highdesertmesa wrote: nehemiahphoto wrote@Steve Spencer@@@ Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby@@ You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje@@ I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa@@ Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj@@ You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
Cv 75/1.5 @f2 from about 6 meters: https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51824482766_763f2e9a27_h.jpgThanks for the reply. In looking at these two images, I wonder if the 75 Lux might be preferred on a monochrome body or for b&w conversions over the CV, at least at this distance and provided the flare was not in the image.
Re: a rendering-based 100 or 90 f/2, I think CV should create a lens that channels the wide-open rendering of the CZ 100 f/2 C/Y or Zeiss Classic/Milvus 135 f/2. I think at this just-beyond full body distance, they need to at least be at 100mm if not longer unless they want to make a larger lens like a 90 or 100 f/1.5....Show more →
The Minolta 100/2 is really an underrated lens. I would not mind if CV duplicated that look. I too enjoyed the CY 100/2 enormously. I tend to prefer older lenses for B/W cause they are lower contrast, transitions between fine tones are softer, even if the micro and global contrast is lower. But I did really enjoy the ZM 35/1.4 for b/w especially. That lens gave amazing fine tone seperation and contrast for B/W to me.
nehemiahphoto wrote: highdesertmesa wrotenehemiahphoto wrote@Steve Spencer@@@@ Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby@@@ You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje@@@ I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa@@@ Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj@@@ You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
Cv 75/1.5 @f2 from about 6 meters: https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51824482766_763f2e9a27_h.jpgThanks for the reply. In looking at these two images, I wonder if the 75 Lux might be preferred on a monochrome body or for b&w conversions over the CV, at least at this distance and provided the flare was not in the image.
Re: a rendering-based 100 or 90 f/2, I think CV should create a lens that channels the wide-open rendering of the CZ 100 f/2 C/Y or Zeiss Classic/Milvus 135 f/2. I think at this just-beyond full body distance, they need to at least be at 100mm if not longer unless they want to make a larger lens like a 90 or 100 f/1.5.The Minolta 100/2 is really an underrated lens. I would not mind if CV duplicated that look. I too enjoyed the CY 100/2 enormously. I tend to prefer older lenses for B/W cause they are lower contrast, transitions between fine tones are softer, even if the micro and global contrast is lower. But I did really enjoy the ZM 35/1.4 for b/w especially. That lens gave amazing fine tone seperation and contrast for B/W to me.
I'll have to try the Minolta 100/2. I think I remember reading that some of the old MD lenses were collaborations with Leica, so perhaps some of the character from each company wore off on the other. I have the Minolta 85/2.8 Varisoft, and with the soft effect at zero (off), it's an amazing lens, especially on the GFX wide open at closer distances.
The ZM 35 1.4 is on my short list.
Veering slight off-topic with regard to platform, but I find the little RF 50 1.8 renders b&w images beautifully on the R5 when shot wide open. I often prefer it to the optically-superior RF 50 1.2 when shooting in b&w.
highdesertmesa wrote: nehemiahphoto wrotehighdesertmesa wrotenehemiahphoto wrote@Steve Spencer@@@@@ Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby@@@@ You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje@@@@ I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa@@@@ Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj@@@@ You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
Cv 75/1.5 @f2 from about 6 meters: https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51824482766_763f2e9a27_h.jpgThanks for the reply. In looking at these two images, I wonder if the 75 Lux might be preferred on a monochrome body or for b&w conversions over the CV, at least at this distance and provided the flare was not in the image.
Re: a rendering-based 100 or 90 f/2, I think CV should create a lens that channels the wide-open rendering of the CZ 100 f/2 C/Y or Zeiss Classic/Milvus 135 f/2. I think at this just-beyond full body distance, they need to at least be at 100mm if not longer unless they want to make a larger lens like a 90 or 100 f/1.5.The Minolta 100/2 is really an underrated lens. I would not mind if CV duplicated that look. I too enjoyed the CY 100/2 enormously. I tend to prefer older lenses for B/W cause they are lower contrast, transitions between fine tones are softer, even if the micro and global contrast is lower. But I did really enjoy the ZM 35/1.4 for b/w especially. That lens gave amazing fine tone seperation and contrast for B/W to me.I'll have to try the Minolta 100/2. I think I remember reading that some of the old MD lenses were collaborations with Leica, so perhaps some of the character from each company wore off on the other. I have the Minolta 85/2.8 Varisoft, and with the soft effect at zero (off), it's an amazing lens, especially on the GFX wide open at closer distances.
The ZM 35 1.4 is on my short list.
Veering slight off-topic with regard to platform, but I find the little RF 50 1.8 renders b&w images beautifully on the R5 when shot wide open. I often prefer it to the optically-superior RF 50 1.2 when shooting in b&w....Show more →
It would be cool to see some of the Mino 85/2.8 varisoft photos if you have them, especially on GFX. I personally do not mind if the thread meanders a bit. Also, not sure if the Mino 100/2 AF is the same as the MD predecessors, but that is the only one I can vouch for.
nehemiahphoto wrote: highdesertmesa wrotenehemiahphoto wrotehighdesertmesa wrotenehemiahphoto wrote@Steve Spencer@@@@@@ Thanks Steve--glad you enjoyed the testing. The longer I shoot, the more I lead towards the 80 Lux, which is softer on axis with worse LoCal, but it has distinctly better draw in terms of smoothness and bokeh off axis. The 75 Lux can feel harsh in comparison for OOF, but the size is much smaller, colors are punchier and it's RF, so there's that. And the price differential...I won't be keeping my 75 Lux of CV, but my 80 Lux absolutely stays.
@Matt Kerby@@@@@ You're welcome, and yes, the Lux is pretty flare and ghost susceptible. Look below at the sun just outside the frame--lots of veiling flare.
@derKoekje@@@@@ I recently sold my M 90/2 pre-asph. I liked it, but I would take the CV or Lux 75 over it, FL aside.
@highdesertmesa@@@@@ Mechanical shutter only. I have noticed before this comp, the 75 Lux has a somewhat "compressed" OFF areas than you'd think compared to other similarly spec'ed lenses. In my 80 vs 75 Summilux article at Phillipreeve's, the 75 Lux seems to have less seperation than the 80, despite being so close in formula and specs. Similar here with the CV 75.
@philip_pj@@@@@ You're welcome--good you enjoyed and found them helpful. Also, I have v1 of the 75 Summilux, which is lighter and smaller than version 2 and 3, but they are all a bit different. v1 is less bulky, and weighs 490g. v2 is 600g and appreciably larger and the most common and cheapest on the used market. v3 is the same dimensions as v2, but weighs 40g less at 560g (the one you cite). All 3 have identical optics, same MFD and 60mm thread though, so no optical differences, beyond the customary coating updates along the way it seems. And I too would love a more rendering-based 100 or 90/2 from CV.
Cv 75/1.5 @f2 from about 6 meters: https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/51824482766_763f2e9a27_h.jpgThanks for the reply. In looking at these two images, I wonder if the 75 Lux might be preferred on a monochrome body or for b&w conversions over the CV, at least at this distance and provided the flare was not in the image.
Re: a rendering-based 100 or 90 f/2, I think CV should create a lens that channels the wide-open rendering of the CZ 100 f/2 C/Y or Zeiss Classic/Milvus 135 f/2. I think at this just-beyond full body distance, they need to at least be at 100mm if not longer unless they want to make a larger lens like a 90 or 100 f/1.5.The Minolta 100/2 is really an underrated lens. I would not mind if CV duplicated that look. I too enjoyed the CY 100/2 enormously. I tend to prefer older lenses for B/W cause they are lower contrast, transitions between fine tones are softer, even if the micro and global contrast is lower. But I did really enjoy the ZM 35/1.4 for b/w especially. That lens gave amazing fine tone seperation and contrast for B/W to me.I'll have to try the Minolta 100/2. I think I remember reading that some of the old MD lenses were collaborations with Leica, so perhaps some of the character from each company wore off on the other. I have the Minolta 85/2.8 Varisoft, and with the soft effect at zero (off), it's an amazing lens, especially on the GFX wide open at closer distances.
The ZM 35 1.4 is on my short list.
Veering slight off-topic with regard to platform, but I find the little RF 50 1.8 renders b&w images beautifully on the R5 when shot wide open. I often prefer it to the optically-superior RF 50 1.2 when shooting in b&w.It would be cool to see some of the Mino 85/2.8 varisoft photos if you have them, especially on GFX. I personally do not mind if the thread meanders a bit. Also, not sure if the Mino 100/2 AF is the same as the MD predecessors, but that is the only one I can vouch for.
The lens renders a very cinematic neutral contrast while remaining sharp at high detail frequencies. I added quite a bit of saturation and contrast to those. I know at least the second image has some soft focus dialed in on the lens.
zhangyue wrote:
VC 75 beat old lux in technical term does not mean too much as well if you think about it. (Dont get me wrong, I love this lens and have it in my bag.) When you compare vc75 to modern Sigma art gf gn 85, you will reach to another conclusion. It is just a tool.
yup, personally i like the look of the lux better in most of the shots, but that is because i like that look and have grown pretty weary of the modern high contrast look. i would probably prefer the old jupiter-9 (totally forgot i had that lens and should use it more) to the cv for most of these.
sebboh wrote: zhangyue wroteVC 75 beat old lux in technical term does not mean too much as well if you think about it. (Dont get me wrong, I love this lens and have it in my bag.) When you compare vc75 to modern Sigma art gf gn 85, you will reach to another conclusion. It is just a tool.yup, personally i like the look of the lux better in most of the shots, but that is because i like that look and have grown pretty weary of the modern high contrast look. i would probably prefer the old jupiter-9 (totally forgot i had that lens and should use it more) to the cv for most of these.
The other day, I pull out Minolta 58mm shooting at f1.2, I got exact same feeling as this comparison here when comparing to any modern 50mm glasses. I just love the film look (flawed or whatever you call it) using on digital camera. If our goal is the fidelity to reproduce reality, then modern glasses win hands down but here, this is so subjective IMHO. One simply can't reproduce the others' look. (at wide aperture)
I want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process
zhangyue wrote:
I want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process
I have a very similar conclusion and experience with this lens. What is your thinking/reasoning? I'd be curious to hear. These tests I just made to show the difference in the structural draw, but real images are a whole other thing.
I own and very much like the above-mentioned Summilux-R 80mm. It definitely has its own signature look and it is actually 2 lenses in one, f1.4 being very different from f2.
That being said, in this thread I actually do prefer the Voigtlander in pretty much all of the images.
That is for the first set of images, in the second set of images it is more of a tie I feel.
Adding also that everybody has their own subjects, and the fact that a lens might render somebody else's subject in an attractive way does not necessarily mean anything for your photography and your choice of subjects.
zhangyue wrote:
I want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process
agreed. for me, at least, a big component of the special rendering of the 75 (and 80) lux is the focus transition on peoples faces. the transition is slower and less abrupt than most modern lenses and this creates a different look. of course the lens also has lots of flare and bad bokeh that can look horrendous in certain situations but really cool in other situations when you think about how to use it.
nehemiahphoto wrote: zhangyue wroteI want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process I have a very similar conclusion and experience with this lens. What is your thinking/reasoning? I'd be curious to hear. These tests I just made to show the difference in the structural draw, but real images are a whole other thing.
Derek's reply almost answer it fully. It about renders 3D subject in close distance. There is almost an "atmosphere" around the subject.
In your sample scenarios, people unavoidably focus on background: which one is smoother, which one has less CA, which one with subject sharper, lower flare those type of technical things. I do forest walk and shooting with 75lux or 80lux as well and choose not showing any of them because they suck so I am not surprised at all with your results.
However, I also do family portraits with both VC and both lux. VC is good, very smooth, sharp and versatile. In a broad spectrum, it close to Modern 85mm f1.4 such as sigma, Nikon, Canon, Sony. You get good results with smoother bokeh. However, it won't give you "lux" portraits. I will hand pick out every lux images out as preferred ones For those, I don't even care background anymore because there is nothing to care about mostly, they are all blur blur blur away, but transition and atmosphere are here to stay draw you attention. If you are into this look, you are hooked.
It is a niche look. I wouldn't deliver those images to clients if I am professional due to difficulty on controlling condition such as flare, sharpness, contrast, focus accuracy, (for some, sharpness means pro)
FM alt people tend to do thing more technically, and people tend to pick winner out of the test. For sharpness, CA correction, distortion, those are super objective. Nothing more. Maybe I could even add bokeh smoothness in the list. However, this type of comparison for lens rendering are bond to fail IMHO. Bokeh is not just smooth and ugly,(there are ugly ones, Sony 35f1.8) There is more to that, and then there is focus transition, SA depth (a word I created for portrait ).
Giving another example, Zeiss 50mm planar, if you compare it to any other modern 50 glasses on bokeh smoothness, sharpness, CA. It fail miserably. Winner for sure is not it. However, if you really use it then you will realize those "WOW" moment that others never bring you.
My philosophy on this are research, look, judge, use and decide. The final two steps are not only important but also better take time because no one know better what you need. At least, for me, there is no universal standard, I love 55OTUS's sharpness, CA correction and clean look, but I also love Nikon 58G ultra smoothness, huge coverage then there is Planar 50 that still has its place in my heart.
As why I brought this thread back again because I was browsing M11 image thread on LUF the other day. The images from 75mm lux and 35mm pre-ASPH brought smile on my face. I told myself these are just so beautiful. 35mm pre-ASPH is another one will fail every single comparison tests like this too, so what?
sebboh wrote: zhangyue wroteI want bring back this thread that I just want to reemphasis that the more images I saw with 75lux and VC75, the more I feel comparison like this won't tell you much about lens rendering, or predict final image results.
75lux has very special looks. Its signature dominate image if you know how to use it. You can't get that from process agreed. for me, at least, a big component of the special rendering of the 75 (and 80) lux is the focus transition on peoples faces. the transition is slower and less abrupt than most modern lenses and this creates a different look. of course the lens also has lots of flare and bad bokeh that can look horrendous in certain situations but really cool in other situations when you think about how to use it.
i should add that this can be seen to a much larger extent in the second test set, especially the pictures of Gordon if you compare the way the nose and the hair on his back look with the focus on the eyes with both lenses.
a more extreme test would be a profile shot like this (80 lux shot) with each lens to see how the focus transition works on a human face. it might be more useful not at mfd but a more normal portrait distance of course.
I agree with you two. Comparing the 75 CV and Lux here in no way changed how I felt about the lenses--I had already owned and shot them both. I know the draws (both nice though very different) and my preferences. Like you say Michael, I like all sorts of lenses new and old--no hard lines. But I do feel like the 35 Lux and 75/80 Lux have extremely high ceilings. They always produce my absolute favorite files, even if they are sometimes a pain to shoot or not as versatile. About 70% of my photogrpahy budget is spent on a small set of lenses that are specialized--I just can't get over how much I like the look when it hits. Like Derek says, the glow and more gradual fall off and the dimensionality that is created in the photo is so pleasing, espcially for portraits and shallow DOF work generally.
For me, I also enormously enjoy the color/contrast and SA combo. Maybe I am just not as good at color management as some, but I can't ever get new lenses to look just like old ones. I chased that with post processing and diffusion filters and such, but the Lux look and "feel" to the files I just can't replicate satisfactorily. So I gave up and purchased them back. I now have a 50 Noct which I won't keep, but it has the same type of characteristics that make the images distinctive.
This post is very helpful and thanks for the comparisons and discussions.
I used to have a nice Germany Lux 75 about 10 years ago but I really couldn't get myself to work with the lens (or the other way round).
The CV 75/1.5 really caught my eyes and I am considering to get one. From the photos here (and elsewhere), the rendering is different to the Lux 75 but still the CV75 has its own characters and the way it draws is quite pleasing. The biggest attraction for me is the size and handling though.
nehemiahphoto wrote: geoffreyg wroteDid anyone compare CV 75 f2.5? Seems to have a good look too.http://gear.vogelius.se/-reviews/voigtlander-heliar-75-ltm/index.html
I have never shot it, but his reviews are excellent, and I found that helpful.
Thanks, so very much, for posting this link! There is much useful information to be found, there, regarding several lenses that are of personal interest, to me, including two, the CV 75mm f/2.5 VM, and the Zeiss 25mm f/2.8 ZM, which I have already acquired, pre-owned, but have yet to get into the field/woods/streets. The articles are more than just reviews, as they provide truly useful advice on shooting with these lenses.