fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024R5II noise performance a step down

  
 
tsunathanh
Offline

p.1 #1R5II noise performance a step down

DP Review posted some studio test shots. The R5 and Z8 look cleaner and have higher DR than the R5II in most (all?) of the comparisons.

https://www.dpreview.com/articles/2189397463/canon-eos-r5-ii-added-to-studio-scene
Aug 06, 2024 at 05:44 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.1 #2R5II noise performance a step down
Looks like they turned off the noise reduction in the raw files, by request from Nikon users

The profile looks a bit different, but color and detail seems well preserved even at +6 EV (EFCS)
Aug 06, 2024 at 05:59 AM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.1 #3R5II noise performance a step down
alundeb wrote:
Looks like they turned off the noise reduction in the raw files, by request from Nikon users

The profile looks a bit different, but color and detail seems well preserved even at +6 EV (EFCS)


Funny, it looks like that is exactly what they did (at least, if you bought into that theory). I see more substantial differences in the comparisons with the R5 than with the Z8. The differences with the Z8 seem marginal.

Tradeoff for faster readout speed than the R5, probably.

WRT DR, photographs that require pulling shadows by +6EV are probably failed to begin with, IMO, so minor differences seen at the very extremes are kind of academic, I think.

All these modern sensors are excellent in absolute terms.
Aug 06, 2024 at 06:43 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.1 #4R5II noise performance a step down
garyvot wrote:
alundeb wroteLooks like they turned off the noise reduction in the raw files, by request from Nikon users

The profile looks a bit different, but color and detail seems well preserved even at +6 EV (EFCS)
I see more substantial differences in the comparisons with the R5 than with the Z8. The differences with the Z8 seem marginal.


I agree. There is more of a stark difference between the R5 to the R5II in comparison which is expected.
However, it looks like the R5II has a slight edge over the Z8 at high ISO. Which is also expected. if we're splitting hairs.
Now in comparison to the A1 or A9III... well... we probably shouldn't bring that up.

I can't wait to see how the R1 performs. It's supposed to be the low light king from the reports so far. I wonder if anyone has got their hands on one yet like they have the R5II.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53906421799_1695a47d21_z.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53906072451_14c6786f9e_z.jpg

Aug 06, 2024 at 09:54 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.1 #5R5II noise performance a step down
garyvot wrote:
WRT DR, photographs that require pulling shadows by +6EV are probably failed to begin with, IMO, so minor differences seen at the very extremes are kind of academic, I think.


That is fairly untrue, except, perhaps, for your case. Anyone who shoots at night will run into this limitation (and run into the effects long before pulling +6EV); it does not mean that the images were 'fails' to begin with. For daytime, any amount of increased DR (i.e. info in the shadows) potentially decreases the need to shoot multiple exposures for HDR.

This is arguably the only body that Canon can claim to be their 'best' for landscape-type imagery, and taking steps backward like this just furthers the argument that Canon is losing sight of what many stills photographers want and need (and have historically wanted and needed). Not everyone shoots birds and captures video half the time.
Aug 06, 2024 at 10:59 AM
PhilH
Offline
Details
p.1 #6R5II noise performance a step down
I'm investigating a few things.

One mystery thing is the discrepancy in sharpness at higher ISO Ratings. i.e. R5 MK II appears to be sharper for whatever reason, which could lead to more pronounced image noise.

We have access to some RAW file tuning, but not all under the hood RAW data image processing. True for all mirrorless bodies for that matter. But I'm curious to see what's going on here.
Aug 06, 2024 at 11:06 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.1 #7R5II noise performance a step down
Once again, there's going to be a divide depending on needs.... From my perspective, the various performance improvements of the R5II relevant to my needs, vastly outweigh whatever the DR penalty might be. And in my case, I'd just run it through Denoise anyway to clean up shadows lifted a couple stops. Bottom line appears to be that it's not a major step backwards.
Aug 06, 2024 at 11:08 AM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.1 #8R5II noise performance a step down
Jeff wrote:
garyvot wroteWRT DR, photographs that require pulling shadows by +6EV are probably failed to begin with, IMO, so minor differences seen at the very extremes are kind of academic, I think.
That is fairly untrue, except, perhaps, for your case. Anyone who shoots at night will run into this limitation (and run into the effects long before pulling +6EV); it does not mean that the images were 'fails' to begin with. For daytime, any amount of increased DR (i.e. info in the shadows) potentially decreases the need to shoot multiple exposures for HDR.

This is arguably the only body that Canon can claim to be their 'best' for landscape-type imagery, and taking steps backward like this just furthers the argument that Canon is losing sight of what many stills photographers want
...Show more →

I can see your point for someone who shoots at ISO 100 on tripods, though I would argue that the differences are still pretty marginal. (For example, these folks probably won't be using electronic shutter.)

That said, I did read an interesting comment over on DPReview earlier which was basically that anybody that cared about low ISO dynamic range was no longer shooting Canon anyway, so this camera won't disappoint any of us, haha.
Aug 06, 2024 at 11:40 AM
kirbic
Offline
Details
p.1 #9R5II noise performance a step down
garyvot wrote:
That said, I did read an interesting comment over on DPReview earlier which was basically that anybody that cared about low ISO dynamic range was no longer shooting Canon anyway, so this camera won't disappoint any of us, haha.


, that almost made me spit my coffee... all these cameras are so good these days that if you can't get the results you are after, it's not your equipment.
That said, initial indications are that the sensor performance with respect to noise and DR is at best "no improvement." For me, it likely means that I will not invest in the Mk II, since I am not nearly as interested in the features that have been improved... other than AF. And I don't think that the AF improvements represent, for me, a $4200 benefit. My opinion may change as more information emerges, but for now that's my take.
I do need to complete my transition to the R mount, so perhaps I will just score a second, lightly-used R5 body.

Aug 06, 2024 at 12:19 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.1 #10R5II noise performance a step down
After looking at the DPR article and reading the comment section I'm seriously thinking of giving my R5II away. I don't want to shoot with such an inferior camera. I'm going to do the same with the A9III, because it produces total trash in terms of DR!

Jokes aside, I think 95% of people that bash Canon @ DPR never held a decent camera/lens (of any brand) in their hands.
Aug 06, 2024 at 01:07 PM
biggles2002
Offline
Details
p.1 #11R5II noise performance a step down
Yes please I'll take it...
Aug 06, 2024 at 02:13 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.1 #12R5II noise performance a step down
docusync wrote:
After looking at the DPR article and reading the comment section I'm seriously thinking of giving my R5II away. I don't want to shoot with such an inferior camera. I'm going to do the same with the A9III, because it produces total trash in terms of DR!

Jokes aside, I think 95% of people that bash Canon @ DPR never held a decent camera/lens (of any brand) in their hands.


I just bought the Nikon Z6iii

To my shock and disbelief- The camera is incredible. Youtube told me otherwise as well as this forum. The amount of measurebating that goes on now and the revenue stream people get from youtube is really annoying to watch.

The R52 looks incredible- Its crazy how much people are talking about some non sense.

Want to shoot a Cinema Quality movie? Nah I wanna just go take amazing pictures today.

The R52 can do both, just like the Nikon Z8/Z6iii

The options we have as photographers/videographers today are mind blowing. Yet we got lost in the non sense- If I wasn't in bed with Nikon already, I would snatch this thing up and love it. Enjoy this camera, it looks awesome.
Aug 06, 2024 at 02:40 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.1 #13R5II noise performance a step down


RustyRus wrote:
docusync wroteAfter looking at the DPR article and reading the comment section I'm seriously thinking of giving my R5II away. I don't want to shoot with such an inferior camera. I'm going to do the same with the A9III, because it produces total trash in terms of DR!

Jokes aside, I think 95% of people that bash Canon @ DPR never held a decent camera/lens (of any brand) in their hands.
I just bought the Nikon Z6iii

To my shock and disbelief- The camera is incredible. Youtube told me otherwise as well as this forum. The amount of measurebating that goes on now and the revenue stream people get from youtube is really annoying to watch.

The R52 looks incredible- Its crazy how much people are talking about some non sense.

Want to shoot a Cinema Quality movie? Nah I wanna just go take amazing pictures today.

The R52 can do both, just like the Nikon Z8/Z6iii

The options we have as photographers/videographers today are mind blowing. Yet we got lost in the
...Show more →

Thank you and congrats on the Z6III! I remember a bunch of unhappy comments on DPR because it had a fraction less DR than the predecessor. No photographer would ever noticed it but the armchair experts. It seems people just don’t understand the meaning of the word “tradeoff”.
Aug 06, 2024 at 03:01 PM
biggles2002
Offline
Details
p.1 #14R5II noise performance a step down
Well it seems like there is a noise/DR penalty of stacked/partial stacked sensors but nowadays they are very good even with a penalty.

AF seems awesome, nice viewfinder.....

While there is a steap MSRP on R5II I think for me, that only have 2 RF lenses, I will wait awhile until I deside wether to buy or not.

The negative I have on Canon are:

* No FF 4k60p oversampled (R5/R5II) ...(8K60p Raw takes up too much space so not an option, 4k60 SRAW use lineskipping so not an option too much aliasing.)

* Not allowing third-party AF lenses (stubborn Japanese)

I'll have to wait too see how it performs until I decide.

Aug 06, 2024 at 03:01 PM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.1 #15R5II noise performance a step down
RustyRus wrote:
docusync wroteAfter looking at the DPR article and reading the comment section I'm seriously thinking of giving my R5II away. I don't want to shoot with such an inferior camera. I'm going to do the same with the A9III, because it produces total trash in terms of DR!

Jokes aside, I think 95% of people that bash Canon @ DPR never held a decent camera/lens (of any brand) in their hands.
I just bought the Nikon Z6iii

To my shock and disbelief- The camera is incredible. Youtube told me otherwise as well as this forum. The amount of measurebating that goes on now and the revenue stream people get from youtube is really annoying to watch.
.


A YT video popped up on my feed titled something like, "Is the R6 still usable in 2024?" People with too much money really lose all perspective on how long gear stays relevant.
Aug 06, 2024 at 03:03 PM
Caleb Williams
Offline
Details
p.1 #16R5II noise performance a step down
Mike_5D wrote:
RustyRus wrote
docusync wroteAfter looking at the DPR article and reading the comment section I'm seriously thinking of giving my R5II away. I don't want to shoot with such an inferior camera. I'm going to do the same with the A9III, because it produces total trash in terms of DR!

Jokes aside, I think 95% of people that bash Canon @ DPR never held a decent camera/lens (of any brand) in their hands.
I just bought the Nikon Z6iii

To my shock and disbelief- The camera is incredible. Youtube told me otherwise as well as this forum. The amount of measurebating that goes on now and the revenue stream people get from youtube is really annoying to watch.
.
A YT video popped up on my feed titled something like, "Is the R6 still usable in 2024?" People with too much money really lose all perspective on how long gear stays relevant.


Canon isn't going to be hunting down R6 users to force them to switch to R6 mk II, but clickbait brings in the eyeballs.
Aug 06, 2024 at 05:31 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.1 #17R5II noise performance a step down
docusync wrote:
It seems people just don’t understand the meaning of the word “tradeoff”.


My interpretation is that Canon's tradeoffs have consistently been in favor of speed and AF performance (and video), which has not benefitted some genres the way it has others. I'm in the speed camp and am happy with Canon's direction, but can appreciate it's not what everyone prefers.

An R5IIs (s for slow ) would have takers. Given how many are eyeing or moving to the Fijifilm GFX series, you'd think this might be on Canon's radar...
Aug 06, 2024 at 07:00 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.1 #18R5II noise performance a step down
rscheffler wrote:
docusync wroteIt seems people just don’t understand the meaning of the word “tradeoff”.
My interpretation is that Canon's tradeoffs have consistently been in favor of speed and AF performance (and video), which has not benefitted some genres the way it has others. I'm in the speed camp and am happy with Canon's direction, but can appreciate it's not what everyone prefers.

An R5IIs (s for slow ) would have takers. Given how many are eyeing or moving to the Fijifilm GFX series, you'd think this might be on Canon's radar...


Yes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
Aug 06, 2024 at 07:12 PM
ISO1600
Offline
Details
p.1 #19R5II noise performance a step down
I think Canon is just still focused (!!) on being the king of sports and journalism. There is clearly a market for high resolution fine art cameras, and as others have pointed out, GFX is grabbing some of that segment.
Aug 06, 2024 at 07:34 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.1 #20R5II noise performance a step down
I am sure that Canon, Nikon and Sony all 3 have high megapixel cameras in the development pipe that prioritize image quality over speed. I see them coming at around 90mp and I see them coming in the next 6 months.

As a user of the GFX-100s and GFX-100II I only use my Z7II these days when I really want to go light or need longer glass for some applications (my Leica R 180mm f2.8 APO remains un-beaten in terms of image quality) since Fuji's 250mm f4 is one of the best lenses in the system optically but it's bulky and heavy.

Cheers,
Bernard
Aug 06, 2024 at 07:53 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister