fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024R5II noise performance a step down

  
 
_Refraction
Offline
Details
p.2 #1R5II noise performance a step down
rscheffler wrote:
My interpretation is that Canon's tradeoffs have consistently been in favor of speed and AF performance (and video), which has not benefitted some genres the way it has others. I'm in the speed camp and am happy with Canon's direction, but can appreciate it's not what everyone prefers.



Agreed. I don't mean to be selfish but I bought into the GFX system ~6 years ago for landscape and so if there's only going to be one body and there have to be trade-offs I would actually prefer that Canon optimised for speed and AF and high ISO performance.

rscheffler wrote:
An R5IIs (s for slow ) would have takers. Given how many are eyeing or moving to the Fijifilm GFX series, you'd think this might be on Canon's radar...


I do really feel for the remaining Canon landscape shooters from the 5Ds/5Dsr era who are probably feeling left out. And I wonder if it would really be that hard for instance to scale up the R7 sensor (even if not stacked), use the R5 II body, and omit the AA filter - that would at least serve that market who aren't being addressed right now. The costs might be higher for a more niche product but I reckon there is still a decent market out there for people who want to use their RF and older EF glass for landscape albeit on a more modern and higher resolution body.

Aug 07, 2024 at 02:17 AM
_Refraction
Offline
Details
p.2 #2R5II noise performance a step down
tsunathanh wrote:
DP Review posted some studio test shots. The R5 and Z8 look cleaner and have higher DR than the R5II in most (all?) of the comparisons.

https://www.dpreview.com/articles/2189397463/canon-eos-r5-ii-added-to-studio-scene


I'm really struggling to see much of a difference between the R5 and R5 II noise performance in the DPreview tool - haven't looked at the Z8. Where are you or others seeing substantial differences, would you mind pointing me to the areas where you see this?

I've been looking at the RAW performance in both EFCS and e-shutter. The character of the noise looks a bit different in some areas of the test chart but not hugely different, and I'm not sure if that is a (random) shot noise difference, or truly different read noise, or something else.

Aug 07, 2024 at 02:24 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #3R5II noise performance a step down

_Refraction wrote:
tsunathanh wroteDP Review posted some studio test shots. The R5 and Z8 look cleaner and have higher DR than the R5II in most (all?) of the comparisons.

https://www.dpreview.com/articles/2189397463/canon-eos-r5-ii-added-to-studio-scene
I'm really struggling to see much of a difference between the R5 and R5 II noise performance in the DPreview tool - haven't looked at the Z8. Where are you or others seeing substantial differences, would you mind pointing me to the areas where you see this?

I've been looking at the RAW performance in both EFCS and e-shutter. The character of the noise looks a bit different in some areas of the test chart but not hugely different, and I'm not sure if that is a (random) shot noise difference, or truly different read noise, or something else.


We are looking at exposure latitude. Open the link in the first post, then click on the link in the text that is blue and says something like "Noisier than those of the EOS R5"
Aug 07, 2024 at 02:26 AM
_Refraction
Offline
Details
p.2 #4R5II noise performance a step down
docusync wrote:
Yes, I'd love to have a modern mirrorless "5DsR" myself, and no AA filter please - it's just a waste of resolution.


Agreed for landscape however for action where moire can be an issue, I'm fine with a weak AA filter to avoid having to manually process sequences that are otherwise fine to share in JPEG form on the web.

My GFX 50R was my all time moire producing champion and although the 100MP bodies do this much less (apparently due to the higher sampling and Fuji giving up in the small pixel aperture thing), I'm a bit scarred from the post I've had to do on clothing where I didn't realise there was severe moire at shooting time. Definitely don't want to be dealing with that for action sequences.
Aug 07, 2024 at 02:29 AM
_Refraction
Offline
Details
p.2 #5R5II noise performance a step down
alundeb wrote:
We are looking at exposure latitude. Open the link in the first post, then click on the link in the text that is blue and says something like "Noisier than those of the EOS R5"


Ah I see, thanks, I was looking at the ISO comparisons.

I see more chroma noise in the +6 stop pushed R5 II shots, but I see more of a magenta shift in the R5. Not sure if that makes it worse or simply different?

NB: I just included the GFX 100s in the comparison test which makes me a bit doubtful about the capture methodology...while I've never done a 6 stop push I've done plenty of ~3 or so stop pushes which have been much cleaner looking than what this chart suggests.
Aug 07, 2024 at 02:40 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #6R5II noise performance a step down
_Refraction wrote:
alundeb wroteWe are looking at exposure latitude. Open the link in the first post, then click on the link in the text that is blue and says something like "Noisier than those of the EOS R5"
Ah I see, thanks, I was looking at the ISO comparisons.

I see more chroma noise in the +6 stop pushed R5 II shots, but I see more of a magenta shift in the R5. Not sure if that makes it worse or simply different?

NB: I just included the GFX 100s in the comparison test which makes me a bit doubtful about the capture methodology...while I've never done a 6 stop push I've done plenty of ~3 or so stop pushes which have been much cleaner looking than what this chart suggests.

Color cast and fixed pattern noise is far more detrimental than regular noise grain in my opinion. The R5II looks good, and visually I don't see any signs of noise reduction applied either.

I think DPR interprets the results wrongly. I don't see any tradeoff for speed, only more natural looking lifted shadows.

If you want to see how bad the shadows used to be, include the 5D III and normalize the image size.

Aug 07, 2024 at 02:47 AM
gkinard1952
Online
Details
p.2 #7R5II noise performance a step down
When you put it all together there is no reason to buy Canon at this stage for birding. Remind me more and more like Intel at this stage.

Edited on Aug 07, 2024 at 03:37 AM · View previous versions
Aug 07, 2024 at 03:25 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #8R5II noise performance a step down


gkinard1952 wrote:
When you put it all together there is no reason to buy Canon at this stage for birding.


What is wrong with the R5II for birding?
Aug 07, 2024 at 03:36 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.2 #9R5II noise performance a step down
alundeb wrote:
gkinard1952 wroteWhen you put it all together there is no reason to buy Canon at this stage for birding.
What is wrong with the R5II for birding?


This was discussed a lot in a recent thread. My personal understanding is that the main topic is lenses compared to Nikon.

The overall conclusion was that Canon has a nice line up with casual wildlife shooters but that demanding photographers are better served by Nikon's lens offering.

Considering that all the bodies feature amazing levels of AF performance, the lenses are clearly the deciding factor these days,

Cheers,
Bernard
Aug 07, 2024 at 05:37 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.2 #10R5II noise performance a step down

bernardl wrote:
alundeb wrote
gkinard1952 wroteWhen you put it all together there is no reason to buy Canon at this stage for birding.
What is wrong with the R5II for birding?
This was discussed a lot in a recent thread. My personal understanding is that the main topic is lenses compared to Nikon.

The overall conclusion was that Canon has a nice line up with casual wildlife shooters but that demanding photographers are better served by Nikon's lens offering.

Considering that all the bodies feature amazing levels of AF performance, the lenses are clearly the deciding factor these days,

Cheers,
Bernard

I know the discussion about the lenses. The reason I asked was the "no reason" and the "putting it all together", and the context of low ISO dynamic range of the R5II.
The "no reason" obviously depends on your preferences when it comes to lenses. So I was curious about the camera part.

The headline for the topic can easily be misunderstood, especially if you don't read more than the headline. In that case it is misleading.

Aug 07, 2024 at 05:43 AM
Hairy Heron
Offline
Details
p.2 #11R5II noise performance a step down
bernardl wrote:
The overall conclusion was that Canon has a nice line up with casual wildlife shooters but that demanding photographers are better served by Nikon's lens offering.




I don't think "casual" vs "demanding" is an accurate comparison. In fact, in the context of the discussion those words have no meaning at all. A hobbyist, which I would consider a "casual" user, can be technically demanding. Then again, some would consider a "casual" user as someone who goes on a hike with a camera and photographs animal as they encounter them with no thought to composition or waiting for a specific moment to occur at an unknown time -- just a snapshot. So it's a nebulous classification.

I agree Nikon has the better wildlife lenses these days, but Canon still has the edge on cameras. I shot Nikon for many years but the AF on its first two mirrorless generations was lackluster and I gave up after the Z7 II. Nikon has caught up now, but not eclipsed either Canon or Sony. I'm not enticed to switch back even if I do lust after a couple of those Z lenses. If I was starting from scratch it might be a tough call. But if Nikon ever makes a "Z500," I'm all in. To me the absence of a pro-grade crop sensor body is where all the camera makers fail wildlife shooters. The D500, after all was one of Nikon's best sellers until it was discontinued.
Aug 07, 2024 at 06:24 AM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.2 #12R5II noise performance a step down
Hairy Heron wrote:
bernardl wroteThe overall conclusion was that Canon has a nice line up with casual wildlife shooters but that demanding photographers are better served by Nikon's lens offering.
I don't think "casual" vs "demanding" is an accurate comparison. In fact, in the context of the discussion those words have no meaning at all. A hobbyist, which I would consider a "casual" user, can be technically demanding. Then again, some would consider a "casual" user as someone who goes on a hike with a camera and photographs animal as they encounter them with no thought to composition or waiting for a specific moment to occur at an unknown time -- just a snapshot. So it's a nebulous classification.

I agree Nikon has the better wildlife lenses these days, but
...Show more →

True, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
Aug 07, 2024 at 06:35 AM
_Refraction
Offline
Details
p.2 #13R5II noise performance a step down
alundeb wrote:
Color cast and fixed pattern noise is far more detrimental than regular noise grain in my opinion.


I'm somewhat agnostic at these big pushes/higher ISOs as I wouldn't use them without some sort of noise reduction, and these days Adobe's advanced NR and DxO's for example seem to deal with pattern noise pretty well. I haven't encountered colour casts though.

alundeb wroteIf you want to see how bad the shadows used to be, include the 5D III and normalize the image size.


Owned one for years and still have heaps of 5D3 files in my archives...so I don't need any convincing on that front!
Aug 07, 2024 at 06:42 AM
gkinard1952
Online
Details
p.2 #14R5II noise performance a step down
alundeb wrote:
gkinard1952 wroteWhen you put it all together there is no reason to buy Canon at this stage for birding.
What is wrong with the R5II for birding?


Nothing really, was just thinking outloud. Most of my birding is "birds on a stick". Unless the R5 II has mind bending AF then I will pick up a used R5 and an adapter. Waiting on the beta tester now. Worked out for me. I am not in the US anyway. Won't be back until Late October.
Aug 07, 2024 at 06:52 AM
Hairy Heron
Offline
Details
p.2 #15R5II noise performance a step down
bernardl wrote:
True, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard



The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see if that happens now that all of Nikon's upper end FF bodies have been refreshed. (I think the Z7 III is the Z8, just rebranded for a fresh start).
Aug 07, 2024 at 08:19 AM
gkinard1952
Online
Details
p.2 #16R5II noise performance a step down
Hairy Heron wrote:
bernardl wroteTrue, but the D500's only advantage compared to a D850 was AF field coverage which isn't relevant in mirrorless anymore.

A Z90 would have to be at least 32mp for it to make sense compared to a Z8/Z9 and feature a fully stacked sensor.

I believe one such camera is coming, but no idea when.

Cheers,
Bernard
The D500 was based on Nikon's flagship D5 and had a similar build quality sans built-in grip and pro-like features, which is my distinction. It was released well before the D 850. Right now there are zero comparable crop sensor mirrorless bodies, they are all, at best high-end consumer grade. I have an R7 in my kit, but the R7 has a lot missing. It's not well weather sealed, AF is finicky, and not great in low light. I'd be fine with a 24mp crop with great DR and low light abilities, so 33 would be amazing. We'll see
...Show more →

Hope you are right about Nikon releasing a high quality crop camera. That is the only thing that will make me switch. I would jump on that fast, with the 600pf... My dream machine. Throw it in a backpack with my clothes and never look back. I have a feeling it won't be long now.

Aug 07, 2024 at 08:22 AM
FlashBazbo
Offline
Details
p.2 #17R5II noise performance a step down
We need to remember what this camera is for. Look at the Canon official previews. Above everything else, this is a camera built for the wedding photographer. Since wedding photography is where most full-time professional photographers in the U.S. make a living, it's hard to fault Canon's strategy. Very few photographers in the U.S. make a living without doing wedding photography anymore. It is THE big professional market. And nowadays, it requires mixing a lot of spontaneous video in with the stills.

Given that . . . Canon is smart to focus the R5ii as they have. While the R5ii retains huge versatility for the diversified shooter, it has amazing specs for wedding shooters -- and especially for those who now shoot a lot of video along the way. In that use case, the noise difference isn't going to matter. The new video features more than make up for it for the people this camera is intended for.
Aug 07, 2024 at 08:43 AM
Jeff
Offline
Details
p.2 #18R5II noise performance a step down
bernardl wrote:
I am sure that Canon, Nikon and Sony all 3 have high megapixel cameras in the development pipe that prioritize image quality over speed. I see them coming at around 90mp and I see them coming in the next 6 months.


Right. Remove Canon from that statement and I'd agree. We've now been waiting a long, long time for the 5Ds successor, and there is zero noise from Canon that it will ever happen. Zero.

FlashBazbo wrote:
We need to remember what this camera is for. Look at the Canon official previews. Above everything else, this is a camera built for the wedding photographer. Since wedding photography is where most full-time professional photographers in the U.S. make a living, it's hard to fault Canon's strategy. Very few photographers in the U.S. make a living without doing wedding photography anymore. It is THE big professional market. And nowadays, it requires mixing a lot of spontaneous video in with the stills.

Given that . . . Canon is smart to focus the R5ii as they have. While the R5ii retains
...Show more →

Spoken like a... wedding photographer. Agree that it's a great camera for weddings/events. And product. And headshots/portraits. Etc.
Aug 07, 2024 at 09:59 AM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #19R5II noise performance a step down
garyvot wrote:
alundeb wroteLooks like they turned off the noise reduction in the raw files, by request from Nikon users

The profile looks a bit different, but color and detail seems well preserved even at +6 EV (EFCS)
WRT DR, photographs that require pulling shadows by +6EV are probably failed to begin with, IMO, so minor differences seen at the very extremes are kind of academic, I think.



There you go making sense again. Nobody's gonna put up with that

Let's all complain about Canon's resolution, when Nikon still hasn't passed 45mp and Sony took 4 years to pass the 5DsR, then only marginally. If you compare it to 33x44 you might get ahead on the larger sensor, but only a little, and look at the considerable tradeoffs in weight, lenses, etc. Not even a real comparison

But of course comparing to 33x44 instead of the other FF makes it easier to bash Canon. Which is probably the whole point
Aug 07, 2024 at 10:50 AM
gkinard1952
Online
Details
p.2 #20R5II noise performance a step down
In birding I base my exposure on the birds bill. Then lift the shodows or highlights. Rarely do I ever go above 1or below 1. If I really really missed my exposure I might go 2. But, at this point for me it is rare. So, this would never be a problem for me. Shooting birds on s stick like I do, looks like the R5 is a little cleaner. Or about the same. So, only reason I would go for the R5II is faster readout and pre-capture. Since I am used to shooting with an ancient camera I am not sure the better AF would help that much. But, curious to find out. If I missed by 2 or 3 I would never open the file anyway.
Aug 07, 2024 at 02:35 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister