fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape

  
 
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #1Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
selahsean wrote:
Having shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.


I prefer 4:3 or 4:5 for vertical shooting as well. However, the A7RV supports 4:3 so I'm not quite sure what you mean in this instance.
Jun 05, 2024 at 12:06 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.14 #2Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
How many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wrote:
Having shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for
...Show more →

Jun 05, 2024 at 01:13 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.14 #3Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
At 4:3, the A7 loses 12.5% of its pixels. Not huge but it’s there…

RoamingScott wrote:
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.
I prefer 4:3 or 4:5 for vertical shooting as well. However, the A7RV supports 4:3 so I'm not quite sure what you mean in this instance.

Jun 05, 2024 at 03:49 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #4Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Of course it does, but it’s still there for someone that prefers it, so not sure how it’s relevant.

gear-nut wrote:
At 4:3, the A7 loses 12.5% of its pixels. Not huge but it’s there…

RoamingScott wrote
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.
I prefer 4:3 or 4:5 for vertical shooting as well. However, the A7RV supports 4:3 so I'm not quite sure what you mean in this instance.

Jun 05, 2024 at 05:13 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #5Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I thought I might add something as I shot Medium Format for many years and had 5 different Phase One backs from 22mpx to 80mpx. I never shot the Fuji here but Medium Format is medium format and the quality level is very high and I used the best glass possible . Sure it's better than any 35mm system out there . I taught 30 workshops and mostly all medium format with very expensive and high quality glass . This shot was my partners P45 as at this time I had the P40 back but it was a lighting workshop and a friend brought in his bike. We where is Florida doing a lighting workshop. I think I used about 14 lights for it in a rental studio we had for a couple days. Im very very good at lighting and after 50 years I should be. The Fuji is a cheaper system per say than what I used most of the time but im sure its very good is it better than 35mm of course it is but Medium Format also has lots of shooting limitations as well. It's mostly tripod bound and it's a far slower pace per se. This shot was with a Phase one camera like a DSLR with a good lens not one of the technical lenses I used a lot but pretty much like shooting a 35mm cam. Anyway they are great systems and if you want to get to this level of IQ it surely is out there for you. I loved it but with limitations I had to give it up for client work as the limitations with them they just did not work shooting most event or Pr type shooting so went back to 35mm. I do miss it and more than anything I have been there with the Gold T shirt on. For high end commercial work it's very hard to beat and many top notch shooters do use them . We shot this tethered to a laptop as the lighting on this was very difficult. This is real not some made up image. The bike did have some lighting and we used that why the 1/5 of a second . I always liked the format using medium format and going back to 35mm kinda sucked. This back used a Kodak CCD sensor which is not made anymore. Fabulous sensor to bad Kodak dumped out of it




  P 45+    80mm    f/8.0    1/5s    100 ISO    0.0 EV  

Jun 05, 2024 at 05:41 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #6Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I would like to try that Fuji to be honest

Just for clarity the P45 back is 39.4-megapixel medium-format sensor
Jun 05, 2024 at 05:49 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.14 #7Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I remember that shoot buddy! I think we used about two dozen lights 😂

GMPhotography wrote:
I thought I might add something as I shot Medium Format for many years and had 5 different Phase One backs from 22mpx to 80mpx. I never shot the Fuji here but Medium Format is medium format and the quality level is very high and I used the best glass possible . Sure it's better than any 35mm system out there . I taught 30 workshops and mostly all medium format with very expensive and high quality glass . This shot was my partners P45 as at this time I had the P40 back but it was a lighting workshop
...Show more →
Jun 05, 2024 at 06:15 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #8Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I know we used every light they had and was looking for more.
Jun 05, 2024 at 06:21 PM
selahsean
Offline
Details
p.14 #9Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
JadedWriter wrote:
How many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways


My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.
Jun 05, 2024 at 07:47 PM
selahsean
Offline
Details
p.14 #10Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
RoamingScott wrote:
Of course it does, but it’s still there for someone that prefers it, so not sure how it’s relevant.

gear-nut wroteAt 4:3, the A7 loses 12.5% of its pixels. Not huge but it’s there…

RoamingScott wrote
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.
I prefer 4:3 or 4:5 for vertical shooting as well. However, the A7RV supports 4:3 so I'm not quite sure what you mean in this instance.


I know the a7r5 supports 4:3 but as noted above you're chopping off part of the resolution to do so. I know the raw files are cropped non-destructively but again I just appreciate being able to shoot 4:3 natively without having to deal with any of that. It wouldn't be the sole reason to choose between the systems but it was something I appreciated having worked with both systems.
Jun 05, 2024 at 07:53 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.14 #11Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Same if you buy a Hasselbladd system. I think with medium format you buy it and look at the lens options and go from there. I have a pretty good idea what my bread and butter focal lengths are, Fuji GF mostly has that stuff minus the exotics and it's just about tailoring your shooting style around the glass. I've had the system since March and I've been churning out images since. You don't buy this system looking for Tamron optics, and no this isn't a knock on Tamron.
selahsean wrote:
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.


Jun 05, 2024 at 08:14 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.14 #12Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
Lenses will be limited and no question hard to find if any 3rd party lenses. Medium format folks is not a cheap option to go with but the results are awesome. I had 2 lenses that cost 6 grand each. Now they where technical lenses in rodenstock and Schneider but they go on a tech cam with movements
Jun 05, 2024 at 08:19 PM
hanay78
Offline
Details
p.14 #13Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
I am coming late to this thread, but I remeber some compariosons from Steve Spencer, that maybe are of interest

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1496482/1#14101187
Jun 06, 2024 at 05:18 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #14Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
selahsean wrote:
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.


That's entirely a matter of tolerances. If you're willing to give up native performance or be satisfied with manual focus, there are plenty of options beyond Fuji's offerings, both designed specifically for larger formats and 135 format lenses that offer larger ICs. You can even get a central shutter option adapting HC lenses.
Jun 06, 2024 at 07:30 AM
selahsean
Offline
Details
p.14 #15Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
freaklikeme wrote:
selahsean wrote
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.
That's entirely a matter of tolerances. If you're willing to give up native performance or be satisfied with manual focus, there are plenty of options beyond Fuji's offerings, both designed specifically for larger formats and 135 format lenses that offer larger ICs. You can even get a central shutter option adapting HC lenses.


Those same lenses would also be totally usable on Sony which again the idea here is that Sony has a larger number of options. I spent a great deal of time adapting old 645 lenses to the 100s and none of them matched native performance. In the context of landscape photography I've not seen a compelling reason to adapt anything to the Fuji (maybe I've missed something). In fact, I think the fact that the Sony can adapt more lenses than the Fuji is a point in the Sony's favor but do people even use adapted lenses for landscape photography?
Jun 06, 2024 at 07:55 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.14 #16Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


selahsean wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
selahsean wrote
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.
That's entirely a matter of tolerances. If you're willing to give up native performance or be satisfied with manual focus, there are plenty of options beyond Fuji's offerings, both designed specifically for larger formats and 135 format lenses that offer larger ICs. You can even get a central shutter option adapting HC lenses.
Those same lenses would also be totally usable on Sony which again the idea here is that Sony has a larger number of options. I spent a great deal of time adapting old 645 lenses to the 100s and none of them matched native performance. In the context of landscape photography I've not seen a compelling reason to adapt anything to the Fuji (maybe I've missed something). In fact, I think the fact that the Sony can adapt more lenses than the Fuji is a point in the Sony's favor but do people even use adapted lenses for landscape photography?

That was not what you said above, you said that you'd be stuck with Fuji.
If it matters to be able to adapt to 400 different lenses instead of 200, then you are right.

What we have to deal with for landscape with the GFX is not the lack of options, nor necessarily the cost, but the bulk and weight.

And yes, some people do use adapted lenses for landscape. Mike Reid comes to mind.
Jun 06, 2024 at 08:14 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.14 #17Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape


alundeb wrote:
SNIP>
What we have to deal with for landscape with the GFX is not the lack of options, nor necessarily the cost, but the bulk and weight.

And yes, some people do use adapted lenses for landscape. Mike Reid comes to mind.

Exactly this^^^. Native GF lenses already cover landscape focal needs several different ways. The only real issue for adopters to decide on, is the bit of added weight and bulk worth the results? (Absolutely for me, respect others views may vary.)
Jun 06, 2024 at 08:18 AM
selahsean
Offline
Details
p.14 #18Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
alundeb wrote:
selahsean wrote
freaklikeme wrote
selahsean wrote
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.
That's entirely a matter of tolerances. If you're willing to give up native performance or be satisfied with manual focus, there are plenty of options beyond Fuji's offerings, both designed specifically for larger formats and 135 format lenses that offer larger ICs. You can even get a central shutter option adapting HC lenses.
Those same lenses would also be totally usable on Sony which again the idea here is that Sony has a larger number of options. I spent a great deal of time adapting old 645 lenses to the 100s and none of them matched native performance. In the context of landscape photography I've not seen a compelling reason to adapt anything to the Fuji (maybe I've missed something). In fact, I think the fact that the Sony can adapt more lenses than the Fuji is a point in the Sony's favor but do people even use adapted lenses for landscape photography?
That was not what you said above, you said that you'd be stuck with Fuji.
If it matters to be able to adapt to 400 different lenses instead of 200, then you are right.

What we have to deal with for landscape with the GFX is not the lack of options, nor necessarily the cost, but the bulk and weight.

And yes, some people do use adapted lenses for landscape. Mike Reid comes to mind.


I was inarticulate in saying that you're stuck with Fuji when I meant to imply that regarding native lenses only. I'm not familiar with Mike but that's a pretty limited data point out of the many different landscape photographers no? Again everyone will come to the evaluation of these two systems in their own way. I can only share what was relevant for me as a user of both and I did find the lack of native lenses an issue and I found adapting lenses on the Fuji GFX wasn't worth the investment. I respect that feeling won't be true for everyone.
Jun 06, 2024 at 08:50 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.14 #19Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
No offense to anyone in particular, but I trust my own eyes more than I trust many FM posters on the subject

I have 5 lenses which I'm going to adapt to GFX and see what kind of results I get. Some are character lenses and I'm sure the character will be amplified. Some are highly corrected and will likely just have weak corners. In those cases, I can get away with not buying the GFX version if I'm ok with manual focus.
Jun 06, 2024 at 08:56 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.14 #20Sony A7R5 vs GFX 100S (et al) for landscape
selahsean wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
selahsean wrote
JadedWriter wroteHow many lens options do you need though for non wildlife stuff? I have done a good amount of portrait work with the 55, 80 and 20-35 so far. These are three lenses. What good would it do stacking 10 more lenses onto this if I can use 3 lenses? Yeah I also carry a second body (XH2 or Z9), but this a lot of the time is so I'm not lens switching another 50 bajillion times during a shoot.
selahsean wroteHaving shot with both the A7RV and the 100s I think the 3:2 vs 4:3 should get talked about a bit more than it has. It definitely made a difference in how I composed images in those systems. I tend to shoot portrait orientation almost exclusively and so I actually prefer the 4:3 format.

In terms of pure IQ I maybe in the minority but there definitely wasn't enough of a difference in pure IQ for me to justify the size/weight of the GFX system. The other factor for me was the lack of lens options. Sony users are spoiled for lens options (probably why I've stuck with Leica and Sony for so long).

Just my two cents anyways
My point here was more that if you don't like the Fuji options for whatever reason you're pretty stuck whereas with Sony you have a ton more options to choose from based on whatever factors are important to you (IQ,Size/Weight/Price etc). Personally I'm at the point with camera bodies (from whatever brand) are about what lenses I get access to rather than features etc.
That's entirely a matter of tolerances. If you're willing to give up native performance or be satisfied with manual focus, there are plenty of options beyond Fuji's offerings, both designed specifically for larger formats and 135 format lenses that offer larger ICs. You can even get a central shutter option adapting HC lenses.
Those same lenses would also be totally usable on Sony which again the idea here is that Sony has a larger number of options. I spent a great deal of time adapting old 645 lenses to the 100s and none of them matched native performance. In the context of landscape photography I've not seen a compelling reason to adapt anything to the Fuji (maybe I've missed something). In fact, I think the fact that the Sony can adapt more lenses than the Fuji is a point in the Sony's favor but do people even use adapted lenses for landscape photography?


I do. The biggest reason I picked up the 50sII was to adapt the Rodenstock 35/4, 60/4, and 100/4 in helicoids for use on the camera. My only native lens was the 23/4, and that was only because there was no smaller MF alternative that was optically as good.
Jun 06, 2024 at 09:01 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister