fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?

  
 
oguruma
Offline

p.1 #1Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I'm considering adding either the 40 F2 or the 50 1.8 to my collection (I have Z8 and Z9 bodies).

Other than the obvious differences of the focal length and aperture size, how do these stack up?

Build quality? Sharpness?
Aug 17, 2023 at 07:24 PM
SoFoFo
Offline
Details
p.1 #2Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I had the 50 and sold it when I got the 40. I much prefer the perspective of 40mm. The 50 is a better lens mostly in every regard optically. And a bit more expensive.
The smaller size and wider FOV won me over to the 40/2. Less money too.
Aug 17, 2023 at 08:10 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
These are both reviewed extensively online with sample and test photos.

The 50/1.8 is exceptionally sharp across the field nearly corner to corner wide open. It is a reference lens. It is big for a 50/1.8 as a result.

The 40/2 is a good performer for its compact size and is decent wide open, though has a fair bit of SA glow when shot wide open on close subjects. It performs quite well stopped down, so it makes a decent compact environmental portrait lens wide open and landscape stopped down. People like to whine about the plastic lens mount because they need things to whine about.

On sale the 50/1.8 is an absolute bargain for its quality. At regular price of $300 some folks feel the 40/2 isn’t such a deal.

The 40/2 is ideal for tossing in a pocket to go along with a F/4 zoom on travel. The 50/1.8 is more of a commitment to bring along.

They each have their uses. My 40/2 comes with me more often than my 50/1.8. Though now my Voigtlander 40/1.2 is offering competition to the 40/2 and probably means my 50/1.8 will never get to go out.
Aug 17, 2023 at 08:16 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ditto what @SoFoFo said, I did the exact same thing; sold my 50/1.8 when I got the 40. Not because the 40 was better, it wasn’t. But the 40 has a more classic rendering, where the 50 is so near perfect it’s clinical, and there’s something special about the 40 focal that just jives with the way I see.
Aug 17, 2023 at 08:18 PM
Nwright09
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I owned both at the same time so I could evaluate them side by side. Can you swing this by utilizing return policies or renting?

I ended up going with the 50mm 1.8 because I felt that the added sharpness and additional 10mm of focal length helped provide just a touch more "pop" to my images - especially of people. Also I found 50mm gapped better with the 28mm prime I already had than 40mm.

Both lenses are great options but only you can determine which one makes the most sense for you given your situation.

Build quality and sharpness for sure both go to the 50mm 1.8. But the 40mm is sharp enough at f2 in the center for 99.9% of all applications and by around f5 it's hard to tell them apart for landscape purposes other than the extreme corners. The 40mm is smaller and lighter which can be a big plus for some. 40mm is arguably better for a one lens walk-around prime than 50mm. In terms of rendering I found they both produce amazing photos.

Have fun with the decision and let us know your final decision!
Aug 18, 2023 at 07:57 AM
GiovanniAprea
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Samples of some Z40 shots, portrait wise specifically?
Oct 08, 2023 at 12:59 AM
Sbatley
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have both.. the. 50 f/1.8 is super sharp and contrasty even wide open… I call it it optically clinical. I love it for high texture low light shots such as woodland in winter ..

The 40 f/2 is however my favourite lens… I take it nearly everywhere with me.. just toss in my camera bag.. some of its weaknesses are its strengths for me.. it renders with a beautiful analogue style, and has a to die for glow in some circumstances… my copy is sharp in centre to reasonably sharp at the edge (pixel peeping), but you do see some purple fringing in bright high contrast edges.. been using it recently to capture some autumnal outdoor cafe scenes in southwest France … it’s perspective and rendering is ideal for my tastes.

Edited on Oct 08, 2023 at 02:18 AM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2023 at 01:14 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
With the 50mm f/1.8 S, you are always on the safe side (for earrings in backlight, consider the Zeiss Otus 55mm f/1.4). The 40mm f/2 will render beautiful pictures in 95 % of all situations, it's not a landscape lens, and you are not on the safe side.
Oct 08, 2023 at 01:25 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
oguruma wrote:
I'm considering adding either the 40 F2 or the 50 1.8 to my collection (I have Z8 and Z9 bodies).
Other than the obvious differences of the focal length and aperture size, how do these stack up?
Build quality? Sharpness?


If you can live with MF assist tools, without AF, then consider Z-mount Voigtlander options too:
- 35/2 Apo Lanthar
- 40/1.2 Nokton
- 50/2 Apo Lanthar

Each one is both optically and mechanically better than any Nikkor Z similar lens.
I own the 50/2 Apo Lanthar; it's impressively sharp w/open with equally impressive sharpness evenness across the frame. The plots below tell more than thousands words. Only drawback is corner light fall off, easily correctable in PP though.

https://download.nikonimagespace.com/2f217685fd567e4806fd8f1bb0942e49/50-1.2%2B1.8%2B2Apo.jpg
Oct 08, 2023 at 03:01 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
It's basically a tradeoff between somewhat higher acuity in the corner and moiré problems in the center and at the edges. If the lens has higher resolution than the sensor, there is a risk that single color subpixels are selectively being activated.
Oct 08, 2023 at 04:16 AM
Ulff
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ripolini wrote:
If you can live with MF assist tools, without AF, then consider Z-mount Voigtlander options too:
- 35/2 Apo Lanthar
- 40/1.2 Nokton
- 50/2 Apo Lanthar

Each one is both optically and mechanically better than any Nikkor Z similar lens.
I own the 50/2 Apo Lanthar; it's impressively sharp w/open with equally impressive sharpness evenness across the frame. The plots below tell more than thousands words. Only drawback is corner light fall off, easily correctable in PP though.


Although it's a bit OT, comparing the Nikon primes to the Voigtländer primes is an interesting topic. While the test charts look impressive in favor for the Voigtländer, for me the real world differences were not enough to give up the AF of the Nikon 50mm for the 50/2 Apo. Here's one of the very few direct comparisons of both lenses:
https://www.downgra.de/Geek/Adapted-50mm-Shootout/
The test reflects the test chart results, but whether or not this advantage is significant enough (given that landscapes usually aren't shoot wide open and for people AF is preferred) is the a personal question.
For 50mm I decided for the Nikon prime, for 35mm I did choose the Apo.
That said, I can also see the appeal the Nikon 40mm lens had: size, weight and focal lenght are all arguments in favor of the 40mm, escpecially without a 35mm lens.
Oct 08, 2023 at 04:35 AM
AcuteShadows
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ulff wrote:
Ripolini wroteIf you can live with MF assist tools, without AF, then consider Z-mount Voigtlander options too:
- 35/2 Apo Lanthar
- 40/1.2 Nokton
- 50/2 Apo Lanthar

Each one is both optically and mechanically better than any Nikkor Z similar lens.
I own the 50/2 Apo Lanthar; it's impressively sharp w/open with equally impressive sharpness evenness across the frame. The plots below tell more than thousands words. Only drawback is corner light fall off, easily correctable in PP though.
Although it's a bit OT, comparing the Nikon primes to the Voigtländer primes is an interesting topic. While the test charts look impressive in favor for the Voigtländer, for me the real world differences were not enough to give up the AF of the Nikon 50mm for the 50/2 Apo. Here's one of the very few direct comparisons of both lenses:
https://www.downgra.de/Geek/Adapted-50mm-Shootout/
The test reflects the test chart results, but whether or not this advantage is significant enough (given that landscapes usually aren't shoot wide open and for people AF is preferred) is the a personal question.
For 50mm I decided for the
...Show more →

There really is a significant difference in corner illumination. If you can't do exposure bracketing, then some of the advantage in sharpness of the Voigtländer Apo-Lanthar may be negated by ISO noise. (I own some Voigtländer lenses - though not the Apo-Lanthar - and enjoy the manual focus when I use them.)
Oct 08, 2023 at 05:36 AM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.1 #13Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ulff wrote:
Although it's a bit OT, comparing the Nikon primes to the Voigtländer primes is an interesting topic. While the test charts look impressive in favor for the Voigtländer, for me the real world differences were not enough to give up the AF of the Nikon 50mm for the 50/2 Apo. Here's one of the very few direct comparisons of both lenses:
https://www.downgra.de/Geek/Adapted-50mm-Shootout/


The CameraLabs review of the Voigt also has a number of controlled comparisons with the Z 50/1.8S:

https://www.cameralabs.com/voigtlander-50mm-f2-apo-lanthar-review/2/

Again, confirm what the charts say but in many cases a visual comparison may be more relevant than numbers on a plot.

---------------------------------------------

AcuteShadows wrote:
There really is a significant difference in corner illumination. If you can't do exposure bracketing, then some of the advantage in sharpness of the Voigtländer Apo-Lanthar may be negated by ISO noise. (I own some Voigtländer lenses - though not the Apo-Lanthar - and enjoy the manual focus when I use them.)


Just to attach some numbers, at least according to LensTip the Voigt 50/2 APO is -2.61EV at F/2 and the Nikon Z 50/1.8S is -1.89EV at F/2. So a bit more than an additional 2/3 stop of vignetting on the Voigt which is getting pretty significant.

Also worth noting that vignetting also impacts bokeh not only in "swirliness" but also just less blur. The above numbers imply the corners of the Voigt may end up with noticeably less blur than the Nikon, but a visual comparison would be much more useful than reading numbers.

Anyway, I didn't mention the Voigt in my original choice as the OP didn't ask and it is a much different trade space as it is MF, not weather sealed, and more expensive. But by all accounts when it comes to sharpness it is a gangbusters lens!

Oh, and as far as edge case uses, the Nikon Z 50/1.8S and Nikon Z 40/2 perform very well for infrared converted cameras. The Voigtlanders tend to be awful in IR across the board, though I haven't seen a specific test for the 50/2 APO. I'd assume it is bad though as I suspect they use the same coatings in all their optics and they have always been a no go for IR shooting.

EDIT: See post further down, the 50/2 APO actually does really well for IR.


Edited on Oct 08, 2023 at 12:48 PM · View previous versions
Oct 08, 2023 at 08:55 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.1 #14Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ulff wrote:
Although it's a bit OT, comparing the Nikon primes to the Voigtländer primes is an interesting topic. While the test charts look impressive in favor for the Voigtländer, for me the real world differences were not enough to give up the AF of the Nikon 50mm for the 50/2 Apo. Here's one of the very few direct comparisons of both lenses:
https://www.downgra.de/Geek/Adapted-50mm-Shootout/


That test suggests that the 50/1.8 S is decentered. The 50/2 Apo Lanthar they've used seems slightly decentered.
I had to send back the 1st 50/2 AL I bought. The 2nd sample was definitely better, almost perfect, as should be for a 1000+ € 50/2 lens.
Oct 08, 2023 at 11:02 AM
Oldwino
Offline
Details
p.1 #15Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ulff wrote:
Although it's a bit OT, comparing the Nikon primes to the Voigtländer primes is an interesting topic. While the test charts look impressive in favor for the Voigtländer, for me the real world differences were not enough to give up the AF of the Nikon 50mm for the 50/2 Apo.


I wonder how much of that is attributed to the better precision of the autofocus.
Oct 08, 2023 at 11:56 AM
Prosophos
Offline
Details
p.1 #16Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I had both but ended up selling the 50/1.8 because I just liked the images I was making with the 40/2 more. I know objectively the 50 has the upper hand with respect to test scores, but I just appreciated the 40's output (as well as slightly wider FOV) more. However, I tend to photograph mostly people so you may have different needs.

If you're interested, I've posted some of my 40 images in the 40/2 Z thread, as well as on my own site.

—Peter.
Oct 08, 2023 at 12:14 PM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.1 #17Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
kwalsh wrote:
Oh, and as far as edge case uses, the Nikon Z 50/1.8S and Nikon Z 40/2 perform very well for infrared converted cameras. The Voigtlanders tend to be awful in IR across the board, though I haven't seen a specific test for the 50/2 APO. I'd assume it is bad though as I suspect they use the same coatings in all their optics and they have always been a no go for IR shooting.



This is a statement that is not really accurate due to its generality.
Both the 35mm f/2 and the 50mm f/2 Apo Lanthar are excellent for B&W IR photography, with no hotspots or aperture selection limitations due to hotspots.
Accordingly, they are listed as well suited "good performers" at Kolari and other hotspot databases without any restrictions.

https://kolarivision.com/lens-hotspot-list/

Comment on the review of the CV 50mm f/2 AL on philipreeve.net underlines this.

"The 50 APO-Lanthar is my go to lens for IR having no hot spot with great sharpness, contrast, tonality. I also own the Voigtlander 65mm f2, 40mm 1.2 that have hot spots. Other IR lenses that are very good for me are Voigtlander 15mm f2, Loxia 21mm and Loxia 85mm. If that was the only lens to own I’d be happy."

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-voigtlander-50mm-f2-apo-lanthar/

However, the two Apo-Lanthars seem to have a major problem with color infrared, the edges of the frame show a significant red colour cast.
I haven't used my HoyaR72 much, but can confirm that for the CV 35mm f/2 AL-Z in the tests I've done so far.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1625777/57#15182061

So you should differentiate exactly, such sweeping assessments "The Voigtlanders tend to be awful in IR across the board" miss the target.
Not all Voigtlander lenses are unusable for IR (look at the Kolari hotspot databese), as with all manufacturers there are good performers and bad performers, then it also depends on the type of IR photography.
Both lenses work excellent for infrared black and white.


Oct 08, 2023 at 12:35 PM
kwalsh
Offline
Details
p.1 #18Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Vento wrote:
kwalsh wroteOh, and as far as edge case uses, the Nikon Z 50/1.8S and Nikon Z 40/2 perform very well for infrared converted cameras. The Voigtlanders tend to be awful in IR across the board, though I haven't seen a specific test for the 50/2 APO. I'd assume it is bad though as I suspect they use the same coatings in all their optics and they have always been a no go for IR shooting.
This is a statement that is not really accurate due to its generality.
Both the 35mm f/2 and the 50mm f/2 Apo Lanthar are excellent for B&W IR photography, with no hotspots or aperture selection limitations due to hotspots.
Accordingly, they are listed as well suited "good performers" at Kolari and other hotspot databases without any restrictions.

https://kolarivision.com/lens-hotspot-list/

Comment on the review of the CV 50mm f/2 AL on philipreeve.net underlines this.

"The 50 APO-Lanthar is my go to lens for IR having no hot spot with great sharpness, contrast, tonality. I also own the Voigtlander 65mm f2, 40mm 1.2 that have hot spots. Other

https://phillipreeve.net/blog/review-voigtlander-50mm-f2-apo-lanthar/

However, the two Apo-Lanthars seem to have a major problem with color infrared, the edges of the frame show a significant red colour cast.
I haven't used my HoyaR72 much, but can confirm that for the CV 35mm f/2 AL-Z in the tests I've done so far.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1625777/57#15182061

So you should differentiate exactly, such sweeping assessments "The Voigtlanders tend to be awful in IR across the board" miss the target.
Not all Voigtlander lenses are unusable for IR (look at the Kolari hotspot databese), as with all manufacturers there are good performers and bad performers, then it also depends on the type of IR photography.
Both lenses work excellent for infrared black and white.

...Show more →

Excellent information! Thanks for the correction.

EDIT: Just to add, I greatly prefer these kinds of specific reports as I know from direct experience with many lenses that the Kolari hotspot database can be kind of coarse in its classification. Some listed as "Good Performers" are not useful for color IR or panoramas at all. A hint is if they note it has a hot spot starting at some aperture the reality is that there is a diffuse hot spot at all apertures that will give color IR or panoramas fits.
Oct 08, 2023 at 12:47 PM
Vento
Offline
Details
p.1 #19Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I agree wholeheartedly.
Unfortunately, the databases are only a rough guide, primarily only with regard to the occurrence of hotspots.
Specific experiences of users who dedicate themselves to IR photography are certainly more meaningful, but unfortunately for already rather little frequented optics often difficult to find.
Often you just have to try it out yourself.
You can often find more comprehensive information in the comments under the database.
Oct 08, 2023 at 01:15 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.1 #20Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I own both right now, but I'll be selling my 50/1.8. It's the better lens, but I have the Sony 50/1.2 GM as my 50mm, and if I want to bring along a small autofocus lens, I'll pop the 40 in my bag instead.
Oct 08, 2023 at 01:31 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister