I have yet to see a comparison in terms of rendering between these two lenses that was illustrative enough regarding rendering (though maybe I just missed it). So I did my own.
Photos are CV 75/1.5 and the Summilux 75/1.4. WB has been numerically matched (not AUTO), stabilization off, a7r2 NKIR thin mod, raws with no lens adjustments or CA correction, all manually focused, ISO100, default LR sharpening or NR applied, and medium contrast tone curve applied to all photos. No tripod with, so held and framed using grid on the camera. No photos have been cropped, framing is close enough to draw conclusions (for me).
Probably of limited interest for most, but some might enjoy. Enjoy
Fred Miranda wrote:
I prefer the Voigtlander in some of the samples. It would probably do better against the light.
Thanks for posting!
I agree. The intended sale of my Nokton 75/1.5 never occurred so I guess I should hold my nose regarding its physical appearance and try using it again.
Thanks for doing this...I've owned both and preferred the CV, it's what I hoped the Summilux would have been. My Summilux was just so prone to flare and the contrast disappeared as soon as there was any light in the frame. In that sense it was a very creative lens, but at times, just annoying. If I was to buy another MF 75, it'd be that CV...It draws beautifully.
not much between them, but to these eyes, there is a wee bit more sophistication in the bokeh of the 'lux. Would be happy with either. It would be interesting to compare vs. CV75 f2.5.
Great comparison. I prefer the Voigtlander in every sample. Smoother, bokeh, better contrast and flare resistance. The Lux also has a lot of fringing around bokeh balls, it's kind of distracting.
Now my real question becomes: CV 75mm F1.5 or Leica 90mm F2 (pre-asph)?
nehemiahphoto wrote: d.s. wroteIs there some motion blur going on here with a touch of front focus? https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/44/2290644.jpgNo motion blur (1/800 and it's sharp), but FL point is just a hair head.
Ah. Ok. The apparent sharpness of the CV then trounces it. I could see wanting to keep both for short distance work.
genji wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI prefer the Voigtlander in all samples. It would probably do better against the light.
Thanks for posting!I agree. The intended sale of my Nokton 75/1.5 never occurred so I guess I should hold my nose regarding its physical appearance and try using it again.
A real ugly duckling of a lens that becomes a swan when it comes to making images.
I have never had the Leica M 75 lux, but I had its brother the Leica R 80 lux and I liked the lens a lot, but I replaced it with the CV 75 f/1.5 and my experience is consistent with the images here. These luxes are close to the pinnacle of a double Gauss design. For their time they were the standard and they still are very nice lenses. They have very little lateral CA -- one of the big benefits of the double Gauss design and very important on film. Wide open there is quite a bit of SA and longitudinal CA which we see in a number of the shots, but stopped down those both go away and from f/4 there is excellent performance across the frame.
This lovely design, however, can't quite keep up with modern advances. As we see here clearly in that very first shot these older lenses lose contrast fast when shooting into brighter light. We also see close up and near wide open (the cedar branch shot is a good example) they lose a lot of sharpness. The bokeh is quite good on the Luxes, but you do have longitudinal CA creating bokeh fringing and these distances to the background it is never completely smooth (the 75 lux which was designed to keep it small also cuts off the bokeh balls quite a bit even toward the center of frame, although the CV doesn't do much if any better on that score). All that said, I think the shot with the Ivy in the center is a great use of the Luxes and takes advantage of its center sharpness (sharpness drops off quickly from the center) and nice bokeh. I think that shot is where the Luxes come closest to the CV 75 f/1.5, and one of the few places that I am not sure I prefer the CV (the shots are different but I don't have a clear preference there with plusses and minuses to each).
Thanks so much for these samples, Nehemiah. It was really nice to have so many shots with these lenses side by side,
nehemiahphoto wrote:
I have yet to see a comparison in terms of rendering between these two lenses that was illustrative enough regarding rendering (though maybe I just missed it). So I did my own.
Photos are CV 75/1.5 and the Summilux 75/1.4. WB has been numerically matched (not AUTO), stabilization off, a7r2 NKIR thin mod, raws with no lens adjustments or CA correction, all manually focused, ISO100, default LR sharpening or NR applied, and medium contrast tone curve applied to all photos. No tripod with, so held and framed using grid on the camera. No photos have been cropped, framing is close enough to draw conclusions (for me).
Probably of limited interest for most, but some might enjoy. Enjoy
Making sure – these were shot with either mechanical or electronic shutter and not EFCS, right? If not, there'd be about a 1-stop loss of bokeh rendering when shot at over 1/500 sec. for f/2 and wider apertures.
Very interesting and illuminating set, thank you. Surprising to see such differences in ostensibly similar lenses. CV went their own way with this one, rather more than most recent others. They have rather successfully developed a house style. If they have abandoned the Lanthars at longer FLs, I'd like a 100/2 of this one if made with the same design intent and style.
Some summary statistics:
CV 75/1.5: 350g; 63mm x 63mm; 7/6 design
Lux 75/1.4: 560g; 80mm x 69mm; 7/5 design
@Steve Spencer Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
nehemiahphoto wrote:
@Steve Spencer@ Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby@ You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje@ I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa@ Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj@ You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
Thanks for the reply. In looking at these two images, I wonder if the 75 Lux might be preferred on a monochrome body or for b&w conversions over the CV, at least at this distance and provided the flare was not in the image.
Re: a rendering-based 100 or 90 f/2, I think CV should create a lens that channels the wide-open rendering of the CZ 100 f/2 C/Y or Zeiss Classic/Milvus 135 f/2. I think at this just-beyond full body distance, they need to at least be at 100mm if not longer unless they want to make a larger lens like a 90 or 100 f/1.5.
This is well expected results for anyone have used both ( like me) I swap 75lux with 80lux and keep 75 voigtlander for its much smaller size and smooth rendering with good sharpness.
75/80 lux is definitely not for everyone. It is part of history and you can use it create images recreate that history look. You certainly can have preference but you can't deny there is a signature look just like 35lux pre aSPH. It is not a smooth bokeh, high contrast or low flare look you get modern lens like 75VC. it is combination of SA, coating, flare and resolution. I love this look for the case for it. It is a tool I will reach for this look.
I will not deny you might be able to get similar from other film era glasses. However, if you want this look carry leica badge and hardwear build, you just have to pay the leica ticket unfortunately. TBH, there is no better or worse for tool like 75lux. This is market, the price of these lux are set by demand and supply. It can have only one way to go, up regardless of how they compare to modern glasses.
VC 75 beat old lux in technical term does not mean too much as well if you think about it. (Dont get me wrong, I love this lens and have it in my bag.) When you compare vc75 to modern Sigma art gf gn 85, you will reach to another conclusion. It is just a tool.
PS, 80lux has better corner and cateye (rendering and coverage) but may be less sharp at WO.
zhangyue wrote:
This is well expected results for anyone have used both ( like me) I swap 75lux with 80lux and keep 75 voigtlander for its much smaller size and smooth rendering with good sharpness.
75/80 lux is definitely not for everyone. It is part of history and you can use it create images recreate that history look. You certainly can have preference but you can't deny there is a signature look just like 35lux pre aSPH. It is not a smooth bokeh, high contrast or low flare look you get modern lens like 75VC. it is combination of SA, coating, flare and resolution. I love this look for the case for it. It is a tool I will reach for this look.
I will not deny you might be able to get similar from other film era glasses. However, if you want this look carry leica badge and hardwear build, you just have to pay the leica ticket unfortunately. TBH, there is no better or worse for tool like 75lux. This is market, the price of these lux are set by demand and supply. It can have only one way to go, up regardless of how they compare to modern glasses.
VC 75 beat old lux in technical term does not mean too much as well if you think about it. (Dont get me wrong, I love this lens and have it in my bag.) When you compare vc75 to modern Sigma art gf gn 85, you will reach to another conclusion. It is just a tool.
PS, 80lux has better corner and cateye (rendering and coverage) but may be less sharp at WO. ...Show more →
I very much agree with you on all fronts. And, to clarify, you kept your CV 75/1.5 and 80 Lux?
And the 80 Lux has smoother transitions and more abstracted bokeh, less cat's eyes, a bit more fringing and more SA. It's not as sharp or "clear" on axis WO or in the midzone, and takes longer to sharpen up when stopping down, but files have more magic to them. I think we agree on that, but it's personal. (75 vs 80 lux)
And yes, I tend to just view lenses at tools with different looks, the technical aspects are interesting and I like to know them, but they don't mean much to me in terms of which lenses I keep or like better. That the CV 75/1.5 besting the 75 Lux is completely unsurprising to me--the 75 Lux came out in 1980 so I hope the CV is better I like the 75 Lux, Canon 85/1.2, Minolta 85/1.4 Limited, CV 75/1.5 GM 85, 85 Contarax--all great tools with different looks.