p.13 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
My current landscape kit is the A7R5, 20-70, and 70-200 f4 II plus TCs. These are not the highest optical quality lenses that I own, but they're definitely good enough for outdoor shooting at f/5.6 or 8, pleasant to carry, well built, and far more versatile than I could get with any GFX kit I've owned or specced out. Sometimes I'll leave out the 20-70 and use my M11 with a few primes instead, it depends on the circumstance. I've come to realize that the 70-200 range is pretty indispensable for me and the 70-200 f/4 II is up there with my favorite lenses of all time because it's so versatile and so easy to carry.
I agree that we nitpick the optical qualities of lenses too much, in reality most viewers of our photographs won't care. But do what makes you happy. If the 20-70 or whatever isn't good enough for you, go ahead and carry something with a different set of tradeoffs that work better for you. When reading threads like this, it's important to keep in mind that these selections are ultimately about choosing a set of tradeoffs. There are rarely objectively correct answers, and it's perfectly fine to pick something different than someone else, because in the end you're the person who cares the most.
p.13 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gdanmitchell wrote:
Haven’t logged in to or posted on FM for weeks, partially because I’ve been traveling (walked the GGW a week ago, etc.) and partially because of how much of the “discussion” on FM has veered into nasty personalization, attacks, and trolling rather than good-faith discussion.
The last page or so of this thread has been a good reminder.
To those of you forming your nasty replies to my post, knock yourselves out.
p.13 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Finally got to the end of this monster thread, and despite the misunderstanding, trolling, and general wankery, there is a lot of interesting out loud thought about photography, equipment, goals, and the human condition.
As someone who primarily loves landscape photography, and has toyed with the idea of Fuji GFX for years but never dabbled beyond trying it out in camera store, yet also loves the flexibility of my Nikon Z 24-120, I FEEL YOU, SCOTT.
The joy of extreme image quality, like that of the Sigma 40mm/f1.4 I sometimes enjoy, contrasts with the pain of lugging around these monsters of glass and metal in a most bittersweet fashion.
Ultralight backpackers think I am insane for bringing 1.8Kg of camera gear on a multinight trip high in the mountains. Photography snobs think it's a waste to go such places without "the best possible gear". As one late poster put it, it's all about the tradeoffs.
Good luck RoamingScott, and others, finding peace And contentment in your chosen tradeoffs.
p.13 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I feel the need to add something to this thread because I think it’s somewhat relevant. Then if enough interest, maybe initiate a new thread on it. Sharpness.
IMHO, sharpness is overrated and moreover has become the apex image criterion photographers seem to be seeking. When I got the GFX 100s with the 32-64 zoom, I was literally blown away by how critically detailed the files were at 100% on my monitor with optimal processing. In fact it is still so much so, I have actually started dialing back sharpening and clarity to remove the clinical edginess that many of the files hold even downsized for web view. Understand they are not over sharpened, just that the native glass, sensor and raw processing engines are so good, they extract an extraordinary detail and crispness that make the image somehow “larger than life” sterile. Maybe I’m not describing this well, but hopefully some of you catch my meaning.
The above is why I’m now on a personal exploration of adapting certain Fx lenses to render a more organic, but still pleasingly sharp image.
Apologies in advance if this discussion isn’t desired here…
p.13 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
I feel the need to add something to this thread because I think it’s somewhat relevant. Then if enough interest, maybe initiate a new thread on it. Sharpness.
Maybe not in this thread since it is so much about achieving sharpness. But I would love to see some comparison using landscape and varied levels of sharpening for discussion. Obviously, portraits and macro work need incredible sharpness so if you focus on landscape, I think that would be more useful. At least to me.
I think it would also be worth exploring sensory perceptions and allowing people to test their own perception without EXIF data beforehand. Call it a "blind" viewing. Personally, I have spent many years critically listening to audio gear and for years debated others about what was good, perceived, or just plain user bias. I now accept that people hear very differently and have different preferences and prefer to enjoy my music solo and keep my inner audio geek to myself.
I'm also part owner in a small winery operation and have a great deal of experiences tasting different styles of wine made different ways. And of course I have listened to others try and describe what they are tasting at length. It strikes me that people have different sensory thresholds for tasting different flavors. This makes is extremely difficult for a group to have consensus on what is good, correct, or flawed.
I did not expect a similar "revelation" in photography, but I'm now at the point that I feel people hear, taste, and see in different ways. I think the visual medium might be even more polarizing because people have greater conviction over what they are seeing before their very eyes. I would love to have a test where people have to choose what format they believe they are viewing. Then again, it might just spark more drama and personal attacks, .
p.13 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
PB_James wrote:
As someone who primarily loves landscape photography, and has toyed with the idea of Fuji GFX for years but never dabbled beyond trying it out in camera store, yet also loves the flexibility of my Nikon Z 24-120, I FEEL YOU, SCOTT.
...
Good luck RoamingScott, and others, finding peace And contentment in your chosen tradeoffs.
We are lucky to "have" to pick between all of these fine systems, systems which are still different enough to offer something unique in their own rights whether lens lineup, ergos, IQ, in camera features, or otherwise.
p.13 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
The GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fit
p.13 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
gear-nut wrote:
I feel the need to add something to this thread because I think it’s somewhat relevant. Then if enough interest, maybe initiate a new thread on it. Sharpness.
IMHO, sharpness is overrated and moreover has become the apex image criterion photographers seem to be seeking. When I got the GFX 100s with the 32-64 zoom, I was literally blown away by how critically detailed the files were at 100% on my monitor with optimal processing. In fact it is still so much so, I have actually started dialing back sharpening and clarity to remove the clinical edginess that many of the files hold even downsized for web view. Understand they are not over sharpened, just that the native glass, sensor and raw processing engines are so good, they extract an extraordinary detail and crispness that make the image somehow “larger than life” sterile. Maybe I’m not describing this well, but hopefully some of you catch my meaning.
The above is why I’m now on a personal exploration of adapting certain Fx lenses to render a more organic, but still pleasingly sharp image.
Apologies in advance if this discussion isn’t desired here…...Show more →
---------------------------------------------
RoamingScott wrote: PB_James wroteAs someone who primarily loves landscape photography, and has toyed with the idea of Fuji GFX for years but never dabbled beyond trying it out in camera store, yet also loves the flexibility of my Nikon Z 24-120, I FEEL YOU, SCOTT.
...
Good luck RoamingScott, and others, finding peace And contentment in your chosen tradeoffs.We are lucky to "have" to pick between all of these fine systems, systems which are still different enough to offer something unique in their own rights whether lens lineup, ergos, IQ, in camera features, or otherwise.
It’s interesting you say that. I find my files from the GFX 100S have a clinical, sterile, cold feel to me when I examine them up close (this is of course subjective but true for me). There is indeed a high amount of resolution (but still not at the level of the Phase One 150mp sensor output which is extraordinary). I enjoy the look of my Pentax 645D and 645Z files much more. For this reason and others, I was happy to leave GFX and return to Nikon Z7II and then Z9, and eventually to my current A7RV which has become my favorite landscape camera and lens system of the last two decades.
I have turned my home office and most of the first floor into a gallery and I have prints ranging from 22” to 60” from drum scanned 4” x 5” and 645cm film, plus fulframe and 'mini-MF' digital, and to my eye they are all beautiful and no one who has come into my home is able to tell a quality difference. The small differences are things we photogs sweat over in the forum
As Scott said, it is fantastic to have all the system choices that exist today. I know there are many who love their GFX gear and produce art from it, just as there are many doing the same with fullframe cameras from all brands. There is no such thing as a single best choice for all. But I have found it important to choose specific gear that resonates with me, because that does help my photographic process be more enjoyable as well as productive.
Enjoy the new 100SII, Scott! Look forward to seeing your work posted from it.
p.13 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
SGinNorcal wrote:
I'm now at the point that I feel people hear, taste, and see in different ways.
Agree with this. Double blind tests can help. Drama happens when people pass judgment, say, if you hear this, taste this, and see this, you are the "elite," and if you don't, you belong to the "unwashed."
More importantly, people have different objectives in enjoying a product. Some people just don't care about certain aspects. They enjoy listening Beethoven, but don't care about discerning the treatment from different performers. They enjoy a good photograph for its content, but don't care about the technicalities. Most people read Shakespeare for the story, not to learn drama writing skills.
And then there is science vs. belief. If science tells you that above a certain frequency only dogs can hear the sound, and a friend claims he can hear it, what do you make of it? Maybe science cannot explain everything.
p.13 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
theaesthetic wrote:
The GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fit...Show more →
I have been debating the 45/2.8 and 50/3.5, and came across this video yesterday. His environmental portraits and documentary shots with the 45/2.8 are great and go against what most seem to say which is the lens has no "medium format" look.
p.13 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Great video -- he pretty much nailed everything about it from my perspective. I noted he mentioned Fuji color several times, and he's right on there as well -- Fuji, even my XT5 and XH2, deliver wonderful color, a little better or perhaps just more realistic than even Nikon IMHO...
p.13 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote: theaesthetic wroteThe GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fitI have been debating the 45/2.8 and 50/3.5, and came across this video yesterday. His environmental portraits and documentary shots with the 45/2.8 are great and go against what most seem to say which is the lens has no "medium format" look.
Where are you getting your GF 45 information from if "most" are saying the GF 45 has no MF look? Your source(s) are whacked, man. Those who believe in the mystical magical fairy dust medium format look often point to the GF 45 as one of the lenses capable of such ethereal unknowable undefinable character – right there behind the GF 110 The GF 80 and GF 55 exist now, so those have taken over as the "look" lenses and have drowned out the early raves about the 45. I did have the 80 for a while, and I still think the 45 looks more "medium format". One of those YMMV things.
p.13 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
SGinNorcal wrote:
Maybe not in this thread since it is so much about achieving sharpness. But I would love to see some comparison using landscape and varied levels of sharpening for discussion. Obviously, portraits and macro work need incredible sharpness so if you focus on landscape, I think that would be more useful. At least to me.
I actually went to some trouble to do such a test. (One resulting article is here. I don’t currently have the URL for a follow—up test that involved making large prints. (If you read the article, you’ll see that I had a lot of positive things to say about the 50S and the 32-64 lens.)
Back in 2017 when the 50R and 50S were the “big thing,” I got my hands on the 50S with the 32-64mm lens. I also had the 50mm Canon 5DsR with the EF 24-70mm f/2.8 lens, giving reasonably comparable lenses to try on both. I put the two systems on tripods, pointed at a boring subject with a lot of detail, and made some very similar test photographs.
Right up front, it was my assumption that the larger 33x44 system would be “better” in several objective ways when it comes to optical potential. (It was also “worse” in some other objective performance measures, such as camera speed and so forth. All systems have pluses and minuses.)
My idea was o do a sort of ABX test, where observers are presented with three samples — one from source A, one from source B, and one from source X, where X could be either A or B. They were asked two things. First, which did they think was better, A or B? Many people would pore over the examples and express a preference. The they were asked whether they though X came from the same source as A or B. This is a sort of validity check on the A/B preference. E.g. — If A or B was objectively better, they should be able to correctly identify whether the unknown sample matched the “better” or “worse” among A and B. (BTW, sometimes A was the Fujifilm example, and sometimes it was the Canon example — so it was not possible for people to know which they were seeing.)
Eventually I prepared crops from various sizes of ready-to-print files — 6” x 10” sections of images sized for printing at various sizes up to and beyond 30” x 40”.
In the end, while people tended to state a preference. Among those who printed the samples and compared, while they often said that they thought one was better than the other, they were no better than random probability at determining whether the X sample matched A or B. This tends to suggest that while the samples might be different, that the choice was not necessarily the result of observable, objectively verifiable differences.
It was only at the 30” x 40” and larger print size level where this value moved from random, and (IIRC) viewers were about 5% more likely to make the right guess about whether X matched A or B.
Like any test, there are things that it did not assess and it was not a “perfect” test. (There are huge problems in trying to construct such a thing, and I’ve never seen it done with complete success regarding cameras and lenses.) But what I could say with some certainty was that there was no evidence that viewers (who were mostly photographers) could tell AT ALL whether an image printed at smaller the 30” x 40” came from a 50MP FF or miniMF system.
Now, there are fine reasons to choose the larger or the smaller system that come down to things like how often you make extremely large prints, the particular subjects you photograph, how you operate as a photographer, the availability of important ancillary equipment (e.g. lenses) for your work, cost, weight and bulk, and more. It comes down to personally evaluating the balance among all relevant factors in light of their real world effect on the photographs we produce.
It is also fair to note that the 100MP sensor was not available back when I did this.
p.13 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
There has been a series of events since the introduction of the GFX system that finally made me choose the GFX 100s as my upgrade path from the 5DSr.
- 100 MP sensor with PDAF
- The GFX 100s with small form factor and IBIS
- The Fringer Pro EF adapter
- The GF 35-70 lens as a viable hiking landscape lens
- The GF 500 5.6 lens
- Finally the launch of the s II which made it possible for me to buy a new GFX 100s at 33% discount
I will get the camera tomorrow and hope it will serve me for a long time
p.13 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I can’t tell how facetious you are being Regarding “the look”, it doesn’t look ALL that different from a fast full frame 35.
Many folks who once had the 45 early on seem to have moved on to the 55 for various reasons, and you never really hear about the 45 anymore. I’ve commented on lots of YouTube videos to see how the posters are still enjoying the 45 and most say they’ve sold it.
highdesertmesa wrote: RoamingScott wrotetheaesthetic wroteThe GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fitI have been debating the 45/2.8 and 50/3.5, and came across this video yesterday. His environmental portraits and documentary shots with the 45/2.8 are great and go against what most seem to say which is the lens has no "medium format" look.Where are you getting your GF 45 information from if "most" are saying the GF 45 has no MF look? Your source(s) are whacked, man. Those who believe in the mystical magical fairy dust medium format look often point to the GF 45 as one of the lenses capable of such ethereal unknowable undefinable character – right there behind the GF 110 The GF 80 and GF 55 exist now, so those have taken over as the "look" lenses and have drowned out the early raves about the 45. I did have the 80 for a while, and I still think the 45 looks more "medium format". One of those YMMV things....Show more →
p.13 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
My wallet hates that I bought the 55 1.7 instead of a used half price 63 2.8, but man do I love the IQ of it, had no interest in the 45. I kind of feel like it's just better to get the 45-100 for the 2.8 prime focal lengths unless you really need the weight savings. RoamingScott wrote:
I can’t tell how facetious you are being Regarding “the look”, it doesn’t look ALL that different from a fast full frame 35.
Many folks who once had the 45 early on seem to have moved on to the 55 for various reasons, and you never really hear about the 45 anymore. I’ve commented on lots of YouTube videos to see how the posters are still enjoying the 45 and most say they’ve sold it.
highdesertmesa wroteRoamingScott wrotetheaesthetic wroteThe GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fitI have been debating the 45/2.8 and 50/3.5, and came across this video yesterday. His environmental portraits and documentary shots with the 45/2.8 are great and go against what most seem to say which is the lens has no "medium format" look.Where are you getting your GF 45 information from if "most" are saying the GF 45 has no MF look? Your source(s) are whacked, man. Those who believe in the mystical magical fairy dust medium format look often point to the GF 45 as one of the lenses capable of such ethereal unknowable undefinable character – right there behind the GF 110 The GF 80 and GF 55 exist now, so those have taken over as the "look" lenses and have drowned out the early raves about the 45. I did have the 80 for a while, and I still think the 45 looks more "medium format". One of those YMMV things.
p.13 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
JadedWriter wrote:
My wallet hates that I bought the 55 1.7 instead of a used half price 63 2.8, but man do I love the IQ of it, had no interest in the 45. I kind of feel like it's just better to get the 45-100 for the 2.8 prime focal lengths unless you really need the weight savings. RoamingScott wroteI can’t tell how facetious you are being Regarding “the look”, it doesn’t look ALL that different from a fast full frame 35.
Many folks who once had the 45 early on seem to have moved on to the 55 for various reasons, and you never really hear about the 45 anymore. I’ve commented on lots of YouTube videos to see how the posters are still enjoying the 45 and most say they’ve sold it.
highdesertmesa wroteRoamingScott wrotetheaesthetic wroteThe GFX quality is notably better in my experience. I know the sensor technically isn’t “true” medium format, but there is something just a little bit better. It sounds silly, but the perspective on wide landscape shots with the GFX tends to feel a bit more immersive (yes, I know these are very qualitative points). I am just a hobbyist, but one thing that the GFX provides is confidence that I have one of the best cameras with one of the largest sensors. If I take a photo that doesn’t look good, it’s completely on me. My time on the B&H website has declined massively since picking one up
On the lens, agree that the 32-64 is hefty. Crazy enough, I’ve actually used the kit 35-70 for some landscape work and I was pretty impressed by the image quality. The 45mm 2.8 is my favorite in the line-up by far, but perhaps the kit zoom or one of the wider primes would be a better fitI have been debating the 45/2.8 and 50/3.5, and came across this video yesterday. His environmental portraits and documentary shots with the 45/2.8 are great and go against what most seem to say which is the lens has no "medium format" look.Where are you getting your GF 45 information from if "most" are saying the GF 45 has no MF look? Your source(s) are whacked, man. Those who believe in the mystical magical fairy dust medium format look often point to the GF 45 as one of the lenses capable of such ethereal unknowable undefinable character – right there behind the GF 110 The GF 80 and GF 55 exist now, so those have taken over as the "look" lenses and have drowned out the early raves about the 45. I did have the 80 for a while, and I still think the 45 looks more "medium format". One of those YMMV things.
I really liked that 45-100mm when I was shooting the 100S, my favorite of the lenses I had. It worked really well for landscapes, since I don’t typically ’see’ very wide. If I was shooting GFX again the 45-100 could easily be my only lens. I guess some would find it too bulky and heavy though.
p.13 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Re the "MF look." IMHO, the MF look left us with film. One of the main facets of that MF look was that grain was smaller, and therefore the images looked smoother than 35mm. Yes there is also a DoF difference such that equivalent framing for MF appeared a good stop or more shallower with equivalent exposures. Some of that DoF effect is present with digital MF, but the grain or noise differences are basically neutralized with digital ISO 1600 or less levels.
To the GF 45 specifically and it holds for the 50 -- the MF look really isn't here because DoF isn't that much different than with a 35 or 40 lens on Fx. The 55 shows it a little in *some* images, but it's not a face smack. THe 63 I don't recall one way or the other, the 80 yes, it shows there somewhat regularly at sub f2.8; and of course with the 110 it's pretty present across the aperture range.
p.13 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Having shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.
In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).