fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?

  
 
futurecorvo
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
40mm is my favorite focal length– something I didn't know until the last year or so where I mostly shot the Sony/Zeiss 55mm. 40mm (FF equiv) on Fuji cameras brought me there.

Anyway.

Having moved to Z (via the Zf), the 40 was an instant, obvious buy and I *love* that lens. That lens is so good. Its vibe exemplifies everything that I dislike about modern cameras and modern glass. Van Neistat said that Sony is for technicians (which– I don't think he meant in the negative way it sounds). But going one step further Sony chases perfection, along with Nikon and Canon. What I think is happening with Nikon though is they're also willing to make the imperfect. The "character" lenses. The things which have a vibe. It seems that 35/1.4 might be that as well. If Sony is for technicians then maybe Nikon is for artists. The Zf is all about feel– there's nothing technically head and shoulders above the others in the line.. but they made something with character, a vibe. The 40/2 is all feel too.

Anyway.

Because I have a problem I went looking and picked up the 50/1.8S for a reasonable price and put it on my new to me Z8 (a technically great camera). They're a good match and the lens seems perfectly perfect. Exactly as intended (though I might still say with a better ~vibe~ than Sony's GMaster lenses– which really are lenses devoid of all sentimentality– if you like charts, get Sony GM).

Anyway.

I think they could coexist. I also want the 35/1.4 (depending on the reviews)... but then my trinity looks like 35/40/50. That's the problem with the 40. Where do you go from there? If we're talking pure focal length then it doesn't make much sense... if you look beyond that though you have some good applications. 35/1.4– if you, like me, photograph mostly indoors, often at night... you like a 1.4. The 40 is for everything. Walk out of the house– put on the 40... golden. The 50 is for when you want a bit more on the technical side. Something where wide open sharpness seems important.

Anyway.

What were we talking about? Which one? Get the 40 used... ~$200 and there's no better value for your money. This thing lives on my camera. It's so great. It brings the vibes. But also... the 50 can be had for ~$400– also a great value. I guess we're back at the beginning.
Jul 22, 2024 at 07:53 PM
Adamwilbert
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
This is sort of my problem too, which is why I was trying to convince myself of the 28 instead.
Jul 22, 2024 at 08:30 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #3Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
This isn’t an either/or choice to me…the lenses are as different as can be in all aspects.

You get the one that meets the most of your criteria or you get both because life sucks and then you die.
Jul 22, 2024 at 08:34 PM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
Interesting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that
...Show more →

So far Scott's comments aren't the most common here, but I don't think they're a far off assessment. The bokeh is nice if you get close up but then most lenses are like that. If it weren't for the price and size, I don't know if I'd keep it.....but I am keeping it for those reasons. I want to work on street photography when I get more time and I think this is a good option where critical sharpness isn't a big deal (and I don't mind vignetting). I have yet to see images from this lens that wows me to be honest, but I haven't used it a lot. If this were a $1000 lens, that would be a criticism, but it's not and I think it has a rightful place in a kit. But then again I'm also giving thought to selling this and the 28mm f2.8 for a manual lens like a voigtlander if I were looking at shooting primarily at f8-11.

I'll share three test shots with my kid.....taken in the same spot. These were done in a quick couple of minutes in a parking lot outside the camera store just to see what my first impression would be in comparison with the 50mm 1.8S and the 58mm f1.4G. My kid's a trooper for always being the test subject and not minding me sharing which I'm thankful for.....but this was just a throw together. On hindsight I would have had removed my kid's glasses since the eye AF on the Z7 front-focused with the 58mm shot, but you'll get the idea of the overall images. I even stopped down the 58mm for more eye sharpness given the framing I picked but still blew it....oh well. Curious what others see. I think the 1.8S is a nice balance with sharpness and bokeh. The 58mm is more artistic with the softness. I don't like it in this particular framing though and I have to center the subject to really get the look I love. Anyway, the 40 to me is more meh for portraits unless stopped down to f4 and taken in tight.

If folks want to see a different comparison, let me know and I'll have a go.

40mm f2 at f2.0

https://photos.smugmug.com/Test-shots/i-gpzq4bf/0/Mh2pXjknSkvMMngjwknMJDs37zLXpvXw3vXqmgNfC/4K/DSC_5803-4K.jpg

50mm f1.8S at f1.8

https://photos.smugmug.com/Test-shots/i-c3L3HsQ/0/LMJXtD2JNbQWSgt9sPzbqRKJD4jxmFnsh2hVTX3xG/4K/DSC_5797-4K.jpg

58mm f1.4G at f1.8

https://photos.smugmug.com/Test-shots/i-KtTJCvb/0/Kh4d48WWW3K2zkKrv3qCTwxWqPXDSTQzmcZVgGcg2/4K/DSC_5795-4K.jpg
Jul 22, 2024 at 10:50 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #5Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I think part of it is…maybe people who came to photography during the MILC era have never had a character lens before the 40 and they get hooked on that feel through it. That doesn’t make the 40 a great lens, but perhaps a gateway to even better character lenses. We are seeing this with younger RF shooters and the 35/1.4.

Now that I own the 40, I can safely stand by what I wrote quoted above. There is nothing inherently special about it short of its low price. I can’t fathom considering the 40 and 50 S for the same usecases.
Jul 22, 2024 at 11:15 PM
KLaban
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
The best thing about the 40 is it's not clinical. The other best thing about the 40 is it's discrete and doesn't frighten the natives. The other best thing about the 40 is it's compact and lightweight. The best thing of all about the 40 is nobody takes it seriously: I like that quality in people.

In a career that has lasted many decades I've been fortunate enough to have used some of finest lenses from the finest manufacturers known to man: and yet this silly little thing is constantly welded to one of my bodies.

Even cats don't take it seriously: I like that quality in cats.

https://www.keithlaban.co.uk/Blue_Cat_large.jpg
Jul 23, 2024 at 01:42 AM
aerospace99
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
futurecorvo wrote:
40mm is my favorite focal length– something I didn't know until the last year or so where I mostly shot the Sony/Zeiss 55mm. 40mm (FF equiv) on Fuji cameras brought me there.

Anyway.

Having moved to Z (via the Zf), the 40 was an instant, obvious buy and I *love* that lens. That lens is so good. Its vibe exemplifies everything that I dislike about modern cameras and modern glass. Van Neistat said that Sony is for technicians (which– I don't think he meant in the negative way it sounds). But going one step further Sony chases perfection, along with Nikon and
...Show more →

I am in the same situation except I am using the Tamron 35 1.4 adapted on a Z7II. Absolutely stunning lens that is superior to the Nikon Z's. But the 40 offsets the beastly weight and bulk of the Tamron. The 50 is sort of like a short telephoto and works well in DX mode for a 75mm shot on a Z7II that's quite good even wide open. These 3 focal lengths with the different setups are quite complimentary. Having the 40 F2 with its character traits inside of 2 very sharp optically correct lenses provides a nice set of alternatives. I pair the 40 with my 105 1.4 to reduce weight for walk abouts. But when I want the finest bokeh and IQ out comes the Tamron 35 1.4. The 50/75 plays the middle ground very well.
Jul 23, 2024 at 04:00 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
urbanwild wrote:
... I even stopped down the 58mm for more eye sharpness given the framing I picked but still blew it....oh well. Curious what others see. I think the 1.8S is a nice balance with sharpness and bokeh.


The 1.8 S has visibly less LoCA (less green fringing in the background).

The Z 40 review by LensTip isn't that encouraging ...
"It seems the Nikon's approach to a 'prime for a beginner' problem is rather minimalistic. They cut corners so to speak and, as a result, we get a lens with a construction and performance similar to the older Nikkors 1.8/50. Mind you, the new lens's build quality is inferior, its standard accessory kit - very modest, and still it is 2-3 times more expensive than the older devices. Cheap optics of good quality? It seems those days are definitely over... "
https://www.lenstip.com/620.11-Lens_review-Nikon_Nikkor_Z_40_mm_f_2.0_Summary.html

Edited on Jul 23, 2024 at 06:15 AM · View previous versions
Jul 23, 2024 at 04:07 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #9Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
It’s an S lens, of course it does compared to this little crackerjacker.

Ripolini wrote:
urbanwild wrote... I even stopped down the 58mm for more eye sharpness given the framing I picked but still blew it....oh well. Curious what others see. I think the 1.8S is a nice balance with sharpness and bokeh.
The 1.8 S has visibly less LoCA (less green fringing in the background).

Jul 23, 2024 at 06:14 AM
Mister-Mr
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
We are in need of more cats in this world ...

To the measurebators ( and there are many ), the 50 is the bee's knees, while the little 40 is likely a source of confliction -- I think..

While I don't own the 40, I believe my internal feline would purchase it - and enjoy it as well ...



KLaban wrote:
Even cats don't take it seriously: I like that quality in cats.





