Bill Claff‘s R5 II sensor measurement is out at PhotonsToPhotos. As expected not better but also not much worse than R5.
The second gain switch takes place at ISO500 vs R5 at ISO400. Consequently the R5 PDR is 1 stop better at ISO400, which I used many times.
Of course Canon baked in noise reduction. Bill and his charts don’t tell whether less than R5 NR.
In ES, PDR 1/2 stop better than R5 at ISO100. Also slightly better than Z8 but worse than Sony A1.
Surprising to me the A1 with its ES and without NR matches the R5 II in EFCS with NR.
BokehBeauty wrote:
Bill Claff‘s R5 II sensor measurement is out at PhotonsToPhotos. As expected not better but also not much worse than R5.
The second gain switch takes place at ISO500 vs R5 at ISO400. Consequently the R5 PDR is 1 stop better at ISO400, which I used many times.
Of course Canon backed in noise reduction. Bill and his charts don’t tell whether less than R5 NR.
In ES, PDR 1/2 stop better than R5 at ISO100. Also slightly better than Z8 but worse than Sony A1.
Surprising to me the A1 with its ES and without NR matches the R5 II in EFCS with NR.
It's interesting that the A1 has the same DR regardless of the shutter choice. So apparently Canon is still reading the sensor differently (faster / less bit depth for ES?)
Another observation - the entire range produced by the R5II has NR applied (triangles). The original R5 only used to apply NR below ISO 800.
I'm not a Canon shooter, but looking at the results on Photons to Photos, I don't see much to be unhappy about. The EFCS looks really strong and the straight electronic shutter isn't bad either. It looks to me like it'll have the DR to perform well for landscape and in ES, at ISOs that are typical for this type of shooting, it'll also be great. There's the noise reduction, but I've never read much in the way of real world unhappiness with the R5 (or the a9iii for that matter), so maybe it doesn't matter at this point.
As I predicted, the concerns were overblown. The R5II is a fantastic camera albeit the buffer lock up (rather than slow down) and the lack of zebras for stills (Canon and Nikon continue to miss). My limited demo experience with the AF on a production body was nothing short of fantastic.