p.1 #1Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Hello,
I know this is asked a lot, but I could not find a post about this recently when I searched. (If I am wrong, kindly let me know!)
What is your latest take on the ageless debate about a UV filter protecting the front element of expensive glass? There are of course, the classic arguments: if you spend $$$ on a lens, you want to protect it from sand, breaking from a fall, etc. Then again, if you spend $$$ on a lens, why are you putting a cheap(er) piece of glass in front of everything, compromising the image quality that you bought the very nice lens for? (In that case, just keep the hood on it and clean the front glass from time-to-time -- what cleaner/method do you recommend?)
p.1 #2Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I stopped using filters a couple decades ago when I notice multiple reflections in a night cityscape. There are also numerous stories of such filters causing AF difficulties. If I shot a lot where ocean spray or wind-blown sand was an issue, I might reconsider.
I always use a hood if I have one.
For cleaning, first a "Rocket Blower," then Zeiss lens eyeglasses cleaning wipes which can be purchased at Walmart. (If I still worked in a laser lab, I would hold lens tissue with hemostats and employ acetone followed by methanol as solvents.)
p.1 #3Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I use one at the beach during big wave season. Afterwards it is caked with salt spray and I remove the filter, rinse in tap water and pat dry. I also wipe down the camera/lens with a damp towel. Dried salt is surprisingly abrasive and, back in the day, I ruined the front element coating trying to clean the salt off, albeit I used wet cleaning.
p.1 #4Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Marvin Berry wrote:
Hello,
I know this is asked a lot, but I could not find a post about this recently when I searched. (If I am wrong, kindly let me know!)
What is your latest take on the ageless debate about a UV filter protecting the front element of expensive glass? There are of course, the classic arguments: if you spend $$$ on a lens, you want to protect it from sand, breaking from a fall, etc. Then again, if you spend $$$ on a lens, why are you putting a cheap(er) piece of glass in front of everything, compromising the image quality that you bought the very nice lens for? (In that case, just keep the hood on it and clean the front glass from time-to-time -- what cleaner/method do you recommend?)
I would say don't use them unless you have to, and use a bulb sprayer as much as possible instead of making contact by wiping the glass. With that said there are plenty of times when I use them because my lenses are taking on roost and I don't want to chip anymore expensive front elements.
If you use the right UV filters you should not be able to see a difference in IQ in the end result. I've tested mine with and without and I cannot see a difference even when I'm trying to.
p.1 #7Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I always had highest quality UV (or Sky) filters, and stopped using them when I saw ghosting in extremely high contrast scenes (imagine street lights at night). The only times I would put it on is as shown here (she's in college now); all other times I go naked, even in places like on a zodiac in Antarctica or in the rain.
Canon EOS-1Ds Mark II24.0 mm lens24mmf/3.51/100s400 ISO0.0 EV
p.1 #8Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I use X4 UV filters from Breakthrough filters (https://breakthrough.photography/products/x4-uv?variant=31478833169). I've never seen any issues with them and they have excellent service and warranties. They feature Schott B720 optical glass, extremely high transmission, nano coatings and made from brass with nice grippy knobs making them easy to remove and difficult to get stuck. And they clean easily. I'm in California so I've seen sand and water and they've saved my lenses many times. Canon L lenses are not weather sealed without a filter.
Polarizers and ND filters are another issue. ND and grads I used Lee, Cokin and Singh-Ray. I'm very happy with their systems. For Circular Polarizers I'm thinking of upgrading to either the B+W High-Transmission MRC-Nano Master Circular Polarizer Filters or the NiSi JetMag Pro True Color Circular Polarizer Magnetic Filters. But I haven't tested either yet.
p.1 #10Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Marvin Berry wrote:
Hello,
I know this is asked a lot, but I could not find a post about this recently when I searched. (If I am wrong, kindly let me know!)
What is your latest take on the ageless debate about a UV filter protecting the front element of expensive glass? There are of course, the classic arguments: if you spend $$$ on a lens, you want to protect it from sand, breaking from a fall, etc. Then again, if you spend $$$ on a lens, why are you putting a cheap(er) piece of glass in front of everything, compromising the image quality that you bought the very nice lens for? (In that case, just keep the hood on it and clean the front glass from time-to-time -- what cleaner/method do you recommend?)
I don't generally use a protective filter and yes, eventually all of my lenses have minor marks on the front element. A couple times I have paid the price of accidentally scuffing the front element due to something rubbing on it while in the bag during a shoot, which resulted in front element replacement.
For me it's like getting pristine new car. Eventually it will get dinged and IMO the sooner the better so I can move on an just use it.
Based on past discussions it seems where image quality concerns with protective filters become the most relevant is with telephoto lenses. You need a high quality, properly flat piece of glass to minimize image quality degradation.
p.1 #13Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
from the comments:
'There is a YT series of videos (about 30hrs total) from Krolop & Gerst, a German camera shop, interviewing the head designer of Zeiss lenses. They asked him exactly this question and his answer was that every lens he owns has a protective filter on it.'
'The expert was very clear on that point. The vulnerability of the front lens (element) coating is key. He highly recommended protecting the coating against micro scratches. Those scratches come over time and they indeed impact the image quality. Using a clear filter is the easiest way to do so.'
What's the first thing a 2nd hand lens buyer does before shining a light into the lens? Checks the coatings on both front and rear elements. Erwin Puts said you lose just 1% of image quality from a filter, that was back before the miracle filters we have today.
Most car windscreens get replaced not because of breakage, but scarring caused by dirt, grit, sand etc. There are many airborne substances harder than optical glass - check out the Mohs Scale if you need to see this for yourself.
I shoot a lot in the GHR, lots of volcanic dust, always a filter. The filters look second hand after a couple of years...But some know better than the cine lens DPs with gear costing six figure sums. Sure, my bros. I actually use the no filter guys as a filter for not buying lenses from them. They don't care about their lenses, so they can sell to someone like themselves.
Jan 03, 2025 at 06:00 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.1 #14Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
If you shoot a new Canon RF lens that has coatings that a dry microfiber will remove, probably yes.
For real lenses, no, a hood will suffice for anything short of the oceanside.
p.1 #15Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Uarctos wrote:
Not.
Except brutal environments.
Correct and only answer. It's not debatable. But also, when going into rough environments, if your camera and lens wasn't built with a decent amount of weather sealing then a filter on your lens is has about the same effectiveness as a wearing windbreaker in the Arctic.
p.1 #16Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
PetaPixel had an appropriate review article concerning this topic:
“The Best Protection Filters for Lenses in 2024.” The article was updated in January 2024.
The topic was well explained and the pros/cons were also discussed. Recommended filter brands were listed.
I hope you find this review beneficial.
Jan 03, 2025 at 06:32 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.1 #17Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I'd rather have a filter but I've had trouble getting flare, especially if you're not careful
It's much easier to clean a filter than an actual element, though.
p.1 #18Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I've come 180 on this. Early in my DSLR days I put a filter on everything to protect the front element. Now I just am sure to put the lens cap on when I'm not shooting, and otherwise don't use a UV/protective filter. Except in the following situations:
1. Really bad weather elements. Rain, extreme dust/sand, etc. and out of an abundance of caution I'll put on a lens filter. As Mike says, it's easier to clean a filter than the front element and if you end up creating microscratches on the filter, easy to replace if needed.
2. When shooting with wide open fast glass in bright light (video and stills) I often have an ND filter on, which then acts as a de facto protection filter...though admittedly that's not its primary job.
3. If I'm in crowded/cramped environments where my lenses could be bumped due to forces outside of my control. I can control my clumsiness, but I can't control other people/animals/etc. doing unpredictable things and running into my gear. Or if I ever decide to get into action photography involving getting on very fast vehicles and shooting in dusty/dirty environments, like being in dune buggies racing through the desert (chance of that: near zero).
Given all of that I'd say I run about 80% of the time bare lens, 15% of the time ND filter (doing ND filter's primary job), and 5% of time with a UV/protection filter due to weather/elements/other environmental factors.
philip_pj wrote:
I shoot a lot in the GHR, lots of volcanic dust, always a filter. The filters look second hand after a couple of years...But some know better than the cine lens DPs with gear costing six figure sums. Sure, my bros. I actually use the no filter guys as a filter for not buying lenses from them. They don't care about their lenses, so they can sell to someone like themselves.
If I was shooting in such conditions, seaside surf, etc, then such a protective filter makes sense. But that's not where I usually work.
As to the second point, I never sell any of my lenses to anyone who nitpicks over micro coating scratches. It's just not worth the hassle. That's what KEH and the like are good for. I want to use my gear and not have a nagging worry that I'm losing an additional 10% or 15% in resale value because of micro-scratches or chips in the paint. I also tend to hold onto my lenses for a long time, so they end up pretty 'weathered.' Meaning, whoever receives my lens after me will get it at a reasonable price.
Anyway, modern lenses are too sharp and high contrast to begin with. Micro-scratch weathering is like seasoning the glass for a more 'rounded' rendering.
p.1 #20Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
The only time I put on a filter is with an ND for super long exposure, a polarizer on my color cameras, when shooting infrared, ultraviolet on my full spectrum body or black and white on my Lieca monochrom or if conditions otherwise require protection(sand, flying debris).
Like Stan when I was in Antarctica only filter used was a polarizer for skies and occasionally reducing water reflections or when I was shooting infrared film and color infrared slide.