“Dimensionality” in an image has almost nothing to do wiht the optical qualities of lenses — e.g. from buying this particular brand of lens or that one.
Photographers (and those working with motion images) understand that the characteristic of depth or dimensionality or whatever you want to call it come from decisions about how you produce, compose, expose, and post process images.
No lens will give it to you, and you can produce images that have this amorphous quality with expensive or extremely inexpensive equipment.
It is about things like composition, color relationships, how subjects are highlighted, the use of background blur, vignetting, choices of vocal length, how color is used, contrast and luminosity curves, and much more.
You can buy all the lenses in the world and not achieve it. Or you can study the visual techniques that produce it and start to understand.
philip_pj wrote:
It's easy enough to live on in a flat photographic world, to the point where potential alternatives don't even exist in the mind. Not everyone feels this way, particularly where it matters, where money enters the framework.
Gathering pace over a decade now, there are serious efforts aimed at understanding the formulas responsible for 'dimensionality' - no less a useful word than 'functionality' and note that words are descriptive thinking tools - across the moving picture industry.
In essence, dimensionality is the 'cinematic look', that immersion into the image that is just not there with so many new flat rendition lenses, hence the initiation of this thread. It asks why not? in design terms, others are asking why does it happen and how can we get more of it?
So the inquiry has moved much further on from looking at single images and yes/no argumentation on photo forums. Here in condensed form is how DZO (who are fans of older Leica M lenses) is marketing its new Simera-C range:
Far from the usual fluff, we see some precise terms and concepts here that feed back into specific lens design requirements:
'smooth bokeh and natural edge fall-off';
'natural edge fall-off';
'human-eye-like field curvature';
'flare is subtly managed';
'closer minimum focusing distance, allowing the capture of greater texture and detail';
'ultra-shallow depth of field adds dramatic depth and spatial separation';
'creamy bokeh and moderate high-contrast';
'striking contrast that accentuates the subject';
'adding dimensionality and spatial depth';
'in the context of high-resolution digital cameras with broader dynamic range';
'inheriting the (Leica) unique mood and texture'; 'created by optic imperfections mixing with softness'.
That's their formula, the one they also used for our stills versions of these same lenses. It's the way they approach the very real challenge of designing emotional immersion into their lenses. Like it or not, flat render lenses are being forced to share the table because they are too 'good' and fail to evoke emotional responses in audiences (and viewers of still images).
All kinds of filters and add-on optical units are now in wide use with the aim of taking digital perfection out of the picture, even using five figure lenses from Arri, Zeiss, Leica etc. It's almost embarrassing for them, but they are realists and will do what is necessary. ...Show more →
gdanmitchell wrote:
“Dimensionality” in an image has almost nothing to do wiht the optical qualities of lenses — e.g. from buying this particular brand of lens or that one.
Photographers (and those working with motion images) understand that the characteristic of depth or dimensionality or whatever you want to call it come from decisions about how you produce, compose, expose, and post process images.
No lens will give it to you, and you can produce images that have this amorphous quality with expensive or extremely inexpensive equipment.
It is about things like composition, color relationships, how subjects are highlighted, the use of background blur, vignetting, choices of vocal length, how color is used, contrast and luminosity curves, and much more.
You can buy all the lenses in the world and not achieve it. Or you can study the visual techniques that produce it and start to understand. ...Show more →
Well, on the one hand that is all true, but on the other hand it underestimates an important aspect, namely that the degree + progression of the sharpness-blurrency areas is definitely influenced by the lens and the effect of the image shown above comes largely from exactly that and would simply not have been possible with, for example, the 2.5/50 G.
Nifty Fifty wrote: gdanmitchell wrote“Dimensionality” in an image has almost nothing to do wiht the optical qualities of lenses — e.g. from buying this particular brand of lens or that one.
Photographers (and those working with motion images) understand that the characteristic of depth or dimensionality or whatever you want to call it come from decisions about how you produce, compose, expose, and post process images.
No lens will give it to you, and you can produce images that have this amorphous quality with expensive or extremely inexpensive equipment.
It is about things like composition, color relationships, how subjects are highlighted, the use of background blur, vignetting, choices of vocal length, how color is used, contrast and luminosity curves, and much more.
You can buy all the lenses in the world and not achieve it. Or you can study the visual techniques that produce it and start to understand.Well, on the one hand that is all true, but on the other hand it underestimates an important aspect, namely that the degree + progression of the sharpness-blurrency areas is definitely influenced by the lens and the effect of the image shown above comes largely from exactly that and would simply not have been possible with, for example, the 2.5/50 G.
Aperture choice and focal length choice are among the factors that a a photographer can employ in order to produce the effect you are after.
But I guarantee you that the decision to use some particular 50mm lens at f/2.5 rather that some other good 50mm lens at the same aperture has essentially nothing to do with the production of this effect.
Good lenses are fine. I use them, and there are many available to choose from. But this subject thing that people are calling “pop,” “dimensionality,” or whatever is barely affected by them if at all. It is truly about other entirely different things.
You can produce a banal, flat image with the most expensive lens and you can produce an image that has this desired effect using a smartphone.
gdanmitchell wrote:
you can produce an image that has this desired effect using a smartphone.
Now it gets silly.
Or maybe you think of something completely different than I do when you think of "this effect".
Nifty Fifty wrote: gdanmitchell wroteyou can produce an image that has this desired effect using a smartphone.Now it gets silly.
Or maybe you think of something completely different than I do when you think of "this effect".
Indeed, a smartphone or a point and shoot or just about any camera can create an image with this thing that people try to describe using terms like, well, you know. I'm not being silly at all.
What is silly is imagining that it comes from selecting some magical lens.
I understand the hope that buying a piece of gear will magically lead to wonderful photographs. Good gear appropriate to the photography one does is important, but not in the way being suggested in this thread.
'natural edge fall-off';
'human-eye-like field curvature'
'The explanation is: nonsense from manufacturers and/or artists.'
Living is easy with eyes closed, misunderstanding all you see.
You can do a simple search on human eye curvature, if interested, but few are. Here is a little piece of established 'nonsense' by a Ph.D. for you to scoff at:
'An important aspect is the regional differences in our visual perception: the central visual field is color-sensitive, has high acuity vision, operates at high levels of illumination whereas the periphery is more sensitive at low levels of illumination, is relatively color insensitive, and has poor visual acuity.'
'Natural edge fall-off' refers to how we see the edges of the visual field (frame) in real life. No one in that field talks about perfect corners! How well do you see at the limits of your visual field? You should be asking why does it matter so much in photos. Works of art are meant to be enjoyed in their entirety, not deconstructed.
It's a bit of a stretch, but I get your point. For the most part the finer things in life, like a good glass of wine, come with an expectation to deliver. Subtle is magnified for some and blind for others.
MARKFER wrote:
It's a bit of a stretch, but I get your point. For the most part the finer things in life, like a good glass of wine, come with an expectation to deliver. Subtle is magnified for some and blind for others.
Speaking of "a good glass of wine," you should be aware of this brilliant study and the role of confirmation bias on wine preferences. (Basically, subjects' evaluations of the quality of wine changed when they were told that it cost more or less — they thought expensive wines were not great when told that the price was low and they though poor wines were better when told that their price was higher.)
These threads come up all the time and the discussion tends to follow the trajectory of this one.
No neuroscientist, but I'm pretty sure 3d perception is highly complex, individual, and a composite of both external factors (the photo, the environment, other stimuli) and internal factors (the perceiving agent's brain). So super hard to understand and thus describe / measure. Which doesn't negate its existence, and means two agents could have vastly different perceptions.
Seems like these conversations would be more useful if they tried to understand the building blocks of 3d perception and then try mapping those to lens attributes. Perhaps some lenses differ in attributes that could add/subtract to 3d-ness in certain conditions, combinations. Can't imagine it is as simple as "lenses with significant field curvature always create more 3d like images". As many have mentioned before, I wish we had some painters here. They could probably provide insight since they build depth and volume from scratch in 2D space.
darrellC. Totally agree. People post what seem like totally ordinary pics and say how incredibly great they are with their "3-D pop". If it was just down to lens design then lenses that have this feature could be marketed as such and we would all be able to agree that they do indeed show this. So far, this has not happened to my knowledge.
This 'try mapping those to lens attributes' is why I posted material from very serious people to help move the thinking along from 'he's just a crank' type responses that we have seen for well, the first giant 3D thread some time long ago.
When you realize lens designers are doing this research and development as they develop their 'house styles' of lens rendering, and even produce bolt-on aberration modules to get new looks, it moves the needle for anyone paying attention.
I never expect success in these discussions, they are as much to get my thoughts clear on paper as they are to inform others. I don't think you can persuade others in this day and age, because people hold opinions more as religious beliefs to be defended, than to enjoy the back and forth from which they might learn something. It must be more fun to act that way than to keep an open mind. I wouldn't know.
philip_pj wrote:
I don't think you can persuade others in this day and age, because people hold opinions more as religious beliefs to be defended, than to enjoy the back and forth from which they might learn something.
THIS! Well stated.
So many people think an argument is happening instead of what’s really happening - a discussion.
'I don't think anybody is saying 'it's just down to lens design''
Pretty much, I am. Why? Because you can imagine two or more lenses taking the same image with all other contributing factors held exactly the same: camera, framing, processing, color, scene brightness range, etc. You will still see a big difference in many complex and challenging scenes.
The lens shapes the image, the sensor capture the resulting shape. The lens dominates the image appearance. Not only that, most of your personal style comes from your lenses. The camera is the last thing in the imaging chain (before the silicon gets involved).
You want a list of these sources saying much the same things about lenses? It's long, they all use same terminology too: immersive, naturalness, soft flares, smooth fall-off, subjects merging into the background, organic, mellow, welcoming, filmic, a blend of modern and vintage character - 'modern vintage'. And the best part? These are long term professionals working with the most respected firms. Everyone is learning. Digital is a stiff challenge, and they all want to take the edge off it. Inside the lens, if possible.
It's an energetic field in the cine world. Go and see the 2025 Superman by James Gunn when it comes out - he used a Leica WATE. That team wanted a more engaging rendering style to move away from the harsh, high contrast, video game look of the 2024 film of that franchise.
Cine and stills imagery are converging, super tech is bringing cameras like the amazing Sony FX3 into many peoples' hands, so the video/cine business is moving downscale for YT music videos, ads, Tik Tok, etc. Even used as B cams for tight space shots in big budget movies. Meanwhile, stills lenses, especially small modern vintage lenses, are big business as they work so well with the new light cameras.
But not all stills lenses. They don't want the super corrected ones with the flat look, like the Sony GMs or Leica SLs, because they already have that clean style in the near perfect, high end cine lenses from Zeiss/ARRI, Canon and Leica etc. via rental firms.
They want things like Summiluxes, you might have noticed the large number of replicas and copies. Technically imperfect lenses, with that certain something that comes from field curvature, astigmatism, spherical aberration (the vintage), but put together very well and complemented with low chromatic aberration and low distortion (the modern). It's actually much harder to pull off, because it requires judgment. They are working from the image backwards, and lens design is the coalface.