fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Yeah, different kit, different kit lens. It and the 23/4 make a nice, decently light two-lens kit.
May 26, 2024 at 04:33 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


freaklikeme wrote:
Yeah, different kit, different kit lens. It and the 23/4 make a nice, decently light two-lens kit.

Except the more useful 20-35/4 zoom actually weighs LESS than the 23/4 prime by about 125 gms, AND is about the same total size — so IMO the much better option.
May 26, 2024 at 04:47 PM
PaulMoorePhoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Short of having an awesome superzoom, the best option might be two bodies. Have you considered just trying to cover a narrow range of your most common FLs with the GFX and then using full frame or even APS-C for the rest? Just a thought because it doesn’t seem like there’s a Goldilocks lens kit for the GFX.
May 26, 2024 at 06:42 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
freaklikeme wroteYeah, different kit, different kit lens. It and the 23/4 make a nice, decently light two-lens kit.
Except the more useful 20-35/4 zoom actually weighs LESS than the 23/4 prime by about 125 gms, AND is about the same total size — so IMO the much better option.


Never used it. It released about the time I dropped the camera.
May 26, 2024 at 08:05 PM
johnvanatta
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I have a Z7 and a GFX 100s. No matter how much I tweak my GFX kit, there's simply no way I can carry the same envelope of lens with me on a hike. It's too much weight. I have to pick and choose lenses depending on what I expect/want to shoot--there's always something missing, and it's hard to avoid lens changing. Plus I have to keep a lot of similar lenses around for slightly different scenarios, since I'm always right on the edge of what's feasible. It's not a setup for a minimalist.

If I was being completely honest with myself, and was simply trying to maximize keepers, I would go hiking with the Nikon. But I have no commercial motive, more photos than I really know what to do with, and it's so satisfying when the planets align with the GFX. So I accept a decrease in hits for a higher high. TBD if that holds true for overnight backpacking, I might simply have to get the weight lower there. And I don't fully trust the build/sealing on the GFX like I do the Z7, but at least the replacement cost is manageable now if it breaks.

My highly-susceptible-to-confirmation-bias feeling is that I can 'sense' the difference between the Z7 and GFX shots viewed (without zooming) on my 32 inch, 6k monitor; but I couldn't really tell on my former 27 inch, 5k monitor.
May 26, 2024 at 09:03 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Thanks for this. What would you say is the closest you’ve come to the most “balanced” gfx kit to take for general landscape purposes?

johnvanatta wrote:
I have a Z7 and a GFX 100s. No matter how much I tweak my GFX kit, there's simply no way I can carry the same envelope of lens with me on a hike. It's too much weight. I have to pick and choose lenses depending on what I expect/want to shoot--there's always something missing, and it's hard to avoid lens changing. Plus I have to keep a lot of similar lenses around for slightly different scenarios, since I'm always right on the edge of what's feasible. It's not a setup for a minimalist.

If I was being completely honest with
...Show more →
May 26, 2024 at 09:30 PM
chiron
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
PaulMoorePhoto wrote:
Short of having an awesome superzoom, the best option might be two bodies. Have you considered just trying to cover a narrow range of your most common FLs with the GFX and then using full frame or even APS-C for the rest? Just a thought because it doesn’t seem like there’s a Goldilocks lens kit for the GFX.


I do think that the two camera-system solution is the thing that makes the most sense. Each format excels in specific contexts and there is no need to force one to work where the other is better or more satisfying.
May 26, 2024 at 10:10 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Pure insanity the implication is that I’d buy and lug a $5000 camera and $2000 lens for 30mm worth of range and then shoot the remaining 150mm on…APS-C?!

And here I’d thought I’d been very clear about my requirements

No, a two camera situation is not the play, for me at least.

PaulMoorePhoto wrote:
Short of having an awesome superzoom, the best option might be two bodies. Have you considered just trying to cover a narrow range of your most common FLs with the GFX and then using full frame or even APS-C for the rest? Just a thought because it doesn’t seem like there’s a Goldilocks lens kit for the GFX.

May 26, 2024 at 10:15 PM
johnvanatta
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
The Fuji 20-35 and 35-70 are a great start for Fuji landscape. It's roughly the same weight as the Nikon 14-24/2.8 and 24-70/4, which is something I've carried before. It's the telephoto part that gets tough. My favorite landscape telephoto is adapting the Canon 100-400, but it's heavy. Those three, packed in an insert ready to go, weights 3298g, plus another kilo for the camera. The only thing that's missing is a semi-macro (important for me) and a small gap from 70-100. But that much weight is a big issue for a long hike. [I didn't get to do the heavy field testing of this kit that I wanted to last fall since I sprained my ankle the first day. Oofk.]

In comparison, a Nikon Z kit of 14-30/4, 24-70/4, Tamron 70-300, 50/2.8 Macro only weighs 2210g. That's what I took with me to Taiwan, swapping in 35mm and 85mm primes for street shooting.

So if telephoto landscape isn't a priority, I'll drop the Canon, and switch to either a Zeiss 135/2 or CV 180/4. The Zeiss is what I'd consider "GFX 100" quality, the CV isn't quite, but it covers the sensor and is light. I didn't like the Fuji 100-200 much, finding that either of those primes was superior in some way. The Fuji 100-200 is a lens that a Sony 70-200/4 would be able to match, maybe exceed, in IQ through much of the range; especially if you're in 3:2 and wider ratios.

I haven't tried the 32-64, it's a bit of an awkward lens for me, not quite as wide as I want for landscape (I definitely want FF-20mm and occasionally go wider), and supposedly no better at f8 than the smaller 35-70, which is plenty good stopped down. If it's barely enough for you, maybe you could pair with the Canon 100-400 and have a manageable two lens kit.

I think my best answer for a balanced GFX kit would be 20-35, 35-70, Zeiss 135. All three of those lenses deliver. Could also swap the Zeiss 135 for a Fuji 120/4 Macro (I don't like GFX 120mm that much, I want longer). Or a Fuji 100-200 (decent at 100mm, meh >150mm).

Three lenses for something it sounds like you can happily cover with a Nikon 24-120 And yes, a Sony R5 + 20-70 + 70-200/4 looks extremely versatile in comparison. It never quite adds up with the GFX...but the highs are high
May 27, 2024 at 12:10 AM
PaulMoorePhoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Pure insanity the implication is that I’d buy and lug a $5000 camera and $2000 lens for 30mm worth of range and then shoot the remaining 150mm on…APS-C?!

And here I’d thought I’d been very clear about my requirements

No, a two camera situation is not the play, for me at least.

PaulMoorePhoto wroteShort of having an awesome superzoom, the best option might be two bodies. Have you considered just trying to cover a narrow range of your most common FLs with the GFX and then using full frame or even APS-C for the rest? Just a thought because it doesn’t seem like there’s a Goldilocks lens kit for the GFX.


It wasn’t implied. It was a question. And no, your requirements aren’t clear. That’s the topic. You’re trying to figure out what you really require.
May 27, 2024 at 01:25 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I mostly shoot landscapes and also print large.

I went from an A7RV (an also excellent camera) to a Nikon Z8 and I don't find the detail lacking in any way.
Reading that the detail of a 45MP sensor isn't anywhere near that of the 61MP sensor is quite funny.

Sure, the 61MP sensor gives a littlebit more detail... but at the same time very fine noise creeps in quickly. That's also why I prefered the A7RIII sensor.
Adobe's excellent noise reduction also does a nicer job with the 42/45MP sensors than with the finer noise from the 61MP sensor IMHO.

You had a Z7II vs A7RIV thread a couple of years ago Scott, where you posted your comparisons.
Back then you mentioned how clean the 45MP files are vs the 61MP ones and no mention of the lacking detail.
May 27, 2024 at 04:14 AM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Jochenb wrote:
Sure, the 61MP sensor gives a littlebit more detail... but at the same time very fine noise creeps in quickly. That's also why I prefered the A7RIII sensor.
Adobe's excellent noise reduction also does a nicer job with the 42/45MP sensors than with the finer noise from the 61MP sensor IMHO.



Yes, in all respects bar crop-ability I preferred the 42MP sensor. I have an A7RV and IV now. That being said, I find the new AI Denoise function from Adobe to be excellent in terms of dealing with the fine noise you mention, and leaves incredibly clean and noise-free files with only a mild application and no apparent loss of detail from my testing.

The higher base level of noise at ISO 100 on the 61MP sensor did bug me somewhat, but now it is a non-issue thanks to the AI Denoise tool.
May 27, 2024 at 05:14 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Jochenb wrote:
You had a Z7II vs A7RIV thread a couple of years ago Scott, where you posted your comparisons.
Back then you mentioned how clean the 45MP files are vs the 61MP ones and no mention of the lacking detail.


I also shot the A7RIII, an excellent camera and a great balance between noise and detail. It's basically what the GFX50 series was but on some extra juice.

Adobe Denoise didn't exist when I made that thread you referenced, and has become a standard part of my workflow for keepers. It's excellent at reducing color noise without smashing too much detail in the process, and I've been using it on my old A7R4 files in comparison to my Z9 files and finding that the Sony files, once processed, are still noticeably sharper and more detailed without any extra processing.

I always described the Sony noise as "gritty" vs the Nikon's, and I won't lie, the Nikon files, when shot at lower ISOs, are much cleaner than the A7R4 files. I have no issues shooting the Nikon up to ISO 12,800, knowing I can clean it up in post just fine. I'm assuming the noise performance between the A7R4 and A7R5 are roughly the same.
May 27, 2024 at 07:00 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
johnvanatta wrote:
The Fuji 20-35 and 35-70 are a great start for Fuji landscape.


This is where I've landed after reading all of these comments. The advantage here is that it's gapless up to 70 (though I personally wouldn't use 20-25 all that much).

Is the Zeiss you referenced the Milvus? Which mount do you use? EF I assume.
May 27, 2024 at 07:06 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I will also note that in my Z7ii vs Riv thread, the biggest pro to the Nikon was the accuracy of the white balance. I’ve read many reports that the Rv has consistently better WB accuracy than the Riv. True?
May 27, 2024 at 07:33 AM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I will also note that in my Z7ii vs Riv thread, the biggest pro to the Nikon was the accuracy of the white balance. I’ve read many reports that the Rv has consistently better WB accuracy than the Riv. True?


When you're talking about landscape photography, and this is a genuine question - does WB accuracy (or lack thereof) even matter? It's trivial to change in post and I daresay most landscape photographers are editing their colours regardless of what is captured in camera.

I can see a greater need for in-camera accuracy if you are shooting mostly JPG, or need to mass-edit hundreds/thousands of RAW files eg doing events/weddings/sports etc. But for landscape where any given image might take hours of processing time, I can't say I've ever worried much about what WB the camera captures as long as it is 'close enough' to properly visualise the scene at the time.
May 27, 2024 at 07:38 AM
nhmorgan
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
dcisive wroteNice to see you embracing more landscape stuff so seriously. I had a A7RV for a while prior to my Z9 and I have to admit, sometimes I wish I'd stayed put. The resolving of that A7RV and it's amazing focus system sure did impress. So what is your motivation to get even higher mp's. Are your prints not large enough or are you cropping big time? The landscapes I took with that A7RV were already so huge to begin with and certainly didn't lack detail.
I doubt I will see a huge difference in autofocus performance between the RV and my Z9. Where I see the biggest difference between Z9 files and my backlog of R4 files is sheer detail...the Sony has it where the Nikon just doesn't.

The R4 has what I always considered a nasty grain pattern even at low ISO, especially compared to the Z9. In testing GFX files, I don't see this noise. The best way I can describe Sony RAW file grain is "gritty".

I do print large. I've made some 60" wide prints off the Z9.


Your experience mirrors mine. The detail on the Nikon files is much cleaner despite the higher resolution of the A7RV. Not sure why this is, but I see it. You won't see a huge difference in AF for landscapes, but the Z9 is the better overall focusing camera. Like you though, I got tired of waiting for Nikon to release a higher MP camera. I shoot astro a lot and the A7RV is the first Sony camera to be completely free of RAW filtering that is destructive for astro images, so that factored into my decision pretty significantly. As to the WB issues, I've found that the Sony WB is no better or worse than it was on my A1, when I used to run that camera. On every Sony I've every used I'm more likely to have to mess with the WB to get it right in post than on Nikon. The only Nikon I had WB issues with was a Z8 and they fixed that green tint issue in firmware.

Edited on May 27, 2024 at 07:45 AM · View previous versions
May 27, 2024 at 07:43 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Aztatlan wrote:
RoamingScott wroteI will also note that in my Z7ii vs Riv thread, the biggest pro to the Nikon was the accuracy of the white balance. I’ve read many reports that the Rv has consistently better WB accuracy than the Riv. True?
When you're talking about landscape photography, and this is a genuine question - does WB accuracy (or lack thereof) even matter? It's trivial to change in post and I daresay most landscape photographers are editing their colours regardless of what is captured in camera.

I can see a greater need for in-camera accuracy if you are shooting mostly JPG, or need to mass-edit hundreds/thousands of RAW files eg doing events/weddings/sports etc. But for landscape where any given image might take hours of processing time, I can't say I've ever worried much about what WB the camera captures as long as
...Show more →

The more consistent you can get your base output, the less fiddling you have to do across the swath of editing, and the more standardized your editing can become over time. My big peeve with Sony (more the Riv than the Riii) was the magenta cast it put into RAW files. It wasn't as trivial as moving a slider to get it out...many times, I'd have to jack with the LR Calibration panel. That meant that every lighting change was a totally different edit, often lots of a trial and error.

Again, by the claims of many here and elsewhere, that overpowering magenta cast seems to have been dampened by the Riv, but...impossible to say till I start editing.
May 27, 2024 at 07:43 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
It might help if @RoamingScott shared a few of the typical images you print big and sell. With that, it’s probably easier to say, yes or no that the 100mp file would be worth it.

Edited on May 27, 2024 at 10:06 AM · View previous versions
May 27, 2024 at 08:12 AM
Aztatlan
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Aztatlan wrote
RoamingScott wroteI will also note that in my Z7ii vs Riv thread, the biggest pro to the Nikon was the accuracy of the white balance. I’ve read many reports that the Rv has consistently better WB accuracy than the Riv. True?
When you're talking about landscape photography, and this is a genuine question - does WB accuracy (or lack thereof) even matter? It's trivial to change in post and I daresay most landscape photographers are editing their colours regardless of what is captured in camera.

I can see a greater need for in-camera accuracy if you are shooting mostly JPG, or need to mass-edit hundreds/thousands of RAW files eg doing events/weddings/sports etc. But for landscape where any given image might take hours of processing time, I can't say I've ever worried much about what WB the camera captures as long as it is 'close enough' to properly visualise the scene at the time.
The more consistent you can get your base output, the less fiddling you have to do across the swath of editing, and the more standardized your editing can become over time. My big peeve with Sony (more the Riv than the Riii) was the magenta cast it put into RAW files. It wasn't as trivial as moving a slider to get it out...many times, I'd have to jack with the LR Calibration panel. That meant that every lighting change was a totally different edit, often lots of a trial and error.

Again, by the claims of many here and elsewhere, that
...Show more →

I guess it depends how you typically shoot and the conditions you do so in. For me, any given landscape shoot may see me only choosing to edit 1-3 images to completion, so I typically would spend quite some time working on them and would usually be using WB and/or colour grading to get the colours how I want them to be anyway, ie I am not necessarily going for a truly accurate representation of what I saw, since you are editing off a memory of the scene only so I try to edit to how I remember feeling the scene felt like at the time with respect to colour, and what is visually pleasing for the prevailing light.

That being said, having shot a lot with the A7R IV I don't remember ever feeling there was a strong magenta cast to my images. I edit on a calibrated display so that shouldn't be masking anything either.

May 27, 2024 at 08:23 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister