fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?

  
 
Pixelpuffin
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I only have filters on L’s as canon recommends for weather sealing. I stopped using L’s due to weight and bulk.

The rest….
I tend to buy a spare 3rd party lens hood (often used off eBay) then chop half or 2/3rds off. I then leave permanently attached with no front lens cap or filter in place. I always use rear caps ALWAYS!!

I find this approach so easy, I remove lens from camera, drop vertically into bag knowing the cut down hood stops the lens touching anything, grab my next lens, swap rear caps over and fit to camera.

Always have a blower in my bag too.

No more losing caps, degradation of filters, way faster in use.

As for flare….
I love flare, I think it adds a sense of realism.
I loathe the current super sharp, super saturated “Pack shot” look that modern mirrorless gives….ugh!!


Jan 04, 2025 at 02:43 AM
Tony Ross
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
There is no reason to use a UV or "Skylight" filter for protection on a digital camera.

This idea started back in the days of film - film can be fogged by UV radiation - a UV or Skylight filter actually makes sense. Digital sensors are not sensitive to UV, so there is no reason to use one.

The other reason for using a UV filter for protection was because they were about the cheapest filters.

If you want to protect a lens with a filter on a digital camera, you should look at purpose-built protective filters - they are clear, with no filtration. I'd expect that they are probably tougher that a regular glass filter - toughened or tempered glass.

There is an ultimate option - Sigma makes protective filters made from transparent ceramic - those are the ones they advertise by bouncing ball bearings off them.

I haven't used protective filters for a while, but I do use a lens hood all the time (and it has protected a lens a couple of times.

I would consider using a filter at the beach - salt spray and windblown sand are real risks. But I haven't been in the situation.
Jan 04, 2025 at 05:13 AM
paulfeng
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Impressive, this post both educated AND insulted me!

philip_pj wrote:



from the comments:

'There is a YT series of videos (about 30hrs total) from Krolop & Gerst, a German camera shop, interviewing the head designer of Zeiss lenses. They asked him exactly this question and his answer was that every lens he owns has a protective filter on it.'

'The expert was very clear on that point. The vulnerability of the front lens (element) coating is key. He highly recommended protecting the coating against micro scratches. Those scratches come over time and they indeed impact the image quality. Using a clear filter is the easiest way to do so.'

What's the first thing
...Show more →
Jan 04, 2025 at 06:49 AM
jedibrain
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I have never seen a benefit to a UV filter, only degradation of results. So I don't use them. Like others, the exception is if I know there will be a hazard of some type, like rain, mist, sand, dirt etc. At that point the hazard usually puts a ceiling on how sharp an image can by anyway.

I prefer a lens cap to protect from incidental scratches, unless maybe crawling through deep brush or something I think they work just as well. The thin filter glass is unlikely to truly protect against some kind of projectile strike. Maybe if they ever figure out transparent aluminum that will change.

Brian
Jan 04, 2025 at 08:42 AM
Danpbphoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I have used a filter on all my lenses. That filter saved at least 3 lenses from damage.

As for the controversy on whether or not they affect the IQ of an image? I have NOT found that to be the case in my personal experience.

Not saying that those who found IQ issues are not correct! Just sayin' I never encountered them.

Now for cleaning, I took this from my daze of astro photography and I used this mixture on all my telescopes(none now) and I use it on all my camera filters and lenses.
It has NOT harmed any lenses or their coatings over some 50 years of use. I use a micro fiber cloth to clean off the solution after spraying it on sparsely!
https://astrowhat.com/articles/cleaning-your-telescope-lens-or-mirror.9/
Good luck!
Dan
Jan 04, 2025 at 10:18 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Tony Ross wrote:
There is no reason to use a UV or "Skylight" filter for protection on a digital camera.

This idea started back in the days of film - film can be fogged by UV radiation - a UV or Skylight filter actually makes sense. Digital sensors are not sensitive to UV, so there is no reason to use one.

The other reason for using a UV filter for protection was because they were about the cheapest filters.

If you want to protect a lens with a filter on a digital camera, you should look at purpose-built protective filters - they are clear, with
...Show more →

Not to mention that pushing/selling a UV/skylight filter added a high profit margin item to what otherwise might have been a low margin sale for the retailer. Having worked in photo retail back in the film days, when a UV or skylight would have made more technical sense, the argument was always that it would protect an expensive investment (the lens) to 'guilt' the new lens owner into spending a little more. At least the clear 'protection' filters are labels as such now.

Regarding the technical merit of using a UV filter nowadays on digital, if you wander over to the Sony board there was a discussion about slight improvements in image color, or elimination of a slight color cast, IIRC, when certain UV filters with a stronger cutoff were used with certain cameras. Plus, you can send off your camera for sensor conversion for UV capture, IR capture, full spectrum, etc. So it's not that digital sensors are not sensitive to UV light, rather that whatever glass is used to cover the sensor blocks UV (and IR).

From my experience with Leica digital cameras, where Leica balances a fine line between making that cover glass as thin as possible to minimize lens sharpness degradation while still blocking/absorbing UV/IR, all of the M-system cameras I have used/owned have had signs of residual IR image contamination. And for a while Leica sold UV/IR filters. Point being, it's possible this can also vary with respect to how effectively UV is cut off. Another possible factor might be UV transmission of the lens... which will depend on the optics. There are specialized lenses for UV photography but it appears that mainstream consumer lenses have varying degrees of UV transmission capability.

https://kolarivision.com/uv-photography-lens-compatibility/
https://kolarivision.com/category/uv-photography/
Jan 04, 2025 at 10:33 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Earlier in this thread I posted a link to something I wrote that looks at this question pretty exhaustively. So I won’t repost all of that here. But…

… to the question of what negative effects a UV filter might have:

1. If “stuff” on your lens is a concern, you’ll still have “stuff” on the filter, and because it is farther from the sensor it will actually tend to be more visible in photographs. (In most cases you won’t see it either way, but at very small aperture, perhaps with a wide angle lens, and with side-light… it can happen.)

2. The flat rear surface of these filters can produce reflections in some cases, seemingly of light on the front of the lens element. It isn’t usually visible, but in some situations it can be. For example, night photographers run into the issue sometimes.

3. Some lenses have had AF issues with UV filters. Again, it isn’t a common thing, but it happens. For example, it was pretty widely known that the older EF 100-400 had such issues.

4. The use of cheap filters (the kind you most often get in those “kits”) has the potential to exacerbate the problems. These filters may not have high quality coatings and can even have optical imperfections. Using the best, expensive filters can allay this concern… but the cost of putting them on all of your lenses can be prohibitive… and not a cost effective way to protect against just one kind of potential lens damage… especially when a lens hood and cap will accomplish this, too.

I can see putting a protective filter on an expensive lens in a particularly hazardous environment, especially if you are using a sealed camera as well. Putting a filter on the lens when the camera isn’t sealed is king of like putting on a rain hat to go out in the rain but not bothering with a rain coat. (Putting a cheapie filter on an expensive lens seems wrong, since you paid a lot for optical excellence. Putting an expensive filter on a cheap lens doesn’t make much sense either.) But for the vast majority of photography these filters serve no useful purpose aside from bringing in a bit of extra profit for the folks selling them.

Edited on Jan 04, 2025 at 09:37 PM · View previous versions
Jan 04, 2025 at 11:31 AM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.2 #8Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Marvin Berry wrote:
Hello,

I know this is asked a lot, but I could not find a post about this recently when I searched. (If I am wrong, kindly let me know!)

What is your latest take on the ageless debate about a UV filter protecting the front element of expensive glass? There are of course, the classic arguments: if you spend $$$ on a lens, you want to protect it from sand, breaking from a fall, etc. Then again, if you spend $$$ on a lens, why are you putting a cheap(er) piece of glass in front of everything, compromising the image quality
...Show more →

I have the same take as decades ago. Use them judiciously when needed in harsh conditions, but not as the default.
The lens or filter cost is never part of my equation since the cost of lost opportunity >10,000km away from home is many times more than having a repair done later at leisure.

In case you don't think of it a polarizing filter is potentially much more degrading to the image since there are three elements rather than just one in a conventional filter.

EBH
Jan 04, 2025 at 12:04 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I like to protect my expensive UV filters by placing a couple of cheap UV filters in front of them. I wouldn't want to risk damaging a $100 filter.
Jan 04, 2025 at 01:51 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
As far as dropping a lens or bumping it into something, a hood offers more protection than a filter.
Jan 04, 2025 at 02:32 PM
mborozny
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I agree. If I had had a hood on my RF35, I wouldn’t have cracked my B+W filter. Now I have both.

Imagemaster wrote:
As far as dropping a lens or bumping it into something, a hood offers more protection than a filter.

Jan 04, 2025 at 03:52 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
gdanmitchell wrote:
2. The flat rear surface of these filters can produce reflections in some cases, seemingly of light on the front of the lens element. It isn’t usually visible, but in some situations it can be. For example, night photographers run into the issue sometimes.


The problem specifically appears to be light reflecting off the highly reflective sensor surface back through the lens. Any flat element surfaces, including a filter, will then reflect some of that light back to the sensor again. It's a reason why the front protective filter/element on earlier digital-era super-tele lenses were made as a slight meniscus (before the recent major optical redesigns that entirely eliminated that protective element).

See the discussion here: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/77116/0&year=2004#629866
Jan 04, 2025 at 04:05 PM
leftymgp
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I've gradually removed the protective filters from all my lenses. And for newer lens purchases, I've just never used them. At some point I realized that (at least for me) I wasn't really doing stuff that put the front element at risk. And that's after tons of traveling, hiking mountains, and generally not being overly careful with my gear.

I can see an argument for using filters in beach spray, etc situations. Though I generally just mount an old lens that's been through a lot when I'm in less forgiving environments.
Jan 04, 2025 at 08:07 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
My picture speaks 1000 words...

https://flic.kr/p/2pbNrS8

This filter saved the front element of my lens.

p.s. The hood was attached at the time of the fall. Hood was damaged as well.
Jan 05, 2025 at 08:17 AM
ctgoldwing
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
I'll throw my $.02 in, for what it's worth.

I always had B+W filters on my lenses. For my new RF lenses (67mm, 77mm and 82mm) I did find 77mm UV and a polarizing filters in my basement 'pile of stuff'. I am putting UV filters on the other 2.

I use them only as physical protection for the front element. Years ago when I shot Nikon film I handed my 2nd camera to a friend to hold while I shot my son from the football stands. Of course she dropped it. It went thru metal framework of the stands and rattled its way to ground. The hood was smashed and the UV filter was cracked. The front element was fine.

I don't shoot for anyone else. A less than perfect shot due to the filter only disappoints me. I don't ever remember that happening tho.
Jan 05, 2025 at 08:45 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #16Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
It's really nice to pull off the filter and see a basically perfect front element. And you can clean your lenses using your shirt etc

I've had flare issues for one thing and I don't use them currently but a lot of that could be mitigated holding your hand up to shade the lens, I'd bet

The camera business is abysmal, if they make a bit off filters that's probably good
Jan 05, 2025 at 12:00 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.2 #17Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
molson wrote:
I like to protect my expensive UV filters by placing a couple of cheap UV filters in front of them. I wouldn't want to risk damaging a $100 filter.


I have actually used a cheap UV filetr as a "lens cap" on top of my expensive polarizers.

EBH
Jan 05, 2025 at 12:26 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Lens caps work pretty well as lens caps, too.
Jan 05, 2025 at 03:14 PM
goalerjones
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
Never use them. I have very good beginning and end of the day habits, using the air blower before and after use. I keep the blower with me also for any incidentals during my day. Once and awhile i will put a thumb print on my front element but I use Kim wipes and my own breath to fog and clean as needed.
Jan 05, 2025 at 04:50 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Timeless debate: protective UV filter or not?
There are endless scenarios where either a cap, filter, or hood may or may not be the best protection. Each scenario depends on the physics that were involved. None of them are effective at a bullet hitting the lens head on. Whether any of them prevent zero damage or any damage to the front element all depends on the size, weight, speed, and angle at which the object is struck. Not rocket science, just physics.

The best protection is the photographer that owns the lens. If you are a clumsy clot, use a filter, cap, and hood all at the same time.
Jan 05, 2025 at 06:08 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister