RoamingScott wrote:
This is as uneducated a statement you could make on the two lenses in question.
oguruma wrote
RoamingScott wrote
This isn’t an either/or choice to me…the lenses are as different as can be in all aspects.
You get the one that meets the most of your criteria or you get both because life sucks and then you die. Considering the characteristics that differentiate lenses, I'd say they're pretty damn similar... The focal length and aperture being the most notable... The 50f f1.8 and the 40 f2 have a pretty similar perspective and field of view, and an almost-identical aperture.
Do they render differently? Sure, but I don't think I would say they are "as different as can be in all aspects".....
Ummmm.... No.
We're comparing 2 modern lenses from the same manufacturer, with a nearly-identical aperture, with a very similar focal length... How in the hell is that "as different as can be in all aspects?"
If we were trying to compare the 50 f1.8 to the 600 F5.6 AI, then you would have a point. The 50 f1.8 and the 600 f5.6 are VERY different lenses (though even those are technically not "as different as can be in all aspects" because they do still have some things in common, and their differences are not actually "as different as can be").
If you said the differences in characteristics of the images produced by the two lenses are very different, that certainly sounds reasonable, but to say "they're as different as can be" is just silly bullshit.