fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?

  
 
stompyq
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I owned both for a short time but returned the 40mm. For me, the 50mm was much better in every way. The only thing the 40mm has going for it is the smaller size. It reminded me too much of the Nikon f mount 50mm 1.8 lenses (in a 40mm FOV). I absolutely hate the 50mm 1.8G and 1.8D. Unless size is the deciding factor I would go with the 50mm 1.8s
Oct 08, 2023 at 04:54 PM
mikard
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Ali three. The 40 when I might need a fast one, the 50 when I definitely will need a fast one, and the 50 1.2 when 1.2 might be the ticket. Mike
Oct 09, 2023 at 11:21 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
There’s no argument the 50/1.8 is the better lens optically, but it’s so good it’s almost clinical in the way it renders. The 40 is a simpler design, rendering in a rounder, more classical way. And then there’s just something unique about the 40 focal length that differentiates it from the 35 or 50; it’s hard to define unless you’ve used it and seen it for yourself...
Oct 09, 2023 at 05:49 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #4Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Interesting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that is meant to be carried everywhere, especially with its weather sealed designation
- tends to have nervous bokeh
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
Oct 09, 2023 at 06:06 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
Interesting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the
...Show more →

You haven’t shot with it for any length of time. It’s a lot more like the Ultron than not, at least at f2.8 up, and it’s got AF
Oct 09, 2023 at 06:11 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #6Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
You haven’t shot with it for any length of time. It’s a lot more like the Ultron than not, at least at f2.8 up, and it’s got AF


Well, I have two eyeballs and a brain with which I can form 3rd hand opinions over time. The other alternative is deriding the photographers behind the largely unimpressive 40/2 shots I've seen as inept. I'm trying to be nice here.

I don't need to drive a Kia Rio to know it's unimpressive against the market at large. If it was the only car I'd ever driven, it would seem a lot cooler.
Oct 09, 2023 at 06:21 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Any comments to the statement in this review?

https://casualphotophile.com/2023/09/01/nikon-nikkor-z-40mm-lens-review/

Which brings up the next little complaint. Focusing close tends to lessen sharpness at all apertures. This is most noticeable at f/2, as one might expect, but it’s present through the range of f/stops.


FYI his final statement is this:

In short, it’s an amazing lens. For Nikon Z series users who want an every day lens with superb performance at a wonderful price, a lightweight travel lens, or a fond reminiscence of the old days of cheap nifty fifties, the Nikon Nikkor Z 40mm F/2 is it.

Oct 09, 2023 at 06:25 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
gear-nut wrote
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
You haven’t shot with it for any length of time. It’s a lot more like the Ultron than not, at least at f2.8 up, and it’s got AF
Well, I have two eyeballs and a brain with which I can form 3rd hand opinions over time. The other alternative is deriding the photographers behind the largely unimpressive 40/2 shots I've seen as inept. I'm trying to be nice here.

I don't need to drive a Kia Rio to know it's unimpressive against the market at large. If it was the only car I'd ever driven, it would seem a lot cooler.


I’ve probably driven more lenses than most — from Nikon to Canon to Leica to Hasselblad; to Contax to Mamiya 645 & 6x7, to Pentax 645 & 6x7 to Phase to Schneider to Rodenstock to Kodak; to Fuji to Zeiss to Sony to Voigtlander, and to a handful of others I can’t recall, and finally back to Nikon.

The Nikon 40 is pretty cool for how it renders, and doubly cool for what it costs. Not so much for the sister 28 however…
Oct 09, 2023 at 07:13 PM
Desmolicious
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
gear-nut wrote
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
You haven’t shot with it for any length of time. It’s a lot more like the Ultron than not, at least at f2.8 up, and it’s got AF
Well, I have two eyeballs and a brain with which I can form 3rd hand opinions over time. The other alternative is deriding the photographers behind the largely unimpressive 40/2 shots I've seen as inept. I'm trying to be nice here.

I don't need to drive a Kia Rio to know it's unimpressive against the market at large. If it was the only car I'd ever driven, it would seem a lot cooler.
I’ve probably driven more lenses than most — from Nikon to Canon to Leica to Hasselblad; to Contax to Mamiya 645 & 6x7, to Pentax 645 & 6x7 to Phase to Schneider to Rodenstock to Kodak; to Fuji to Zeiss to Sony to Voigtlander, and to a handful of others I can’t recall, and finally back to Nikon.

The Nikon 40 is pretty cool for how it renders, and doubly cool for what it costs. Not so much for the sister 28 however…


Talk to me Goose. About the 28
Oct 09, 2023 at 09:36 PM
runamuck
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Optical limits test 50 f1.8. See all pages
https://opticallimits.com/nikon_ff/1109-nikkorz5018s
Oct 09, 2023 at 09:56 PM
richyirich
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Here's a thread about Nikon Z 40mm f/2.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1722095

Sample images look fantastic to me.
Oct 10, 2023 at 05:18 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Desmolicious wrote:
Talk to me Goose. About the 28


It’s sharp enough centrally but that fades rather abruptly starting about halfway to the edges wide open, and the fade nor blurred areas are what I’d call pleasing. The fade zone does extend as you stop it down, but even at f8 doesn’t really make it to the edges. The corners never really sharpen up, and the blur isn’t anything special. Mind you the overall rendering isn’t particularly ugly, just nothing special—it’s kind of a “meh” lens overall, where the 40 at least shows some character. Both the 24-120 and 14-30 render better at 28 than the little pancake does. It is probably a pretty decent performer overall on a Dx sensor however...

I have not tried the 26, so there’s a chance it could be better — ?
Oct 10, 2023 at 06:58 AM
RWNPhoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I have both. The 40mm f/2 I used on my Zfc (for sale now), but never used on the z7 or z8. I always use the 50mm f/1.8 on them. The 50mm f/1.8 I have is better optically than the 40mm, but is bigger, longer, heavier. On the Zfc the 50mm f/1.8 was a bit too big/heavy for my tastes.
Oct 10, 2023 at 08:29 AM
Spectro
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?


RWNPhoto wrote:
I have both. The 40mm f/2 I used on my Zfc (for sale now), but never used on the z7 or z8. I always use the 50mm f/1.8 on them. The 50mm f/1.8 I have is better optically than the 40mm, but is bigger, longer, heavier. On the Zfc the 50mm f/1.8 was a bit too big/heavy for my tastes.


Agree with this. I have both but mostly use the 40 as a travel portrait lens on my Z50. It’s great for that.
I’m mainly a 50 shooter and find that for personal photography the 50 and the 24-120 covers most of my needs on my Z9. If I need other focal lengths I will use the FTZ.
I’m happy to keep both considering the price of the 40.
Oct 10, 2023 at 09:08 AM
kilowhiskey
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I had both the 50/1.8 & 40/2. I kept the 40 for my travel kit which is 14-30, 24-200 & the 40. No need to keep the 50/1.8 as I have the 50/1.2. I just wanted something light & inexpensive for travel & the 40/2 fits the bill.
Oct 10, 2023 at 10:42 AM
Max Power
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
gear-nut wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
gear-nut wrote
RoamingScott wroteInteresting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- isn't small enough to make any Z body pocketable

I can only imagine the reason it's looked upon so fondly is because it's cheap as dirt, and is therefore seen as "punching above its weight". I don't get it. All my opinion of course.
You haven’t shot with it for any length of time. It’s a lot more like the Ultron than not, at least at f2.8 up, and it’s got AF
Well, I have two eyeballs and a brain with which I can form 3rd hand opinions over time. The other alternative is deriding the photographers behind the largely unimpressive 40/2 shots I've seen as inept. I'm trying to be nice here.

I don't need to drive a Kia Rio to know it's unimpressive against the market at large. If it was the only car I'd ever driven, it would seem a lot cooler.
I’ve probably driven more lenses than most — from Nikon to Canon to Leica to Hasselblad; to Contax to Mamiya 645 & 6x7, to Pentax 645 & 6x7 to Phase to Schneider to Rodenstock to Kodak; to Fuji to Zeiss to Sony to Voigtlander, and to a handful of others I can’t recall, and finally back to Nikon.

The Nikon 40 is pretty cool for how it renders, and doubly cool for what it costs. Not so much for the sister 28 however…


I pre-ordered that 28mm, then canceled to wait for reviews. I am glad I did. I had high hopes it would come close to my 24mm 1.8 but nope.
Oct 10, 2023 at 10:58 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
I've shared this image elsewhere on the forum, but figure this a good place to repeat it. I really enjoy this lens on my camera as my "walk around at night" lens while traveling -- no other gear carried, just this lens on the body. I grabbed this snap in the town of Oban at night when we were there back in July. It's handheld at ISO 25,000. (As a side note, a lot of folks complain about the Z9 noise -- I personally don't find it that bad at all even here at 25K, but respect YMMV):





Oban at Night

Oct 10, 2023 at 11:27 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
Here's another snap from the same evening. Nothing great, but hopefully gives another look at how the 40 renders:





Oban Inn

Oct 10, 2023 at 12:18 PM
akul
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
RoamingScott wrote:
Interesting thread. I've looked a tons of samples of the 40/2 over the years. It's such a tough focal length at which to stand apart from the crowd.

- has none of the character of the CV 40/1.2 or Ultron 40/2
- lacks the critical sharpness of the Z 50/1.8
- in general, the images from it grab me less than those from the Sony 40/2.5
- it has, IMO, less interesting rendering than the 35 equivalent on the X100v
- has a mount construction inferior to the majority of competing lenses
- has no fluorine coating, which is an odd choice for a lens that
...Show more →

This lens is a bit of mystery to me. I have seen samples matches your criticism, but I also have seen images that just draws me in. Samples from Colin ( DeltaSigma) or gear-nut come to my mind. It could be purely their style of photographies that draws out characters, but not for others, While, I don’t see any room for this lens in my setup, and my style of shooting probably only exasperate its weakness, but I keep enjoying seeing shots that amazse me and go ‘hmm’ .

My 2 cents.

Luka

Edited for correct name and screen name. Sorry!

Edited on Oct 15, 2023 at 08:09 PM · View previous versions
Oct 10, 2023 at 10:13 PM
Prosophos
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Nikon Z 40 F2 vs 50 1.8?
To add to my previous comments (and since a picture is worth a 1,000 words), here are some examples with the 40/2.

Maybe these examples will serve to further illustrate the criticisms of those who don't like this lens, but for me they demonstrate how I've used it to shoot a variety of situations with more than satisfactory results.

I've tried many fine lenses (from Nikon, Leica, Mamiya, Sony, Canon, Fuji, etc.), and really like the 40/2.

—Peter.

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/08/taste-of-the-danforth-2-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2-1.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2022/11/golden-honey-autumn-morning-2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/08/taste-of-the-danforth-24-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/08/taste-of-the-danforth-15-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/01/calm-in-the-storm-3-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2-bw.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/01/winter-walk-3-prosophos-nikon-z9-nikon-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-17-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-30-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-23-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/07/night-game-4-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-8-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-16-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/09/dowtown-22-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg

https://prosophos.files.wordpress.com/2023/08/taste-of-the-danforth-19-prosophos-nikon-z9-40mm-f2.jpg
Oct 11, 2023 at 04:23 AM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister