fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2022 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2022CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering

  
 
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.5 #1CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
'..even you missed critical focus, you can still get magic look. Can't say the same for Modern Glasses.'

Very true and an encouragement to all MF portrait shooters. The beauty of the image overwhelms the slight miss. The 75/1.4 Summilux produces the finest output and must be reintroduced.
Mar 28, 2025 at 07:04 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #2CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
I would love to see Light Lens Lab remake the 75 Lux version 1 at a lower weight. It would be a wonderful option as an M mount portrait lens. It is so rare, however, that it is hard to plan to get one and especially so at the inflated price the scarcity creates. To me it is just the sort of lens I would love to see them recreate.
Mar 29, 2025 at 09:42 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #3CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
Steve Spencer wrote:
I would love to see Light Lens Lab remake the 75 Lux version 1 at a lower weight. It would be a wonderful option as an M mount portrait lens. It is so rare, however, that it is hard to plan to get one and especially so at the inflated price the scarcity creates. To me it is just the sort of lens I would love to see them recreate.


+1

Remake it with a 0.7m MFD and include the same hood, but in metal instead of plastic. The most frustrating thing about the Leica 75/1.4 Lux v1 is how rare its plastic hood is. It sells for $800 on eBay. That’s just crazy.
Mar 29, 2025 at 11:46 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #4CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
I have wanted replicas of the 50/1 Noct (v1 or v2) and 75 Lux (v1) for years. Nobody cares lol

So many 35 Lux Pre-ASPH alternatives.

@fredmiranda Have you looked at 3rd party options?

@Steve Spencer I remember you liked your 80 Lux—prices are lower on those than they have been in a couple years. Just an FYI if that’s an attractive option for you.
Mar 29, 2025 at 12:01 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #5CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I have wanted replicas of the 50/1 Noct (v1 or v2) and 75 Lux (v1) for years. Nobody cares lol

So many 35 Lux Pre-ASPH alternatives.

@fredmiranda@ Have you looked at 3rd party options?

@Steve Spencer@ I remember you liked your 80 Lux—prices are lower on those than they have been in a couple years. Just an FYI if that’s an attractive option for you.


Did you mean third-party options for the hood? I looked but couldn't find any.

By the way, I just shared this feedback with Light Lens Lab. Hopefully, they'll consider it in the future!
Mar 29, 2025 at 12:31 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #6CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@fredmiranda@@@@

Yes there is a difference.

My barrel read ".9" meters and "3" feet on my V1. But it focused a bit closer than marked, just like my V2 did. My v2 was marked as ".8" meters on the barrel, but I think it went close to .6 meters. From my 75 Lux v2 review:

"The Lux 75 doesn’t feature an aspheric element and isn’t corrected for close distance. However, the 75 Lux unofficially goes down to about 0.6 meters which is desirable, but you’ll find increased spherical aberrations wide open at MFD."

I did not take out a measuring tape for any of my copies 3 copies I've owned. So, not sure exactly how much closer the versions focus closer than the stated MFD. I would guess on a v1, you're getting about .8, so not too long nor too short for a 75mm IMO. But v2 was closer.

Aren't you using a modded a7x camera now? On my a7r2 mod, I was easily able to get .7 with a helicoid with v1.
It's a bit confusing, but the main takeaway is that v1 doesn't focus as close as v2, and I didn't realize that. Thanks for clearing it up.

I mostly shoot with the M-D and M10-R, but I also occasionally use Leica M lenses on my modded A7CR.
Ahh. Then:

v1 = .9 meters on the barrel (you can get a hair closer)

v2 = .8 meters on the barrel (you can get closer, about .6 meters)

Hope that helps and is more simple.


This thread has caused some confusion. Someone mentioned that a version of the 75mm Summilux V1 focused down to 0.7m:
https://www.l-camera-forum.com/topic/248513-minimum-focus-distance-on-75mm-summilux-v1/

Thinking about it more, I believe you started this thread before trying the Sonnetar 73/1.5. I remember this lens was one of the main reasons I sold the 75 Lux, aside from using the 50/1 Noct, which, as you noted, has a similar rendering.

I played with the Sonnetar today and was reminded why I liked it so much. It is compact and lightweight with a unique character. Wide open, it has some glow and beautiful rendering. My only complaint is the short focus throw, which can make focusing very sensitive and sometimes inaccurate, especially at long distances.

You posted a comparison between the Sonnetar 73/1.5 and the Leica 75/1.4 Lux. It’s pretty funny: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1568520/1&year=2018#14669420
Mar 29, 2025 at 07:17 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.5 #7CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I have wanted replicas of the 50/1 Noct (v1 or v2) and 75 Lux (v1) for years. Nobody cares lol

So many 35 Lux Pre-ASPH alternatives.

@fredmiranda@ Have you looked at 3rd party options?

@Steve Spencer@ I remember you liked your 80 Lux—prices are lower on those than they have been in a couple years. Just an FYI if that’s an attractive option for you.


I did really like the 80 lux, and I may pick one up again. I do like both the Thypoch 75 f/1.4 and the CV 75 f/1.5, however, and have the CV. Given that both of those lenses are quite a bit smaller than the 80 lux (and would therefore fit much better in a travel or daily carry kit), I would buy the lux for its specific rendering for portraits as one of several looks I like. Right now, that isn't enough of a priority to get it, but it is a lens I like very much.
Mar 30, 2025 at 06:16 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #8CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@fredmiranda@@@@@

Yes there is a difference.

My barrel read ".9" meters and "3" feet on my V1. But it focused a bit closer than marked, just like my V2 did. My v2 was marked as ".8" meters on the barrel, but I think it went close to .6 meters. From my 75 Lux v2 review:

"The Lux 75 doesn’t feature an aspheric element and isn’t corrected for close distance. However, the 75 Lux unofficially goes down to about 0.6 meters which is desirable, but you’ll find increased spherical aberrations wide open at MFD."

I did not take out a measuring tape for any of my copies 3 copies I've owned. So, not sure exactly how much closer the versions focus closer than the stated MFD. I would guess on a v1, you're getting about .8, so not too long nor too short for a 75mm IMO. But v2 was closer.

Aren't you using a modded a7x camera now? On my a7r2 mod, I was easily able to get .7 with a helicoid with v1.
It's a bit confusing, but the main takeaway is that v1 doesn't focus as close as v2, and I didn't realize that. Thanks for clearing it up.

I mostly shoot with the M-D and M10-R, but I also occasionally use Leica M lenses on my modded A7CR.
Ahh. Then:

v1 = .9 meters on the barrel (you can get a hair closer)

v2 = .8 meters on the barrel (you can get closer, about .6 meters)

Hope that helps and is more simple.
This thread has caused some confusion. Someone mentioned that a version of the 75mm Summilux V1 focused down to 0.7m:
https://www.l-camera-forum.com/topic/248513-minimum-focus-distance-on-75mm-summilux-v1/

Thinking about it more, I believe you started this thread before trying the Sonnetar 73/1.5. I remember this lens was one of the main reasons I sold the 75 Lux, aside from using the 50/1 Noct, which, as you noted, has a similar rendering.

I played with the Sonnetar today and was reminded why I liked it so much. It is compact and lightweight with a unique character. Wide open, it has some glow and beautiful rendering. My only complaint is
...Show more →

Yeah I started that thread—my copy was pre-ordered and is from the first batch. I always love it for the same reasons you stated. I do wish the MFD was a bit shorter and the aperture ring could be turned independently of the focus ring, but it’s ok.

I sold the 75/80 Lux because I can crop the Noct to closely resemble the 75 Lux and because the Sonnetar is so cool.

Of all the lenses I have owned, I don’t really miss many of them. But I do regularly miss the 80 Lux, 85/2 contarex, and the RX1 size/IQ/rendering combo.

We should really put that 73/1.5 next to the new FE 85 Otus for a size comp

And yes—I meant 3rd party. There were some around when I had my v1, but I don’t see them now.

Here’s one for $300…

https://www.ebay.com/p/1404112803
Mar 30, 2025 at 08:38 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.5 #9CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@fredmiranda@@@@@@

Yes there is a difference.

My barrel read ".9" meters and "3" feet on my V1. But it focused a bit closer than marked, just like my V2 did. My v2 was marked as ".8" meters on the barrel, but I think it went close to .6 meters. From my 75 Lux v2 review:

"The Lux 75 doesn’t feature an aspheric element and isn’t corrected for close distance. However, the 75 Lux unofficially goes down to about 0.6 meters which is desirable, but you’ll find increased spherical aberrations wide open at MFD."

I did not take out a measuring tape for any of my copies 3 copies I've owned. So, not sure exactly how much closer the versions focus closer than the stated MFD. I would guess on a v1, you're getting about .8, so not too long nor too short for a 75mm IMO. But v2 was closer.

Aren't you using a modded a7x camera now? On my a7r2 mod, I was easily able to get .7 with a helicoid with v1.
It's a bit confusing, but the main takeaway is that v1 doesn't focus as close as v2, and I didn't realize that. Thanks for clearing it up.

I mostly shoot with the M-D and M10-R, but I also occasionally use Leica M lenses on my modded A7CR.
Ahh. Then:

v1 = .9 meters on the barrel (you can get a hair closer)

v2 = .8 meters on the barrel (you can get closer, about .6 meters)

Hope that helps and is more simple.
This thread has caused some confusion. Someone mentioned that a version of the 75mm Summilux V1 focused down to 0.7m:
https://www.l-camera-forum.com/topic/248513-minimum-focus-distance-on-75mm-summilux-v1/

Thinking about it more, I believe you started this thread before trying the Sonnetar 73/1.5. I remember this lens was one of the main reasons I sold the 75 Lux, aside from using the 50/1 Noct, which, as you noted, has a similar rendering.

I played with the Sonnetar today and was reminded why I liked it so much. It is compact and lightweight with a unique character. Wide open, it has some glow and beautiful rendering. My only complaint is the short focus throw, which can make focusing very sensitive and sometimes inaccurate, especially at long distances.

You posted a comparison between the Sonnetar 73/1.5 and the Leica 75/1.4 Lux. It’s pretty funny: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1568520/1&year=2018#14669420
Yeah I started that thread—my copy was pre-ordered and is from the first batch. I always love it for the same reasons you stated. I do wish the MFD was a bit shorter and the aperture ring could be turned independently of the focus ring, but it’s ok.

I sold the 75/80 Lux because I can crop the Noct to closely resemble the 75 Lux and because the Sonnetar is so cool.

Of all the lenses I have owned, I don’t really miss many of them. But I do regularly miss the 80 Lux, 85/2 contarex, and the RX1 size/IQ/rendering combo.

We should
...Show more →

Unfortunately, that hood does not fit the 75/1.4 Lux v1. I have searched for a similar alternative but haven’t had any luck.

By the way, I heard back from LLL, and unfortunately, they have no interest in re-making the Leica 75/1.4 Lux. However, they do have plans for this focal length with upcoming Panchro SP2, S21, and APO versions.
Apr 01, 2025 at 09:16 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #10CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
Fred Miranda wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@fredmiranda@@@@@@@

Yes there is a difference.

My barrel read ".9" meters and "3" feet on my V1. But it focused a bit closer than marked, just like my V2 did. My v2 was marked as ".8" meters on the barrel, but I think it went close to .6 meters. From my 75 Lux v2 review:

"The Lux 75 doesn’t feature an aspheric element and isn’t corrected for close distance. However, the 75 Lux unofficially goes down to about 0.6 meters which is desirable, but you’ll find increased spherical aberrations wide open at MFD."

I did not take out a measuring tape for any of my copies 3 copies I've owned. So, not sure exactly how much closer the versions focus closer than the stated MFD. I would guess on a v1, you're getting about .8, so not too long nor too short for a 75mm IMO. But v2 was closer.

Aren't you using a modded a7x camera now? On my a7r2 mod, I was easily able to get .7 with a helicoid with v1.
It's a bit confusing, but the main takeaway is that v1 doesn't focus as close as v2, and I didn't realize that. Thanks for clearing it up.

I mostly shoot with the M-D and M10-R, but I also occasionally use Leica M lenses on my modded A7CR.
Ahh. Then:

v1 = .9 meters on the barrel (you can get a hair closer)

v2 = .8 meters on the barrel (you can get closer, about .6 meters)

Hope that helps and is more simple.
This thread has caused some confusion. Someone mentioned that a version of the 75mm Summilux V1 focused down to 0.7m:
https://www.l-camera-forum.com/topic/248513-minimum-focus-distance-on-75mm-summilux-v1/

Thinking about it more, I believe you started this thread before trying the Sonnetar 73/1.5. I remember this lens was one of the main reasons I sold the 75 Lux, aside from using the 50/1 Noct, which, as you noted, has a similar rendering.

I played with the Sonnetar today and was reminded why I liked it so much. It is compact and lightweight with a unique character. Wide open, it has some glow and beautiful rendering. My only complaint is the short focus throw, which can make focusing very sensitive and sometimes inaccurate, especially at long distances.

You posted a comparison between the Sonnetar 73/1.5 and the Leica 75/1.4 Lux. It’s pretty funny: https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1568520/1&year=2018#14669420
Yeah I started that thread—my copy was pre-ordered and is from the first batch. I always love it for the same reasons you stated. I do wish the MFD was a bit shorter and the aperture ring could be turned independently of the focus ring, but it’s ok.

I sold the 75/80 Lux because I can crop the Noct to closely resemble the 75 Lux and because the Sonnetar is so cool.

Of all the lenses I have owned, I don’t really miss many of them. But I do regularly miss the 80 Lux, 85/2 contarex, and the RX1 size/IQ/rendering combo.

We should really put that 73/1.5 next to the new FE 85 Otus for a size comp

And yes—I meant 3rd party. There were some around when I had my v1, but I don’t see them now.

Here’s one for $300…

https://www.ebay.com/p/1404112803
Unfortunately, that hood does not fit the 75/1.4 Lux v1. I have searched for a similar alternative but haven’t had any luck.

By the way, I heard back from LLL, and unfortunately, they have no interest in re-making the Leica 75/1.4 Lux. However, they do have plans for this focal length with upcoming Panchro SP2, S21, and APO versions.


Odd..my hood says #12539 but looks different than the one I linked which also says 12539. You’re right, that’s not the right fit.

Bummer but not surprised by LLL. Seems like no one is overly interested in the two replicas I’d like.
Apr 02, 2025 at 12:00 AM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #11CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
zhangyue wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote@zhangyue@@@ I also prefer the 80 Summilux to the 75 and agree with you 100% on the 3D soft images. Also agree on the Luxes are light picky and have to be deployed selectively. More than even lots of character glass.

Outside the 80 Lux, what do you find the be other excellent vintage portrait lenses Michael?
I have one more character lens I really loved is Contax 80mm f2. This one might have the nicest bokeh in my personal view. It is great for portrait but just in general with good soft looking bokeh.. I think 50 planar classic has similar look some times but not consistently and could have much busier bokeh occasionally that benefit from slightly stop down to get calm image. Contax 645 80mm is just in general easier to control and use than 50 planar. I used it on Leica S006. A combo I still take out whenever I want to truly
...Show more →

Sorry--I was driving today and just remember I hadn't properly responded to this message. Yes, I really like the look of that lens sometimes but have never had a chance to shoot it. mI never bonded with the CY 50/1.4 though I have seen some lovely photos with it. Would you mind to show some of your favorite 80/2 shots here?

Another planar I really enjoyed is the 80/2.8 for Hasselblad 500c--that lens draws so nicely sometimes.

Edited on Apr 06, 2025 at 04:19 PM · View previous versions
Apr 06, 2025 at 03:04 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #12CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
philip_pj wrote:
'..even you missed critical focus, you can still get magic look. Can't say the same for Modern Glasses.'

Very true and an encouragement to all MF portrait shooters. The beauty of the image overwhelms the slight miss. The 75/1.4 Summilux produces the finest output and must be reintroduced.


The slight miss in full swing here with the 80 Lux




Apr 06, 2025 at 03:05 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.5 #13CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
A wonderful image and what a memory for the future. We tend to forget we are engaged in recording our lives as they unfold literally in front of us. We ask too much of the exactitude of focus these days and tend to miss many moments that deserve to be preserved even as not quite perfect.

Last week an attendant permitted me to shoot one in the generally forbidden Basillica of Bom Jesus, of Francis Xavier's tomb. It was not perfect at 1/60s and a wide aperture on a 75mm, but I hastily took the opportunity.
Apr 06, 2025 at 09:18 PM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.5 #14CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
nehemiahphoto wrote:
zhangyue wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@zhangyue@@@@ I also prefer the 80 Summilux to the 75 and agree with you 100% on the 3D soft images. Also agree on the Luxes are light picky and have to be deployed selectively. More than even lots of character glass.

Outside the 80 Lux, what do you find the be other excellent vintage portrait lenses Michael?
I have one more character lens I really loved is Contax 80mm f2. This one might have the nicest bokeh in my personal view. It is great for portrait but just in general with good soft looking bokeh.. I think 50 planar classic has similar look some times but not consistently and could have much busier bokeh occasionally that benefit from slightly stop down to get calm image. Contax 645 80mm is just in general easier to control and use than 50 planar. I used it on Leica S006. A combo I still take out whenever I want to truly have some fun to take photos which is much less frequently compare to 5 years ago. Not really classic, but almost all S glasses have really nice look IMHO.

Not shooting much now days, my kids grow up that they never really let me take their picture anymore. I can't blame them because I think I might have overdone it before. So Manual lens is out of use for family stuff. I used mostly AF lenses and rely on eye/face AF now to take quick images
Sorry--I was driving today and just remember I hadn't properly responded to this message. Yes, I really like the look of that lens sometimes but have never had a chance to shoot it. mI never bonded with the CY 50/1.4 though I have seen some lovely photos with it. Would you mind to show some of your favorite 80/2 shots here?

Another planar I really enjoyed is the 80/2.8 for Hasselblad 500c--that lens draws so nicely sometimes.


Sorry for the late reply. I have a few old Flickr shots with this lens and S006. All edited to my like but this lens is my favorite in term of rendering. Another big plus using this on S006 is I can stitch image easily without worry too much about corner vignette due to generous coverage. I also had legendary Hasselblad 110mm f2 but I don't like it as much. it will give shallow DOF look but lacking character to my like, maybe it needs 6x6 format to shine.

S006_c80 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_c801 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C8018 by ZHNL, on Flickr

C80 by ZHNL, on Flickr

C801 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C8020 by ZHNL, on Flickr

c804 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C809 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C8011 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C803 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C8023 by ZHNL, on Flickr

S006_C80 by ZHNL, on Flickr

Apr 13, 2025 at 11:44 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.5 #15CV 75/1.5 vs Lux 75/1.4 rendering
zhangyue wrote:
nehemiahphoto wrote
zhangyue wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote@zhangyue@@@@@ I also prefer the 80 Summilux to the 75 and agree with you 100% on the 3D soft images. Also agree on the Luxes are light picky and have to be deployed selectively. More than even lots of character glass.

Outside the 80 Lux, what do you find the be other excellent vintage portrait lenses Michael?
I have one more character lens I really loved is Contax 80mm f2. This one might have the nicest bokeh in my personal view. It is great for portrait but just in general with good soft looking bokeh.. I think 50 planar classic has similar look some times but not consistently and could have much busier bokeh occasionally that benefit from slightly stop down to get calm image. Contax 645 80mm is just in general easier to control and use than 50 planar. I used it on Leica S006. A combo I still take out whenever I want to truly have some fun to take photos which is much less frequently compare to 5 years ago. Not really classic, but almost all S glasses have really nice look IMHO.

Not shooting much now days, my kids grow up that they never really let me take their picture anymore. I can't blame them because I think I might have overdone it before. So Manual lens is out of use for family stuff. I used mostly AF lenses and rely on eye/face AF now to take quick images
Sorry--I was driving today and just remember I hadn't properly responded to this message. Yes, I really like the look of that lens sometimes but have never had a chance to shoot it. mI never bonded with the CY 50/1.4 though I have seen some lovely photos with it. Would you mind to show some of your favorite 80/2 shots here?

Another planar I really enjoyed is the 80/2.8 for Hasselblad 500c--that lens draws so nicely sometimes.
Sorry for the late reply. I have a few old Flickr shots with this lens and S006. All edited to my like but this lens is my favorite in term of rendering. Another big plus using this on S006 is I can stitch image easily without worry too much about corner vignette due to generous coverage. I also had legendary Hasselblad 110mm f2 but I don't like it as much. it will give shallow DOF look but lacking character to my like, maybe it needs 6x6 format to shine.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52034130373_6180ec3b4c_h.jpgS006_c80 by ZHNL, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/52033051087_ade61407b6_h.jpgS006_c801 by ZHNL, on Flickr

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51218981454_cd4c48b17a_h.jpgS006_C8018 by ZHNL,
...Show more →

No worries Michael. Just lovely photos and processing—you’re skilled at making harsh light subtle and soft without losing visual strength. That first picture and portrait is epic.

The OOF rendering on photos 1,5,7 and 11 strike me as being brilliant and show the Planar’s potential. Have you shot the 80/2 on FF? Does it loose its magic?
Apr 14, 2025 at 04:05 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister