Did you check the Samyang V-AF cinema lenses? The lenses are also rehoused Sony versions of Samyang/Rokinon1.8 series. I have the 100mm T2.3 version, since they have not released that as a regular lens.
The 75/1.5 Simera-C is smaller in length and diameter than the 75/1.5 Nokton in the same mount - Sony E. It's only made in E-mount. It's 65 grams lighter and has the same MFD of 0.55m. In the video above, 9:25 for the 75mm test, gives a good sense of the (16 blade) rendering and DOF of subjects for portraits, and bokeh at each step in aperture.
It's a true 72mm at infinity, breathing is 'not controlled' but is pretty minimal to my eyes, you might pick up an extra 4-5mm. (thanks, Doug, very good use of the aesthetics). 'See-meh-ra' means 'today' in Greek.
serhan_ wrote:
Did you check the Samyang V-AF cinema lenses? The lenses are also rehoused Sony versions of Samyang/Rokinon1.8 series. I have the 100mm T2.3 version, since they have not released that as a regular lens.
Many thanks to mak543 for directing me to Flickr. I had not used this for some time.
I just posted some more images that show detail at infinity in a landscaping situation, possible distortion of the Simera 50, a comparison test of the Simera 50 at 1.4, against the Leica SL 50 1.4 at 1.4, and others as well.
A well-structured look at the forthcoming Thypoch/DZO lenses, with a lot of footage and detailed assessment. In many respects, they represent an incursion of still lenses into the emerging 'cinema light' and video worlds, with hitherto cine-averse aspects like vignette and breathing. Regardless, both fit comfortably within our expectations in the MF stills world. Weight and size alone are shocking, given the performance on offer.
Even many of those who are orthodox in these matters can sense something special about the Simeras. They strike a sound balance between the need for technical image performance and endearing character, expressed in image depth and cinematic focus roll-off. It's likely to be an easy formula for aficionados to appreciate. The C lens range will soon include a 21mm, presumably T1.5.
The 75 T1.5 is being introduced ahead of the Simera stills version - it would be great if that one, as a 75/1.4, incorporated the same 16 blade aperture built into the C version. Many are fussy about bokeh ball shapes and that focal length would also show the bokeh and fall-off more fully than the shorter focal lengths. It's fair to say many of us find more to like in the variety of 50mm lenses than in 75-85mm lenses, where you may have to be more fussy, because these are more likely to be used as portrait focal lengths, shot at/near wide open.
This video features a set of pre-release M-mount lenses but E-mount comes first. It appears we may see all four mounts catered for in the SImeras, both C and stills versions. These people are out to build a presence and they will not be wasting any time doing so.
Thank you again, Doug, very impressive. Is it possible, if you find time, to post images from the Simera and Summilux f1.4s on the same body? It would give more of an apples to apples comparison, by taking the body out of the equation.
The 21mm Simera cine lens may appear at year's end. From its dimensions, it looks like being much the same weight and max aperture as the others. These being rehoused stills lenses we can perhaps expect this one early next year. These cine lenses will appear in both E and M-mounts first. See below for the 75mm on a Sony body, and the sizes of the cine lenses lineup (images courtesy of Spenser Sakurai). This YT was shot with one of the Simera-C lneses, plenty of detail in this one also:
'Somehow the best lenses I've ever reviewed'
YouTube
Spenser Sakurai
17 Oct 2024
He's looking forward to the 75mm; so am I.
Using the Simera-C 75mm on Sony
The Simera-C range, the 21mm looks to be T1.5 (= f1.4).
What would make these lenses much more interesting from my perspective: tweak the optics for e-mount.
We know how much you're giving up on the 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Bastian's reviews in terms of sensor stack induced FC. The 50/1.4 and 75/1.4 will probably be less to minimally affect, while the 21/1.4 is a wild card, but will probably only like either e or m.
If we had lenses this small and cine ready with uncrippled performance, that would be lovely. They might not be the most characterful lenses, but the utility is extremely high.
'Available Now for Z/E/X/RF Mount
The Simera series expands its lens mount options with native Z, E, X, and RF mounts that are seamlessly integrated into its classic and elegant design. Perfectly compatible with Nikon, Sony, Fujifilm, and Canon mirrorless cameras, it prevents potential image quality loss associated with adapters.'
'With a maximum image circle of 43.2mm, Simera-C covers full-frame sensors and is also compatible with Super 35 and APS-C formats. Featuring a native Sony E-mount, it works seamlessly with a wide range of cameras, from entry-level mirrorless to high-end systems like DJI Ronin 4D, and Sony Venice. The 28-50mm lenses share a consistent 67mm front diameter for M62 filters, while the 75mm lens uses a 72mm front diameter for M67 filters.'
I've read the E-mount is next for the stills version of the 50/1.4. The cine lenses will be first released in E-mount, then (from memory) M-mount. People still think Thypoch is a jumped up, el cheapo outfit. They maybe don't know about DZO.
I'm interested in the 75/T1.5 as I believe they will pay greater attention to tolerances and QC - the cine world is very unforgiving due to opportunity costs etc. Also, a 75mm can take best advantage of the 16 blade aperture, and that lens is very well-specified, it's small by MILC standards, and just 450g native to Sony. Close focus quality is vital, as we see in the 50mm in particular. MFD matches the E-mount CV 75/1.5, it's a little closer than the 0.7m of the VM 75/1.5 I use.
Per Bastian: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1825553/10#16548544
"I got confirmation from the manufacturer today: the optics are the same as the M-mount version. No adjustments have been made to account for the thicker filter stack of the other camera systems"
'Available Now for Z/E/X/RF Mount
The Simera series expands its lens mount options with native Z, E, X, and RF mounts that are seamlessly integrated into its classic and elegant design. Perfectly compatible with Nikon, Sony, Fujifilm, and Canon mirrorless cameras, it prevents potential image quality loss associated with adapters.'
'With a maximum image circle of 43.2mm, Simera-C covers full-frame sensors and is also compatible with Super 35 and APS-C formats. Featuring a native Sony E-mount, it works seamlessly with a wide range of cameras, from entry-level mirrorless to high-end systems like DJI Ronin 4D, and Sony Venice. The 28-50mm lenses share a consistent 67mm front diameter for M62 filters, while the 75mm lens uses a 72mm front diameter for M67 filters.'
I've read the E-mount is next for the stills version of the 50/1.4. The cine lenses will be first released in E-mount, then (from memory) M-mount. People still think Thypoch is a jumped up, el cheapo outfit. They maybe don't know about DZO.
I'm interested in the 75/T1.5 as I believe they will pay greater attention to tolerances and QC - the cine world is very unforgiving due to opportunity costs etc. Also, a 75mm can take best advantage of the 16 blade aperture, and that lens is very well-specified, it's small by MILC standards, and just 450g native to Sony. Close focus quality is vital, as we see in the 50mm in particular. MFD matches the E-mount CV 75/1.5, it's a little closer than the 0.7m of the VM 75/1.5 I use. ...Show more →
Using as evidence the block diagrams are identical, so what exactly was the optimization made by Cosina to ensure 'the lens is optimized for the image sensors of mirrorless cameras with the Nikon Z-mount.' A similar circumstance applies to the 50/1 Nokton. Cosina have been telling people for ages that their VM lenses work on MILC cameras. This from the 50/1, surely a lens that could be expected to cause cross-mount problems:
'Not only can it be used with many rangefinder cameras, but it also has an excellent balance when attached to a mirrorless digital camera via an appropriate adapter.' What exactly does 'balance' mean in this context? Well, for the 40/1.2 VM we see:
'but *design-wise* it also balances very nicely when mounted on mirrorless digital cameras with a mount adapter.' Not physical, but 'design-wise'. Again, what changed in the newer made for Z-mount, the one with the identical block diagram?
Lost in translation, I am guessing, but room for doubt. If not, DZO will face a lot of returns and loss of reputation if the problem is serious. Come what may, the cine 75 T1.5 is not a knock-off of an M optic, but a native E-mount lens, and it already exists and we have reviews of it.
Last month, Marc Alhadeff tested an E-mount version of the Simera 35/1.4 - one of the 'no adjustment for thicker sensor stacks' ones - and found the corners as good as the CV 35/1.2 at f1.4 and f2; and better than the CV 35/1.4 at all apertures. Imagine if it had been optimized! He used a Sony A1.
He comes fairly close to understanding what the lens does in examining its characteristics, but he is interested more in the side-by-side metrics business. As always, a little background reading would help understand our lenses. Cine lenses are, of course, people lenses but just a couple of found portraits here.
Using as evidence the block diagrams are identical, so what exactly was the optimization made by Cosina to ensure 'the lens is optimized for the image sensors of mirrorless cameras with the Nikon Z-mount.' A similar circumstance applies to the 50/1 Nokton. Cosina have been telling people for ages that their VM lenses work on MILC cameras. This from the 50/1, surely a lens that could be expected to cause cross-mount problems:
'Not only can it be used with many rangefinder cameras, but it also has an excellent balance when attached to a mirrorless digital camera via an appropriate adapter.' What exactly does 'balance' mean in this context? Well, for the 40/1.2 VM we see:
'but *design-wise* it also balances very nicely when mounted on mirrorless digital cameras with a mount adapter.' Not physical, but 'design-wise'. Again, what changed in the newer made for Z-mount, the one with the identical block diagram?
Lost in translation, I am guessing, but room for doubt. If not, DZO will face a lot of returns and loss of reputation if the problem is serious. Come what may, the cine 75 T1.5 is not a knock-off of an M optic, but a native E-mount lens, and it already exists and we have reviews of it. ...Show more →
I don't think there is the uncertainty that you suggest at least in the ways that are most important. Cosina makes a lot of M lenses for Leica M mount cameras. Some of these lenses they also make for Sony E-mount, Nikon Z-mount, and Canon RF-mount cameras. What isn't uncertain is that when they make these lenses for these other mounts they don't underperform on those mounts compared to how they perform on Leica M mount cameras and perform at least as well. I don't think there are any exceptions to that general rule. What is uncertain is whether they tweaked the lenses to get this at least equivalent performance. Some lenses they may well have not needed to tweak (e.g., the 75 f/1.5), whereas other lenses are clearly different for Leica M mount vs. other mounts (e.g., 50 f/2 APO, which even has a different number of elements with special glass on mirrorless mounts compared the Leica M mount).
In my view, Cosina has been very careful to offer lenses to mirrorless mounts that have really good performance on those mounts. This is in contrast to these new Thypoch lenses. It is clear that the 28 f/1.4 and 35 f/1.4 Thypoch Leica M mount lenses perform better on a Leica M camera than the mirrorless mount versions of these lenses perform on the mirrorless mounts. For cine purposes I am not sure how important that lesser performance is--I am ambivalent about that myself--but it is a notable difference between these Thypoch lenses and Cosina Voigtlander lenses. Perhaps part of the reason there are so many Leica M mount Voigtlander 28 and 35 mm lenses that don't have corresponding mirrorless mount versions is that making such lenses that perform as well on mirrorless cameras as they do on Leica M cameras is not an easy adjustment. It appears that Thypoch has taken the road of not adjusting and just living with the reduced performance, whereas Cosina has not brought out lenses with reduced performance in mirrorless mounts. I am not sure what I prefer, but the difference is notable.