nehemiahphoto wrote: geoffreyg wroteDid anyone compare CV 75 f2.5? Seems to have a good look too.http://gear.vogelius.se/-reviews/voigtlander-heliar-75-ltm/index.html
I have never shot it, but his reviews are excellent, and I found that helpful.
Wow, this was an extensive review! I have never tried this lens before. Seems to be well corrected?
Fred Miranda wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotegeoffreyg wroteDid anyone compare CV 75 f2.5? Seems to have a good look too.http://gear.vogelius.se/-reviews/voigtlander-heliar-75-ltm/index.html
I have never shot it, but his reviews are excellent, and I found that helpful.Wow, this was an extensive review! I have never tried this lens before. Seems to be well corrected?
Yes, seems very well corrected generally (never shot it either). Have almost purchased it serval times over as many years. It’s a relatively slow tele—seems they are easier to design than many lenses.
He thinks the 75/2.5 CH has a 'more balanced signature'. I have both. I disagree, the newer lens is much easier/faster to focus, has much better tonal control and colour separation, has far less tetchy bokeh in my environments at mid-distances (rocks are as bad as branchlets), is less prone to highlight breakouts (which can be aesthetic of course, seen another way). So the heart and the head lead me that way. (all comments re Sony usage).
The 75/2.5 is a very nice lens and more versatile than you might first think for its spec. Deep rich colour palette, good subject shaping, often striking. Closer to Leicas than modern CVs, understandable given its very early release date. Note also his focal distances. A nice review.
Fred Miranda wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotegeoffreyg wroteDid anyone compare CV 75 f2.5? Seems to have a good look too.http://gear.vogelius.se/-reviews/voigtlander-heliar-75-ltm/index.html
I have never shot it, but his reviews are excellent, and I found that helpful.Wow, this was an extensive review! I have never tried this lens before. Seems to be well corrected?
His reviews are consistently thorough and well-informed.
I have the Color-Heliar LTM 75/2.5 and it's an ideal companion for the APO-Summicron 75/2. I'm so much happier with this combination than with the Summarit-M 75/2.5 and the haptically horrible Nokton VM 75/1.5 I was using previously. The Color-Heliar 75/2.5 is one of the few CV lenses I'll hold onto as I gradually transition to a Leica-branded lens lineup.
Well, I just got a 75 Lux and, lovely as its rendering certainly is, it’s a beast to carry around compared to the APO-Summicron or the Color-Heliar. A special purpose tool, really, though I’ll eventually figure out a use case for it.
My Color-Heliar 75 has been switched to film duty along with its turn-of-the-century LTM siblings: the 25/4, 28/1.9, 35/1.7, 50/1.5, and 90/3.5. With the exception of the 25/4, they all have a gorgeous black paint finish as well as knurled focusing rings. And, happily, it’s not just the CH 75 that is “closer to Leicas than modern CVs”, the Ultron 35 and Nokton 50 also share that enviable quality.
genji wrote:
Well, I just got a 75 Lux and, lovely as its rendering certainly is, it’s a beast to carry around compared to the APO-Summicron or the Color-Heliar. A special purpose tool, really, though I’ll eventually figure out a use case for it.
My Color-Heliar 75 has been switched to film duty along with its turn-of-the-century LTM siblings: the 25/4, 28/1.9, 35/1.7, 50/1.5, and 90/3.5. With the exception of the 25/4, they all have a gorgeous black paint finish as well as knurled focusing rings. And, happily, it’s not just the CH 75 that is “closer to Leicas than modern CVs”, the Ultron 35 and Nokton 50 also share that enviable quality....Show more →
crazeazn wrote:
Bumping an old post. Thank you for the extensive review. No thank you because I need a 75lux.
You're welcome. I sold my 75 Lux. I have owned multiple copies now, but I have settled on a trinity of a 35 Lux pre-asph v2, 50/1 Noct v2 and an 80 Summilux.
nehemiahphoto wrote: crazeazn wroteBumping an old post. Thank you for the extensive review. No thank you because I need a 75lux.You're welcome. I sold my 75 Lux. I have owned multiple copies now, but I have settled on a trinity of a 35 Lux pre-asph v2, 50/1 Noct v2 and an 80 Summilux.
I just dumped my Sony gear and purchased a 35lux FLE. Now I need a body and a portrait lense and I'm good to go.
crazeazn wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotecrazeazn wroteBumping an old post. Thank you for the extensive review. No thank you because I need a 75lux.You're welcome. I sold my 75 Lux. I have owned multiple copies now, but I have settled on a trinity of a 35 Lux pre-asph v2, 50/1 Noct v2 and an 80 Summilux.I just dumped my Sony gear and purchased a 35lux FLE. Now I need a body and a portrait lense and I'm good to go.
I have my foot in both words as I got my a7r2 modded. I may pick up an m10 or 240 again though at some point as I just enjoyed RF shooting so much. Have fun!
zhangyue wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotezhangyue wroteI want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process I have a very similar conclusion and experience with this lens. What is your thinking/reasoning? I'd be curious to hear. These tests I just made to show the difference in the structural draw, but real images are a whole other thing.Derek's reply almost answer it fully. It about renders 3D subject in close distance. There is almost an "atmosphere" around the subject.
In your sample scenarios, people unavoidably focus on background: which one is smoother, which one has less CA, which one with subject sharper, lower flare those type of technical things. I do forest walk and shooting with 75lux or 80lux as well and choose not showing any of them because they suck so I am not surprised at all with your results.
However, I also do family portraits with both VC and both lux. VC is good, very smooth, sharp and versatile. In a broad spectrum, it close to Modern 85mm f1.4 such as sigma, Nikon, Canon, Sony. You get good results with smoother bokeh. However, it won't give you "lux" portraits. I will hand pick out every lux images out as preferred ones For those, I don't even care background anymore because there is nothing to care about mostly, they are all blur blur blur away, but transition and atmosphere are here to stay draw you attention. If you are into this look, you are hooked.
It is a niche look. I wouldn't deliver those images to clients if I am professional due to difficulty on controlling condition such as flare, sharpness, contrast, focus accuracy, (for some, sharpness means pro)
FM alt people tend to do thing more technically, and people tend to pick winner out of the test. For sharpness, CA correction, distortion, those are super objective. Nothing more. Maybe I could even add bokeh smoothness in the list. However, this type of comparison for lens rendering are bond to fail IMHO. Bokeh is not just smooth and ugly,(there are ugly ones, Sony 35f1.8) There is more to that, and then there is focus transition, SA depth (a word I created for portrait ).
Giving another example, Zeiss 50mm planar, if you compare it to any other modern 50 glasses on bokeh smoothness, sharpness, CA. It fail miserably. Winner for sure is not it. However, if you really use it then you will realize those "WOW" moment that others never bring you.
My philosophy on this are research, look, judge, use and decide. The final two steps are not only important but also better take time because no one know better what you need. At least, for me, there is no universal standard, I love 55OTUS's sharpness, CA correction and clean look, but I also love Nikon 58G ultra smoothness, huge coverage then there is Planar 50 that still has its place in my heart.
As why I brought this thread back again because I was browsing M11 image thread on LUF the other day. The images from 75mm lux and 35mm pre-ASPH brought smile on my face. I told myself these are just so beautiful. 35mm pre-ASPH is another one will fail every single comparison tests like this too, so what?
Great point about the Zeiss 50mm f/1.4 Planar. It’s far from technically outstanding, but it delivers beautiful images, and I love its painterly rendering.
Regarding the CV 75mm f/1.5 vs. the 75mm Summilux, the same comparison applies to the CV 50mm f/1 vs. the 50mm f/1 Noctilux. The Voigtlander is superior in contrast and off-axis resolution, but there’s something about the Noctilux images. As you said, an atmosphere. It’s like watching an HD show compared to a film, hard to put into words.
Fred Miranda wrote: zhangyue wrotenehemiahphoto wrotezhangyue wroteI want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process I have a very similar conclusion and experience with this lens. What is your thinking/reasoning? I'd be curious to hear. These tests I just made to show the difference in the structural draw, but real images are a whole other thing.Derek's reply almost answer it fully. It about renders 3D subject in close distance. There is almost an "atmosphere" around the subject.
In your sample scenarios, people unavoidably focus on background: which one is smoother, which one has less CA, which one with subject sharper, lower flare those type of technical things. I do forest walk and shooting with 75lux or 80lux as well and choose not showing any of them because they suck so I am not surprised at all with your results.
However, I also do family portraits with both VC and both lux. VC is good, very smooth, sharp and versatile. In a broad spectrum, it close to Modern 85mm f1.4 such as sigma, Nikon, Canon, Sony. You get good results with smoother bokeh. However, it won't give you "lux" portraits. I will hand pick out every lux images out as preferred ones For those, I don't even care background anymore because there is nothing to care about mostly, they are all blur blur blur away, but transition and atmosphere are here to stay draw you attention. If you are into this look, you are hooked.
It is a niche look. I wouldn't deliver those images to clients if I am professional due to difficulty on controlling condition such as flare, sharpness, contrast, focus accuracy, (for some, sharpness means pro)
FM alt people tend to do thing more technically, and people tend to pick winner out of the test. For sharpness, CA correction, distortion, those are super objective. Nothing more. Maybe I could even add bokeh smoothness in the list. However, this type of comparison for lens rendering are bond to fail IMHO. Bokeh is not just smooth and ugly,(there are ugly ones, Sony 35f1.8) There is more to that, and then there is focus transition, SA depth (a word I created for portrait ).
Giving another example, Zeiss 50mm planar, if you compare it to any other modern 50 glasses on bokeh smoothness, sharpness, CA. It fail miserably. Winner for sure is not it. However, if you really use it then you will realize those "WOW" moment that others never bring you.
My philosophy on this are research, look, judge, use and decide. The final two steps are not only important but also better take time because no one know better what you need. At least, for me, there is no universal standard, I love 55OTUS's sharpness, CA correction and clean look, but I also love Nikon 58G ultra smoothness, huge coverage then there is Planar 50 that still has its place in my heart.
As why I brought this thread back again because I was browsing M11 image thread on LUF the other day. The images from 75mm lux and 35mm pre-ASPH brought smile on my face. I told myself these are just so beautiful. 35mm pre-ASPH is another one will fail every single comparison tests like this too, so what?
Regarding the CV 75mm f/1.5 vs. the 75mm Summilux, the same comparison applies to the CV 50mm f/1 vs. the 50mm f/1 Noctilux. The Voigtlander is superior in contrast and off-axis resolution, but there’s something about the Noctilux images. As you said, an atmosphere. It’s like watching an HD show compared to a film, hard to put into words.
Still have 80lux after all these years. I choose it over 75lux due to more generous sensor coverage and better economic to focus. Close distance portraits with 75 or 80lux are just magic due to SA and deeper DOF. (this is against modern concept from Leica and Zeiss) You can't get those dreaming looks with modern lens because DOF is razor thin. The image won't have those "3D" soft look make you focus more on in focus region than whole subject or story. The draw back for classic lenses like 80lux and 75lux is they don't like "harsh light" and require patience and skill to use them wisely.