Edited on Jul 23, 2024 at 03:16 PM · View previous versions
Jul 23, 2024 at 07:02 AM
roybenjey
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Initial impressions of the 40mm:

Yes, I wish it had a metal mount, but otherwise it feels like the 50mm f/1.8D did at the time, albeit more solid. For a general use lens, it will work well due to it's size and weight and could likely replace the need for a 35mm and 50mm in my kit.
Jul 23, 2024 at 07:49 AM
rick-reno
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have both. on the Zf I use the 40 a lot, Inlike the size. On the Z9 the 50 gets used, it’s size just works better for me on that big camera, They’re both sharp, with the 50 being better across the whole frame.
Jul 23, 2024 at 07:52 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
It’s an S lens, of course it does compared to this little crackerjacker.


It's not the 35/2 Apo-Lanthar though.
I should have written: both the 58/1.4G and Z 40/2 have more LoCA than the 35/1.8 S.
Jul 23, 2024 at 11:48 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #14Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Character lenses have LoCA, news at 11.

Just wait till you find out about the 40/1.2!
Jul 23, 2024 at 11:58 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
Character lenses have LoCA, news at 11.


I see no technical reason that should correlate LoCA and "character" (a rather nebulous concept ...). If you have any physical reason, please share it with us.
I understand that residual spherical aberration, coma, field curvature might contribute to a more pleasing background.

I own both the Zeiss 100/2 Makro-Planar and the Zeiss 135/2 Apo Sonnar. The former shows LoCA at the wider apertures and I find it rather annoying. The Apo Sonnar has negligible CAs, and I like its drawing characteristics. In other words, "character" lenses with well-corrected LoCA do exist. The 135/1.8 Plena does show a bit of LoCA wide open and even at f2.8, but not too much. It's a rather well-corrected lens.

Jul 23, 2024 at 12:31 PM
atnpro
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
In photography, less is more, generally.
Jul 23, 2024 at 02:19 PM
roybenjey
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Not too bad wide open in this test:

Nikon Z6II • Nikkor 40mm f/2 @f2
Jul 23, 2024 at 05:42 PM
wind30
Online
Details
p.4 #18Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
urbanwild wrote:
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that is meant to be carried everywhere, especially with its weather sealed designation
- tends to have nervous bokeh
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
So far Scott's comments aren't the most common here, but I don't think they're a far off assessment. The bokeh is nice if you get close up but then most lenses are like that. If it weren't for the price and size, I don't know if I'd keep it.....but I am keeping it for those reasons. I want to work on street photography when I get more time and I think this is a good option where critical sharpness isn't a big deal (and I don't mind vignetting). I have yet to see images from this lens that wows me
...Show more →

nice comparison shots. Much better than a lot of reviews shooting a near subject with the background blown into oblivion.

I like the f1.8 s the best. The problem for the 40mm is the nervous rings around all the bokeh highlights... I can't stand those. The 58mm has very distracting colour fringing. I think the f1.8s is pretty good, subjective opinion.
Jul 23, 2024 at 06:20 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
There seems to be a trend that less corrected lenses have more character and pop, including LoCA. Take the Nikon 58mm f1.4 as an example:
https://www.lenstip.com/397.5-Lens_review-Nikon_Nikkor_AF-S_58_mm_f_1.4G_Chromatic_and_spherical_aberration.html

The Voigtlander 40mm f1.2, (I have the E mount version) is practically two lenses in one. Wide open it's soft and dreamy, stop it down a few stops and it's quite sharp.

I plan on picking up the Nikon 40mm f2, I almost grabbed it during the July sales, but it was back ordered at the sites I checked. My feeling is it will serve me well as a nice compact AF lens for when size matters, or a fairly fast lens I can easily keep in my bag in case I run into a low light situation. I don't expect a $300 compact lens to be stunning optically, but at the same time, I have never placed my Sigma 40mm f1.4 in my bag just in case I need a low light lens. Some lenses are designed for IQ above all else, some are designed for practicality and fun.

So far I think Nikon has been striking a nice balance between high IQ lenses and practical lenses with their Z lens lineup.
Jul 23, 2024 at 06:35 PM
jrscls
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I bought the 50 f/1.8 S and didn’t care for either of the 35 offerings, so I just picked up the 40 f/2. I really like the focal length and the lens. In fact, I opted to return the 50 as I prefer the lighter weight and wider FOV of the 40.

I will pair the 40 with a 105 MC and 24-120 on my Z8. I have the 180-600 for wildlife so these four lenses cover most of my needs.
Aug 01, 2024 at 08:16 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister