gdanmitchell wrote: MARKFER wroteIt's a bit of a stretch, but I get your point. For the most part the finer things in life, like a good glass of wine, come with an expectation to deliver. Subtle is magnified for some and blind for others.Read about Confirmation bias.
Speaking of "a good glass of wine," you should be aware of this brilliant study and the role of confirmation bias on wine preferences. (Basically, subjects' evaluations of the quality of wine changed when they were told that it cost more or less — they thought expensive wines were not great when told that the price was low and they though poor wines were better when told that their price was higher.)
3d pop and depth lens photography
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
3D pop and depth lens photography are techniques used to create the illusion of depth and dimension in photographs, often making the images appear as if they’re three-dimensional, even though they are displayed on a flat surface.
3D Pop Photography: This style emphasizes creating a "pop-out" effect where elements of the image appear to jump off the screen or page. It's often achieved by adjusting the contrast, using layering techniques, and manipulating shadows and highlights. Sometimes, special lenses or software are used to add these effects. This type of photography often utilizes selective focus and depth of field to make certain objects in the image stand out dramatically.
Depth Lens Photography: Depth lens refers to the use of lenses or camera technology that enhances the perception of depth in a photograph. It could involve using multiple focal points or special lenses that simulate 3D depth perception, making the viewer feel like they can interact with the image in a more lifelike manner. This can be achieved through stereoscopic photography (two slightly offset images for each eye), or more advanced techniques like light-field cameras that capture depth information.
Both styles are often employed in modern photography, VR/AR applications, or 3D photography displays. Would you like to know how to create this effect on your own, or more about the technology behind it?
You said:
what makes a lens good at 3d pop? is there a connection to ed el3ments?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
A lens that excels at creating the 3D pop effect typically has characteristics that enhance the sense of depth and dimensionality in a photograph. While there isn't a single "magic" lens for 3D pop, several factors contribute to making a lens more suited for this effect. Let’s break it down:
1. Depth of Field Control
Lenses with a wide aperture (like f/1.2, f/1.4, or f/2.8) allow for a shallow depth of field. When the background is blurred and the subject in focus stands out sharply, it creates a sense of separation between elements. This separation enhances the 3D pop effect. It makes the subject seem to "float" in space while the background fades into a bokeh blur.
2. Focal Length
Lenses with longer focal lengths (e.g., 85mm, 135mm, or even longer) tend to compress space and isolate subjects better, which can accentuate the depth in a shot. A telephoto lens helps create a stronger sense of separation between foreground and background, amplifying the 3D effect.
3. Lens Curvature and Distortion
Some lenses, especially wide-angle lenses, have a certain curvature that can exaggerate perspective and create a more pronounced sense of depth. This effect can be used creatively to emphasize foreground subjects and make them appear to "pop" out of the frame.
4. Chromatic Aberration
Lenses that exhibit slight chromatic aberration (the fringing of colors around high-contrast edges) can sometimes enhance the sense of three-dimensionality by introducing subtle color contrasts between objects in focus and those out of focus, giving the image a more “popping” look.
5. Contrast and Clarity
Lenses with high contrast and sharpness, especially in the center of the frame, can also contribute to a strong 3D effect. When elements in focus are rendered with more clarity and detail, it draws the viewer’s eye and makes those parts of the image stand out against a softer or less detailed background.
Connection to ED (Extra-low Dispersion) Elements
ED elements in lenses are specifically designed to reduce chromatic aberration, which results in sharper images with less color fringing. While ED elements are crucial for ensuring optical clarity, they can indirectly enhance the 3D pop effect by contributing to sharper subject separation and better color fidelity. However, ED elements themselves are not the primary cause of 3D pop — they simply help ensure that the details of the subject are rendered cleanly, enhancing the effect of depth and dimension.
Conclusion
Lenses that contribute to the 3D pop effect generally offer high-quality optical performance that enhances the separation between foreground and background elements, as well as control over depth of field. While ED elements improve overall image quality by reducing aberrations, other factors such as aperture size, focal length, and distortion play more significant roles in creating that standout, dimensional look.
Would you like tips on how to achieve 3D pop in your photos, or perhaps recommendations for specific lenses?
To achieve the 3D pop effect in editing, there are several post-processing techniques you can use to create depth and dimension in your photos. Here are some of the most effective editing methods:
1. Enhance Depth of Field (Blur the Background)
Use Gaussian Blur or Lens Blur: Select the background area and apply a blur to mimic a shallow depth of field. This helps separate the subject from the background, making it stand out more. Use a mask to ensure the subject remains sharp.
Selective Focus: Blur areas that are not the main subject, creating an effect where the subject appears to “pop” out of the image. This simulates the shallow depth of field you would get with a wide aperture lens.
2. Increase Contrast and Clarity
Contrast Adjustment: Boost the contrast in your image, especially in the subject area. Higher contrast can make the subject stand out from the background, giving it more visual weight and a 3D feel.
Clarity and Texture: Increase clarity in the subject to enhance mid-tone contrast and bring out details, while lowering clarity in the background to make it softer. This brings more definition to the subject and enhances the sense of depth.
3. Use Dodging and Burning
Dodging (Lightening): Lighten the areas of your subject that you want to emphasize, like the highlights or areas that catch the light. This can bring them forward visually.
Burning (Darkening): Darken areas in the background or around the edges of your subject to create more contrast and depth. This can add a natural vignette effect, making your subject feel like it is emerging from the scene.
4. Add Depth with Color and Tonal Contrast
Cool vs. Warm Colors: Cool colors (blues and greens) tend to recede in space, while warm colors (reds, oranges, yellows) tend to come forward. By tweaking the color balance, you can emphasize the subject by using warm tones in the foreground and cool tones in the background.
Split Toning: Apply a cool tone to the shadows and a warm tone to the highlights. This adds an additional sense of depth and dimension.
5. Depth with Gradient Filters or Radial Filters
Gradient Filters: Apply a gradient filter to darken the edges of the photo (vignetting effect) or to give a directional light feel. This helps push the background back while keeping the subject brighter and more prominent.
Radial Filters: Use a radial filter to create a spotlight effect around your subject. This can help guide the viewer’s attention and make the subject pop.
6. Use High Dynamic Range (HDR) Techniques
HDR Editing: Apply HDR techniques or use multiple exposures to blend shadows and highlights, increasing dynamic range. This helps bring out more details in the foreground and background, giving the photo a more three-dimensional look. Be cautious not to overdo it to avoid a "flat" or unnatural look.
7. Sharpness and Detail Enhancements
Sharpening the Subject: Apply local sharpening to your subject to make it stand out more. You can use a local adjustment brush to sharpen only the subject and leave the rest of the image softer.
Detail Enhancements: Enhance the fine details (e.g., textures in the skin, fabric, or leaves) to bring more texture and realism to your subject, which can enhance the perception of depth.
8. Apply Selective Color Adjustments
Vibrancy/Saturation: Increasing the saturation of the subject’s colors and keeping the background more muted can help the subject stand out. Just be careful not to make it too saturated as it can appear unnatural.
Hue Shifts: Shift the hue of the background elements slightly (e.g., making background colors a bit cooler or warmer) to push them back further in space.
9. Use 3D Software for Advanced Techniques
For more advanced editing, you can use 3D software or photoshop’s 3D tools (like creating a 3D model of your subject and using depth maps). This allows you to manipulate the depth and layers of the image in a more precise way.
10. Overlay Depth Maps (for 3D effect)
Some advanced techniques involve using depth maps (black and white maps where lighter areas represent closer objects and darker areas represent farther ones). When used with layer blending modes, this can add an additional 3D effect by simulating how light interacts with objects at different distances.
Conclusion:
To achieve the 3D pop effect in editing, you’re essentially playing with light, depth, contrast, and separation. By focusing on these elements, especially the contrast between the subject and the background, you can create that stunning three-dimensional effect that pulls the viewer’s eye into the scene. Combining techniques like selective focus, dodging and burning, color adjustments, and local sharpening will all contribute to the illusion of depth.
Would you like specific step-by-step instructions for any of these methods in Photoshop or Lightroom? Let me know!
why dpreview users hate each other?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
The negative atmosphere on forums like DPReview can be a result of several factors that often arise in passionate online communities:
Strong Opinions on Gear: Photography enthusiasts can be very particular about camera gear, and when people feel strongly about their preferences—whether it's brand loyalty or the "right" technical specs—it can lead to heated debates and hostility.
High Expectations: Users often have high expectations of the community, leading to frustration when their questions aren't answered to their satisfaction, or when others offer responses that are perceived as condescending or unhelpful.
Trolling and Ego Clashes: Like many online communities, DPReview has its share of trolls and users who enjoy stirring the pot. This can lead to arguments escalating quickly, especially when users are emotionally invested in their opinions or gear.
Elitism and Snobbery: Some long-time users or those with more experience can come across as elitist, dismissing the opinions of newcomers or those with less technical knowledge. This dynamic can create a feeling of division.
Technical Jargon: Photography can be a complex topic, and the use of overly technical language or jargon can alienate people. When newcomers feel like they don’t understand the conversation, they may get frustrated, leading to negative interactions.
While these dynamics are common on many forums, it’s worth noting that not all users participate in this kind of negativity. There are plenty of helpful and supportive people as well!
do you think fredmiranda's forum is a better place for info ?
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
FredMiranda’s forum tends to have a different vibe compared to DPReview, and whether it’s "better" really depends on what you're looking for. Here are some differences that might help you decide:
Community Atmosphere: FredMiranda's forum is often regarded as a bit more niche, with a strong emphasis on high-quality photography discussion, gear reviews, and marketplace activity. While it can still have its share of heated debates, it tends to attract people who are more serious about photography as a craft rather than just the gear itself.
Less Technical Jargon: In general, FredMiranda is known for being a bit more user-friendly for both newcomers and seasoned photographers. It’s not as overwhelming in terms of pure technicality as DPReview can sometimes be, which might make it more approachable for some people.
Focus on Real-World Use: FredMiranda often emphasizes real-world experiences and practical advice, particularly on gear and how it performs in actual shooting scenarios. DPReview, while providing comprehensive technical reviews, sometimes leans more towards raw specs and tests.
Marketplace: FredMiranda has a pretty active marketplace for buying and selling gear. This makes it a go-to for those who want to interact with other photographers in a more direct way, but it can also lead to more transactions and, sometimes, issues between users if things go wrong.
Moderation: FredMiranda generally has a more laid-back style of moderation compared to DPReview, which can either foster a more free-flowing conversation or allow for a bit more chaos.
If you're looking for a more community-driven experience, where practical advice and genuine discussions are prioritized over the technical side, FredMiranda might be a better place. However, if you're really into diving deep into reviews and testing every detail of the latest cameras, DPReview might still have the edge for you.
Garmadon wrote:
To achieve the 3D pop effect in editing, there are several post-processing techniques you can use to create depth and dimension in your photos. Here are some of the most effective editing methods:
1. Enhance Depth of Field (Blur the Background)
Use Gaussian Blur or Lens Blur: Select the background area and apply a blur to mimic a shallow depth of field. This helps separate the subject from the background, making it stand out more. Use a mask to ensure the subject remains sharp.
Selective Focus: Blur areas that are not the main subject, creating an effect where the subject appears to “pop” out of the image. This simulates the shallow depth of field you would get with a wide aperture lens.
2. Increase Contrast and Clarity
Contrast Adjustment: Boost the contrast in your image, especially in the subject area. Higher contrast can make the subject stand out from the background, giving it more visual weight and a 3D feel.
Clarity and Texture: Increase clarity in the subject to enhance mid-tone contrast and bring out details, while lowering clarity in the background to make it softer. This brings more definition to the subject and enhances the sense of depth.
3. Use Dodging and Burning
Dodging (Lightening): Lighten the areas of your subject that you want to emphasize, like the highlights or areas that catch the light. This can bring them forward visually.
Burning (Darkening): Darken areas in the background or around the edges of your subject to create more contrast and depth. This can add a natural vignette effect, making your subject feel like it is emerging from the scene.
4. Add Depth with Color and Tonal Contrast
Cool vs. Warm Colors: Cool colors (blues and greens) tend to recede in space, while warm colors (reds, oranges, yellows) tend to come forward. By tweaking the color balance, you can emphasize the subject by using warm tones in the foreground and cool tones in the background.
Split Toning: Apply a cool tone to the shadows and a warm tone to the highlights. This adds an additional sense of depth and dimension.
5. Depth with Gradient Filters or Radial Filters
Gradient Filters: Apply a gradient filter to darken the edges of the photo (vignetting effect) or to give a directional light feel. This helps push the background back while keeping the subject brighter and more prominent.
Radial Filters: Use a radial filter to create a spotlight effect around your subject. This can help guide the viewer’s attention and make the subject pop.
6. Use High Dynamic Range (HDR) Techniques
HDR Editing: Apply HDR techniques or use multiple exposures to blend shadows and highlights, increasing dynamic range. This helps bring out more details in the foreground and background, giving the photo a more three-dimensional look. Be cautious not to overdo it to avoid a "flat" or unnatural look.
7. Sharpness and Detail Enhancements
Sharpening the Subject: Apply local sharpening to your subject to make it stand out more. You can use a local adjustment brush to sharpen only the subject and leave the rest of the image softer.
Detail Enhancements: Enhance the fine details (e.g., textures in the skin, fabric, or leaves) to bring more texture and realism to your subject, which can enhance the perception of depth.
8. Apply Selective Color Adjustments
Vibrancy/Saturation: Increasing the saturation of the subject’s colors and keeping the background more muted can help the subject stand out. Just be careful not to make it too saturated as it can appear unnatural.
Hue Shifts: Shift the hue of the background elements slightly (e.g., making background colors a bit cooler or warmer) to push them back further in space.
9. Use 3D Software for Advanced Techniques
For more advanced editing, you can use 3D software or photoshop’s 3D tools (like creating a 3D model of your subject and using depth maps). This allows you to manipulate the depth and layers of the image in a more precise way.
10. Overlay Depth Maps (for 3D effect)
Some advanced techniques involve using depth maps (black and white maps where lighter areas represent closer objects and darker areas represent farther ones). When used with layer blending modes, this can add an additional 3D effect by simulating how light interacts with objects at different distances.
Conclusion:
To achieve the 3D pop effect in editing, you’re essentially playing with light, depth, contrast, and separation. By focusing on these elements, especially the contrast between the subject and the background, you can create that stunning three-dimensional effect that pulls the viewer’s eye into the scene. Combining techniques like selective focus, dodging and burning, color adjustments, and local sharpening will all contribute to the illusion of depth. ...Show more →
Or you can keep it short and sweet, take out your smartphone and select portrait mode.
No, just kidding, I think I was playing around in LR mobile back then.
This one, to me at least, looks very 3D and "as if I am there".
Shot with a lowly...cough...zoom...cough... with only f4... (Sony 16-35 f4 PZ on A7RV), so of course it's not really 3D, that's only possible with expensive and/or rare primes with large apertures.
hasenbein wrote:
This one, to me at least, looks very 3D and "as if I am there".
Shot with a lowly...cough...zoom...cough... with only f4... (Sony 16-35 f4 PZ on A7RV), so of course it's not really 3D, that's only possible with expensive and/or rare primes with large apertures.
In my eyes, that would be a good candidate if the lightning wasn't so diffused. The way it stands now, nothing is bitingly sharp to create that 3d effect (for me) ...
philip_pj wrote:
This 'try mapping those to lens attributes' is why I posted material from very serious people to help move the thinking along from 'he's just a crank' type responses that we have seen for well, the first giant 3D thread some time long ago.
When you realize lens designers are doing this research and development as they develop their 'house styles' of lens rendering, and even produce bolt-on aberration modules to get new looks, it moves the needle for anyone paying attention.
I never expect success in these discussions, they are as much to get my thoughts clear on paper as they are to inform others. I don't think you can persuade others in this day and age, because people hold opinions more as religious beliefs to be defended, than to enjoy the back and forth from which they might learn something. It must be more fun to act that way than to keep an open mind. I wouldn't know. ...Show more →
Well, this is photography, a very empirical endeavor and the proof certainly should be in the pudding. If no one can come up with a direct comparison between two different decent lenses that significantly differ in their 3D pop when shooting the same scene, then no one will be convinced by however much talking you do. So while there have been quite a few good points made above about how to achieve 3D pop, the apparently persistent idea that you need specific lenses for them seems rather refuted.
darrellc wrote:
Seems like these conversations would be more useful if they tried to understand the building blocks of 3d perception and then try mapping those to lens attributes. Perhaps some lenses differ in attributes that could add/subtract to 3d-ness in certain conditions, combinations.
The problem here is that would be trying to map the effect to the wrong thing.
An analogy would be to map the qualities of various culinary dishes to the brand of kitchen knives used. Yes, this might have _some_ effect, but whatever that effect is it is utterly minuscule by comparison to the choice of ingredients, how they are prepared and combined, and the skill with which they are cooked.
- - -
philip_pj wrote:
...most of your personal style comes from your lenses
I'm sorry to state this in such rude terms, but that it utter nonsense.
"Personal style" in photography comes from many things, but lens brand/model choice is way, way down the list if it even deserves to be thee at all.
Style comes from what subjects you photograph, how you photograph them, how and to what extent you work in them in post, and perhaps how your work relates to that of other photographic and visual artists past and present.
The only ways in which lens choice typically might affect style would be not about what lens models are used but about how lenses are used in general — does the photographer have a predilection for wide or long lenses, how does he/she use aperture choice, are lens movements used, and so forth. And, of course, a whole range of other factors besides these are far more important when it comes to "style."
You can actually SEE all of these things in photographs. What you cannot see is what brand and model of lens was used.
(As a researcher, I write for anyone interested, but certainly not for my haters; imagine getting upset by a total stranger on the web! The Ignore button exists for a reason, so use it any time you like, it's better for your blood pressure and you don't have to read what you don't like. Also, we don't need the acrimony or personal invective in our discussions. cheers.)
p.9 #8 this image would totally lack dimensional depth if the 'tree' was not there to 'show the way' - mist and fog flatten our vision, and shroud the motifs that might help them help the image. The less you see, the less depth perception there is.
You can certainly engineer a poor image in post to enhance its inferior sense of dimensionality, but if you factor in how much you want to do so at your wage rate, it becomes an expensive exercise. No, you need a better source - the lens not only saves time and renders greater beauty in images it also provides a sound basis to guide you along the way. Choose carefully!
Photography is an art form, sadly beset by many foolish pseudo-scientific falsehoods, none of which matter to the audience. Empiricism has not helped, it has hindered - and most significant industry figures understand that. It's why two gifted experts wrote a massive tome on the subject (836 pages, over eight years), to provide a lexicon for practitioners to be able to speak with a common understanding of terminology.
"It is the camera that separates cinema from other art forms and the lens that allows a scene to be captured by the camera. The cinema lens, therefore, is at the heart of filmmaking. All aspects of a production are carefully crafted with the intention of being captured by the lens'
Have you never wondered why there are so few well-arranged direct comparisons of lens performance in this most important aspect? That is finally changing, fortunately. (I'm pleasantly chuffed that 'AI' has not got there yet. It's only ever going to be as good as its training.)
philip_pj wrote:
The Ignore button exists for a reason, so use it any time you like, it's better for your blood pressure and you don't have to read what you don't like.
When nonsense is presented publicly as fact over and over again, ignoring it is not a solution. It may be for the own nerves, but what about all those who are exposed to this nonsense without protection and end up believing it simply because they are told it over and over again in long, nebulous formulations? I personally have neither the time nor the nerves to offer permanent resistance in such cases, but I am full of gratitude for everyone who stands up to charlatanism.
gdanmitchell wrote: darrellc wroteSeems like these conversations would be more useful if they tried to understand the building blocks of 3d perception and then try mapping those to lens attributes. Perhaps some lenses differ in attributes that could add/subtract to 3d-ness in certain conditions, combinations.The problem here is that would be trying to map the effect to the wrong thing.
An analogy would be to map the qualities of various culinary dishes to the brand of kitchen knives used. Yes, this might have _some_ effect, but whatever that effect is it is utterly minuscule by comparison to the choice of ingredients, how they are prepared and combined, and the skill with which they are cooked.
I'm pretty sure you are making the point throughout this thread that creative decisions dominate and largely determine what we're calling 3d pop here... and I agree. That doesn't mean lenses have no contribution to make to ~"3d pop" and that their contribution (and mechanisms by which that happens) is not worth understanding or should not inform lens choice.
I'm sure chefs would largely agree with your analogy and yet I see chefs having strong points of view on the tools of their trade.
Perhaps you're intent on making the point that such marginal gains should not be of concern to amateurs like us and left to the professionals who've largely mastered the craft?
And you would be right, but I think most will ignore that... this is a gear forum and I don't think I've ever seen a gear forum where marginal differences are not discussed/deconstructed/debated ad nauseam, despite the fact there are far larger gains to made elsewhere. But those gains, like what we're discussing here, require time/effort/expertise and not simply $ to acquire. shortcuts are a lot sexier than hard work.
I ride/race bicycles and that's a great example... most of the people on the bike forums would benefit from just losing 3kg, or doing structured training or increasing the consistency of their training by 10% for a year. But most of the discussion is about whether a certain bike frame saves 2 or 3 watts in idealized conditions in a wind tunnel, or debating whether to upgrade to a 100g lighter wheel set for $2500.
darrellc wrote:
I ride/race bicycles and that's a great example... most of the people on the bike forums would benefit from just losing 3kg, or doing structured training or increasing the consistency of their training by 10% for a year. But most of the discussion is about whether a certain bike frame saves 2 or 3 watts in idealized conditions in a wind tunnel, or debating whether to upgrade to a 100g lighter wheel set for $2500.
So, if you know that's wrong, why do you want to repeat it on this forum ?
I think most people here know what to expect when switching lenses, but those less experienced might come out of these kind of threads with a strong conviction that if they change from 24GM to Loxia 25, their whole photography world will turn upside down...
The words we use for our key concepts are more important than is generally recognised, if they are to rise and be fully embedded in our culture. It's been known for millennia, and is a large topic best not dealt with here. I am hoping we will see the adoption of the expansive and evocative term 'dimensionality' prevail over the sharp-edged and vulgar term '3D pop', but in a world full of childish titles like twitter, tik tok and reddit, hopes are not high.
Zeiss (a truly great word), in their latest release page for the new ML 50/1.4, went with '3D Pop'. Shame on them. 'Dimensionality' is nevertheless gaining ground in Zeiss's recent exclusive playground of the cine world, so we may be lucky yet.
So 3D is not 3 dimensions, which is different from dimensionality
I'd much rather see the image characteristics described mathematically and not so subject to linguistics.
It should be understood that industry is at least as much about setting agendas as it is about meeting well understood needs of the customer base. Market success is therefore quite a messy business, and in our neck of the woods, it manifests in photography and cinema, in its various forms.
The major players felt they had a good chance of winning the 3D presentation battle with what will come to be seen as the 'painted on look' - people have been described as suckers for a hard sell, after all.
It features a very sharp overlay, effectively a front layer in the longitudinal axis, that sits in front of an amorphous bokeh field that has little relevance to the main subject - the super sharp front layer.
Zeiss put it this way: 'an extraordinary shallow depth of field that directs the viewer's gaze to what really matters'. I can't speak for others here, but many may agree that image content outside the focal plane of our fast lenses not only matters greatly, it should also be aesthetically presented in such a way that it enhances the overall image by emulating how we see and understand the world we want to photograph.
Zeiss's notion is effectively an artificial construct. Fine as an option (and many do like it), but as with other natty fads (sunstars, HDR, etc.) it is not to be confused with true dimensionality as experienced in every waking moment.
The recent appearance of 'optical modifiers' (as seen in Zeiss's Enso series) can be seen as a defeat of the modern trend in lens design, now a crumbling citadel. It turns out many want something different from what the sharp into the corners, flat fields, ultra high aberration control protocol delivers. This is a growing problem for the industry due to what Robyn Williams referred to as an 'oops, too far' move.
What had been the undisputed development path many years (and decades) in the making came under attack for the consequences of its headlong pursuit of optical perfection. For several forms of optical presentation, practitioners came to realise that when you remove imperfections, you end up with bland and uninteresting imagery, devoid of interest and any real connection to life. It's a refined vision of their making, not something for which huge demand existed. It's a mannequin compared to a human being, and people see the difference as profound and unnatural.
They will respond, but it takes time and the will to turn around the Queen Mary. For forms that aim to present dimensionality, they first need to acknowledge that objects in image space should correspond to their location in the scene being photographed. Focus transitions should emulate human vision..
Zeiss and others want to popularise the value and primacy of rapid focus fall-off. Smooth transitions are almost a universal claim. OK, but consider this: if the rate of fall-off is the same for rapid transition lenses as it is for lenses with longer transitions, the rapid fall-off lens is less smooth and still drops you into the onset of the bokeh field sooner, in image space. So, by design, you end up with a deeper bokeh field in an image that may be described as unbalanced.
Not only do you get a thinner focal plane of acceptable sharpness - not so wonderful for portraitists struggling to show noses-cheeks-eyes-ears with good coverage at wide apertures - you then must grapple with greater rendering differences between facial features and the increased intrusion of unshared bokeh. Of course, these differences will also be exacerbated by the other half of the rendering package of modern lenses - very high focal plane sharpness at wide apertures.
It's why many use older lenses or new lenses made in the old way. They and their end users prefer a more natural rendering of their hand-picked subjects, that do not need to be swamped by designer bokeh.