If you aren't pixel peeping, the 40mm 4/2 is nice, fast, sharp enough, smaller, lighter, and cheaper. The 50mm 1.8 as everyone said is just stupid sharp, its still light. In the end, it's $190 vs $400. I was in the same boat, but because I've had the 50mm 1.8 S a few times, I went with the 50mm 1.8 because of its optical quality.