back then. Own(ed) all Touit, Loxia and Batis.
Love the L25, L35, B40, L85, B135 the most.
Favorite of my daily kits is L25, B40, L85 for quite some time.
My GM24, GM35, GM50/14, GM50/12, GM85II are collecting dust. Because i just adore the Zeiss colors, contrast and overall depth so much more. A feeling of being present back in the moment. Focus and other optical metrics of the GMs might be mostly better to way better, but its of no relevance to me.
Btw: Love the GM2470II and GM70200II way more for what they are then the GM primes. Love to bring the zooms with some Loxias.
Anyways…
If all FL would be available as Otus ML, hypothetically, i would opt for:
A) L21, ML28, B40, ML50, L85 (light kit version: ML28/ML50)
B) L25, ML35, B40, L85 (light kit version: L25/ML35/L85)
In essence, i would love to have insight into whether we get a 28 or 35. Because i doubt we will get both.
And i find it really odd they start with 50/85.
Would have loved 28/50 or 35/85 as a starting combo.
Or 35/50 like with the Loxia series. Or 25/85 like with the Batis series.
<Include lots of insight into how GAS is a useless virus and non of this is of importance.. yet, keeping me up planning and anticipating the next kit rebuild all night nevertheless >
Steve Spencer wrote: Bokehddicted wroteIt WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.I know you asked Brad (freaklikeme) this question, and he provided a very reasonable answer, but I thought I would add my two cents. Zeiss has consistently brought out sets of lenses for mirrorless up to this point. First, it was the Batis series and that has 18, 25, 40, 85, and 135 mm lenses, and at about the same time they brought out the Loxia lenses. Those were of course 21, 25, 35, 50, and 85 mm lenses. So, I think it is reasonable to expect 5 or 6 Otus lenses.
That said, I think Zeiss is trying to find its place in the market. I don't think they want to compete with Voigtlander lenses especially as the Voigtlander lenses are made by the same company (Cosina) as they are using for these Otus lenses. It looks to me like they are trying to find a niche in mirrorless between their Milvus and Otus lines for DSLRs. I had and liked the Otus 28 and 55, and the Milvus 18 f/2.8, 21 f/2.8, 25 f/1.4, 35 f/1.4, 85 f/1.4, and 135 f/2 APO, and I currently have the Zeiss ZE 25 f/2. 50 f/2 Makro, and the 100 f/2 Makro and like those lenses a lot too. It is my positive experience with all of those lenses that to a large extent makes me interested in the new Otus lenses for mirrorless.
I think Zeiss is trying out these lenses and how many they make will likely be determined by how well this 50 and the 85 Otus do. If they sell well, then I think we will see at least a 5 lens set of Otuses. Probably something like 21, 25, 35, 50, & 85 (like the Loxia line) but maybe 25, 35, 50, 85, and 135 (which may be more fitting for these faster lenses especially if they let the 135 be f/1.8 or f/2). If they aren't a success and sell pretty poorly, then I think we might get just a 28 beyond the 50 and 85 and maybe not even that. If they sell moderately well, something like a 21, 28, 50, 85 set or a 28, 50, 85, 135 set also seems possible.
I think Zeiss probably has some ideas about what they would like to do, but I suspect before they will put any plan into production, they want to see how these lenses sell. I don't think they need huge volumes, but they need to sell enough to make decent profits and I think it is hard to know what sell enough will mean....Show more →
Jonas B wrote: Steve Spencer wrotePersonally, I would never make an axial CA evaluation solely from reviews and videos. [...] YMMV, but I am more intrigued by the reviews and not turned off, but as always my experience with the lens will matter most.I never make a, for me, complete evaluation from reviews. In this case however I have seen a level of CA which considering the price, size, weight and APO designation turns me off.
A lens this size and so on has to be freak'n close to perfect or it can't defend its place in my bag. Pretty good CA, good but not extreme sharpness, nice bokeh is not enough.
I read your next post and noted the Zeiss 50/2 makro and 100/2 makro are parts of your lens collection. Those lenses are also examples of too high axial CA for my taste. I think we simply judge this problem differently (what is acceptable and what is too much). (And yes, I am aware of the definition of an "APO lens" and know it is about amplifying red green and blue the same at the focal plane (IIRC), which has nothing to do with axial CA as we then per definition is in out of focus realm.)
It will of course be interesting to see how people here judge the 50ML once it is available and tried in real life by experienced people. I write "of course" as I would like to see Zeiss succeed in the current still photography world - but, as mentioned earlier, I don't think that will happen. ...Show more →
I do think we have different approaches to axial CA, and it isn't that I am ok with it. I don't like axial CA, and I pretty much throw away any shot in which it is at all prominent. In practice, however, there are lots of ways to deal with it. The obvious ones include stopping down. Axial CA does reduce with all lenses when stopping down, and that means for me that an important question is when does axial CA go away when you stop down and that question in most reviews isn't even addressed. Instead, reviewers just talk about the presence or absence of axial CA.
A second obvious way that axial CA can be avoided in many images is by shooting in black and white. Generally axial CA is not a problem in black and white images. I shoot about 25% of my images in black and white, and for those images I generally don't worry about axial CA.
So, let's take a lens like the ZE 100 f/2 Makro planar. Does it have strong axial CA in some images? Yes. Is that something I can work around in most images? Also yes. Does it deliver stunning images when I can work around the axial CA? Well, it has delivered some of my favorite images that are currently hanging on my wall.
So do I let the fact (and it is a fact) that the lens can have strong axial CA prevent me from owning the lens? No. I am glad to own the lens and for me it is a matter of keeping the axial CA in check when I am shooting and actually in practice it rarely is an issue and not that hard to work around. I do wish I didn't have to think about it, but the strong axial CA doesn't keep me from owning the lens, YMMV.
What does this mean for this new mirrorless Milvus 50? For me, it isn't that I don't wish it didn't have axial CA at f/1.4, but it does mean that if in the few reviews that address when the axial CA goes away on stopping down are right, then for my shooting it would never be a problem stopped down to even f/2. That is really good axial CA performance in terms of when it goes away and among the best that I have seen and way better than the ZE 100 f/2 Makro, and if the sharpness profile and the bokeh are as good as they seem to be in most reviews it will still be a really nice lens. I am also not scared away by the size or the price, although I of course would like it to be smaller and cheaper. So, I am still interested in the lens. I certainly won't rule it out just because of the axial CA and I think it would be really useful for a lot of the types of images I often shoot.
Bokehddicted wrote:
I had a handful of ZE and Milvus back then. Own(ed) all Touit, Loxia and Batis.
Love the L25, L35, B40, L85, B135 the most.
Favorite of my daily kits is L25, B40, L85 for quite some time.
My GM24, GM35, GM50/14, GM50/12, GM85II are collecting dust. Because i just adore the Zeiss colors, contrast and overall depth so much more. A feeling of being present back in the moment. Focus and other optical metrics of the GMs might be mostly better to way better, but its of no relevance to me.
Btw: Love the GM2470II and GM70200II way more for what they are then the GM primes. Love to bring the zooms with some Loxias.
Anyways…
If all FL would be available as Otus ML, hypothetically, i would opt for:
A) L21, ML28, B40, ML50, L85 (light kit version: ML28/ML50)
B) L25, ML35, B40, L85 (light kit version: L25/ML35/L85)
In essence, i would love to have insight into whether we get a 28 or 35. Because i doubt we will get both.
And i find it really odd they start with 50/85.
Would have loved 28/50 or 35/85 as a starting combo.
Or 35/50 like with the Loxia series. Or 25/85 like with the Batis series.
<Include lots of insight into how GAS is a useless virus and non of this is of importance.. yet, keeping me up planning and anticipating the next kit rebuild all night nevertheless >
...Show more →Steve Spencer wroteBokehddicted wroteIt WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wrotefreaklikeme wrote[...]
While I think every lens is marketed with the idea of hybrid use, I'd be surprised if we saw a line as complete as the Nanos in the Otus MLs. I wouldn't hold my breath for it, anyway, but who knows?I would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.I know you asked Brad (freaklikeme) this question, and he provided a very reasonable answer, but I thought I would add my two cents. Zeiss has consistently brought out sets of lenses for mirrorless up to this point. First, it was the Batis series and that has 18, 25, 40, 85, and 135 mm lenses, and at about the same time they brought out the Loxia lenses. Those were of course 21, 25, 35, 50, and 85 mm lenses. So, I think it is reasonable to expect 5 or 6 Otus lenses.
That said, I think Zeiss is trying to find its place in the market. I don't think they want to compete with Voigtlander lenses especially as the Voigtlander lenses are made by the same company (Cosina) as they are using for these Otus lenses. It looks to me like they are trying to find a niche in mirrorless between their Milvus and Otus lines for DSLRs. I had and liked the Otus 28 and 55, and the Milvus 18 f/2.8, 21 f/2.8, 25 f/1.4, 35 f/1.4, 85 f/1.4, and 135 f/2 APO, and I currently have the Zeiss ZE 25 f/2. 50 f/2 Makro, and the 100 f/2 Makro and like those lenses a lot too. It is my positive experience with all of those lenses that to a large extent makes me interested in the new Otus lenses for mirrorless.
I think Zeiss is trying out these lenses and how many they make will likely be determined by how well this 50 and the 85 Otus do. If they sell well, then I think we will see at least a 5 lens set of Otuses. Probably something like 21, 25, 35, 50, & 85 (like the Loxia line) but maybe 25, 35, 50, 85, and 135 (which may be more fitting for these faster lenses especially if they let the 135 be f/1.8 or f/2). If they aren't a success and sell pretty poorly, then I think we might get just a 28 beyond the 50 and 85 and maybe not even that. If they sell moderately well, something like a 21, 28, 50, 85 set or a 28, 50, 85, 135 set also seems possible.
I think Zeiss probably has some ideas about what they would like to do, but I suspect before they will put any plan into production, they want to see how these lenses sell. I don't think they need huge volumes, but they need to sell enough to make decent profits and I think it is hard to know what sell enough will mean.
I don't see the 50 and 85 to start as being so odd. The Loxia series had a 50mm and one of the first two lenses and the Batis series had an 85 as one of the first two lenses and I believe the Otus DSLR series started with a 50mm and then added the 85mm before adding the 28mm. Of the first two lenses for the Loxia, Batis, and mirrorless Otus, the odd one that stands out (to me anyway) is the Batis 25 f/2. I think 35mm, 50mm, and 85mm all make sense for first lenses from a series.
It would be nice to know what they are planning, but they may not have mede final decisions yet. Personally, I would pair the 50 Otus ML with a Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 much of the time and with the ability to crop on my high MP A7r V and the fast aperture, those two lenses would serve me well in about 90% of my shooting situations.
i didnt mean ‚odd‘ in terms of focal length choice. I think 50 and 85 is perfect.
I mean in terms of starting grid. If, like you rightly point out, they might wait for market reactions before they continue with a third lens, they might also consider that it stays with the ‚first two‘ if market reaction is lack luster.
And if it stays with just two, then i would have loved to have a typical two lens kit combo (one wide, one tighter). 28/50 being my favorite. Or 35/85. Or 28/85. Or 25/55. You get my drift.
Steve Spencer wrote: Bokehddicted wroteI had a handful of ZE and Milvus back then. Own(ed) all Touit, Loxia and Batis.
Love the L25, L35, B40, L85, B135 the most.
Favorite of my daily kits is L25, B40, L85 for quite some time.
My GM24, GM35, GM50/14, GM50/12, GM85II are collecting dust. Because i just adore the Zeiss colors, contrast and overall depth so much more. A feeling of being present back in the moment. Focus and other optical metrics of the GMs might be mostly better to way better, but its of no relevance to me.
Btw: Love the GM2470II and GM70200II way more for what they are then the GM primes. Love to bring the zooms with some Loxias.
Anyways…
If all FL would be available as Otus ML, hypothetically, i would opt for:
A) L21, ML28, B40, ML50, L85 (light kit version: ML28/ML50)
B) L25, ML35, B40, L85 (light kit version: L25/ML35/L85)
In essence, i would love to have insight into whether we get a 28 or 35. Because i doubt we will get both.
And i find it really odd they start with 50/85.
Would have loved 28/50 or 35/85 as a starting combo.
Or 35/50 like with the Loxia series. Or 25/85 like with the Batis series.
<Include lots of insight into how GAS is a useless virus and non of this is of importance.. yet, keeping me up planning and anticipating the next kit rebuild all night nevertheless >
Steve Spencer wroteBokehddicted wroteIt WOULD NOT surpise you if it ends there? Or it WOULD surprise you..
I think it will very likely be a 5-6 lens set
freaklikeme wroteJonas B wroteI would be very surprised and I'm afraid we'll see an Otus failure coming. With the CA demonstrated in the influencer's marketing material I don't think the lens will be a success at all.I doubt it'll fail. I don't think it was ever destined to be a "fly off the shelves" item, but it will find an audience. The branding, focal length, speed, and positive performance metrics along with the build quality and long focus throw makes it an attractive proposition. We'll see the 85 and likely a 28, but it wouldn't surprise me if it ends there.I know you asked Brad (freaklikeme) this question, and he provided a very reasonable answer, but I thought I would add my two cents. Zeiss has consistently brought out sets of lenses for mirrorless up to this point. First, it was the Batis series and that has 18, 25, 40, 85, and 135 mm lenses, and at about the same time they brought out the Loxia lenses. Those were of course 21, 25, 35, 50, and 85 mm lenses. So, I think it is reasonable to expect 5 or 6 Otus lenses.
That said, I think Zeiss is trying to find its place in the market. I don't think they want to compete with Voigtlander lenses especially as the Voigtlander lenses are made by the same company (Cosina) as they are using for these Otus lenses. It looks to me like they are trying to find a niche in mirrorless between their Milvus and Otus lines for DSLRs. I had and liked the Otus 28 and 55, and the Milvus 18 f/2.8, 21 f/2.8, 25 f/1.4, 35 f/1.4, 85 f/1.4, and 135 f/2 APO, and I currently have the Zeiss ZE 25 f/2. 50 f/2 Makro, and the 100 f/2 Makro and like those lenses a lot too. It is my positive experience with all of those lenses that to a large extent makes me interested in the new Otus lenses for mirrorless.
I think Zeiss is trying out these lenses and how many they make will likely be determined by how well this 50 and the 85 Otus do. If they sell well, then I think we will see at least a 5 lens set of Otuses. Probably something like 21, 25, 35, 50, & 85 (like the Loxia line) but maybe 25, 35, 50, 85, and 135 (which may be more fitting for these faster lenses especially if they let the 135 be f/1.8 or f/2). If they aren't a success and sell pretty poorly, then I think we might get just a 28 beyond the 50 and 85 and maybe not even that. If they sell moderately well, something like a 21, 28, 50, 85 set or a 28, 50, 85, 135 set also seems possible.
I think Zeiss probably has some ideas about what they would like to do, but I suspect before they will put any plan into production, they want to see how these lenses sell. I don't think they need huge volumes, but they need to sell enough to make decent profits and I think it is hard to know what sell enough will mean.I don't see the 50 and 85 to start as being so odd. The Loxia series had a 50mm and one of the first two lenses and the Batis series had an 85 as one of the first two lenses and I believe the Otus DSLR series started with a 50mm and then added the 85mm before adding the 28mm. Of the first two lenses for the Loxia, Batis, and mirrorless Otus, the odd one that stands out (to me anyway) is the Batis 25 f/2. I think 35mm, 50mm, and 85mm all make sense for first lenses from a series.
It would be nice to know what they are planning, but they may not have mede final decisions yet. Personally, I would pair the 50 Otus ML with a Voigtlander 21 f/1.4 much of the time and with the ability to crop on my high MP A7r V and the fast aperture, those two lenses would serve me well in about 90% of my shooting situations....Show more →
You have to bear in mind that Zeiss are absolutely fixated on 85mm lenses, most of which are actually 90mm lenses at portrait distances (via breathing).
I had hoped they would break out of this chronic behavioral disorder and deeply embedded corporate ideology, by revamping the Nanos into lithe and fair weight stills lenses (a la DZO/Thypoch), which feature the coming popular distribution of 50-75-100mm.
Maybe in 5-10 years time, they will. We can't rush Zeiss, as recent history has proven. They are the epitome of stubbornness and they will take their own sweet time. Maybe when you have been around for 150 years or more, what is the big deal with 10 years or so?
So a couple days in and I'm impressed. Compared to the Sony 50/1.4GM and the Canon 50/1.4L, it is a bit lighter on center resolution wide open, but it makes up for it at the third marks, where Sony has, once again, managed a mid-zone dip and the Canon's FC is just getting warmed up. In that way, it's very much like the Otus 55. It's rewarding you for framing like you were taught to frame. They all breathe roughly the same.
The spherochromatism is as high as the influencers make it look, so if the goal is to use it wide open close focused on high contrast subjects heavily backlit, you get what you get. Unfortunately, one positive aspect of the lens performance (well corrected SA throughout the focus range creating stronger contrasting edges) works against it in that respect. It would still be higher in appearance compared to the Sony or Canon (or the APO-Lanthar 50/2) but it wouldn't be quite so ugly.
All the other objective measures favor the Otus. Significantly lower distortion, lower overall FC, better flare resistance, well-defined lightstars, higher resolution at portrait distances and shorter, more neutral SA correction throughout the range, lower coma, slightly lower natural vignetting, and about the same optical vignetting so far as impact across the frame, but the Otus keeps a slightly rounder shape to the cat's eyes. Focus roll off isn't quite as smooth as the Otus 55 wide open, but it's less harsh than Sony or Canon and it catches up with the 55 at f/2.
It communicates distance to the camera, so you get 5-axis IBIS. The build quality is gorgeous. It fixes all the little niggling complaints I have about the Milvus/Otus and Loxia designs. And it's big, but it feels great on the a1. Also, I am very thankful for the a1's EVF. Focusing with my rII UT and rII mono means spending a lot more time in a magnified view. Side note; the mild FC improves to the point of insignificance on the UT mod and then swings the other way on my bare-sensor rII mono.
It's one of the greats, but it's not making me an all-around 50 shooter. I'd still rather have a 35.
I love many Zeiss lenses, but as this one arrives, I have a ridiculous number of 50s, almost none of which get any use, after having gotten the f/1.2 GM a few years ago.
I would, however love to see a 28/1.4 ML with the draw of the Otus 28.
Que me up for the ML28 as well, like i stated above 🥳
Grenache wrote:
I love many Zeiss lenses, but as this one arrives, I have a ridiculous number of 50s, almost none of which get any use, after having gotten the f/1.2 GM a few years ago.
I would, however love to see a 28/1.4 ML with the draw of the Otus 28.
freaklikeme wrote:
So a couple days in and I'm impressed.[...]
Congratulations to your new Otus!
To sum it up the lens seem to behave as expected then? The to me new observation on the FC - it's mild but do you think it will have impact on real life images?
----
f/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?
Jonas B wrote: freaklikeme wroteSo a couple days in and I'm impressed.[...]Congratulations to your new Otus!
To sum it up the lens seem to behave as expected then? The to me new observation on the FC - it's mild but do you think it will have impact on real life images?
----
f/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?
No, no, no. Not mine. Not even a rental. My boss gave me the go ahead to request evaluation copies because our video team wanted to compare it to the Nano 50, so I did all my standard testing on it as well. I only had it out of my test environment briefly yesterday afternoon, but the FC didn't impact my real world shots. Just don't try to do two-dimensional reproduction work (or shoot test charts) at wide apertures and you'll probably never see it (just like most people wouldn't see the mid-zone dip on the GM). I'll have it out more this afternoon and let you know if I find a situation where it's impactful.
There haven't been a lot of surprises. I know the CA is disappointing. I find it a little disappointing on my beloved APO-Sonnar 135/2, but I forgive it because it doesn't let me down in any other way. I'm sure the Otus 50 will be that kind of lens for some manual 50 lovers.
The only things I can objectively say favor the Otus over the APO-Lanthar are transmission, because the Otus is between a half and third stop ahead of the Lanthar at like apertures down to f/4, the distance scale is easier to read, so it's faster to prefocus before bringing the camera to your eye, vignetting is lower, distortion's lower and simple, and the Lanthar shows more degradation in resolution the closer you focus. There may be enough there to change some Lanthar lovers' minds about taking on a relative giant instead, but the Lanthar packs so much power in so little space, my guess is the Otus will be an additional 50 for some; not a replacement. Subjectively, I prefer the Otus in use. I like packing and carrying little lenses, but, once I'm shooting with them, I'd rather have more weight and grip. If I were going to pick a slower, less expensive alternative to the Otus, I'd gravitate to the APO-Lanthar 65/2 for several reasons, but a lot of it would be for that size and weight.
Jonas B wrote: f/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?
freaklikeme wrote: No, no, no. Not mine. Not even a rental. My boss gave me the go ahead to request evaluation copies because our video team wanted to compare it to the Nano 50, so I did all my standard testing on it as well. I only had it out of my test environment briefly yesterday afternoon, but the FC didn't impact my real world shots. Just don't try to do two-dimensional reproduction work (or shoot test charts) at wide apertures and you'll probably never see it (just like most people wouldn't see the mid-zone dip on the GM). I'll have it out more this afternoon and let you know if I find a situation where it's impactful....Show more →
Ah, I see. Not your then. Fun to try out anyway I guess!
Some people even don't notice the midzone dip on some of the Leica m-lenses... To me it sounds as "sharp enough" (which I btw not find the Summilux-M 35/1.4 to be talking about midzone dips).
There haven't been a lot of surprises. I know the CA is disappointing. I find it a little disappointing on my beloved APO-Sonnar 135/2, but I forgive it because it doesn't let me down in any other way. I'm sure the Otus 50 will be that kind of lens for some manual 50 lovers.
But the APO-Sonnar is better, no?! That's at least my guess judging from influencer material.
The only things I can objectively say favor the Otus over the APO-Lanthar are transmission, because the Otus is between a half and third stop ahead of the Lanthar at like apertures down to f/4, the distance scale is easier to read, so it's faster to prefocus before bringing the camera to your eye, vignetting is lower, distortion's lower and simple, and the Lanthar shows more degradation in resolution the closer you focus. There may be enough there to change some Lanthar lovers' minds about taking on a relative giant instead, but the Lanthar packs so much power in so little space, my guess is the Otus will be an additional 50 for some; not a replacement. Subjectively, I prefer the Otus in use. I like packing and carrying little lenses, but, once I'm shooting with them, I'd rather have more weight and grip. If I were going to pick a slower, less expensive alternative to the Otus, I'd gravitate to the APO-Lanthar 65/2 for several reasons, but a lot of it would be for that size and weight....Show more →
Hmm. Nothing of that make me think about getting an Otus.
The distance scale I'm not sure what you mean. The color? I'm a metric guy so the white numbers are easy to see.
The distortion? Frankly I have neveer thought about the Lanthar distortion. FM says negligible, Lenstip says 0.38% and I don't care.
Degradation in resolution the closer you focus? I have to get close enough start worrying. That of course depends on what the lens is used for...
Your observation on the light transmission is interesting. It's not a deciding factor for me but can probably be for some users. When i need more photons I get by using slower shutter speed. At least for the most of the time.
As I suspected the Otus is not for me. I'm happy to read about your findings though. It sounds as some will be happy with the lens!
Thank you for getting back with your report, it's appreciated!
freaklikeme wrote: Jonas B wrotefreaklikeme wroteSo a couple days in and I'm impressed.[...]Congratulations to your new Otus!
To sum it up the lens seem to behave as expected then? The to me new observation on the FC - it's mild but do you think it will have impact on real life images?
----
f/1.4 and f/2 is not the same thing. Let's say we can live with an f/2 lens. What's the real gain with the new 50ML compared to the Voigtländer 50APO? A better aperture ring I'm sure, but optically perhaps something more?No, no, no. Not mine. Not even a rental. My boss gave me the go ahead to request evaluation copies because our video team wanted to compare it to the Nano 50, so I did all my standard testing on it as well. I only had it out of my test environment briefly yesterday afternoon, but the FC didn't impact my real world shots. Just don't try to do two-dimensional reproduction work (or shoot test charts) at wide apertures and you'll probably never see it (just like most people wouldn't see the mid-zone dip on the GM). I'll have it out more this afternoon and let you know if I find a situation where it's impactful.
There haven't been a lot of surprises. I know the CA is disappointing. I find it a little disappointing on my beloved APO-Sonnar 135/2, but I forgive it because it doesn't let me down in any other way. I'm sure the Otus 50 will be that kind of lens for some manual 50 lovers.
The only things I can objectively say favor the Otus over the APO-Lanthar are transmission, because the Otus is between a half and third stop ahead of the Lanthar at like apertures down to f/4, the distance scale is easier to read, so it's faster to prefocus before bringing the camera to your eye, vignetting is lower, distortion's lower and simple, and the Lanthar shows more degradation in resolution the closer you focus. There may be enough there to change some Lanthar lovers' minds about taking on a relative giant instead, but the Lanthar packs so much power in so little space, my guess is the Otus will be an additional 50 for some; not a replacement. Subjectively, I prefer the Otus in use. I like packing and carrying little lenses, but, once I'm shooting with them, I'd rather have more weight and grip. If I were going to pick a slower, less expensive alternative to the Otus, I'd gravitate to the APO-Lanthar 65/2 for several reasons, but a lot of it would be for that size and weight....Show more →
Thank you for your interesting information.
Since I understand that you tested lots of lenses, I'd like to ask you two questions.
1. Talking about midzone dip, have you seen it in the Sony GM 1,2/50mm as well?
2. How does the LoCA of the Otus ML 50mm compare to that of the original Otus 55mm?