fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Choderboy wrote:
Worth a nit pick: EVF is only 3.1 mega pixels. Maybe 1.5? when it drops quality.
Of course, 9.something million dots sounds way more impresive.
Nikon's EVF low dot count wins no pissing contests but impresses many who actually use it.
(while photographing, reviewing of course, the Sony is great)



What I also noticed right away between the two is how much brighter Nikon's EVF is.
This really helps in some shooting situations.

In practice I was never amazed by image reviewing in the A7RV EVF. Sure it has loads of resolution, but even when turning sharpening and noise reduction all the way down the EVF still showed me details that looked slightly mushy/oversharpened (when checking focus at 100%).
Just not a look I enjoy.

Interesting to read your findings Scott.
Your first impressions of the Sony 20-70 mimic mine. It's size is great, but it leans too much on strong software corrections. When I tested it I was often disappointed by the (extreme) corners.
May 29, 2024 at 07:09 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
The brightness of the Z9 EVF is a double edged sword...it's great on sunny days, but you have to remember to lean on the hard-to-read histogram because your files will be noticeably darker than what you're seeing in the EVF.
May 29, 2024 at 07:15 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
The brightness of the Z9 EVF is a double edged sword...it's great on sunny days, but you have to remember to lean on the hard-to-read histogram because your files will be noticeably darker than what you're seeing in the EVF.


True, but in the end it's always better to trust your histogram.
I like that I can see a scene better when composing an image.

On this topic also:

Even when selecting the "sunny weather" option on the A7RV the LCD is still quite dim.
On the A7RIII it was quite a bit brighter.
A bit annoying in those brighter conditions/when the sun is hitting your camera.



Edited on May 29, 2024 at 07:33 AM · View previous versions
May 29, 2024 at 07:25 AM
tsdevine
Online
Details
p.9 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

Wow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.
May 29, 2024 at 07:32 AM
IndyFab
Online
Details
p.9 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I might have also thrown into the mix for consideration the Hasselblad X2D

Medium Format
100mp BSI CMOS Sensor 1
Ibis 5-Axis 7-Stop In-Body Image Stabilisation
PDAF Phase Detection Autofocus
1TB Built-In SSD
15 stops Dynamic Range
16 bit Colour Depth
Hasselblad Natural Colour Solution

https://www.hasselblad.com/x-system/x2d-100c/

**DEEP POCKETS**

Edited on May 29, 2024 at 07:40 AM · View previous versions
May 29, 2024 at 07:34 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.9 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
tsdevine wrote:
Wow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.


I was editing my image before I saw this reply.

It was not a deal breaker for me, but the A7RV isn't very bright at all. It's noticeable more dim than the A7RIII.
May 29, 2024 at 07:35 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
IndyFab wrote:
I might have also thrown into the mix for consideration the Hasseblad X2D

Medium Format
100mp BSI CMOS Sensor 1
Ibis 5-Axis 7-Stop In-Body Image Stabilisation
PDAF Phase Detection Autofocus
1TB Built-In SSD
15 stops Dynamic Range
16 bit Colour Depth
Hasselblad Natural Colour Solution

https://www.hasselblad.com/x-system/x2d-100c/

**DEEP POCKETS**


Pockets ain't that deep, and relearning a post app is not on my current to-do
May 29, 2024 at 07:38 AM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Some A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.

You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.

The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily
...Show more →

Is the Sony first, Nikon second in this A/B testing?
May 29, 2024 at 07:56 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
patotts wrote:
RoamingScott wroteSome A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.

You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.

The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily apparent where the Nikon remains rather flat looking.

I see no tangible detail advantages on the Sony files.

Immediate takeaway: if I'm potentially willing to carry a Fuji with far less range than the 24-120, why am I unwilling to carry the Z9 and 24-120, which is a world class optic in this category. Food for thought I don't see the Sony 20-70 being a serious competitor for this particular lens range for me.

24

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787733_ffbc1f3521_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011680_bec8bfb6f5_o.jpg

28

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753922044_b407f06517_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920874_02fb2fa36b_o.jpg

35

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787168_c15a4c5bf4_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920794_fc24cba2a3_o.jpg

50

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753921379_c18bd143f7_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920804_105ff5ac61_o.jpg

70

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011135_9b602a4f4d_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53752677737_2d9052c074_o.jpg
Is the Sony first, Nikon second in this A/B testing?


Other way around
May 29, 2024 at 08:04 AM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
patotts wrote
RoamingScott wroteSome A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.

You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.

The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily apparent where the Nikon remains rather flat looking.

I see no tangible detail advantages on the Sony files.

Immediate takeaway: if I'm potentially willing to carry a Fuji with far less range than the 24-120, why am I unwilling to carry the Z9 and 24-120, which is a world class optic in this category. Food for thought I don't see the Sony 20-70 being a serious competitor for this particular lens range for me.

24

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787733_ffbc1f3521_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011680_bec8bfb6f5_o.jpg

28

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753922044_b407f06517_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920874_02fb2fa36b_o.jpg

35

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787168_c15a4c5bf4_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920794_fc24cba2a3_o.jpg

50

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753921379_c18bd143f7_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920804_105ff5ac61_o.jpg

70

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011135_9b602a4f4d_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53752677737_2d9052c074_o.jpg
Is the Sony first, Nikon second in this A/B testing?
Other way around


That was my first impression because of the warmer white balance, and a bit more punch file, but then you got me confused with the order of the other test :-)

Funny thought, I don't find my a7RV files to be as warm as yours?! Are you using LR Classic latest version? Which RAW profile? Adobe's standard?
May 29, 2024 at 08:07 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.9 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Jochenb wrote:
tsdevine wroteWow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.
I was editing my image before I saw this reply.

It was not a deal breaker for me, but the A7RV isn't very bright at all. It's noticeable more dim than the A7RIII.


I think there might be something wrong with your rV EVF.
May 29, 2024 at 09:01 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
patotts wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
patotts wrote
RoamingScott wroteSome A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.

You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.

The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily apparent where the Nikon remains rather flat looking.

I see no tangible detail advantages on the Sony files.

Immediate takeaway: if I'm potentially willing to carry a Fuji with far less range than the 24-120, why am I unwilling to carry the Z9 and 24-120, which is a world class optic in this category. Food for thought I don't see the Sony 20-70 being a serious competitor for this particular lens range for me.

24

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787733_ffbc1f3521_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011680_bec8bfb6f5_o.jpg

28

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753922044_b407f06517_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920874_02fb2fa36b_o.jpg

35

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787168_c15a4c5bf4_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920794_fc24cba2a3_o.jpg

50

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753921379_c18bd143f7_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920804_105ff5ac61_o.jpg

70

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011135_9b602a4f4d_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53752677737_2d9052c074_o.jpg
Is the Sony first, Nikon second in this A/B testing?
Other way around
That was my first impression because of the warmer white balance, and a bit more punch file, but then you got me confused with the order of the other test :-)

Funny thought, I don't find my a7RV files to be as warm as yours?! Are you using LR Classic latest version? Which RAW profile? Adobe's standard?


LR Classic, all defaults. I see the Sony "camera matching profiles" are as useless as they've always been that's once nice part about Nikon, they are great starting off points for different use cases, but without totally changing the colors like the Sony ones do.
May 29, 2024 at 09:10 AM
jmmaher
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
freaklikeme wrote:
Jochenb wrote
tsdevine wroteWow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.
I was editing my image before I saw this reply.

It was not a deal breaker for me, but the A7RV isn't very bright at all. It's noticeable more dim than the A7RIII.
I think there might be something wrong with your rV EVF.


I have to agree. I no longer remember how bright the R3 was but the A7rV is much brighter than the A7RIV

May 29, 2024 at 10:50 AM
rmurphy
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Pixel peeping your flowers photos, I agree the Nikon seams to be a bit more front focused. It also looks like the Sony was taken from a little higher angle making it difficult to really compare Bokeh. I own the 20-70 and find the Bokeh OK but certainly not a strong point. I like using it on an a7rc/a7rv for landscapes while hiking in the Rockies but I am definitely one of those middling users.
May 29, 2024 at 11:14 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
freaklikeme wrote:
Jochenb wrote
tsdevine wroteWow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.
I was editing my image before I saw this reply.

It was not a deal breaker for me, but the A7RV isn't very bright at all. It's noticeable more dim than the A7RIII.
I think there might be something wrong with your rV EVF.


No I was talking about the LCD here, not the EVF.
The sunny weather option is only available for the LCD.

The A7RV LCD is more dim than the one on the A7RIII.
May 29, 2024 at 11:28 AM
freaklikeme
Online
Details
p.9 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Jochenb wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Jochenb wrote
tsdevine wroteWow, the Nikon must be a torch. I thought the a7R V set to Sunny Weather was pretty bright.
I was editing my image before I saw this reply.

It was not a deal breaker for me, but the A7RV isn't very bright at all. It's noticeable more dim than the A7RIII.
I think there might be something wrong with your rV EVF.
No I was talking about the LCD here, not the EVF.
The sunny weather option is only available for the LCD.

The A7RV LCD is more dim than the one on the A7RIII.


Sorry, my mistake. And I think you're right. I wonder if there was some engineering trade-off there for the flexibility of the new screen.
May 29, 2024 at 11:37 AM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
patotts wrote
RoamingScott wrote
patotts wrote
RoamingScott wroteSome A/B of a favorite setup that I like to use to test near-ish focus with lots of different elements in play. I left AWB on for both since I was curious how the Sony's "new" AWB system works.

You can view any of these full size if you open them in a new tab. I immediately noticed how "bubbly" the 20-70 bokeh is compared to the 24-120. The Nikon is, in general keeping things held together in the background better.

The corners are also a pretty stark difference at almost all focal lengths, as the 20-70's correct distortion is still readily apparent where the Nikon remains rather flat looking.

I see no tangible detail advantages on the Sony files.

Immediate takeaway: if I'm potentially willing to carry a Fuji with far less range than the 24-120, why am I unwilling to carry the Z9 and 24-120, which is a world class optic in this category. Food for thought I don't see the Sony 20-70 being a serious competitor for this particular lens range for me.

24

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787733_ffbc1f3521_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011680_bec8bfb6f5_o.jpg

28

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753922044_b407f06517_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920874_02fb2fa36b_o.jpg

35

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753787168_c15a4c5bf4_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920794_fc24cba2a3_o.jpg

50

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753921379_c18bd143f7_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53753920804_105ff5ac61_o.jpg

70

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53754011135_9b602a4f4d_o.jpg

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/53752677737_2d9052c074_o.jpg
Is the Sony first, Nikon second in this A/B testing?
Other way around
That was my first impression because of the warmer white balance, and a bit more punch file, but then you got me confused with the order of the other test :-)

Funny thought, I don't find my a7RV files to be as warm as yours?! Are you using LR Classic latest version? Which RAW profile? Adobe's standard?
LR Classic, all defaults. I see the Sony "camera matching profiles" are as useless as they've always been that's once nice part about Nikon, they are great starting off points for different use cases, but without totally changing the colors like the Sony ones do.


Hey, compared to how LR used to handle my Fujifilm files back in the day... ;-)

May 29, 2024 at 11:47 AM
A74me
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
A74me wrote
gear-nut wrote
A74me wrote
gear-nut wrote
A74me wrotesmoother tonality is a direct effect of larger pixels not higher resolution.
Uh no.
ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.
Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.
totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.
Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.


i disagree as ive shot with m43 system for 5 years with smaller pixels and the images always looked "Blocky/muddy" shooting my daughters outdoor netball with my em1mk2 compared to my then a7r2 the images from the a7r2 were life like and beautiful smooth transitions of colours compared to the olympus that were digital looking , so when it came to buying a portrait studio camera i chose the sony a74 as the best compromise on pixel size /sensor size and im not dissapointed. in fact its the best camera i have used ever for extreme macro work to 10x mag as the 5um pixels are perfect for shooting 10x objectives as smaller pixels show diffraction and loss of detail as well as low iso noise that is stacked into blobs.
May 29, 2024 at 03:59 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.9 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
m4/3 has always been a joke from an IQ perspective. Those that claim it's competitive up to full frame are the first people I stop paying attention to
May 29, 2024 at 04:04 PM
Jack Flesher
Online
Details
p.9 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


A74me wrote:
gear-nut wrote
A74me wrote
gear-nut wrote
A74me wrote
gear-nut wroteUh no.
ive been researching and direct comparisons of tonal separation from the 25yo old canon d30 3meg sensor 11um pixels no current camera can match it. no one wants to hear the facts these days they are to rapped up in more is better. im actually chasing one at the moment to have a play with.
Been there, done that, have the tee-shirt. There is a more organic look from fat pixels that perhaps someone uninitiated assumes is enhanced tonal range but it’s not — it’s probably the relative lack of noise. Smaller pixels deliver smoother and broader tonality, at least at or near base ISO’s.
totally incorrect larger pixels record more accurate voltage/charge, download any of the test charts from cameras of the stepped chart used for measuring DR and look at the how well the steps are recorded, the d30 can record perfect steps of tone, in fact no other camera can towards the ends. also download a sample image from the d30 and push the near black shadows and the tones/detail are recovered absolutely amazing.
Yes. And No. I am taking tonality across the image, not per-pixel accuracy. Fat pixels record more accurately, but they’re averaging the tonal range held within them. By contrast, pixels ⅓ the size are recording perhaps slightly less accurately individually, but combined they give you up to 9 shades within the same area as the 3x fatter pixel, in turn rendering more tonality across the image.
i disagree as ive shot with m43 system for 5 years with smaller pixels and the images always looked "Blocky/muddy" shooting my daughters outdoor netball with my em1mk2 compared to my then a7r2 the images from the a7r2 were life like and beautiful smooth transitions of colours compared to the olympus that were digital looking , so when it came to buying a portrait studio camera i chose the sony a74 as the best compromise on pixel size /sensor size and im not dissapointed. in fact its the best camera i have used ever for extreme macro work to 10x
...Show more →
We’re talking smaller pixels across the same sensor size, not m43 or cell phones. Sheesh.
May 29, 2024 at 05:08 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister