Getting ready for work this morning my dog comes in with the top to my daughter's trashcan stuck on her head. She was evidently dumpster diving for some left over goldfish wrappers in my daughter's room. Gave me an opportunity to test out my new 28.
Thypoch Simera 28 1.4 M mount adapter with TTartisan and used green box focus confirmation on all of these.
From what is seen so far, I think this 28mm might be the star of the range for creative photography, until they fill it out in the next period. It can be used in a number of ways, and seems to suit many different styles.
Shunned for so long by the major manufacturers, the humble 28mm focal length has a habit of turning up real gems every so often. I've seen enough to know I am going to love this high versatility one.
A little known fact is that the 28mm focal length is close to being the mean of the focal lengths used in large scale moviemaking. Many of the best movies of the past 20 years have been shot with them, give or take a few millimetres. Zeiss/Arri list both a 28mm and a 32mm. So it will be in good creative company, this time for a much wider audience.
Sony failed their users apart from a low end pretty good early one, and Cosina only bestowed modern 28mm lenses on their only real target audience - M-mount users - in the past few years. But they don't care enough for mirrorless users to produce any for them, not even to throw them a few scraps at 28mm. It took a new entrant to correct this industry failure to make such lenses.
philip_pj wrote:
From what is seen so far, I think this 28mm might be the star of the range for creative photography, until they fill it out in the next period. It can be used in a number of ways, and seems to suit many different styles.
Shunned for so long by the major manufacturers, the humble 28mm focal length has a habit of turning up real gems every so often. I've seen enough to know I am going to love this high versatility one.
A little known fact is that the 28mm focal length is close to being the mean of the focal lengths used in large scale moviemaking. Many of the best movies of the past 20 years have been shot with them, give or take a few millimetres. Zeiss/Arri list both a 28mm and a 32mm. So it will be in good creative company, this time for a much wider audience.
Sony failed their users apart from a low end pretty good early one, and Cosina only bestowed modern 28mm lenses on their only real target audience - M-mount users - in the past few years. But they don't care enough for mirrorless users to produce any for them, not even to throw them a few scraps at 28mm. It took a new entrant to correct this industry failure to make such lenses. ...Show more →
It still awaits to be seen, however, whether Thypoch really gave us a 28mm for mirrorless or they just swamped the mount and gave us a Leica M lens with various mirrorless mounts. The Leica M mounts 28mm lenses for Leica and Voigtlander can all be used with an adapter on Sony and Nikon (and presumably Canon RF and L mount too), but the performance of all of them suffers quite a bit. I know the ones I used (and I have used: Leica lux Asph & cron Asph, Voigtlander f/2 II), I was disappointed with them on Sony, but really enjoyed them on a Leica M10. I am eager to see what Fred says as he reviews this lens. I am not optimistic about it, but I hope I am wrong. We will know a lot more once Fred finishes his review.
Depends what you are worried about, I guess. 'Suffers quite a bit' is rather vague. A good number of fair-minded reviews of non M-mount Simeras in 28mm and 35mm are available because the lenses have been out for some time, over a year in fact.
They are performed by trusted people with decades of experience and literally hundreds of reviews under each of their belts. Dustin Abbott used an M-mount 28/1.4 and Techart on the high end Sonys and liked it very much. If he is not off limits in some way, you might consider a short read?
They all say the same things about performance aspects - great build, low distortion, designer flare, fast lens vignette pattern, well-controlled (not image relevant) CA, excellent centres wide open, soft corners wide open firming steadily until excellent at f5.6, great close up image quality, fine focus fade, fine colour, great bokeh at all apertures, a sound blend of image quality and 'vintage' character.
I feel these lenses have a much brighter future on mirrorless mounts, where size constraints are less of an issue (thinking of the 75mm here), close focusing, AF adapters, and less cultural baggage acting as a deterrent for buy-in. More photographic lenses will, I believe, become quite a trend as people see the digital pendulum has swing too far. People are ready for more naturalism in their images.
The E-mount 28/1.4 is 25 grams lighter than using the M-mount equivalent lens and a Novoflex adapter. It will be so much easier to use, store and carry in the field and travel. I don't expect Thypoch's (DZO's) priorities to be special editions and blue lenses, and shunning mirrorless users.
Steve Spencer wrote: philip_pj wroteFrom what is seen so far, I think this 28mm might be the star of the range for creative photography, until they fill it out in the next period. It can be used in a number of ways, and seems to suit many different styles.
Shunned for so long by the major manufacturers, the humble 28mm focal length has a habit of turning up real gems every so often. I've seen enough to know I am going to love this high versatility one.
A little known fact is that the 28mm focal length is close to being the mean of the focal lengths used in large scale moviemaking. Many of the best movies of the past 20 years have been shot with them, give or take a few millimetres. Zeiss/Arri list both a 28mm and a 32mm. So it will be in good creative company, this time for a much wider audience.
Sony failed their users apart from a low end pretty good early one, and Cosina only bestowed modern 28mm lenses on their only real target audience - M-mount users - in the past few years. But they don't care enough for mirrorless users to produce any for them, not even to throw them a few scraps at 28mm. It took a new entrant to correct this industry failure to make such lenses.It still awaits to be seen, however, whether Thypoch really gave us a 28mm for mirrorless or they just swamped the mount and gave us a Leica M lens with various mirrorless mounts. The Leica M mounts 28mm lenses for Leica and Voigtlander can all be used with an adapter on Sony and Nikon (and presumably Canon RF and L mount too), but the performance of all of them suffers quite a bit. I know the ones I used (and I have used: Leica lux Asph & cron Asph, Voigtlander f/2 II), I was disappointed with them on Sony, but really enjoyed them on a Leica M10. I am eager to see what Fred says as he reviews this lens. I am not optimistic about it, but I hope I am wrong. We will know a lot more once Fred finishes his review....Show more →
I have a copy of the Simera 50/1.5 @Steve Spencer, in e-mount. It performs worse on the stock Sony than a modded Sony at portrait distance in the midframe to the corners. But it's still pretty usable in my book and not as affected as I expected. I will test at infinite this weekend. Unlike the 35mm I owned, the build and IQ feel better, ergo is wonderful with the long smooth focus throw and solid feel. I found the m-mount a bit tin-y, though not cheap. I will shoot this for a bit, but I think the 50/1.4 (and C 1.5) are quality glass.
But at this point, we have conclusive evidence that Thypoch's e-mount offerings are not optically optimized. Or at least this one. Somebody else can buy and test every e-mount to find out that Thypoch didn't tailor the optics. No wonder they didn't want Bastian to tell people. And that means, if you are shooting the e-mount 35mm and 28/1.4's, get ready for a heavily compromised optical performance. From my limited shooting thus far, the 50mm I would feel good about using on either from a sensor stack induced perspective.
nehemiahphoto wrote: Steve Spencer wrotephilip_pj wroteFrom what is seen so far, I think this 28mm might be the star of the range for creative photography, until they fill it out in the next period. It can be used in a number of ways, and seems to suit many different styles.
Shunned for so long by the major manufacturers, the humble 28mm focal length has a habit of turning up real gems every so often. I've seen enough to know I am going to love this high versatility one.
A little known fact is that the 28mm focal length is close to being the mean of the focal lengths used in large scale moviemaking. Many of the best movies of the past 20 years have been shot with them, give or take a few millimetres. Zeiss/Arri list both a 28mm and a 32mm. So it will be in good creative company, this time for a much wider audience.
Sony failed their users apart from a low end pretty good early one, and Cosina only bestowed modern 28mm lenses on their only real target audience - M-mount users - in the past few years. But they don't care enough for mirrorless users to produce any for them, not even to throw them a few scraps at 28mm. It took a new entrant to correct this industry failure to make such lenses.It still awaits to be seen, however, whether Thypoch really gave us a 28mm for mirrorless or they just swamped the mount and gave us a Leica M lens with various mirrorless mounts. The Leica M mounts 28mm lenses for Leica and Voigtlander can all be used with an adapter on Sony and Nikon (and presumably Canon RF and L mount too), but the performance of all of them suffers quite a bit. I know the ones I used (and I have used: Leica lux Asph & cron Asph, Voigtlander f/2 II), I was disappointed with them on Sony, but really enjoyed them on a Leica M10. I am eager to see what Fred says as he reviews this lens. I am not optimistic about it, but I hope I am wrong. We will know a lot more once Fred finishes his review.I have a copy of the Simera 50/1.5 @Steve Spencer@, in e-mount. It performs worse on the stock Sony than a modded Sony at portrait distance in the midframe to the corners. But it's still pretty usable in my book and not as affected as I expected. I will test at infinite this weekend. Unlike the 35mm I owned, the build and IQ feel better, ergo is wonderful with the long smooth focus throw and solid feel. I found the m-mount a bit tin-y, though not cheap. I will shoot this for a bit, but I think the 50/1.4 (and C 1.5) are quality glass.
But at this point, we have conclusive evidence that Thypoch's e-mount offerings are not optically optimized. Or at least this one. Somebody else can buy and test every e-mount to find out that Thypoch didn't tailor the optics. No wonder they didn't want Bastian to tell people. And that means, if you are shooting the e-mount 35mm and 28/1.4's, get ready for a heavily compromised optical performance. From my limited shooting thus far, the 50mm I would feel good about using on either from a sensor stack induced perspective. ...Show more →
Thank you for getting the lens and testing it out. I am disappointed they didn't tweak the design for better performance on stock Sony E mount than on a thin sensor stack, but I can't say that I am surprised given the comments they made to Bastian. I also can't imagine that if they didn't tweak the performance of this lens in the cine housing for E mount that they tweaked any of the other lenses for Sony E mount. I am going to assume the other Thypoch lenses perform better with thinner sensor cover glass than on a stock sensor until I see evidence to the contrary.
For me this is another push to getting my sensor modified. It is another lens that I think I would like to have that would perform better on a modified sensor camera than on a stock sensor camera.
Lenses I am interested in that I think would perform better on a modified sensor camera now include: Thypoch 50 f/1.4, Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4, Voigtlander 28 f/1.5, Voigtlander 28 f/2 II, Thypoch 28 f/1.4 (we'll see, after Fred's review I may lose interest), Zeiss ZM 25 f/2.8, Leica M 24 f/2.8 Asph, Zeiss ZM 18 f/4, Zeiss ZM 15 f/2.8
Lenses that I am interested in that I think would perform better on a modified sensor camera now include: Zeiss Loxia 25 f/2.4, Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, Zeiss Batis 18 f/2.8, Sony/Zeiss 16-35 f/4 OS
Lenses I am interested in that I am not sure whether they will perform better on a modified sensor camera or on a stock sensor camera include: Voigtlander 28 f/2.8 Color Skopar Asph, LLL 28 f/2.8 9 element
Lenses that I am interested in that I can get optimized for either sensor stack include: Voigtlander 21 f/1.4, Voigtlander 35 f/2 APO, Voigtlander 40 f/1.2, Voigtlander 50 f/1.2, Voigtlander 50 f/2 APO
Lenses that I am interested in that I don't think the sensor stack cover glass thickness will matter: Leica M 75 f/2.4, Voigtlander 75 f/1.5, Thypoch 75 f/1.4 (we'll see after it comes out but based on the 50 I am optimistic), Zeiss Loxia 85 f/2.4, Voigtlander 125 f/2.5 APO Macro, any Sony or Minolta E or A mount lens 85mm or longer
I know what I like and the Thypoch 50 f/1.4 is very much to my liking, but especially on Leica M or a thin sensor modified Sony. I like a lens with less CA; but I also like smoother less structured bokeh. I like a lens that is reasonably sharp, but a bit of spherical aberration wide open is fine to soften that aperture a bit. I like a lens with excellent performance at close distances, but I want decent performance at long distances at least stopped down. To me I am looking for balance, between these often competing attributes and I think this Thypoch 50 f/1.4 has really nice balance in that way. We'll see about the 28 and 35. I have some hope for the 28, but little for the 35. I am will be waiting to see Fred's review of the 28mm and I almost always find his reviews really give me a great sense of how the lens performs.
On ergonomics I still don't know and won't until I actually use one of course, but I expect it to be fine, but nothing fantastic either. Said another way, I don't expect it to have the ergonomics of the Leica lenses I have owned which I have mostly loved, but I expect it to be a bit better than the Zeiss Loxia lenses which really could be a lot better.
Steve Spencer wrote:
Lenses I am interested in that I think would perform better on a modified sensor camera now include: Thypoch 50 f/1.4, Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4, Voigtlander 28 f/1.5, Voigtlander 28 f/2 II, Thypoch 28 f/1.4 (we'll see, after Fred's review I may lose interest)....
p.14 #10New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
Ok all--I did two rounds of testing. I found some issues with the first round, and I now tested the 50.1.5 Simera e-mount at 3 distances. I have to go back on my statement above. And massive props to Thypoch. I don't know why they aren't tell people their lenses have been tweaked for Sony, or at least the 50mm. I am now very curious if the 28mm and 35mm has been tweaked for Sony sensors, or at least the cinema versions.
The Thypoch-C 50/1.5 has been optically tweaked to work better for Sony sensors.
My finds are that, the midzone is slightly better at near distance on a modded a7rII with an e-mount lens, but the corners are worse at near (3-4 feet), mid (12 feet) and infinite (200+ feet). The modded camera here is an a7rII (42mp), the stock an A7cii (33mp). So the crops you arelooking at for the modded crops are higher magnification than the Stock. Just something to keep in mind too, at all distances and apertures, the lens is re-focused on the center.
So, the corners are worse on the modded sensor at all distances while the center and midzone are only academically different, indicating the e-mount version is indeed better for e-mount, and has been tweaked from the m-mount copy. Bastian's crops show the Simera M 50/1.4 performing much worse on a Stock a7r2 and better on m-mount.
Another interesting observation, this e-mount 50mm plays very well on both sensors, unlike the m-mount. I personally would not hesitate to use it on both unless I was worried about extreme corner sharpness--the e-mount Simera is great on stock Sony at f4, but needs to be at 5.6 on the mod. Beyond that, it's a 50mm that works very well on both sensors, with some slight advantage on the stock Sony overall. I am not seeing quite the color richness and micro-contrast of the 50 Lux, but honestly, the Simera 50 is pretty impressive and better in many other areas.
p.14 #11New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
'And massive props to Thypoch. I don't know why they aren't tell people their lenses have been tweaked for Sony, or at least the 50mm.'
I've watched more interviews of DZOFilm spox and the people in the Thypoch outreach program than most. They are very much of a Chinese engineering mindset. Add to that, the 'lost in translation' statements that are often misconstrued, and you see why people jump to conclusions. Some really got into it with relish, and enjoyed giving them a kick while they were down.
To answer more directly, they probably can't conceive that anyone would believe they would deliberately manufacture and market a lens that was not fit for purpose. There were people who though they had just kicked off and operated more or less out of a shed.
I have a 28/1.4 E-mount on order after the due diligence period of analyzing the work of respectable reviewers was complete. I expect it to work perfectly. You don't learn how to produce middle tier cine optics by accident.
Thank you for your efforts here. I hope they make the 50mm in the major mirrorless mounts a.s.a.p. That is where their future lies - in mainstream acceptance. Early days, but we can now see the beginnings of a more photographic consciousness appearing in those forums.
p.14 #13New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
I believe I see the early signs of more interest in vintage lenses, in what it means to look past 'sharpness'. Thyese things can move in cycles, remember ten years back we saw most members on the same wavelength on these issues.
Then, with the consolidation of the EVF camera brands, and the rise of the SL Leicas plus Fuji MF the emphasis went back to uber-quality in a more narrow, more digital sense. Lenses element counts grew quickly - many 50s have 12-14 elements, more f1.2 lenses appeared, more great wide open lenses came along, more (and I don't like the term) clinical lenses were identified and the issue arose as a concern near the end of that period.
More recent reviewers - I read a lot of them - have many more images than just a year ago. More character lenses, more adapting of older lenses. This is what I mean by that term. We also saw the rise and rise of YouTube photographic reviewers, a kind of grass roots movement of sorts. Some makers will pay them a good amount of attention, as feedback from these 'influencers'.
p.14 #14New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
I am seeing a lot of reviewers saying the Simera 28mm has very fine, though not perfect, CA correction of both main kinds and that is impressive given the performance of their two main 28mm competitors from Cosina and Leica. We will probably see a little green/magenta color in tiny OOF balls usually seen only in close inspection, as in the 50/1.4. But its idiosyncratic bokeh remains its main drawcard.
p.14 #16New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
I have added some pics taken this am while dog walking. Take notice of the shot of the barn image. On the extreme top edge I accidentally captured some communication cables. This gives you a good idea of the xtreme edge and corner sharpness, although it was at F11 I believe.
This lens continues to impress me despite the fact that my copy 'back focuses dramatically. I have compensated by testing to determine the critical focus point to get landscape images critically sharp from near to far, at 5.6, F8, and F11. I then put a small slice of yellow tape on the lens that identifies the setting. I then know that the horizon will be sharp and the depth of sharpness is determined by the aperture. With a vertical shot it would be most often F11. As I have said shooting with the Simera 28 reminds me of the old Distagons, where the side and bottom edges of the picture are so very rich in details.
p.14 #17New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
Dustin Abbott pointed out that the 28mm retained detail even deep into diffraction. F11 was fine according to him, and at f16 'it's a little softer but still usable.' Rich in detail, all right.
p.14 #18New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
Interestingly, DZO/Thypoch are hooked into some serious players in the burgeoning imaging world.
'To ensure the accuracy and scientificity of the measurement data, Thypoch brand MTF data comes from the company's equipment TRIOPTICS ImageMaster HR series products. As of 2024, this equipment will still be the top measuring instrument in the industry.'
That's a tall claim. But looking deeper into both the the device and the companies behind it, they are indeed world class players. Trioptics was recently taken over by Jenoptics, whose credentials also speak for themselves:
In its 13/11 design, the lens features two aspherical elements, three low-dispersion elements, and three high-refractive-index elements designed to reduce flare and chromatic aberration. Eight elements of 'special glass'. 490 grams, 16-blade aperture, 67mm filters, MFD 0.23m. E-mount native, $879.
We are now waiting on the non M-mount versions of the 50/1.4, and the appearance of the 75/1.4 and this 21/f1.4. But they are moving fast. Many cine lenses are not purchased but leased, the serious volumes will be in the stills versions.
p.14 #20New M-Mount 28/1.4 and 35/1.4 from Thypoch
Thypoch announced their new 21mm T1.5 in Simera-C form. Spenser Sakurai scored a loaner of it and the 75mm T1.5. He made a pleasant and stylish video of it in at the start of this account of the new lenses:
The 21mm he got is in M mount, so that conforms with their practice of making lenses for several mounts. It's a true 21.6mm and breathes a little, to end up at around 23mm or so at its MFD (stated as 0.23m), my guess. MFD is about the same as the E-mount version of the CV 21/1.4 - 0.25m there. (VM version is 0.5m).