fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024R5II noise performance a step down

  
 
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.3 #1R5II noise performance a step down
docusync wrote:
Yes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.


No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg


Aug 07, 2024 at 02:50 PM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.3 #2R5II noise performance a step down
gkinard1952 wrote:
So, only reason I would go for the R5II is faster readout and pre-capture. Since I am used to shooting with an ancient camera I am not sure the better AF would help that much. But, curious to find out. If I missed by 2 or 3 I would never open the file anyway.


Gary - I know you've been itching for a while to update your camera so I strongly suggest you at least rent one of the recent Canon bodies (R6II, R5) to experience the AF systems on these modern cameras. I guarantee you will be shocked. And from what I've seen so far, this new R5II puts it over the top.

I recall 4 years ago when I first got my R5, how blown away I was with the AF system. My first outing with it I saw a small bird fly up into a tree full of leaves. When I first looked through the VF after I pulled the camera up, I couldn't see the bird at first but then I noticed the AF point over to the side a little and sure enough, it was already on the bird!

I'm sure you already know how difficult it is to follow one of these spazzy little darts around in trees and bushes let alone get a shot off before they're gone 2.9 nano seconds later. The ancient R5's AF snapped on him numerous times and allowed me to finally get a few keepers of one of these little buggers. So yep, trust me the new AF system works wonders for birds on a stick.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52015424647_1bbc3afdc4_h.jpg
Aug 07, 2024 at 03:03 PM
docusync
Offline
Details
p.3 #3R5II noise performance a step down
Toothwalker wrote:
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg



That seems like a JPEG compression thing. Try switching from JPEG to raw and it will be more readable:
https://bit.ly/46EFlbN

Overall, yes, they are pretty close, the Canon is smoother, and the Nikon is sharper. The A7r5 is the best but it's 61Mpx no AA, so no wonder.
Aug 07, 2024 at 04:02 PM
gkinard1952
Online
Details
p.3 #4R5II noise performance a step down
lighthound wrote:
gkinard1952 wroteSo, only reason I would go for the R5II is faster readout and pre-capture. Since I am used to shooting with an ancient camera I am not sure the better AF would help that much. But, curious to find out. If I missed by 2 or 3 I would never open the file anyway.
Gary - I know you've been itching for a while to update your camera so I strongly suggest you at least rent one of the recent Canon bodies (R6II, R5) to experience the AF systems on these modern cameras. I guarantee you will be shocked. And from what I've seen so far, this new R5II puts it over the top.

I recall 4 years ago when I first got my R5, how blown away I was with the AF system. My first outing with it I saw a small bird fly up into a tree full of leaves. When I
...Show more →

Yes, you are right. I have been holding off for years. I may just break down and go for the R5II. Sounds like, if the R5II's AF is better or as good as the R5 I may have to start my birding tours all over again... ))). I'm kicking it around. Minumim I will buy a used R5...

Edited on Aug 07, 2024 at 05:28 PM · View previous versions
Aug 07, 2024 at 04:45 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.3 #5R5II noise performance a step down
Hairy Heron wrote:
bernardl wroteTrue, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see
...Show more →

The thing is that 24mp APS-C offers no advantage over 45mp full frame, it's basically the same pixel density. You might as well shoot a Z8/Z9 in DX mode, same thing (but 60 fps jpgs). The AF sensor coverage advantage that APS-C DSLRs used to have is gone with mirrorless and there is no more frame rate advantage either.

This is why I am saying it has to be at least 33mp. The challenge being to see whether it makes sense economically to develop a fast fully stacked sensor for this market. They could probably reach 1/400s read-out speed with the 3 years old Z8/Z9 sensor tech, meaning possibly 1/800s with a next generation sensor. This would be one way to attract photographers looking for faster flash sync speed even if they don't do birding. Why not... I am almost convinced it makes sense.

Cheers,
Bernard

Aug 07, 2024 at 05:20 PM
FlashBazbo
Offline
Details
p.3 #6R5II noise performance a step down
Jeff wrote:
Spoken like a... wedding photographer. Agree that it's a great camera for weddings/events. And product. And headshots/portraits. Etc.


Maybe I should have mentioned . . . I'm not a wedding photographer and I've never shot one. It's just obvious that the wedding market is the one Canon is primarily targeting with the R5ii. It also works well for just about everything else, but for weddings, it's THE perfect weapon.
Aug 07, 2024 at 07:38 PM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.3 #7R5II noise performance a step down


bernardl wrote:
Hairy Heron wrote
bernardl wroteTrue, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see if that happens now that all of Nikon's upper end FF bodies have been refreshed. (I think the Z7 III is the Z8, just rebranded for a fresh start).
The thing is that 24mp APS-C offers no advantage over 45mp full frame, it's basically the same pixel density.



Cost
Aug 07, 2024 at 07:48 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.3 #8R5II noise performance a step down
Jeff wrote:
Spoken like a... wedding photographer. Agree that it's a great camera for weddings/events. And product. And headshots/portraits. Etc.

FlashBazbo wrote:
Maybe I should have mentioned . . . I'm not a wedding photographer and I've never shot one. It's just obvious that the wedding market is the one Canon is primarily targeting with the R5ii. It also works well for just about everything else, but for weddings, it's THE perfect weapon.


I'd broaden this from weddings to any kind of people photography. That's where the biggest market is - people photographing people. It's just that the majority here on this board occupy the real world niche of bird/wildlife photography. Therefore the discussions here are skewed in that direction.
Aug 07, 2024 at 09:28 PM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.3 #9R5II noise performance a step down


Toothwalker wrote:
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg


I am pretty sure the Z8 has an AA filter, though it may be on the weak side. I suspect that you could eliminate most of that moiré with Adobe's "Enhanced" demosaic algorithm though.
Aug 07, 2024 at 09:38 PM
numbertwo
Offline
Details
p.3 #10R5II noise performance a step down
Toothwalker wrote:
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg



Not saying that I don’t agree, but maybe showing jpg is not the most appropriate to make your point.
Aug 07, 2024 at 10:14 PM
goalerjones
Offline
Details
p.3 #11R5II noise performance a step down
FlashBazbo wrote:
Jeff wroteSpoken like a... wedding photographer. Agree that it's a great camera for weddings/events. And product. And headshots/portraits. Etc.
Maybe I should have mentioned . . . I'm not a wedding photographer and I've never shot one. It's just obvious that the wedding market is the one Canon is primarily targeting with the R5ii. It also works well for just about everything else, but for weddings, it's THE perfect weapon.


I do some weddings, church events, horse racing, candid street images, etc. The R5M2 seems to solve problems the R5 had such as LED light banding and rolling shutter for sports in ES mode, while still allowing instant switching to video for all those types of photos as well.

Aug 08, 2024 at 01:16 AM
jayviary
Offline
Details
p.3 #12R5II noise performance a step down
We will see when it hits Photons to Photos, but I'm essentially expecting:

- Similar/slightly worse DR from base ISO to ~400-800 compared to the R5 mechanical shutter.
- Roughly the same DR as the R5 electronic shutter from 800 to high ISOs.
- Which means roughly the same DR as every other high end, FF stacked sensor from ISO ~600 on up.

As soon as they announced it was stacked, I knew it would likely take a hit at lower ISOs (I'm still intrigued if Canon managed to bypass this issue with the R1).

I know this bums a lot of people out. For me, a lot of my subjects are small, fast birds against varied backgrounds.

I also live in the Pacific Northwest, so I forget ISOs < 1600 exist sometimes.

Basically, news of impeded DR doesn't hurt me much, although I feel for those that it does.

Aug 08, 2024 at 01:53 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #13R5II noise performance a step down
Toothwalker wrote:
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg



I confronted this question way back when trying to decide between the 5DsR (cancelled AA) and the 5Ds (with AA-filtering).

I did a bunch of tests of raw files and, if I looked very closely at images at very high magnifications I could see the subtle softening effect of the AA filtering on the original raw files.

However…

The full post-processing workflow is different depending on which source image you use. I found that I would typically apply sharpening with lower “amount” and smaller “radius” in the non-AA-filtered files and a bit more of each in the AA filtered files.

Once I did that, in the end the files were virtually indistinguishable.
Aug 08, 2024 at 09:17 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.3 #14R5II noise performance a step down
Mike_5D wrote:
bernardl wrote
Hairy Heron wrote
bernardl wroteTrue, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see if that happens now that all of Nikon's upper end FF bodies have been refreshed. (I think the Z7 III is the Z8, just rebranded for a fresh start).
The thing is that 24mp APS-C offers no advantage over 45mp full frame, it's basically the same pixel density.
Cost


Bulk. Weight. (of camera and lenses)
Aug 08, 2024 at 09:18 AM
Toothwalker
Offline
Details
p.3 #15R5II noise performance a step down
docusync wrote:
That seems like a JPEG compression thing. Try switching from JPEG to raw and it will be more readable:
https://bit.ly/46EFlbN


When I saw these artifacts I wondered whether it could be a compression thing, but I rejected the idea because that should not happen with a > 20 MB JPEG file.

Anyway, I downloaded some files and opened them in Lightroom. There is no difference for the Z8 between raw and JPEG. Strangely, the R5II raw file looks a bit worse than the JPEG, also depending on the shutter mode. We can see artifacts with all cameras if we play with their settings, but the Z8 is the worst when it comes to legibility of the small print.


garyvot wrote:
I am pretty sure the Z8 has an AA filter, though it may be on the weak side. I suspect that you could eliminate most of that moiré with Adobe's "Enhanced" demosaic algorithm though.


Yup. It improves the readability. It takes a long time though on my PC.



numbertwo wrote:
Not saying that I don’t agree, but maybe showing jpg is not the most appropriate to make your point.


Fair enough, but it was the highest quality and I did not detect a difference.



gdanmitchell wrote:
I confronted this question way back when trying to decide between the 5DsR (cancelled AA) and the 5Ds (with AA-filtering).

I did a bunch of tests of raw files and, if I looked very closely at images at very high magnifications I could see the subtle softening effect of the AA filtering on the original raw files.

However…

The full post-processing workflow is different depending on which source image you use. I found that I would typically apply sharpening with lower “amount” and smaller “radius” in the non-AA-filtered files and a bit more of each in the AA filtered files.

Once I
...Show more →


I remember that several people compared them side by side and found it very hard to tell the difference between the two. I would have chosen the 5Ds just to be safe, but that is me. I never sharpen my images by the way, except after downsizing.
Aug 08, 2024 at 02:23 PM
armd
Offline
Details
p.3 #16R5II noise performance a step down
garyvot wrote:
Toothwalker wrote
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg
I am pretty sure the Z8 has an AA filter, though it may be on the weak side. I suspect that you could eliminate most of that moiré with Adobe's "Enhanced" demosaic algorithm though.


The Z8 does not have an AA filter. https://www.zsystemuser.com/z-mount-cameras/z-camera-database/nikon-z8-specifications.html
Aug 08, 2024 at 06:02 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.3 #17R5II noise performance a step down
I would advise to try Capture One moire removal function, it works well.

Since they have the sharpest sensors and lenses they know a thing or 2 about moire issues.

Cheers,
Bernard
Aug 08, 2024 at 07:30 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.3 #18R5II noise performance a step down
Mike_5D wrote:
bernardl wrote
Hairy Heron wrote
bernardl wroteTrue, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see if that happens now that all of Nikon's upper end FF bodies have been refreshed. (I think the Z7 III is the Z8, just rebranded for a fresh start).
The thing is that 24mp APS-C offers no advantage over 45mp full frame, it's basically the same pixel density.
Cost


Sure, I was speaking about technical abilities for birding. But even on cost, considering the cost of the serious birding lenses the difference of body price is pretty minor, isn't it?

Cheers,
Bernard

Aug 08, 2024 at 07:32 PM
garyvot
Offline
Details
p.3 #19R5II noise performance a step down
armd wrote:
garyvot wrote
Toothwalker wrote
docusync wroteYes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.
No AA filter adds more crap than that it improves resolution. I clicked on the link in the first post and moved the window around. From the looks of it, the Z8 has no AA filter. At first glance it looks a bit more crisp than the R5 II, and this is probably what appeals to some people. However, crispness is not the same as resolution. Try to read the small print below and then talk about AA filters and resolution.

https://www.vanwalree.com/temp/aatext.jpg
I am pretty sure the Z8 has an AA filter, though it may be on the weak side. I suspect that you could eliminate most of that moiré with Adobe's "Enhanced" demosaic algorithm though.
The Z8 does not have an AA filter. https://www.zsystemuser.com/z-mount-cameras/z-camera-database/nikon-z8-specifications.html


Thank you for the clarification.
Aug 08, 2024 at 08:59 PM
Yaniv
Offline
Details
p.3 #20R5II noise performance a step down
How did they do the comparison?

The official RAW format is not out yet, Adobe can read the raw file but they are stating that the image quality is not yet finalized which means may be noisier.


https://helpx.adobe.com/camera-raw/kb/camera-raw-plug-supported-cameras.html#Preliminary_Support_meaning


I think they jumped the gun here. Am I missing something?
Aug 08, 2024 at 10:44 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister