fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?

  
 
roybenjey
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
jrscls wrote:
I bought the 50 f/1.8 S and didn’t care for either of the 35 offerings, so I just picked up the 40 f/2. I really like the focal length and the lens. In fact, I opted to return the 50 as I prefer the lighter weight and wider FOV of the 40.

I will pair the 40 with a 105 MC and 24-120 on my Z8. I have the 180-600 for wildlife so these four lenses cover most of my needs.


Going to be running a similar setup:

- 40mm for street and general use
- 85mm for portrait
- 105mm MC for detail and portrait (testing this weekend)
- 180-600mm for wildlife

Since I don't live in a place that has a lot of particularly scenic landscapes to capture, I figured I would invest in the wildlife lens and rent landscape lenses as needed.
Aug 06, 2024 at 07:17 AM
Driften
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I'm thinking of paring my 40mm with the 26mm, 85mm, and maybe 28-400mm. I love the 24-120 f/4 I used to have but for landscapes and some wildlife it's too short. While a 180-600mm would be great, it's too heavy for me. If I need longer than 400mm I could always use my Canon R7 which only really gets used for wildlife.
Aug 06, 2024 at 11:38 AM
Pechorin
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Lovely portrait.

And it shows that, yes, it's not as sharp at close distances as the S lenses. But it's more than adequate. The skin tones look nice. The bokeh is pleasing.

I have the 50mm f/1.8s, but I think I may keep this one too (I got it for 240 with the ZF a few days ago).
Aug 15, 2024 at 07:40 AM
Max Power
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
I think part of it is…maybe people who came to photography during the MILC era have never had a character lens before the 40 and they get hooked on that feel through it. That doesn’t make the 40 a great lens, but perhaps a gateway to even better character lenses. We are seeing this with younger RF shooters and the 35/1.4.

Now that I own the 40, I can safely stand by what I wrote quoted above. There is nothing inherently special about it short of its low price. I can’t fathom considering the 40 and 50 S for the
...Show more →

I feel like I came from an era where everything was a character lens and that's why detail impresses me more these days than whatever character is. I will take that 1.8 all day long. Of course, I don't do portraits, so there is little downside to the extra sharpness for me. It's awesome for architecture and nature.

This must drive lens manufacturers nuts. Look at just about any F mount 50mm Nikon lens, and there is not a lot to get excited about. So the designers sit down with this new mount and say lets build a 50mm that will rank as well as the best 50mm lenses ever made. Release it, crowd goes nuts, then all of a sudden it's too clinical and the crowd wants character, ya know, like before. I can hear a lot of palms slapping foreheads on the other side of the pond.
Aug 15, 2024 at 09:37 AM
Jockel
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
The 40mm is a nice lens. Not more. It has character (obviously that's what we call optical imperfections today) but will never come in the Z 35/1.8 or Z 50/1.8 league.

If I want character to the Z 1,8 lenses I start Photoshop.
If I want a clinical and overall sharp look with the 40mm ... sorry, not possible.
Aug 15, 2024 at 03:00 PM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Spent some time with the 40mm tonight again. Perhaps I've been tough on this lens with my comments given that I quite enjoy having something so light. It's far from perfect but it's so inexpensive I find it hard to think I'll part with it anytime soon given that it's a fun lens to walk around with. Still, I have no thoughts of selling the 50mm f1.8S lens. If I'm doing a portrait specifically, it's a no-brainer to use the 50mm over the 40mm.....but for street photography and random informal portraits, the 40mm is quite nice. I'll post a few pics from the 40mm on the image thread page.
Aug 15, 2024 at 03:08 PM
jrscls
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have been putting together my Nikon kit (recently switched from a Sony A7RV to the Nikon Z8) and have been going back and forth on 35/40/50 primes.

I like the 40mm focal length, but I think I'm going to stick with the 50 f/1.8 S along with the 20 f/1.8 S, MC 100 f/2.8 S and 24-120. The 50 f/1.8 S may not have as much character as the 40, but the 50 just wins for image quality.

Edited on Aug 24, 2024 at 12:27 PM · View previous versions
Aug 15, 2024 at 07:27 PM
oguruma
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
This isn’t an either/or choice to me…the lenses are as different as can be in all aspects.

You get the one that meets the most of your criteria or you get both because life sucks and then you die.


Considering the characteristics that differentiate lenses, I'd say they're pretty damn similar... The focal length and aperture being the most notable... The 50f f1.8 and the 40 f2 have a pretty similar perspective and field of view, and an almost-identical aperture.

Do they render differently? Sure, but I don't think I would say they are "as different as can be in all aspects".....
Aug 15, 2024 at 07:40 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.5 #9Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
This is as uneducated a statement you could make on the two lenses in question.

oguruma wrote:
RoamingScott wroteThis isn’t an either/or choice to me…the lenses are as different as can be in all aspects.

You get the one that meets the most of your criteria or you get both because life sucks and then you die.
Considering the characteristics that differentiate lenses, I'd say they're pretty damn similar... The focal length and aperture being the most notable... The 50f f1.8 and the 40 f2 have a pretty similar perspective and field of view, and an almost-identical aperture.

Do they render differently? Sure, but I don't think I would say they are "as different as can be in all aspects".....

Aug 15, 2024 at 08:08 PM
oguruma
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
This is as uneducated a statement you could make on the two lenses in question.

oguruma wrote
RoamingScott wroteThis isn’t an either/or choice to me…the lenses are as different as can be in all aspects.

You get the one that meets the most of your criteria or you get both because life sucks and then you die.
Considering the characteristics that differentiate lenses, I'd say they're pretty damn similar... The focal length and aperture being the most notable... The 50f f1.8 and the 40 f2 have a pretty similar perspective and field of view, and an almost-identical aperture.

Do they render differently? Sure, but I don't think I would say they are "as different as can be in all aspects".....


Ummmm.... No.

We're comparing 2 modern lenses from the same manufacturer, with a nearly-identical aperture, with a very similar focal length... How in the hell is that "as different as can be in all aspects?"

If we were trying to compare the 50 f1.8 to the 600 F5.6 AI, then you would have a point. The 50 f1.8 and the 600 f5.6 are VERY different lenses (though even those are technically not "as different as can be in all aspects" because they do still have some things in common, and their differences are not actually "as different as can be").

If you said the differences in characteristics of the images produced by the two lenses are very different, that certainly sounds reasonable, but to say "they're as different as can be" is just silly bullshit.
Aug 15, 2024 at 11:55 PM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
urbanwild wrote:
Spent some time with the 40mm tonight again. Perhaps I've been tough on this lens with my comments given that I quite enjoy having something so light. It's far from perfect but it's so inexpensive I find it hard to think I'll part with it anytime soon given that it's a fun lens to walk around with. Still, I have no thoughts of selling the 50mm f1.8S lens. If I'm doing a portrait specifically, it's a no-brainer to use the 50mm over the 40mm.....but for street photography and random informal portraits, the 40mm is quite nice. I'll post a few
...Show more →

We must have the same set of eyes because I have the same thoughts on this. I am on my third go round with the 40 after souring on the new 35 1.4 Z recently I sent it back). It is a good lens but lacks something. The Tamron 35 1.4 is my best 35 but I am done with the extra weight, and am relying more on a Tamron 28-75 G2 now. So it looks like the 40 gets the nod after all for a prime. The 40 offsets the very sharp 50 1.8s which is just a great lens. I am making peace with this. The 40 and 50 are very complimentary. I have some images with the 40 stopped down to 2.5 in DX mode on my Z7II that come close to the 58 1.4 at 2.5. So much so that I can set the 58 aside. That is primarily indoors in lower light without flash. It would be stupid to let this lens go again. I see it as a counterweight lens, to take the edge off of well corrected lens, creates a slight vintage look and provide the lightweight alternate all in a small form factor for perfect street use and run and gun. The 35 1.4 was supposed to be that lens but I did not see the compelling reason to use that lens at 1.4 in the end. The extra 5mm makes a difference. If I really need a bit wider, the flexibility of the 28-75 G2 to float between 28-50 range is a decent choice.

I could also see the 40 along side the 35 1.8Z. That makes sense as well.
Aug 16, 2024 at 03:28 AM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
aerospace99 wrote:
urbanwild wroteSpent some time with the 40mm tonight again. Perhaps I've been tough on this lens with my comments given that I quite enjoy having something so light. It's far from perfect but it's so inexpensive I find it hard to think I'll part with it anytime soon given that it's a fun lens to walk around with. Still, I have no thoughts of selling the 50mm f1.8S lens. If I'm doing a portrait specifically, it's a no-brainer to use the 50mm over the 40mm.....but for street photography and random informal portraits, the 40mm is quite nice. I'll post a few pics from the 40mm on the image thread page.
We must have the same set of eyes because I have the same thoughts on this. I am on my third go round with the 40 after souring on the new 35 1.4 Z recently I sent it back). It is a good lens but lacks something. The Tamron 35 1.4 is my best 35 but I am done with the extra weight, and am relying more on a Tamron 28-75 G2 now. So it looks like the 40 gets the nod after all for a prime. The 40 offsets the very sharp 50 1.8s which is just a great
...Show more →

I think you've nailed it here. I haven't compared it with the 35mm 1.8S enough yet but will be doing more of that soon. I've been traveling with the 24-120 this past week and it's been super nice to just go out in the evening with the 28mm f2.8 SE in my pocket and the 40mm f2 SE on the Zf.
Aug 16, 2024 at 09:38 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister