I had seen it mentioned how the A7RV EVF drops quality in AF-C, that is interesting to see in practice, the moire it introduces is...gross. Overall, not as blown away by the 9+mil pixels as I thought I would be, but image review is very nice.
I did an A/B test with EyeAF on my kid, just because we've been discussing iris vs eyelash focus on the Z8/Z9 in another thread...and boy oh boy, the Sony AF is just so much more surefooted for that. Kind of wild.
Would be interesting to see how the GFX 100S II fares there.
An interesting use case...close focus at 70mm on both. Here the Sony outperforms the Nikon in regards to details at f/9 by a reasonable margin. This is a shot I'd typically shoot at 120mm on the Nikon, so it was interesting to see it struggle at bit at 70mm. Both lenses have a .39x mag, just two different ways to get there.
Worth a nit pick: EVF is only 3.1 mega pixels. Maybe 1.5? when it drops quality.
Of course, 9.something million dots sounds way more impresive.
Nikon's EVF low dot count wins no pissing contests but impresses many who actually use it.
(while photographing, reviewing of course, the Sony is great)
RoamingScott wrote:
I had seen it mentioned how the A7RV EVF drops quality in AF-C, that is interesting to see in practice, the moire it introduces is...gross. Overall, not as blown away by the 9+mil pixels as I thought I would be, but image review is very nice.
I did an A/B test with EyeAF on my kid, just because we've been discussing iris vs eyelash focus on the Z8/Z9 in another thread...and boy oh boy, the Sony AF is just so much more surefooted for that. Kind of wild.
Would be interesting to see how the GFX 100S II fares there.
Choderboy wrote:
Worth a nit pick: EVF is only 3.1 mega pixels. Maybe 1.5? when it drops quality.
Of course, 9.something million dots sounds way more impresive.
Nikon's EVF low dot count wins no pissing contests but impresses many who actually use it.
(while photographing, reviewing of course, the Sony is great)
RoamingScott wroteI had seen it mentioned how the A7RV EVF drops quality in AF-C, that is interesting to see in practice, the moire it introduces is...gross. Overall, not as blown away by the 9+mil pixels as I thought I would be, but image review is very nice.
I did an A/B test with EyeAF on my kid, just because we've been discussing iris vs eyelash focus on the Z8/Z9 in another thread...and boy oh boy, the Sony AF is just so much more surefooted for that. Kind of wild.
Would be interesting to see how the GFX 100S II fares there.
Yes, this is the rub. The composing and shooting with the Nikon wins handily, and it completely falls apart on image review
Took a walk around the neighborhood, and the 20-70 is a great little lens for that. I can see why it's popular for light travel, blogging, etc. It's got nice IQ with a functional range, and for that crowd, corner performance and bubbly bokeh means nothing.
RoamingScott wrote:
An interesting use case...close focus at 70mm on both. Here the Sony outperforms the Nikon in regards to details at f/9 by a reasonable margin. This is a shot I'd typically shoot at 120mm on the Nikon, so it was interesting to see it struggle at bit at 70mm. Both lenses have a .39x mag, just two different ways to get there.
RoamingScott wrote:
There are so many variables that go into all of this that it's really not possible to make a fully informed decision without all of it in your hands.
For example, when I was comparing Sony and Nikon before I made that switch, I had people saying they couldn't see any difference between the transition zones on the Nikon and Sony 100-400 lenses...well, after shooting thousands of images with each, the differences (in favor of the Nikon) were readily apparent to me. If the improvements the Nikon offer don't matter to someone, or they didn't have enough experience to know what to look for to make a qualified statement, they'd come to a thread like this and proclaim "the 100-400GM is just as good" without knowing how or why they are wrong.
So yeah, these threads are useful for gaining a GENERAL sense of what people see, and why they make the decisions they make...but there are plenty of people shooting GFX that are straight up wasting their money if they think their results are better than what FF could give them, simply because they aren't at the GFX level of skill. That doesn't matter of course, everyone is free to do as they please, but there is a level of finesse required to maximize the gains when we get to this edge of photography.
And after 6 pages, we have one online article derided for its failures in A/B testing, a few folks that have both, or HAD both, and decided that the heft wasn't worth it and use their Sony stuff more, and a bunch of people justifying their purchase on one side of the house without having tried the other ...Show more →
MF users reminds me of tradies that drive RAMS and tow a trailer instead of just buying a Toyota aluminium tray back that is way more productive and practical 😁
gear-nut wrote: Daran wroterdeloe wroteAztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”...Show more →
smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.
I consider the rV's EVF to be a gift to manual lens shooters. There's no focusing aides necessary when you can just see what's in focus. I'm fine with the performance when I use continuous AF, but I've got the max FPS set to six.
I'm surprised more people aren't talking about what joys the 100s and 50sII are to use. I was and am very impressed with those cameras. Ergonomically, I find them very comfortable in hand and the controls/custom buttons to be easy to reach with enough separation between them to keep them well-defined in muscle memory. They're not button-crazy, but there are enough and you get six custom setting slots to help define situational behavior for the camera. The EVF and LCD are enough, but, if I were looking now, I'd hold out for the upgrade in the 100sII. The top LCD's huge and crystal clear, though it can get cluttered.
The UI's packed with features, but has a nice layout. It's the first camera I've had where I like the image profiles, particularly mono emulations and the three color digital filters you can apply. If you get shots with the profile and think it captures it all, you can process a TIFF of it in camera and export it with your RAWs. It gives a bloated but nicely robust file for any further editing you want to do. Most of the shots I processed like that got some minor curve adjustments, cropped for printing aspect ratio, and went to the printer. I thought I might use that feature more when I started with it, but I mostly used it to remember profiled shots I thought would make good prints.
I think the cameras were successfully designed to make late-model DSLR shooters feel comfortable with them. The AF is disappointing for those coming from smaller format cameras, but compared to the SLR medium format cameras, it's snappy and far more accurate. They may be large by mirrorless standards, but they're very compact by medium format standards and they packed that larger sensor, great IBIS, focal plane shutter, and giant mount into a body smaller than either the the 5D IV or D850. Fuji gives you a lot of reasons to want to use them beyond any perceived jump in quality over what the best of the 135 format cameras can produce with quality lenses and good technique. If you're really interested in maximizing the quality of the 100MP sensor, look to Hasselblad. Their reliance on central shutters is a pain point for people adapting lenses, but it pays off quite a bit with long exposures and exposure bracketing.
I enjoyed my time with the 50sII because Fuji did a lot right with it. I went back to Sony because it was easier to normalize a lens kit 180 and wider with my mono-converted a7rII, which is my primary camera. That and the 300GM won't adapt to the GFX. I doubt I'll ever return to the format, but I don't regret the year I spent with the 50sII.
p.8 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: Choderboy wroteWould be interesting to see how the GFX 100S II fares there.from what ive read it is not good at all at eye af. let alone focusing on the iris.
Well, if the 100SII AF is anything like the 100II (and I think they’re the same in AF), then I have to say that eye af is good. Even VERY good for MF! Could it be improved? Sure, but so could the Sony AF. I know, because I’ve used the Sony (A7RIV), and now using the GFX100II.
p.8 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: gear-nut wroteDaran wroterdeloe wroteAztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.
p.8 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: A74me wrotegear-nut wroteDaran wroterdeloe wroteAztatlan wroteBy all means compare on factors like dynamic range, noise, etc, but testing sharpness is largely redundant.It's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.Uh no.
ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.
p.8 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
@A74me Well...if you're happy with those kind of results, then be happy. I would certainly not be happy. They just don' t look sharp enough and focal point is weird.
Just curious....are you happy with those results? If so, why?
p.8 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Mujabad123 wrote:
@A74me@ Well...if you're happy with those kind of results, then be happy. I would certainly not be happy. They just don' t look sharp enough and focal point is weird.
Just curious....are you happy with those results? If so, why?
its a demonstration of how the eye is focused not the eye lash or fur.
p.8 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: Choderboy wroteWould be interesting to see how the GFX 100S II fares there.from what ive read it is not good at all at eye af. let alone focusing on the iris.
Interesting. I did not say that though. It was RoamingScott.
p.8 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: gear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteDaran wroterdeloe wroteIt's difficult to compare sharpness, but it's only redundant if you don't care about it. I don't think it's unreasonable as a comparison point if we're comparing high end systems like these.If you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.Uh no.ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.
Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.
p.8 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote: A74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteDaran wroteIf you shoot high resolution sensors through a low resolving optic, the predictable result is that the higher resolution sensor gains you rather little. So using that to evaluate the actual relative merits of those sensors is pointless.
Of course another great leveler is aperture. For landscapes you'd usually wana shoot closed up apertures for it's larger DOF, but that will also limit the achievable resolution. And this effect is independent of sensor size: as you close the larger and the smaller sensor systems to equivalent apertures, the limiting effect of diffraction will also be equivalent.Yes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.Uh no.ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.
totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.
p.8 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: Mujabad123 wrote@A74me@@@ Well...if you're happy with those kind of results, then be happy. I would certainly not be happy. They just don' t look sharp enough and focal point is weird.
Just curious....are you happy with those results? If so, why?its a demonstration of how the eye is focused not the eye lash or fur.
In that case I would like the eye to be more visible. Hardly visible how good the eye itself is focused.
p.8 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
A74me wrote: gear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteA74me wrotegear-nut wroteYes but. Even with a lesser optic, more mp almost always gives you smoother tonality, which frankly is what I think gives MF the “look” edge over Fx capture in the first place — this in turn adds to gentler transitions into the oof areas, also adding to that MF look. Then add any higher contrast edge, and even the poorer lenses can resolve it on the high mp sensor, and it’s smoother due to the higher mp count, and this in turn adds to the impression of greater overall “sharpness” even though there is lower micro contrast. Finally, lesser lenses usually have other optical imperfections, like a little more flare which can open up shadows in high contrast scenes, again enhancing the impression of smoothness, albeit at the expense of micro detail. But combine all that, and now getting a unique look to the images AND/OR the best resolution (when using best glass) is the reign of MF capture — but almost always at the cost of flexibility…
Now whether those subtleties are worth the loss of flexibility in weight gain, focal limitation and cost to the individual photographer are arguable, and ultimately up to that individual as to how they want to create their art or want it to “look.”smoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.Uh no.ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.
Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.