Nifty Fifty wrote: gdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.
I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
- - -
chez wrote:
Of course if one is looking to disprove something…their eyes see what they want to disprove.
Equally true: If one wishes to believe something… their eyes see what they want to believe.
That’s called “confirmation bias.”
- - -
Garmadon wrote:
It is 50mm , not a wide angle.
And so it is. I stand corrected on that point. (I think the vehicle is longer than I thought it was, and the strong converging perspective lines convinced me it was wider. In any case, the strength of those lines is significant in creating the sense of depth, along with other features I noted. In fact a key general observation about this photograph (which is quite eye-catching) is that it uses a range of features to produce a sense of depth — vignetting, strong use of perspective lines, compositional choices, color differences between subject and non-subject, post-processing to increase contrast in the main subject, less saturated and out-of-focus background and so forth.
Same photographer ,different lens , also shiny and saturated with reflections - but less dimensional .
Correction: I wasn’t originally looking at the right photo.
Camera position and the position of the vehicle produce some of the same strong perspective lines on the van. (The slight tile of the image — down on the right side — lessens the impact of that somewhat.) The vehicle isn’t nearly as shiny and reflective as the original one, and all of those reflections change the appears quite a bit. Here, too, the background is obviously out of focus, likely from the aperture choice, but could also be done in post. Because the background is so dark and its colors more intense and similar to those of the vehicle, color isn’t playing as big of a role here in separating foreground from background. Vignetting is still at work in focusing attention away from edges, but it isn’t working quite as well here because of the already-dark sky at upper left and center, which makes the upper right corner still seem quite bright.
- - -
foto16 wrote:
The need for awe and for a mythical power beyond us satisfies the deepest psychological yearning in humans, from the cave dwellers who used charcoal to draw things on the wall of the cave to modern day photo hobbyists who wield precision optics.
Well, OK, but not sure how that times to the specific topic…
- - -
For anyone who wants to prove that the lens itself is primarily responsible for whatever effect it is that they hope to see, the right way to test is more or less as follows.
Put the camera on a tripod. Focus on a specific point in the subject field. Select an aperture and then an appropriate shutter speed. Make sure that the light is steady – e.g. no clouds thickening/thinning, etc. (There are some other obvious steps I’ve left out.) Make an exposure. Now put the second subject lens on the same camera. Focus carefully again. Use the same aperture. (If light transmission issues necessitate a slightly different exposure, adjust via shutter speed.) Make the second exposure.
Repeat this process with multiple subjects that differ in significant ways.
Do not post-process the images at all.
If possible, print the images. Make sure that there is no information at all about the image’s source on the prints, and none mentioned to the observers. Don’t even say that you are comparing two different lenses, much less tell them that one is better/worse or more/less expensive, etc. You could say that there is something different about them, but do not reveal what.
Hand them the stack of print pairs. Be sure to mix up the pairs — e.g. don’t put the first photo first in each pair. Randomly mix them so that sometimes the first photo is first and sometimes second.
Ask them to describe anything significant that they observe about the print pairs. After they do that, only then ask them if they can (or cannot) identify one in each pair as better than the other.
Do this with multiple observers. After you finish, note what trends you do (or do not) see in their evaluations.
If there is a consistent and perceptible difference you should see a clear pattern emerge. Or not.
Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a 65-inch OLED screen, I feel like the bus is about to jump out of the screen and into my living room. I believe it has to do with the transition of sharpness with the 50/1.4 ZA. I’ve had this lens for many years, and I keep noticing that the sharpness gradually and smoothly falls off. Often, when I view the images, I can’t tell at all where sharpness transitions into blur
To me the "pop" comes from the bright bus and very bright reflection on the bus, the relatively blurry and dark background, the angle of the bus, and the lines in the picture. If you have shot it with another 50/1.4, I would expect the same "pop" (not saying there would not have been some subtle differences).
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness. While I was taking the pictures, I noticed during the image review in the viewfinder that the subject looks very three-dimensional. The effect is therefore not related to post-processing. It’s so strong that it’s almost uncomfortable for me to view the images on a large screen. I think "the emperor's new clothes" looks different.
Here the "pop," if there is any, comes from the DOF, bright foreground and dark background, and the lead lines created by the dog, person, and the road. I would expect the same "pop" if you shot them with another lens with the same shooting parameters.
I guess the more reasonable explanation for why I see so much dimensionality and pop in Sony/Zeiss 50mm 1.4 Planar shots is that the people who chose (completely and utterly randomly) this lens have better mastered composition, lighting, and post processing.
(Shout out to Schwarzlicht, a number of the images I'm drawn to are yours)
I wonder how the maturation of the abilities of these photographers coincided with choosing to shoot this lens, it's pretty wild when you think about it. You know, since there is no way a lens can contribute to what we see in an image. At least we know now...that sometimes lighting contributes...and there may be other things that might as well, except the lens of course, which can in no way have any type of influence in the differing qualities we see in an image.
I realize, now of course, that there is no way even in the slightest, a lens might be able to make a contribution to a resulting image. I apologize that I keep repeating it, but I do so that in my weak minded ways, I don't forget it.
I guess that settles it, we can close this thread right?
Good to know. Some posts made me think the 3D pop effect is a supernatural character of certain lenses independent of the lighting and composition of the image itself. In reality, even how you view the image makes a difference in how one perceives the "pop:" the same way seeing a movie in the theater has a different visual impact than seeing it on my laptop.
gdanmitchell wrote: Nifty Fifty wrotegdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
.
I have not noticed it before but I think you're right - there's some masking going on. Take a look at the front wheel as well, the wheel itself is sharp while the pavement looks like a bit of gaussian blur was applied to it...
I don't think such processed pictures contribute much to the discussion about lens 3d pop capability.
j4nu wrote: gdanmitchell wroteNifty Fifty wrotegdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
.I have not noticed it before but I think you're right - there's some masking going on. Take a look at the front wheel as well, the wheel itself is sharp while the pavement looks like a bit of gaussian blur was applied to it...
I don't think such processed pictures contribute much to the discussion about lens 3d pop capability.
Of course, I'm very sorry that I couldn't meet your expectations and that I have little to contribute. Here's a small tip: open the image on Flickr using the link located under the photo and check it out in full resolution. No "Gaussian blur" was applied. (Whatever that may be.) It would also be helpful to see some of your images that contribute to the discussion about the 3D pop capability of lenses. That would give me the confidence that we're talking about the same topic—unless your lenses aren't capable of 3D pop.
Schwarzlicht wrote: j4nu wrotegdanmitchell wroteNifty Fifty wrotegdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
.I have not noticed it before but I think you're right - there's some masking going on. Take a look at the front wheel as well, the wheel itself is sharp while the pavement looks like a bit of gaussian blur was applied to it...
I don't think such processed pictures contribute much to the discussion about lens 3d pop capability.Of course, I'm very sorry that I couldn't meet your expectations and that I have little to contribute. Here's a small tip: open the image on Flickr using the link located under the photo and check it out in full resolution. No "Gaussian blur" was applied. (Whatever that may be.) It would also be helpful to see some of your images that contribute to the discussion about the 3D pop capability of lenses. That would give me the confidence that we're talking about the same topic—unless your lenses aren't capable of 3D pop.
I'm sorry then - it's the only way I could explain the difference in sharpness between the front wheel and its closest area and the ground around it as exif also pointed to masking. I guess this will become another 3d pop mystery to me...
I posted one photo some time ago in a thread similar to this one, but I can't find it now - I'll try again tomorrow .
j4nu wrote: Schwarzlicht wrotej4nu wrotegdanmitchell wroteNifty Fifty wrotegdanmitchell wrote9. Curiously, while the rear of the vehicle is very sharp, the underlying plaza/road surfaces at the same distance are not as sharp. There could be several reasons for this, not all of which I’ll mention. One possibility is that non-vehicle areas were softened/de-focused in post. (Look at the paving beneath and just beyond the rear wheel to see this.)In my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
.I have not noticed it before but I think you're right - there's some masking going on. Take a look at the front wheel as well, the wheel itself is sharp while the pavement looks like a bit of gaussian blur was applied to it...
I don't think such processed pictures contribute much to the discussion about lens 3d pop capability.Of course, I'm very sorry that I couldn't meet your expectations and that I have little to contribute. Here's a small tip: open the image on Flickr using the link located under the photo and check it out in full resolution. No "Gaussian blur" was applied. (Whatever that may be.) It would also be helpful to see some of your images that contribute to the discussion about the 3D pop capability of lenses. That would give me the confidence that we're talking about the same topic—unless your lenses aren't capable of 3D pop.I'm sorry then - it's the only way I could explain the difference in sharpness between the front wheel and its closest area and the ground around it as exif also pointed to masking. I guess this will become another 3d pop mystery to me...
I posted one photo some time ago in a thread similar to this one, but I can't find it now - I'll try again tomorrow .
"Hmm, when I open the image on Flickr and zoom in, the front tire and the ground beneath it are somewhat sharp. The rear tire and the ground underneath it are out of focus. Of course, the RAW file has been edited. As you can see, there are no shadows cast anywhere, no light, no shadow, because it's cloudy. Therefore, the contrast has been slightly increased. There was also no selective sharpening done; the entire image was sharpened normally. The whole picture has reddish tones. The ground is red, and so is the building in the background. Only the bus stands out with its blue color. The depth of field from the 50/1.4 lens also contributes to this effect. In my opinion, these are the reasons that make the image appear somewhat three-dimensional to me. The photo was taken many years ago (03/2028), so I don't remember exactly where I set the focus. I believe it was centered on the windshield. For this image, the focus should be on the right headlight:
Schwarzlicht wrote: j4nu wroteSchwarzlicht wrotej4nu wrotegdanmitchell wroteNifty Fifty wroteIn my opinion, you are wrong here. The sharpness gradients on the ground and on the bus are obviously identical.I’d say that it is open to question, but the rear of the vehicle seems quite sharp while the pavement under the rear of the vehicle and the lighter pavement at the same distance to the right seem softer to me. In any case, feel free to ignore that point among those I made.
.I have not noticed it before but I think you're right - there's some masking going on. Take a look at the front wheel as well, the wheel itself is sharp while the pavement looks like a bit of gaussian blur was applied to it...
I don't think such processed pictures contribute much to the discussion about lens 3d pop capability.Of course, I'm very sorry that I couldn't meet your expectations and that I have little to contribute. Here's a small tip: open the image on Flickr using the link located under the photo and check it out in full resolution. No "Gaussian blur" was applied. (Whatever that may be.) It would also be helpful to see some of your images that contribute to the discussion about the 3D pop capability of lenses. That would give me the confidence that we're talking about the same topic—unless your lenses aren't capable of 3D pop.I'm sorry then - it's the only way I could explain the difference in sharpness between the front wheel and its closest area and the ground around it as exif also pointed to masking. I guess this will become another 3d pop mystery to me...
I posted one photo some time ago in a thread similar to this one, but I can't find it now - I'll try again tomorrow ."Hmm, when I open the image on Flickr and zoom in, the front tire and the ground beneath it are somewhat sharp. The rear tire and the ground underneath it are out of focus. Of course, the RAW file has been edited. As you can see, there are no shadows cast anywhere, no light, no shadow, because it's cloudy. Therefore, the contrast has been slightly increased. There was also no selective sharpening done; the entire image was sharpened normally. The whole picture has reddish tones. The ground is red, and so is the building in the background. Only the bus stands out with its blue color. The depth of field from the 50/1.4 lens also contributes to this effect. In my opinion, these are the reasons that make the image appear somewhat three-dimensional to me. The photo was taken many years ago (03/2028), so I don't remember exactly where I set the focus. I believe it was centered on the windshield. For this image, the focus should be on the right headlight:
Indeed, this one also looks 3d and the blur looks normal as well.
I hope you don't mind, but I cropped the part from the previous image that made me wonder what's going on: https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/54146241847_590dd4842b_o.jpg
In the new image I can't see anything like that .
I also believe depth of field contributes to the "3d pop" effect and it's a thin line between too little and too much...
Jonas B wrote: Daran wroteSchwarzlicht wroteHere’s another example. The images were taken with the Batis 40/2 lens. I used apertures of f2, f2.2, and f4. At f4, a large portion of the image is sharp, and I find that the effect is most pronounced here. So, it has nothing to do with sharpness.Sharpness is only one of the factors, as I hope we can all agree on by now. But in your images a jump in sharpness from the dog to the background only happens for your f4 shot. The faster two shots have too little DOF for your subject. Most of the dog is soft in those two, particularly the outline is soft. Hence instead of a sharp subject in front of a soft background these have a sharp face surrounded by a soft dog. So reducing the visual contrast of the dog to the background, rather than supporting it.All I see is a very patient woman.
Figures. But for clarification, why do you think you posted a comparison series if you refuse to look at it?
foto16 wrote:
Es gibt eine gewisse Motivtrennung durch Schärfentiefe und Perspektive, wenn man das als „Pop“ bezeichnen kann.
This is exactly the problem that some forum users have already mentioned. People are discussing an effect that has nothing more than a name (3D pop), but which is not defined anywhere. Five out of 10 people imagine something different and are therefore discussing completely at cross purposes. Personally, I can say that I have the impression that the term "3D pop" is often used when a subject is so exaggeratedly isolated that it feels like it has been glued into the picture. A type of representation that I personally don't like at all. But as I said, the term is not defined and the different opinions on whether the level of sharpness at the rear of the bus is the same as that on the ground alone show me how completely pointless the whole discussion is. If everyone believes they see something different even in the same photo, what will come of a subsequent discussion about why one person sees something and another doesn't? And here it's nothing more than determining where the level of sharpness is. This discussion is similar to the one that hi-fi fans have about whether cable sound exists.
Are you implying that there’s no 3D pop? When images with 3D pop are presented, I tend to be one of those people who don’t recognize it. However, with some images, the subject sometimes stands out so much that even I can see it. Several explanations that make sense to me have been mentioned here in the discussion: quickly or slowly falling off areas of sharpness, colors, micro-contrast, post-processing, composition, light fall-off... Here’s a picture I took a few years ago with the FE 50mm F1.4 ZA at an aperture of f/1.4. When I look at this image on a 65-inch OLED screen, I feel like the bus is about to jump out of the screen and into my living room. I believe it has to do with the transition of sharpness with the 50/1.4 ZA. I’ve had this lens for many years, and I keep noticing that the sharpness gradually and smoothly falls off. Often, when I view the images, I can’t tell at all where sharpness transitions into blur
That image of a van would have looked exactly the same if it was taken with any other 50mm lens at the same distance and aperture. The "poppiness" is a characteristic of a scene+light, not lens.
It's like saying "this lens makes you look 20" and then using a photo of a 20 year old model to "prove" it. Again, as I said above, show me before/after images side by side, the same scene+subject+light taken by two lenses: one with 3D pop and one without.
Nifty Fifty wrote: foto16 wroteEs gibt eine gewisse Motivtrennung durch Schärfentiefe und Perspektive, wenn man das als „Pop“ bezeichnen kann.This is exactly the problem that some forum users have already mentioned. People are discussing an effect that has nothing more than a name (3D pop), but which is not defined anywhere. Five out of 10 people imagine something different and are therefore discussing completely at cross purposes. Personally, I can say that I have the impression that the term "3D pop" is often used when a subject is so exaggeratedly isolated that it feels like it has been glued into the picture. A type of representation that I personally don't like at all. But as I said, the term is not defined and the different opinions on whether the level of sharpness at the rear of the bus is the same as that on the ground alone show me how completely pointless the whole discussion is. If everyone believes they see something different even in the same photo, what will come of a subsequent discussion about why one person sees something and another doesn't? And here it's nothing more than determining where the level of sharpness is. This discussion is similar to the one that hi-fi fans have about whether cable sound exists....Show more →
Yes the term is empty. At the very least people should distinguish between global "pop" vs. local "pop" when they talk. The impression of 3D at the global image level is always primarily driven by the content of the image, perspective, things like DOF, lighting, and color that create subject and background separation, like in the painting that Darrellc showed earlier (page 3). These would dwarf any minute differences in lens character, which may affect local contrast. The images folks posted here are just regualr photographs in the sense that they have nothing in "pop" that cannot be explained by the above factors.
zeitlos wrote: old-gregg wroteThat image of a van would have looked exactly the same if it was taken with any other 50mm lens at the same distance and aperture.Why do you know that?