Seems to me RoamingScott wants a Sony system. For the Fuji GFX setup, the first lens to buy for landscapers that want to hike, and care maybe more about weight than the images, would have been the Fuji GFX 35-70mm F/4.5-5.6...
But some would pooh pooh its variable aperture, and it being 4.5 at the widest, but for landscapes, neither matter. It is wide enough for most subjects, if you want wider, stitch 2 or 4 (2x2). The 35-70 is less than half the weight, and half the price, of the 32-64.
RWNPhoto wrote:
Seems to me RoamingScott wants a Sony system. For the Fuji GFX setup, the first lens to buy for landscapers that want to hike, and care maybe more about weight than the images, would have been the Fuji GFX 35-70mm F/4.5-5.6...
But some would pooh pooh its variable aperture, and it being 4.5 at the widest, but for landscapes, neither matter. It is wide enough for most subjects, if you want wider, stitch 2 or 4 (2x2). The 35-70 is less than half the weight, and half the price, of the 32-64.
It seems to me Scott wants the best system for his needs, which appear to be best image quality in as lightweight of package as possible. Unfortunately that presents a significant dichotomy as respects system choice. I further think he *wants* the Sony 60mp sensor and lenses to deliver what he *knows* the gfx 100’s and their glass can deliver, and that would make the GFX the logical choice IF he were willing to accept the added weight and smaller focal ranges. Then in turn he seems to not be very flexible on weight and focal range, hence his impasse; he can’t have that exact cake… Now his choice on what he’s willing to give up does appear to be leaning toward weight and range at the expense of best IQ for (what he’s hoping is) adequate IQ, and so yes, the Sony system is probably the best answer. At least for him… We will find out eventually.
PS: I also think the bigger issue that adds difficulty for him is that most of us that own the GFX 100mp have said the weight and focal range limitations are outweighed by the IQ. And nobody that owns and uses both has really chimed in to say, yeah the Sony 60 is as good as… 😎
nhmorgan wrote:
Your experience mirrors mine. The detail on the Nikon files is much cleaner despite the higher resolution of the A7RV. Not sure why this is, but I see it.
Cool. So since you can see it and we are talking about images, you can certainly show it? I mean, someone might learn something? Personally I find that many of my images have worse IQ than some I previously shot. Pretty sure that in my case it isn't due to the camera, though, as it is the same...
I have the Zeiss ZF.2 135/2. It's actually another tough decision between F and EF, and Z.2 and Milvus versions.
The F mount versions have a dedicated aperture ring, so they only need a cheap dumb adapter. But of course that means no EXIF, and sometimes the GFX 100s forgets which dumb lens it's set to, which is annoying. Plus always having to use the aperture ring instead of camera dials to set aperture [IMO another nuisance]. There's a small possibility that the EF versions have less cats-eye due to the larger mount throat, AFAIK nobody has tested that.
The Milvus versions have newer coatings, weather sealing, and slightly improved haptics. But they weigh nearly 200g more. Ugh.
I'm considering swapping out my ZF.2 copy for an EF mount copy now that I have a Fringer smart adapter, but it's a low priority.
RWNPhoto wrote:
Seems to me RoamingScott wants a Sony system.
I thought I'd made it pretty clear my top preference would be a Z7iii, but things being as they are...more creative solutions are being sought.
Jack has a good point. It's all about finding that balance between IQ, portability, etc. It's made harder by the A7R5, 20-70, and 70-200 costing me less than a 100S II after tax.
It would take a bit to recoup the extra cost of the GFX system via sales, but I'm not all that concerned about that. I'm more concerned about going to a place once and missing a shot because I was worried about changing lenses in tough conditions, or worse, simply lacking the needed focal length and cropping into and winding up with a 50mp shot on my 100mp camera.
Now, one thing no one has addressed is...is a GFX 100mp image cropped to 60mp still better than a native Sony 60mp image? Given what folks say about highlight retention, dynamic range, tonal gradations, you'd think it would still be.
A shift of mental perspective could be that the GFX is the 60mp sensor on steroids...even if shooting in 35mm mode, the results would still be a step ahead of the A7R5...and that any images made with the full sensor are pure cake.
As I mentioned before in this thread, the vast majority of my landscapes are shot between 24mm and 60mm om FF terms, and then a lesser but significant amount at 105/120. In that regard, the 35-70 just barely doesn't fit the bill, but COULD for many shots. I'd have to stitch for wider than 28mm equiv shots, which is a pain. I'd have to crop for anything past 56mm. The shots that manage to fall in between would hopefully be a significant step up from full frame.
Where I'd start losing shots in a meaningful way is all things past 56mm, considering how much I use the long end of my 24-120 and that's where you have to start being creative.
I vote for your Sony kit, if I was building this kit I'd do A7CR, 20-70 F4, and 70-200 F4.
I have not used the GFX, but I'd love to try it out. Mostly I'm a big fan of light and compact. You could get the Sony kit in a Wotancraft 3.5L no problem.
RoamingScott wrote:
I was actually looking at the Nikon 200 PF as a pretty attractive alternative as well.
The Nikon 200/2 will just cover if the rear baffle is removed, but it's a stupid heavy lens. Most longer Nikon lenses do not cover well as the throat size gets too restrictive, But IDK on the 300PF. But that throat issue is why Canon EF is generally the better mount to go with if you want to maintain automaticity in AF and AE...
The Canon EF 200/2.8's i and ii both cover, the Canon 300/2.8 and non-IS f4 cover; and the 400 DO covers, FWIW. As mentioned above, the Canon 100-400 covers, but apparently only to about 320.
Hmm? The Nikon 200/2 isn't PF, and it's huge. Did you mean the 300/4 PF? I briefly tried that on the GFX.
The haptics were really bad on a dumb adapter--Fringer has a smart adapter now, so it should be more viable--so I didn't do a lot of tests with it. It doesn't completely cover the sensor but it gets most of it. Some IQ falloff outside the FF image circle. My quick impression is that it's like the CV 180/4, not quite delivering to GFX-quality, but maybe a reasonable compromise for lighter weight. The GFX 250/4 is better, no question, but again, heavy and inflexible.
It's an important question how much the 'compromise' lenses are going to be used--buying a GFX only to primarily use lenses like this...well...it probably only makes sense if you /really/ like the 4:3 ratio.
p.4 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote
Now, one thing no one has addressed is...is a GFX 100mp image cropped to 60mp still better than a native Sony 60mp image? Given what folks say about highlight retention, dynamic range, tonal gradations, you'd think it would still be.
The people talking about 'highlight retention' and 'tonal gradations' tend not to like controlled A/B comparisons much . Some also really like the native 4:3 aspect ratio. And the modest ~2x zooms, cropped to their sweet spots, will probably outperform a Sony 20-70/4 somewhat.
p.4 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
SNIP
Now, one thing no one has addressed is...is a GFX 100mp image cropped to 60mp still better than a native Sony 60mp image? Given what folks say about highlight retention, dynamic range, tonal gradations, you'd think it would still be.
A shift of mental perspective could be that the GFX is the 60mp sensor on steroids...even if shooting in 35mm mode, the results would still be a step ahead of the A7R5...and that any images made with the full sensor are pure cake.
As I mentioned before in this thread, the vast majority of my landscapes are shot between 24mm and 60mm om FF terms, and then a lesser but significant amount at 105/120. In that regard, the 35-70 just barely doesn't fit the bill, but COULD for many shots. I'd have to stitch for wider than 28mm equiv shots, which is a pain. I'd have to crop for anything past 56mm. The shots that manage to fall in between would hopefully be a significant step up from full frame.
Where I'd start losing shots in a meaningful way is all things past 56mm, considering how much I use the long end of my 24-120 and that's where you have to start being creative....Show more →
I think your shift in mental perspective is good as it essentially gives you 2 systems using a single GFX body: With GFX lenses you get known, stellar performance; and then when you need to go lighter with more varied focal length optics, then a set of good Canon zooms in the ranges and weights you want cropped to Fx 60MP is going to be about as it gets. With this logic, you get the best of both worlds, have it all in the car and then just decide last minute which option(s) are going to suit best.
I am just going to repeat -- and it's IMHO very good you already have the 32-64 -- because IMO the GFX with that and the 20-35 is landscape nirvana for *me*. Add a Canon 70-200 and the 2 ounce Fringer adapter, and you've got the world you want covered; albeit with a heavy-ish but outstanding 32-64, an equally outstanding 20-35 and a relatively lightweight 70-200.
PS: The Fx 70-200 is what I am investigating for myself right now. The one option I've seen that is supposed to cover well is the Sigma Canon 70-200/2.8 sport lens. I've heard two reports it's excellent and one it was crap . S I need to find out for myself and have feelers out for one so I can test it. If it works in full 33x44 mode, or cropped to say even 75 or 80MP at 3:4, then I'll be all over that instead of the bulkier 45-100 or the limited to about 150mm 100-200 (and especially not carrying both!) GFX lenses. If the Sigma doesn't hold up, then plan B is a good Canon 70-200 and crop down as far as needed, hopefully still being able to hold onto more than 60 MP -- we will see...
PPS edit: I am *NOT* overly optimistic the Fx 70-200's will cover the entire 33x44 well -- some may illuminate the entire IC, but that doesn't mean they'll deliver. My only point above is that *worst case* I can use my GFX in Fx mode or even crop to that same IC in 3:4, like around 26x32 and still get good performance at 60/65MP.
p.4 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
No really helping just want to say I'm interested in GFX mainly because it has vastly superior long exposure capability compare to Sony. With A7R2 I can use SR app to shoot beyond 30s (without external bulk timer) but since I brought A7R4 than upgraded to A7R5 they can't use app anymore, but that also exhausted the fund for a GFX (50sII was the plan), but then I also shoot other stuffs (like pets, an active dog and that's difficult to do with R2 or GFX).
Not saying I did a lot of long exposure (1 to 3 minutes) in day light but when I do I like the results.
My father used to occationaly shoot with a Bronica MF (the camera and 2 lenses are still here but the body probably isn't working properly). Maybe that's part of the reasons I want to try MF. I also like the "slower" approach at times (although in practice it's not easy).
GFX100 sensor seems to be just the bigger version of 60MP sensor (same pixel size just different "cut") which is also the same as 26mp APSC sensors. (that makes sense from design and manufacturing cost point of view). Given that they are just the same sensor, highlight retention should be similar but maybe you can afford to under expose a bit.
I have read that some Sigma Art DSLR lens are good for GFX, like 135/1.8 and the pig sized 40/1.4.
p.4 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I'm primarily a landscape shooter. I shot the 50s with 23/4, 32-64, 100-200 for a couple of years, dual system with Sony. I'm now shooting solely Sony A1. I do eyeball the GFX 100II and 100SII but I like hiking and travelling with my gear and I remind myself why I sold out of GFX
* Lens size and weight
* Lack of telephoto options
* Field curvature on 23/4 and 32-64 made it hard to focus stack
* Close focus distance kind of sucked which means near to far wide angle landscapes (which I like) were harder to achieve with GFX.
I do miss shooting GFX but only when the location is close to the car. Once I'm hiking I'm happy to have Sony.
BTW a good alternative to the 70-200/4 GII is the Tamron 70-300. You will lose the macro ability but otherwise it's a fine, small light telephoto.
My LAF kit will eventually be A7RC, 16-35/4, 28-60, Tamron 70-300 or thereabouts.
p.4 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
dakel wrote:
I'm primarily a landscape shooter. I shot the 50s with 23/4, 32-64, 100-200 for a couple of years, dual system with Sony. I'm now shooting solely Sony A1. I do eyeball the GFX 100II and 100SII but I like hiking and travelling with my gear and I remind myself why I sold out of GFX
* Lens size and weight
* Lack of telephoto options
* Field curvature on 23/4 and 32-64 made it hard to focus stack
* Close focus distance kind of sucked which means near to far wide angle landscapes (which I like) were harder to achieve with GFX.
I do miss shooting GFX but only when the location is close to the car. Once I'm hiking I'm happy to have Sony.
BTW a good alternative to the 70-200/4 GII is the Tamron 70-300. You will lose the macro ability but otherwise it's a fine, small light telephoto.
My LAF kit will eventually be A7RC, 16-35/4, 28-60, Tamron 70-300 or thereabouts....Show more →
Thanks for this input, Derrick, it was helpful to look through your Flickr and square your findings against your style of shooting.
This was an interesting read through. TL;DR, the GFX 100mp sensor is considerably better at recovering shadow detail, and the 61mp Sony is better at recovering highlight detail. He mentions that the new AWB in the A7R5 is much more accurate than the A7R4 and that it actually oversaturates blues of all things now.
The GFX100 II in comparison delivers top-notch image quality, colors and tones at a more affordable price. The weight of the camera is manageable, and the electronic viewfinder is outstanding. It also costs twice as much as the Sony which overall is still a great performer.
After testing the Fuji camera, I have decided to stick to the A7R V for now for my architectural and interior work. Switching system always ends up being a costly exercise and I am satisfied with the quality produced from the Sony. I found the GFX100 II's overall image quality to be better, but only by a small margin...For most people seeking the best colors and image quality, The GFX100 II is currently the best choice.
A tripod based arch shooter opting to stay with the Sony system despite the visible gains of GFX, and he doesn't even get to the top of mountains with it
p.4 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
When I started with the GFX system for landscapes, I was carrying the 23/4, 32-64, 120mm macro and then I added the 80/1.7. I did eventually get the 100-200mm. I agree when primarily shooting from the car it was a great combo. With mixed shooting (not just landscape) I usually take the Sony A7RV. However, I recently got a Lecia M11 and a few lenses and when traveling by plane and photography is not the main reason for the trip, it is hard to beat the size of the M11 system. Of course it is not the best for activity shots. I have been considering selling all my GFX gear because I have not used it much. I sold the original GFX100 but have the GFX100S and may re-visit this system again.
dakel wrote:
I'm primarily a landscape shooter. I shot the 50s with 23/4, 32-64, 100-200 for a couple of years, dual system with Sony. I'm now shooting solely Sony A1. I do eyeball the GFX 100II and 100SII but I like hiking and travelling with my gear and I remind myself why I sold out of GFX
* Lens size and weight
* Lack of telephoto options
* Field curvature on 23/4 and 32-64 made it hard to focus stack
* Close focus distance kind of sucked which means near to far wide angle landscapes (which I like) were harder to achieve with GFX.
I do miss shooting GFX but only when the location is close to the car. Once I'm hiking I'm happy to have Sony.
BTW a good alternative to the 70-200/4 GII is the Tamron 70-300. You will lose the macro ability but otherwise it's a fine, small light telephoto.
My LAF kit will eventually be A7RC, 16-35/4, 28-60, Tamron 70-300 or thereabouts....Show more →
p.4 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
mark1958 wrote:
When I started with the GFX system for landscapes, I was carrying the 23/4, 32-64, 120mm macro and then I added the 80/1.7. I did eventually get the 100-200mm. I agree when primarily shooting from the car it was a great combo. With mixed shooting (not just landscape) I usually take the Sony A7RV. However, I recently got a Lecia M11 and a few lenses and when traveling by plane and photography is not the main reason for the trip, it is hard to beat the size of the M11 system. Of course it is not the best for activity shots. I have been considering selling all my GFX gear because I have not used it much. I sold the original GFX100 but have the GFX100S and may re-visit this system again.
...Show more →dakel wroteI'm primarily a landscape shooter. I shot the 50s with 23/4, 32-64, 100-200 for a couple of years, dual system with Sony. I'm now shooting solely Sony A1. I do eyeball the GFX 100II and 100SII but I like hiking and travelling with my gear and I remind myself why I sold out of GFX
* Lens size and weight
* Lack of telephoto options
* Field curvature on 23/4 and 32-64 made it hard to focus stack
* Close focus distance kind of sucked which means near to far wide angle landscapes (which I like) were harder to achieve with GFX.
I do miss shooting GFX but only when the location is close to the car. Once I'm hiking I'm happy to have Sony.
BTW a good alternative to the 70-200/4 GII is the Tamron 70-300. You will lose the macro ability but otherwise it's a fine, small light telephoto.
My LAF kit will eventually be A7RC, 16-35/4, 28-60, Tamron 70-300 or thereabouts.
The size of the GFX 100 was a total non-starter, including the moronic sharp-edge vertical grip. The 100S line is where the appeal is.
p.4 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I suppose the linked above A/B tests aren't QUITE A/B given the difference of the lenses...
Looking at these in LR, what immediately jumps out is the color cast on the Sony images. The Fuji whites are just...white. The Sony has some yellow and green in the white that stubbornly hangs around.
On high key areas, you can see the smoothness that the highlights roll off, and on the Sony, it's a more stark demarcation.
The Fuji colors pop more off the jump too. Whether that is realistic or not...who can say?
Then you return to reality and stop looking at 100% and they are, for all intents, the same photo. No one on IG, my website, FM, or otherwise would ever notice the differences between the two.
p.4 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
I suppose the linked above A/B tests aren't QUITE A/B given the difference of the lenses...
Looking at these in LR, what immediately jumps out is the color cast on the Sony images. The Fuji whites are just...white. The Sony has some yellow and green in the white that stubbornly hangs around.
On high key areas, you can see the smoothness that the highlights roll off, and on the Sony, it's a more stark demarcation.
The Fuji colors pop more off the jump too. Whether that is realistic or not...who can say?
Then you return to reality and stop looking at 100% and they are, for all intents, the same photo. No one on IG, my website, FM, or otherwise would ever notice the differences between the two....Show more →
Not since the Nikon D800/E in 2012 have I actually felt sensor quality was a material limiting factor in my images. These days one may turn their nose up to only 36MP of course, but it was massive at the time, at least for a FF camera. Since then I have owned the D810 and every model of the A7R series. That isn't to say I don't appreciate more IQ, but generally the reasons I've upgraded over the years have been for reasons besides IQ with that being a bonus.
I admit I have lusted after the GFX line at times, as a landscape photographer only (besides the odd family photo) the system would be well suited for me on paper. What ultimately has stopped me is cost, weight and limited available lenses. Take for example the 20-35 - besides the fact that 20mm is the absolute widest lens available on the system with no option to go wider, which is less than ideal, if I didn't gel with that lens for whatever reason then my next widest option is the 23mm prime. I'm not saying there's anything wrong with the 20-35, but even on Sony there are ostensibly great lenses that I don't love, but there is usually a half dozen alternatives in the same focal range. Even if 20mm is wide enough for you, that lens also isn't very fast - out of luck if you want a 14mm/1.8 for astro, for example.