Steve Spencer wrote:
... It is clear that the 28 f/1.4 and 35 f/1.4 Thypoch Leica M mount lenses perform better on a Leica M camera than the mirrorless mount versions of these lenses perform on the mirrorless mounts.
Do you have a link to images (or MTF plots) that show this lesser performance? E.g., Z 28/1.4 on Z camera vs M-mount version on a Leica M with same pixel count. Thanx.
Ripolini wrote: Steve Spencer wrote... It is clear that the 28 f/1.4 and 35 f/1.4 Thypoch Leica M mount lenses perform better on a Leica M camera than the mirrorless mount versions of these lenses perform on the mirrorless mounts.Do you have a link to images (or MTF plots) that show this lesser performance? E.g., Z 28/1.4 on Z camera vs M-mount version on a Leica M with same pixel count. Thanx.
No, I have only seen examples in pictures of the serious decrease in performance on Sony E mount in the mid frame and corners. Here is Bastian's review at philipreeve.net that clearly shows that:
This MTF 50 results in the borders and corners look pretty bad until f/4 or f/5.6. It might be a bit better on Z mount than E mount, but it seems both are a noticeable downgrade in the edges and corners compared to Leica M. Of course it is still pretty early perhaps it won't be that bad and I still have hope it will work well as a cine lens.
Well, I've read those reviews.
The tests by Bastian show that
i) at infinity the M-mount version on Leica M10 doesn't perform well in the corners at the wider apertures. To have an even rendition in the center, midframe and corners, the lens must be stopped down at f/8. These findings somewhat resemble what Opticallimits measured in the case of the Z-mount version (on Z7, i.e., a camera with a higher pixel count, where things become more challenging);
ii) corner performance deteriorated when the M-mount version was mounted on Sony A7rII; this isn't surprising and doesn't allow drawing any meaningful conclusion on the performance of the Z-mount version on Z bodies.
I have to disagree with the Bastian findings. I have posted on this site my results of the Thypoch Simera 50 1.4 shot on an M9-P and a S1R. I show comparisons with the Leica SL 50 Summilux 1.4.
I find the lens to be very good side to side and in the corners on these cameras.
Here is a link to those images again.
Doug Ball wrote:
I have to disagree with the Bastian findings. I have posted on this site my results of the Thypoch Simera 50 1.4 shot on an M9-P and a S1R. I show comparisons with the Leica SL 50 Summilux 1.4.
I find the lens to be very good side to side and in the corners on these cameras.
Here is a link to those images again.
nehemiahphoto wrote: Doug Ball wroteI have to disagree with the Bastian findings. I have posted on this site my results of the Thypoch Simera 50 1.4 shot on an M9-P and a S1R. I show comparisons with the Leica SL 50 Summilux 1.4.
I find the lens to be very good side to side and in the corners on these cameras.
Here is a link to those images again.
RustyRus wrote: nehemiahphoto wroteDoug Ball wroteI have to disagree with the Bastian findings. I have posted on this site my results of the Thypoch Simera 50 1.4 shot on an M9-P and a S1R. I show comparisons with the Leica SL 50 Summilux 1.4.
I find the lens to be very good side to side and in the corners on these cameras.
Here is a link to those images again.
Ripolini wrote:
Well, I've read those reviews.
The tests by Bastian show that
i) at infinity the M-mount version on Leica M10 doesn't perform well in the corners at the wider apertures. To have an even rendition in the center, midframe and corners, the lens must be stopped down at f/8. These findings somewhat resemble what Opticallimits measured in the case of the Z-mount version (on Z7, i.e., a camera with a higher pixel count, where things become more challenging);
ii) corner performance deteriorated when the M-mount version was mounted on Sony A7rII; this isn't surprising and doesn't allow drawing any meaningful conclusion on the performance of the Z-mount version on Z bodies....Show more →
It is hard to compare the pictures from Bastian's review to the MTFs from Optical Limits, but I don't think the Leica M performance on Bastian's pictures is similar to the MTFs at Optical Limits. The MTFs for the corners have pretty bad performance at f/1.4 and f/2.0 that seems significantly worse than the pictures in Bastian's review, but it is of course comparing apples to oranges. I also would be quite happy with the evenness of the cross frame performance of the Leica M lens at f/5.6 from Bastian's pictures with the Leica M. In contrast the MTFs only get even at F/8 on the Optical Limits test on Z mount and then only because the center performance drops. Based on those MTFs I would expect below average performance for landscapes with this lens on Nikon Z. There would be lots and lots of lenses I would expect to perform better including most zooms that cover 28mm. Again it is hard to know without more tests at Optical Limits, but I was not impressed by the MTFs at all, YMMV.
My take is that on Nikon Z it could be fine for cine and portraits where cross frame sharpness is not needed, but would be weak as a landscape lens. It could serve well, but not as an all around lens. We'll see as we get more reports and better side by side tests, but that is my bet for now. I could be wrong, however.
Not many cine lenses get used at T1.5 for infinity landscapes. There are people wanting 28/1.5 Voigts to use on Sonys, and some do and enjoy it because it suits their very different photography.
The Simeras are well made and high quality - not surprising as they are cross-packaged cine lenses made by a respected cine company. DZO would have been better advised to use their own name in their ill-fated early venture into hostile Leica territory, where the M glow shades all else, often including rationality. But in the cine world, everyone uses range names as a convention: Super Speeds, M 0.8s, Signature Primes, etc.
These Simera lenses certainly reward good vision, that much is obvious. They are not striving to be Otuses or SLs, any more than the f1.5 CV lenses are. They are fine examples of what Guy refers to as 'look lenses'. They have a narrow niche, within which they are very good indeed. The small 21/1.4 will be very interesting, as will the 75/1.4.
But DZO should have first produced the stills Simeras in E-mount because:
. it is the nearest thing we have to long established universal coverage
. it has a usage history of full spectrum manual focus lenses, with little aesthetic baggage
. this would have enabled leverage from the serious Sony cine camera presence
. MF lenses simply work better in TTL via EVFs, where image depth can be easily assessed
. video vlogging.
And DZO should have done this *after* the Simera-C cine range was bedded in. Marketing decisions, essentially, but they do matter - beginnings are delicate times. Fortunately, they can recover from this misstep and even do very well without the M-mount involvement at all.
philip_pj wrote:
Not many cine lenses get used at T1.5 for infinity landscapes. There are people wanting 28/1.5 Voigts to use on Sonys, and some do and enjoy it because it suits their very different photography.
The Simeras are well made and high quality - not surprising as they are cross-packaged cine lenses made by a respected cine company. DZO would have been better advised to use their own name in their ill-fated early venture into hostile Leica territory, where the M glow shades all else, often including rationality. But in the cine world, everyone uses range names as a convention: Super Speeds, M 0.8s, Signature Primes, etc.
These Simera lenses certainly reward good vision, that much is obvious. They are not striving to be Otuses or SLs, any more than the f1.5 CV lenses are. They are fine examples of what Guy refers to as 'look lenses'. They have a narrow niche, within which they are very good indeed. The small 21/1.4 will be very interesting, as will the 75/1.4.
But DZO should have first produced the stills Simeras in E-mount because:
. it is the nearest thing we have to long established universal coverage
. it has a usage history of full spectrum manual focus lenses, with little aesthetic baggage
. this would have enabled leverage from the serious Sony cine camera presence
. MF lenses simply work better in TTL via EVFs, where image depth can be easily assessed
. video vlogging.
And DZO should have done this *after* the Simera-C cine range was bedded in. Marketing decisions, essentially, but they do matter - beginnings are delicate times. Fortunately, they can recover from this misstep and even do very well without the M-mount involvement at all....Show more →
Have you actually owned any of the lenses? Or at least played with the raw files?
First thing I noticed is that the focusing is not as smooth as voigtlander or Leica lenses. Second thing was that my copy doesn’t have the 0.55m distance marker; it goes from 0.7 to 0.45 unlike pictured in their official photos.
Will test out the lens more and compare to the summilux 50mm CF
philip_pj wrote:
But DZO should have first produced the stills Simeras in E-mount
I reckon the E mount crowds are hard to please with philosophy of rendering from the simera lines. People want the same character but can take 200mp full frame resolution and still pin sharp across the frame wide open when pixel peep.
I don't think there is such a thing as the E-mount crowd, but I've only been with the E-mount since, well, late 2012. It's without doubt the most diverse user group and has been all that time.
You're describing the GM sub-crowd. They are johnny-come-latelys! Have you noticed how few images they post here these days? Why, I have no idea, the lenses are fine. It's sad.
And that is how we can gauge the level of enthusiasm among different user bases. Did you know how many autofocus lenses Canon and Nikon made for (D)SLRs? Over 100 million each. How many of them are being used now? Thanks for your contribution, by the way.
Re the Simeras, there is perhaps a lot of push back on them because they are, the horror, Chinese! It's a rerun of the end of German production of consumer lenses several decades back. Excellence knows no borders, however, but it could be a factor here, certainly. How many know the largest manufacturer of vaccines and generic medicine is, drum roll, India? It's a global world, held together by trade. cheers.
philip_pj wrote:
You're describing the GM sub-crowd. They are johnny-come-latelys! Have you noticed how few images they post here these days? Why, I have no idea, the lenses are fine. It's sad.
Re the Simeras, there is perhaps a lot of push back on them because they are, the horror, Chinese! It's a rerun of the end of German production of consumer lenses several decades back. Excellence knows no borders, however, but it could be a factor here, certainly. How many know the largest manufacturer of vaccines and generic medicine is, drum roll, India? It's a global world, held together by trade. cheers....Show more →
Those are on point, it's perhaps the group of the crowd that push Sony to make GM lenses and, to put it bluntly, "anything non GM/APO level".
As for Chinese manufacturer, a good lens is a good lens, being a Chinese manufacturer means we still enjoy the discounted price because they can't command higher price tag. I rarely post in forums nowadays as I just enjoy my 28/1.4 m mount.
It's raining and snowing here in Minnesota so I can't take the Thypoch out for a real spin. So, I improvised. I mounted the Thypoch on my Sony A1 with the Techart LM-EA9 which gives me autofocus and even closer MFD than the specified 0.45M. AF was pretty snappy. In any case, it gave me an hour of fun.
nehemiahphoto wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI finally received the Thypoch Simera 50mm f/1.4 for review. It came directly from China.Cool! Better late than never.
What other modern 50mm’s will you compare it too? And, will we see the performance on a stock Sony sensor?
The only similarly modern lens I own at the moment is the Leica 50/1.4 Lux, which seems to be Simera’s main competitor. So, I will compare them for resolution, contrast, flare, etc.
I do not own a stock Sony at the moment. My A7CR is now a UT sensor version. (which I love btw)